Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Bowl Gouge to buy

Posts

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#26

Re: Thank you, Bill and Wayne

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

The alloy mixtures for tool steels are very sensitive. The difference between M-2 and M-7 for Carbon in a 100# batch is .05#/100#. The cheaper steels do not allow for quality control. If you can afford it, go for quality! If you learn to sharpen on cheap stuff, and perhaps you discover your perfect grind, you will want it to last more than 2 minutes.

Alloying compositions of common high speed steel grades (by %wt)

Grade C Cr Mo W V Co Mn Si

T1[6] 0.65 3.75 - 17.25 0.9 - 0.1 0.2

M2 0.95 4.2 5 6 2 - - -

M7 1 3.8 8.7 1.6 2 - - -

M35 0.94 4.1 5 6 2 5 - -

M42 1.1 3.8 9.5 1.5 1.2 8 - -

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#27

Watch for sales on the better tools

Craig Daymon

I suspect Doug and Dave don't often run sales, but they might.

I have a few of Doug's tools and they are very nice, though I have yet to get a large bowl gouge that would really show the edge holding ability.

My bigger bowl gouges are Sorby, Benjamin's and Crown Pro-PM. I really like the Crown's (they are powdered metal, and I think, cryo as well) and consider them a quality tool. The Sorby does seem to get a sharper edge.

Anyway, with the bigger brands (Sorby, Crown, Henry Taylor, Kelton, Oneway, P&N) watch the different catalogs/companies selling turning tools. Especially watch for close-out sales.

Woodcraft, Rockler, Craft Supplies, Packard, Hartville Tools.

I haven't checked recently, but Hartville had the Crown Pro-PM tools on special for quite a while. Really good prices. I picked up a 1/2" thick, 1/2" square and 1" round nose scraper from Woodcraft a few years back on close out for about a quarter the regular price. Those are really nice and that nice thick steel means I really have to be doing something wrong to feel any vibration. (The scrapers are not Pro-PM tools.) I find Hartville runs turning related sales frequently. Sorby, Crown, Oneway (chucks). I picked up a P&N roughing gouge on special. It's a really sweet tool, but a little pricey. (Though, it should last a LONG time.) Doug made one that surpassed it, but doesn't appear to currently.

Keep an eye on close-outs.

As far as the cheap tools, it's great to have a few BB tools around for special grinds for a specific job. Especially cheap scrapers to regrind. If you are close to the Penn State store, they always seem to have a tub of misfit tools for $10 that you can repurpose. Last time I was there they had diamond (shaped) parting tools. Previously, they had detail gouges. Penn State also sells a, I think 1.5" wide round nose scraper that is a nice 3/8" thick for about $30. Pretty reasonable and pretty thick.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#28

How sharp can they get.

john lucas

I have 7 thompson tools now. I guarantee I can get anyone of them as sharp as any tool in my kit, including the old high carbon tools. I ran a test when I first got the Thompson skew because I had heard over and over that you can't sharpen these tools as sharp as some others, especially high carbon tools. Well I sharpened all the skews I had using the scary sharp system I use for my hand planes. I cannot tell the difference. I used them to shave hair, slice paper and peel up endgrain by hand (not lathe powered). Everyone of them felt the same with the possible exception of the blunter angles and I'm not sure that wasn't just me imagining it.

I have since run the test on my spindle gouge because I have about 5 or 6 2 of which are high carbon steel. These were sharpened on the grinder to 35 degree angle and then honed up to 1200 grit. I can't tell any difference in how they cut.

Some of the tools have harder steel and take longer to hone. At least that's what I suspect, I don't have a way to check the hardness. I hone until I can feel the burr on the inside and then polish this off with a round hone. The harder steels take longer to raise the burr.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#29

Re: I don't buy all that I am reading ...

Dick Wilson

Ed, I don't think anyone, including myself is claiming that Benjamin Best tools are on an equal level with Thompson Tools. In terms of metal quality, maintaining an edge, etc. without a doubt Tompson, Sorbie, and a number of others are better. We are addressing a question from someone who is a beginner, not someone like you or myself with years of experience.

When I teach beginner turners I always tell them to purchase the best quality tools they can afford. If they are strapped because of lathe purchase, go with the more inexpensive tool to get started. There are a lot of makes out there that are garbage. I have used some of them. I think they are made of pig iron. I suggest BB tools. You can get 3 tools for the price on a Crown, Sorby, Thompson, etc. etc. As the person gains experience they can save up for the Cadillac of tools.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#30

I'm Sorry But....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

I just don't understand why so many people, some experienced turners, advise beginners to buy a cheap tool and wear it out learning to sharpen. Learning to sharpen tools simply isn't that difficult. When I'm teaching, a class or one on one, the first thing we do is go to the grinder and work on sharpening. You can't learn to turn until you have sharp tools. I'm sure that I can teach anyone to sharpen turning tools in less than an hour. That's especially true when using a jig.

I say buy fewer tools but buy the best you think you can afford.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#32

Amen to that Wally!!

jorge Castaneda

You said all...

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#33

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Just like my 7 Iron Story...yup

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#34

Re: I'm Sorry But....

