Overheard on an elevator at Totally Turning
steven antonucci
"I just bought this carbide tool... now I don't need to sharpen."
Fingernails. On. A. Blackboard.
S
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Overheard on an elevator at Totally Turning
steven antonucci
"I just bought this carbide tool... now I don't need to sharpen."
Fingernails. On. A. Blackboard.
S
Re: Overheard on an elevator at Totally Turning
Alan Zenreich
It's actually a fairly reasonable comment. It lets people be more productive and get better results with less shop equipment.
Being a tool junkie, I have a mix of very fine carbide, high speed and powdered metal tools.
There's a place for them all, and you can do most things with most tools (especially if you take the time to learn how to get the most out of a given tool)
I admit that the carbides are the one I reach for first.
Oh, Steve: screeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeechhhhhh
Re: Overheard on an elevator at Totally Turning
Alan Zenreich
I forgot to mention that I'm also a sharpening tool junkie < vbg >
I hope you know that's completely wrong?
steven antonucci
and you are just trying to push my buttons...
In general, carbide is not as sharp as HSS, so you start out as less sharp and degrade from there with every cut with no way to renew your edge. You trade edge sharpness for wear, and your edge will degrade more slowly than a better steel edge, which means you'd sharpen less often if you could sharpen at all.
Trading wear for edge might make sense if I was making 200 of something per day, but for the average turner, it's not going to reduce anything but their wallet. If they knew how to rub a bevel and which way the grain was running, they would know that they don't need carbide to cut wood cleanly.
BTW- I brought a box of burl scraps for you to the NJW meeting last night. We discussed my tool making workshop at the meeting, and you should come so I can fix all of the things that you learned wrong 
Steve
Re: I hope you know that's completely wrong?
Alan Zenreich
Steve,
Not wrong... different. Have you watched Steve Sherman do ultra-fine finial work with his little round carbide tools (in cutting mode... riding the bevel, not scraping)?
It also depends on the material.
When doing acrylics (and particuarly the very brittle Inlace Acrylester), I use a rounded square carbide tool and go directly to a micromesh. It takes much less time than using conventional tools. Others have given up on the material because they spend at least as much time sharpening as they do cutting.
So, I wonder what kind or results you would get if you were stranded on an island with a carbide tool or two... I'm confident that you would exploit the tools beautifully and perhaps even gain a new respect for this emerging class of lathe tools.
Now, where did I put that laser...? < vbg >
Re: I hope you know that's completely wrong?
Alan Zenreich
Steve,
Sorry I couldn't attend last night's meeting... too much to do here.
I forgot to mention, if folk tried carbides a few years ago (originally designed for metal working or wood planing machines), they might be surprised at how well the new nano-carbide formulas perform. These new cutters are used in the better lathe tools, and for finished cuts are IMO well worth the price. Roughing cuts can be done with just about anything (some of us demote bits from finish use to roughing use as they age).
As far as toolmaking goes... let's just say that I've been building/tweaking tools, workshops, darkrooms, cameras, etc. to my specifications for a long, long time (probably since you were in diapers < vbg >). At my age I prefer to buy rather than build... and then do the tweaking to add functionality.
As I mentioned this past weekend... I'm an enthusiast, not an evangelist.
I don't care if people do things differently from the way I do. I only explain the reasons that I often take the "road less traveled", and if it works for them, great... if not, I have no vested interest.. so I'm happy.
So, I guess I'm an 'eccentric' rather than 'mainstream' turner, eh?
Re: I hope you know that's completely wrong?
Jim in River Oaks, Ont.
eh 
Now I know what I am, I enable myself to buy what I like and do just that, tweak it to my style.
I am also a carbide convert with my pen making, going directly to 400-600 from the tool is very clean work.
Now I have some cane's to make, I'll be using both HSS and carbide, maybe 
Where did I put that 7 Iron...
