Re: Bowl Gouge to buy
Greg Haugen
Bob,
Do you know about the "sizes" of bowl gouges. My apologies if you already do. English made bowl gouges are size by the flute. English made spindle gouges are sized by the steel. Don't ask me why they're different. It's the English. :-) just kidding about that. ALL American gouges are sized by the size of the steel.
I would recommend, neither. I'd recommend a Henry Taylor or Hamlet. They are the most bang for your dollar gouge. They're english steel, comes with a nice handle and it's as expensive as Sorby. I've recommend going through Craft Supplies, Packard, or Traditional Woodworker.
Personally, I use a swept back grind for everything but finishing the interior of a bowl. I do use 2-3 different bowl gouges with different grinds to turn a bowl, no scrapers for most bowls. For that I use a stubby ground traditional grind. It is more versatile, from cuts to shear scraping, to cutting with just a wing.
Do you have a turning club? Find someone near by to try a couple of theirs. No reason to grind and regrind a gouge before you know what you like.
As far as the gouge goes, Henry Taylor or Hamlet are recommendations.
I do like Thompson's as well.
If you look at Packard Woodworks. The "Packard" labeled tools are Hamlets with Packard printed on the handle. They're a good tool as well.