Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Bowl Gouge to buy

Posts

Bowl Gouge to buy

#1

Bowl Gouge to buy

Bob S

I am trying to decide what type of bowl gouge to buy. I am a complete novice, and will be turning small 7-8" dia. max, bowls. I am thinking 3/8" Sorby, but wonder if a less expensive 'Woodriver' might be acceptable. I also, am confused about the 'fingernail' versus normal bowl gouge, is the fingernail more forgiving for a beginner like myself? If I spend the $ for a Sorby, i'd like to get the best fit.

Thanks,

Bob

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#2

JL

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

JL

I'm mostly a spindle turner - so take what I say with a grain or two of salt.

The best bowl gouge to buy is two of them. One "small" - 3/8" or so and one "large" - 5/8". That way you can "rough" with the large bowl gouge and "refine" with the smaller. I've purchased one of the Woodriver tools and it works reasonably well. I see no reason why the bowl gouge wouldn't be okay.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#3

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

Greg Haugen

Bob,

Do you know about the "sizes" of bowl gouges. My apologies if you already do. English made bowl gouges are size by the flute. English made spindle gouges are sized by the steel. Don't ask me why they're different. It's the English. :-) just kidding about that. ALL American gouges are sized by the size of the steel.

I would recommend, neither. I'd recommend a Henry Taylor or Hamlet. They are the most bang for your dollar gouge. They're english steel, comes with a nice handle and it's as expensive as Sorby. I've recommend going through Craft Supplies, Packard, or Traditional Woodworker.

Personally, I use a swept back grind for everything but finishing the interior of a bowl. I do use 2-3 different bowl gouges with different grinds to turn a bowl, no scrapers for most bowls. For that I use a stubby ground traditional grind. It is more versatile, from cuts to shear scraping, to cutting with just a wing.

Do you have a turning club? Find someone near by to try a couple of theirs. No reason to grind and regrind a gouge before you know what you like.

As far as the gouge goes, Henry Taylor or Hamlet are recommendations.

I do like Thompson's as well.

If you look at Packard Woodworks. The "Packard" labeled tools are Hamlets with Packard printed on the handle. They're a good tool as well.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

Dick Hines

I am not a new turner and use a bowl gouge in most of my turning. As far as I am conserned Doug Thompson has the best tools on the market. Very reasionable prices and great tools. I have 5 bowl gouges and they are all Thompson tools.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#5

Re: Can't beat Doug Thompson

Steve in Durham NC

I agree. Call Doug Thompson, tell him your situation and he will fix your up. IMHO, Doug has the best tools for the $$$. While you are at it, get a handle from him as well.

Steve

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#6

Ditto on the Thompson gouges *LINK*

john lucas

You pay a little more but you get the best steel on the market and it comes with a good grind on it. You can go to his website to see how to grind it using the Oneway Wolverine jig. With this jig and careful grinding the tool will last a very long time.


http://www.thompsonlathetools.com/

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#7

Jim Evans

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

Jim Evans

One of the hardest things for beginners to do is sharpen your tools without grinding them to a nub. I would recommend Penn State bowl gouges as they are M2 HSS and a 3/8" bowl gouge costs about $16.

Then after you get the sharpening down, get a Thompson or other tool. You will also have figured out what tools you will most likely need/use.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#8

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

Fred Holder

Bob,

There are a lot of acceptable bowl gouges on the market. I personally have three 5/8 inch bowl gouges and one 3/8 inch. Mildred also has a couple of Robert Sorby, a Crown bowl gouge. The Crown tools are all Pro-PM tools, which have excellent edge holding power. I also have two bowl gouges from D-Way Tools Inc.here in Washington state. They also have excellent edge holding quality.

But regardless of the maker, the grind you put on the bowl gouge makes a great difference in how well it cuts. Several years ago, I watched David Ellsworth doing a bowl turning demonstration. David stressed that with his grind, you only need one bowl gouge and he recommended the 5/8 inch. I purchased one of his jigs from Woodcraft and ground up a couple of gouges. After I used them, I ground all of our bowl gouges to the Ellsworth Grind.

A number of professional turners do not use a jig to sharpen, they grind freehand. I personally recommend purchasing a jig to grind your turning tools.

I mostly use the Oneway system, but grind all bowl gouges the first time with the Ellsworth Jig.