Take care,
Jim
Y'all noticed I said wood, right?
steven antonucci
and you both counteracted with "non wood" (acrylics don't grow on trees in NJ... not sure about Canada?
)
I did watch Steve Sherman for a bit, and I couldn't help but wonder why for the work he was doing? I will venture a guess that I could also do exactly what he was doing with carbide tools and here's the big reveal: IT HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH CARBIDE.
So, if it's the proficiency with the 7 iron that makes the difference, why would you switch makers? A Ping vs Calloway? If the club in the hands doesn't make me a better golfer, carbide doesn't make me a better turner.
It may be carbide is better suited for acrylics and Trustone blanks, but then again, we are talking about wood 90% of the time...
S
P.S. I'm going to start marketing a carbide hook tool pretty soon. When the hook breaks, you just buy another one 
Re: Y'all noticed I said wood, right?
Alan Zenreich
Steve,
My mentioning Steve Sherman's demo was in response to your inference that carbide tools aren't as sharp nor cut as well as HSS.
As for materials other than wood... I agree that most turners stick to wood (cute pun, eh?). The "brown and round" crowd is clearly the mainstream.
So, those of us that want more, how shall I say, 'flexible' tools that work with the various, more challenging, materials we mount on the lathe have found the tools nicely applicable to wood.
I'd better go back to sharpening my allen wrenches. Now where did I put that new foot treadle?
Re: Y'all noticed I said wood, right?
Jim in River Oaks, Ont.
You are completely right Steve 
Now...easy does it ...but you know I love my 7 Iron, but this new hybrid carbide thing works great on the acrylic/man made courses... I'm a Wilson Pro Staff kind of guy, but in the case of playing on the street vs grass, I'm saving my Wilson for the soft green surfaces, the carbide for street hockey...
Did I just cross two sports with a turning tool? 
Do we have wood in Canada?? Sure, Jack Pine is premium here .... 
Bring on the Hook!! Fore!!
Take care,
Jim
more challenging?
steven antonucci
A 1.5" x 1/4" disc of wood may be suitable for carbide because you'd never have to sharpen it. When you throw a shaving that's bigger than one of your finished projects, replacing carbide @$20 every couple of weeks isn't really an option.
I have seen some impressive work done with sharpened allen keys too. David Ellsworth has a drawer full of them for his small vessels. Perhaps some day he can step up to something as challenging as a pendant... 
Off to throw away my treadle lathe and buy me a carbide one... 
S
I can't swing a 7 iron or a driver
steven antonucci
Played golf 2x in my life, and I think golf balls are a lot like carbide cutters. I would slice once with them and then replace them 
S
Re: more challenging?
Alan Zenreich
I respectfully submit that the folk using carbide tools for roughing their bowls are not throwing away bits every couple of weeks.
It's funny, my use of these tools on small pieces is not what the tool designers had in mind... they developed them for more typical uses.
I guess I'll have to start displaying some larger work... I have some mulberry that's just crying out for a fair sized hollow form.
Then again, if I do that, then it will be 'yet another hollow form', not to be confused with my 'yet another bowl' project. Part of the reason we often choose to work small is that there are fewer people doing it... yet another branch of the road less taken.
So, as you can see, I like being an eccentric, and I'm working my way up to being a curmudgeon.
Carbide is the future of woodturning
Ron McKinley
You would be surprised how little I sharpen these days. I make a few pens, all wood, and carbide is the only tool I use. I turned a bowl yesterday with all carbide and never used the 80 grit gouge. Try it. You'll like it! ...Ron
Nano-carbide question?
steven antonucci
If you take a brand new nano-carbide insert out of the box, is it sharp enough to shave hair off of your arms? I have no doubt that it can cut skin, but I wondered if it was as sharp as a skew? My skews take hair...
(Serious question)
Steve
Re: Y'all noticed I said wood, right?
keith tompkins
Steve, I may be able to answer your question: If carbide is the new, biggest, hottest commodity, then wouldn't it make economic sense to market "nano carbide" technology in an attempt to boost sales?
