An advantage of HSS over carbide
steven antonucci
When you use up carbide, you throw it away. You can always resell you HSS tools 
S
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
An advantage of HSS over carbide
steven antonucci
When you use up carbide, you throw it away. You can always resell you HSS tools 
S
Totally agree...
steven antonucci
Used to be a commercial that ran for a local clothing store (Syms)...
"An educated consumer is our best customer"
What I think upsets me most isn't carbide vs. HSS, but the carbide tool sales pitch that it cures what ails you, solves world peace and gets you into heaven. I think if most people that watched the demos at these shows were allowed to turn with the tool, they'd find out that they were no better off with carbide than HSS.
You are an educated consumer, and skilled hands, making conscious decisons. The material will know that you've presented whatever edge is in your hands properly, and it will respond correctly. I just wish that the vendors wouldn't compromise ethics in their sales process so much. Never saw one DVD sold with a carbide tool on how to properly use it. Just jam it in and cut...
No malice towards the users of these things, but the first step is education.
Good conversation always ensues when people disagree,
Steven
Re: Totally agree...
Jim in River Oaks, Ont.
As Happy Gilmore said...
"Yeah. Alright, now, if you get that puck in that net over there, I'll never bother you again. But if you miss, you got to give me a big fat kiss. And you have to pretend you like it too. "
So try it... 

I agree 100% with what you said my friend, education on the proper use and maintenance of any tool is best.
Take care,
Jim
Carbide is also for cripples
Ken Vaughan
Being a turner with slowly progressing arthritis -- I can no longer even approximate the "lathe dance". Carbide is a good thing for those who turn from a sitting position.
I am still learning style, design, visualization of grain and movement and am thoughtful about them regardless of the tool in hand.
I do notice as I am stuck with turning from a stool, that my patience is often tried by those who rigidly link the physical process with tools to the outcome and thought processes needed to control to tools and produce the outcomes that are better than what I did yesterday.
Carbide corrects tool presentation too? maybe
steven antonucci
Whether sitting or standing, a cut is only as good as the edge and how it's presented (a paraphrase of a Russ Fairfield quote).
If you can properly present carbide from a sitting position, HSS, carbon steel or a wet noodle could also be presented properly. The odds are that you are getting better result today by using carbide because the nose angle is different and better aligned with the way you present the tool seated. Basically, two errors cancelling each other out.
I teach beginning turners all of the time, and I spend a lot of time lowering their handles to get them back on bevel. With most of the carbide cutters I have seen, the nose angle is something like 80 degrees, which would mean that you'd have the tool up higher to ride the bevel. Since the cutter only has a micro bevel, it's really easy to be within a range of "on bevel", but much harder to control (aka... why carbide tools are so "grabby" when you present them wrong).
Glad that they work better for you, but don't think for a second it's because they are carbide. You'd get the same results from an HSS disc, and you could resharpen it...
Steve
You ain't shaving me......!!!!
Mike Stafford
I am not trusting this beautiful face to an amateur with a sharp skew...... 
Re: What comes next?
dick gerard
Ssssshhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
The next "BIG" material will be ceramics.
With lasers
steven antonucci
Not even for money
steven antonucci
Re: What comes next?
Alan Zenreich
I guess I shouldn't mention the fine Kyocera ceramic knives that I've had in my kitchen knife block for years, eh? They are some of my favorite cutting instruments.
Just so that folk don't think I'm an anti-steel snob... I'm one of those people who regularly sharpen my kitchen knives, and hone before-or-after each use.
Originally I set up my shop intending to be a knife-maker, so I've got professional grade equipment for making "cutting edge" things and creating very fine edges on various materials (ever try to sharpen titanium??)
So don't think for a minute that I'm opposed to sharpening or using conventional tools. Then again, it's my understanding that 40 years ago, a "bowl gouge" wasn't considered a conventional tool when the main instructors were demo'ing scrapers (never mind "winged" grinds). Times change along with tools and techniques.
There are so many things brought up in this conversation that I have opinions on... but for the moment, I'll sit back and watch some of the other comments.
I appreciate the conversation.
))))
Stephen Mushinski
Re: Carbide corrects tool presentation too? maybe
Ken Vaughan
Steve == pull up a stool and sit on it for a couple hours while turning -- and do not stand up to make any of the cuts --
The world looks different from the stool with generally only upper body movement easily available and some easy moves on your feet becoming very ackward and difficult while sitting. Reaching down to drop a handle does not work the same way.
Best anology I can think of is playing basketball in a wheelchair -- the points of reference and muscle memory functions are not the same.
Re: Carbide corrects tool presentation too? maybe
Coyne
Ken, perhaps this should be the start of a new thread. What type stool do you find best. How many others are having to use stools part or full time? What can you share that will help us old codgers who can't stand long or at all any more? Coyne
Not "rigid," concerned about safety...
Katherine Kowalski
Ken,
The difference is that you, as an experienced turner, already know about grain direction and how to make a good curve.
And I am in agreement with Jim as well -- if you already are an experienced turner, you should choose the tools that work best for your specific needs. (Don't we all?) I also choose the cutting technique that works best for me, especially when doing production items.
I am simply concerned with the safety aspects of new turners who will be at serious risk from flying blocks of wood because they don't know the first thing about cutting wood. As Steve mentioned -- to my knowledge, none of those carbide tools comes with a video.
There is a controversy in Colorado now -- that children should no longer be taught how to hand-write cursive because of the digital age. (Now I am all about computers, been using them since I was two years old). BUT... will these people even know how to write, or read handwriting when they grow up? What if their computer breaks down? Could they even write a shopping list? (How will they sign their woodturnings?)
I just come from a standpoint of knowing basics before you tackle the Master projects. (Knowing basic tooling improves the design process, since you can experiment with new ways of cutting, and know what is possible/not, or how to make it possible.)
Ken, my compliments to you for continuing to work your passion. (In my profession, I too make tools for the differently-abled, and people who have illnesses which prevent them from using the "standard" commercial products).
Katherine