As I say sharp tools with the proper grind is about 90 percent of the value of a bowl gouge. If you use anything other than an Ellsworth Grind, or something close, you will need two gouges: One with a fingernail grind for the outside of the bowl and one with a conventional straight across grind with a 60 degree or more grind on the bevel.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#9

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I took a bowl class with 3 gouges: 3/8" Crown, 1/2 Packard's, and a 5/8" Woodriver. I used all three in every bowl. The Woodriver required sharpening in one third the time as the others. Buy quality steel, the Sheffields, Thompsons, etc. You want to spend your time cutting, not grinding! Find a turning club as the others have said.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#10

Richard Allen

Penn State best value *LINK*

Richard Allen

Without a shadow of a doubt the Penn State tools are the best value in turning tools today. Doug makes good tools but his tools are not 5 times better than the Penn State tools.

As important as the tool is the sharpness of the tool is more important. You must constantly sharpen your tools. You need a bench grinder with AO wheels (80 grit or so). You also need a jig for sharpening. You should be able to use a sharp tool for years before you have ground away the tool past sharpening.

There are several approaches to learning when to sharpen your tools.

Approach one is to sharpen every 15 minutes of use. You will eventually learn when a tool is dull by doing this and you will be turning with sharp tools almost all the time.

Approach two is to sharpen your tool every time the tool doesn't appear to be cutting right. There are several reasons that you may not be cutting right. One of those reasons is a dull tool.

The third approach is to have two identical tools which are both sharp. When the tool doesn't appear to be cutting as easily as it was, switch to the known sharp tool. You will quickly learn the difference between a dull tool and less than optimal tool usage.

As for size the 5/8" Penn State bowl gouge is a perfect tool to learn with.


Penn State 5/8" bowl gouge

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#11

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Wish I had Known

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I just gave away a PM 3/8 gouge, sorry. It was a pretty good size, maybe my favorite bowl gouge size. I haven't needed it in a few years.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#12

Re: Penn State best value

Dick Wilson

I agree with Richard. I have several Penn State Benjamin Best bowl gouges. I really like them. Of course I am not a grinder. Once in the morning and hone rest of time during day as a rule. At 1/3 the cost of a tool they are ideal for beginners. Also buy one tool at a time. Most people that buy the kits only use 2-3 tools.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#13

Re: Wish I had Known

ken ward

Sorry,but I have to disagree on the comparison between BB and DT I have about 5 of Dougs and about 10 of BB laying on the shelf.In this case,you get what you pay for and IMHO compairing BB to DT is like compairing a yugo to a cadilac.Get a 3/8 an 1/2 and you can do about any bowl turning with them.just get the sharpening jig and its not all that hard to learn sharpening with it.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#14

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

jerhall

Bob,

I agree on Penn State tools but I would definitely recommend you get a 1/2" (steel diameter) bowl gouge for learning and for the size objects you describe.

An AAW mentor is a great first step too.

And look at the first three free Sharpening Videos at http://woodturningvideos.weebly.com/

Get the basic Wolverine sharpening system on sale here: http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2001998/2509/Wolverine-Grinding-Jig.aspx

And finally get a decent grinder. Woodcraft has their fine basic grinder with good wheels on sale now at $90. Really an excellent deal here: http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2080939/29437/8in-Slow-Speed-Grinder.aspx

This is all like buying a 10 cent gold fish. You need a few other things too!

Welcome to turnng!

Jerry

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#15

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

It takes one bowl gouge to turn a bowl... that said learn to turn the right way and keep that tool in your hand until you can use it well. A 1/2 inch diameter V shape bowl gouge will turn most anything you want! Since you are starting out... be a woodturner not a tool collector so buy a video from Bill Grumbine and see how one tool can do it all, David Ellsworth promotes the same. You will see a need for different diameters or flute shapes but wait until you see a need.

We seem to forget what our parents and grandparents taught us... America still makes the best products in the world.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#16

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I will second that notion....

Jesper, Denmark

.... when it comes to turning tools.

It is also the right idea to buy one gouge to start. Once you have a few dozen bowls under your belt, you will have found a way to work and an idea of what you need to have it work better.