Re: Nano-carbide question?
Alan Zenreich
Steve,
The answer is yes. Using an Easy Wood Tools radiused square cutter, I now have three bare patches of skin on my otherwise hairy wrist.
Now for part B...
steven antonucci
Can you take the same tool that you've been using and the cutter that's in it that you have not rotated but still considered "sharp enough" and tell me what happens? I suspect that you'll find that it no longer cuts as well, and you have proven my point:
Carbide is equal to HSS only once in it's lifetime, but I can shave you baby smooth with a skew and a strop...
Tell Lauren I'm on my way 
S
Re: Carbide is the future of woodturning
John Lucas
Ron I have tried them. So far I don't see the advantage of the flat carbide cutters other than they require no skill to use. I love being able to make a pass over a bowl or vessel with a bowl gouge and really get the shape right and very clean. With the scrapers you have to sneak up on the shape and so far I can't get as clean a cut.
Now the Hunter and Eliminator tools are different. The do cut clean and since your rubbing the bevel you can control the shape very well. You can also shear scrape with them to really clean up a cut but it's not as clean as using the bevel rubbing cut.
I think that's the answer
steven antonucci
carbide is appealing to new turners who may be sturggling with sharpening and tool control. It's most likely a scraping cut for most new turners who don't possess the tool control to ride the bevel, and it's stuck out on the end of a heavy round rod instead of a thin, flat scraper so there is less vibration.
Unless you turn stone for a living, carbide is a great marketing ploy against developing skills. There is at least one video on Youtube from a carbide tool manufacturer that jams the cutter into a blank to round it and proudly proclaims that it is easy and such. The end grain surface of the bowl blank is worse than a chainsaw leaves.
I think that the economics of the carbide market are fighting the standard turning market. When you start to see teaching professionals instruct using carbide tools, then perhaps the tools will be a valuable addition to an arsenal. For now, it's just another thing to buy.
Steve
What comes next?
steven antonucci
When all of the beginners buy nano-carbide tools and don't get any better, will they have to wait for pico-carbide technology? Oh, the humanity!
S
Re: Carbide is the future of woodturning
Carole Valentine
For all you folks who are going carbide, can I have your old HSS tools? 
To all the new turners out there...
Katherine Kowalski
Steve,
I completely share your sentiment -- I don't think I could have said it better myself.
As a teacher of turning technique, these tools scare the life out of me... not because I think they'll put me out of a job, but because most of the woodturners using them will NEVER pay attention to the grain, never learn to cut wood properly, and be in SERIOUS danger of a catch with any other tool they pick up.
These folks will also never know the serious pleasure of making a really sweet curve... the movement of the whole body in an almost sacred experience.
Carbide tools have their place, certainly, (cutting acrylics, stone, Trustone, etc.), but NOT, "shove this tool into the wood and you'll have a bowl in no time," which I have seen demonstrated at several events around the country.
To all you new turners out there -- learn to use the traditional tools properly... you'll achieve better shapes, learn better technique, and achieve a much finer finish. (And you can be proud of yourself for actually learning a new skill... instead of just "making chips.")
Anyone who needs helps, feel free to ask... many of us here teach turning and sharpening, myself included. Don't go the "easy" route... it will make your learning curve that much steeper...
Katherine
Re: Nano-carbide question?
Ron McKinley
I've never tried that. Next time I get a new cutter I'll try it.....Ron
Re: What comes next?
Jim in River Oaks, Ont.
Isn't it wonderful to have choices.. and in the end, the materials we use to create what we have joy for really doesn't care what we are holding in our hands, it's what we do with the tool of choice.
I also don't buy into the school of thought that some people proclaim that some of these carbide tools require less skill, who cares? Let's make things, let's create, let's enjoy what we like doing and not get so concerned about what brand name of style of tool we use, by the way, my original 7 iron, a Spalding Pro Flyte, do you think the ball cares??
Take care,
Jim