Carole Valentine

Wally, some folks (myself included) do not have access to experts to teach us how and we have to just learn by trial and error and sort it out on our own. My first gouge was a (then relatively inexpensive) Packard and I ground off a considerable amount of it before I found a grind that I liked. I still use what's left of it, though it is almost too short for a jig. It was a good gouge and I will give it a respectful burial during which I will ask it's forgiveness for shortening it's life! LOL I only wish that I had had someone like you around to teach me first hand! It certainly would have shortened my learning curve and saved some steel. ;)

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#35

Re: I'm Sorry But....

Gordon Seto

A bowl gouge is not a plug and play tool. On a fingernail grind gouge, the tool edge is not a simple shape. Different portion of the tool edge presented at a different angle can affect the characteristic of the cut. Knowing what gouge(s) to buy won�t help much.

Instead of buying cheap tools, experimenting on your own using the �Poke & Pray� method, I like the suggestion of Joining the AAW local chapter, watching the instructional DVDs as suggested. (Be careful of some U-Tube videos, some of them are good; but some of them are what not to do.) Learn from a mentor, or take some classes. If you are using a sharpening jig, it shouldn�t take you more than 15 minutes to learn sharpening simple turning tools. Learning how to present the sharp tool to achieve good results will take more time, but rewarding.

I didn�t put my teenagers in the cheapest cars I can find and expecting them to learn driving after several crashes. I made sure they had enough driving experience by riding with them long after they had their licenses.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#36

Re: I'm Sorry But....

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Walley, I agree! Sharpening is so easy to do also very mis-understood along with what characteristics to look for when buying a bowl gouge. It can be taught in short time, in the fall I'm going to start giving demos on just that.

Use caution when you surf the internet, everything you read is not there to help you or can be written by someone who started turning last week.

Some tools I don't make all the time because after the materials, labor and tooling are paid it's not worth the effort. BB can manufacture and ship a tool halfway around the world for 12 bucks... amazing.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#37

Steven Antonucci

Save your money on the tools and get instruction!

steven antonucci

Truth of the matter is that most beginners will get much more out of quality instruction than they will out of good steel. If you don't know how to sharpen, or even worse, don't understand what you need to do with a sharp tool to make it work like the demo showed it...

In the end, it doesn't really matter who puts their name on the steel, but much moreso who puts their hands on the steel at the lathe. A good bit of high quality woodturning is done with stuff someone hammered out themselves in their garage...

Find a club... find a class... and you'll find what you are lookng for.

Steve

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#38

Bill Blasic

Re: I'm Sorry But....

Bill Blasic

Wally,

Exactly!

Bill

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#39

Brad Vietje

I'm with Steven...

Brad Vietje

I agree completely.

Sorry, Wally, but as Carole mentioned, many turners -- I'd hazard a guess MOST turners -- either don't have access to a skilled mentor, or don't know that they do have access to a skilled instructor, if they would take the time to attend a few club meetings. And, for some, turning clubs are pretty far away, so attending and meeting acceptable mentors just isn't very easy.

I would agree completely that sharpening is a skill that can be mastered with just a little practice when taught by a skilled and experienced turner. However, Bob was also asking about what grind and/or profile to use, and that takes some practice with a number of different tools to learn. It takes quite a bit of practice time to know how deep-fluted gouges differ from shallower, and what the different grinds will do when presented to the spinning wood.

That's where a club can be very helpful, as there may be opportunities to try out a number of different grinds before investing a lot of money. Learning how to turn, and all about tool geometry can save a lot of time, money, and frustration.

Many turners try out a few different grinds on a given tool before settling down to really know and understand what they want, while others just spend a ton of money collecting different gouges. Once they know what they really want, sharpening and edge maintenance is pretty easy to master. For those who have a skilled instructor, I'd agree with Wally. If one-on-one instruction isn't available, classes are a great option. For the rest of the newbie turners out there, practicing on a less expensive tool is a pretty good option. Then they can buy the finest tool they can afford when they really know what they want.

Lastly, just in case we gave the wrong idea, really good tools are not all that expensive. Really junky tools may cost very little, and they are a complete waste of time. Great tools like Thompson tools, D Way, P&N, and others won't cost very much, and once you know how to maintain them, will last for many years.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#40

Re: Penn State best value

Jim Jakosh

Hi Dick. I agree on the Benjamin's Best tools. I bought 3 of the bowl gouges and use them all the time!!

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#41

Re: I'm with Steven...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Brad, I agree that with no instruction at all a turner has to feel their way to learn how to sharpen. Most of us have had to do that.

I suppose that few turner know that an excellent 90 minute video on tool sharpening is available from AAW. Presenters are Bonnie Klein, John Jordan, Alan Lacer and Bill Johnson. I think that any of us, beginners and experienced turners alike can benefit from watching this video.

Regarding buying low end tools vs. getting the best, when you consider how many hours of turning will be done before wearing out a tool such as a bowl gouge, getting cheap tools is a false economy. Why not enjoy the best.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#42

Buy Quality Tools and You Won't Be Disappointed

Barry

I have not used Benjamin's Best tools. I have used Crown, Crown PM, Sorby, Doug Thompson and CET/Glaser. I have always believed that you get what you pay for and have found that to be true in most cases. In the case of Sorby, I think you are paying for a little more than you actually get. No quarrel with quality though. I have no issue with Crown or Crown PM or Doug Thompson tools. Doug Thompson's hold a nice edge for a long time and are very reasonably priced, in my opinion. I have never found buying cheap tools any of kind to be a good value or a wise decision. I have never heard anybody say, "I wish I had bought a cheaper tool!"