Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Respirators

Posts

Respirators

#1

Respirators

Mick (in The Bahamas)

I have recently been having some reaction to dust from old reclaimed hardwoods I have been working on. I have tried a bunch of "surgical" type masks that are available in hardware stores, but they don't seem to cut it. So.......... I guess I have to look at something like a full face mask respirator. Am thinking of the Trend Pro but before I shell out $300+ I would like to hear some comments, pro and con, by anyone who has used one of these, or any alternative anyone can personally reccommend. Price is important but not as important as how well it works and comfort. I am concerned that if it too heavy or uncomfotable it will end up gathering dust on a shelf. All comments and suggestions would be appreciated.

Mick

Re: Respirators

#2

Re: Respirators *LINK*

David Walser

Mick,

I've used both the Trend (original, not the pro) and the Triton Powered Respirator. Of the two, I prefer the Triton. I own one and use it virtually every time I go into my shop. Here are my reasons for preferring the Triton over the Trend:

* Comfort. The Trend has the fan, filter, and battery pack in the helmet. In contrast, the Triton has the fan, filters, and battery pack mounted on a belt around your waist. The result, for me, is better balance -- particularly when leaning over at the lathe. I'm able to wear the Triton for hours at a time and even forget that I have it on.

* Protection. The Triton's face-shield is combined with a hardhat and hard shell hearing protectors. While I seldom use the hearing protection while at the lathe (I like to hear the sound of tool cutting wood), I do use them when at the tablesaw, grinder, or with the other noisy equipment in the shop. It's handy to have the hearing protection built-in. (This feature is available as an extra cost option with the Trend.) In addition, I like the protection provided by the Triton's hard hat. Fortunately, I've not NEEDED the hard hat, but I started woodworking in a commercial furniture mill where a hard hat was required. I like having that protection in case I were to knock a stack of wood onto my head off the upper shelf when reaching for a blank.

The Trend, particularly, the Pro model, is a worthy unit. Many turners have one and like them a lot. I just prefer the Triton, for the reasons given.

One more thought: Both the Trend and the Triton are "consumer" quality units. Much better than a non-powered respirator, but not nearly as good as an industrial unit. The industrial units are a significant step-up in quality -- and cost. The following link will take you to a vendor that carries the Trend, the Triton, and industrial quality units. (For woodturning, the industrial units to consider are the 3M Airstream and the 3M BreatheEasy with the BreatheEasy 1 headpiece.) I've no affiliation with the vendor, just a satisfied customer.

Good luck!


Airware America

Re: Respirators

#3

Re: Respirators

Bob Edwards

I'd give the mask sold by Vince Welch a try first. It is the most comfortable and efficient non-powered Respiratory mask I have ever used.

http://www.vinceswoodnwonders.com/Respiratory%20Mask.htm

Re: Respirators

#4

Alan Zenreich

Re: Respirators

Alan Zenreich

I use either a Trend Airshield Pro or a 3M Breathe Easy. Both units have the optional ear muffs attached.

The trick with the Trend is to get the right balance on your head by adjusting the pivot locks.

Once adjusted properly it's a very comfortable helmet.

I really wanted to like the Triton but could not. I tried on 6 of them. Because of the faceshield's bubble shape, I could not get past the slight distortion to the visual field. I'm pretty picky about this in respirators and motorcycle helmets.

For the past few weeks I've been testing a 3M Breathe Easy helmet that I've tethered to a HEPA room air filter via a hose (instead of using a belt pack). So far, I rather like the arrangement.

Re: Respirators

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Respirators

Richard Allen

Make sure that breathing clean air is going to solve your problem working the suspect wood. A properly sized and fitted N95 mask with insure that you are breathing clean air for a buck or two.

Once you are sure that breathing clean air solves your problem then consider the different respirators available. You may find an N95 "paper" mask works for you.

Collecting dust at the source is the most effective way to provide clean air to breath.

Re: Respirators

#6

Re: Respirators

Jim Canning

I have the Trend pro and it is great easy to use. It is expensive but it works great and we are talking about your lungs. Every turner should use one! Just my two cents worth.

Re: Respirators

#7

Re: Respirators

Barbara Gill

Save yourself some money, get a North 7700 series or the 3-M equivalent. All the protection, no batteries and <$50. It will fit under your face shield. I have used the North since 1985.

Re: Respirators

#8

Re: Respirators

john lopez

Lots of choices out there.

This link is to the 3M option.

http://www.envirosafetyproducts.com/3m-6000-series-full-facepiece-respirator.html

I'm using one like this now and find it quite comfortable.

There is an overpriced spectacle harness arrangement for

glasses if you use them.

Together they were about $200 US

I like the Trend too however it takes more money to get one.

Re: Respirators

#9

Chuck Jones - West TN

I'm happy with my AirShield Pro

Chuck Jones - West TN

I'm very pleased with the Airshield Pro, but it's the only one I have even tried on. I had some difficulty getting used to putting it on and off. For a couple days I thought I would have to hire a wardrobe assistant. After getting it adjusted correctly I have no problem with fit, weight, or anything else. I wear it almost all the time I am in the shop. I bought the extra battery, but I don't really need it. One battery runs for all the hours I want to work at one time.

I have a beard so the respirators like the North 7700 won't do it.

Re: Respirators

#10

Re: Respirators

woodspinner Harry Robinette

I tried the mask and a power cap I finally took the power cap apart and put the filter and fan from the front

bill of the cap to a Uvers face shield and that worked good. BUT the best thing I've done is put a Y in my dust collector hose and put two hoses one in front one in back,this has done more for my healthy breathing then any of the mask,respirators or anything. I turned Walnut and don't have brown gooo when I clean my nose.I use the flex duct that Woodcraft sells, I'm using two 4" hoses .I still us my homemade air pressure face shield but mainly for the face shield.

Re: Respirators

#11

Re: Respirators

Vince Welch

Hi Mick,

As Bob mentioned many people are happy with the mask I offer and if you are not happy with the mask I will refund your money!!! Call or email me if you have any questions.

Vince

Re: Respirators

#12

Re: Respirators

Mick (in The Bahamas)

Thank you to everyone who replied to my query. I appreciate your comments and suggestions. There is more options and "stuff" out there than I realised!

Mick

Re: Respirators

#13

Re: Respirators

Terry Scott

I have a Racal and a trend

However I am thinking of doing what Malcolm Zander has and run an out side air supply (or in his case air from a room inside his air conditioned/heated house)

I have to admit I find all of them including the Tritan bulky cumbersome items to wear ,and through laziness dont were them as much as I should.

I do however use my super sucker (dust extractor) and a fan set by the head stock

I can open both doors at each end of my shop and the fan sends dust out the door This must work as I am always getting told off as the bosses washing seems to make a good filter (the clothes line is 10 foot away )

I also have an air cleaner running which collects a surprising amount of dust.

I know of turners that as soon as they walk into the shop put on a helmet and leave it on. Call me stupid but I just cannot bring myself to get into this habit even putting on the helmet when sanding for 10 mins is a pain in the ..... dust extractor