Finding a local turning club is also a very good idea. It is amazing how other turners are anxious to help out and show you how to overcome any difficulties you run into.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#17

I don't buy all that I am reading ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

in this thread. Doug Thompson of Thompson Tools and Dave Schweitzer of D-Way Tools produce the absolute best woodturning tools available and these tools are MADE IN AMERICA. And I have put my money where my mouth is. When I hear that the Penn State tools are as good as Thompson and D-Way tools it is like speaker feedback in my ears. Having taken a metallurgy course MANY years ago I know that different steels take and hold an edge differently. If I am to drive from the East Coast to the West Coast and I may choose to drive a Yugo or a BMW, it doesn't take me long to choose the BMW. If I am choosing a tool to use for five years, I know the kind of tool that I want in my hand. As I observe those who choose the Yugo approach I find that I would not take a course from them because they lack discernment and have an unsophisticated view of tools. Good artisans appreciate good tools. I appreciate Doug and Dave and the tools that they produce.

Ed

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#18

Re: I don't buy all that I am reading ...

Bill Neddow

I agree. If you have a poor tool and are having trouble turning because of it, you will not be turning for long. When the Penn State BB gouges became available, I bought five. I have given them all away or ground them up trying weird sharpening angles as experiments. They are good for that. I have put over 30,000 hours at a lathe over the years mainly using a 5/8 inch bowl gouge, and mainly doing production turning. So I know how to use these tools. There is a world of difference between a cheap tool and a good one. Even beginners will quickly appreciate the difference. All my tools now come from Doug Thompson and Dave at D-Way.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#19

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

Bob S

Thanks for all the great inputs. I was very surprised (and glad)to hear that the more inexpensive tools, are adequate for a beginner. I will go with a 'starter' bowl gouge, and if interested, progress to a superior quality. I understand the necessity of fine tools as I progress and appreciate all responses.

I constantly hear that sharpening is key. I should probably 'hone' my skills using the Penn State or similar tool.

As for sharpening: I have a 6 inch bench grinder, with 'Vitrified' wheels? Are these acceptable (36 ^ 60 Grit, Grade M). I could use some advice on getting started learning to sharpen as well. There has been mention of a suitable jig on a few of the earlier posts, and I will look into that.

Thanks to All!

Bob

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#20

Re: I don't buy all that I am reading ...

Wayne Kuhn

Ed, I could not agree with you more. I am by no means an expert however just yesterday I did a demo and one of our members brought along his Benjamin's best tools and asked if I could show him how to sharpen with my wolverine jig.

After sharpening my Sorby and Thompson tools all day, I was amazed at how soft the Benjamin tools felt. They heated up and blued almost instantly and made me change the way I sharpened his tools versus mine. I did get them sharp but for how long?

Wayne

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#21

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

Carole Valentine

Bob,

I agree with buying a good quality gouge. I prefer the Thompsons. 3/8" V is my favorite. (Be aware of the fact that some manufacturers base their size designations on the diameter of the steel (Thompson, for instance) and other base it on the width of the flute.) Have not tried the D Way. A friend had a BB and was unhappy with it as it has sections of steel that appeared to be of a different hardness than the rest of the tool and would not hold an edge in that area. Quality control thing I assume. If you can, get two...a good one (which will make your learning journey much faster and more enjoyable) and an inexpensive one to learn how to use your grinding jig. I might add that you may have stepped into a bigger hole here than you anticipated...unless you are accomplished at tool making, the expense of a lathe is only the beginning when it comes to woodturning! LOL

Regarding the grinder...IMO an 8 inch grinder is far better. The smaller wheel of a 6" grinder puts too much of a concave surface on bevels for me. When buying a grinder, keep in mind the type of sharpening jig you will buy. Some of the new grinders out there have been designed with a wide base that comes out below the wheels which prohibits the use of jigs like the Wolverine. I use the Woodcraft grinder mentioned elsewhere, with a Oneway balancing kit. It is fine. In fact, I have just purchased a second one. I have 80 and 120 grit on my current grinder. Will probably put Norton 3X 60 and 100 grit on the second one.

Lastly, as others have said, see if you can find a local turner or club and get some mentoring. And definitely go to the Oneway site and look for their video on how to use the Wolverine Vari-grind.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#22

Thank you, Bill and Wayne

Ed Moore in SW VA

I don't drink, but if I were to have a glass of wine I am going to listen to a wine connoisseur for a recommendation rather than the fellow who recommends "Ripple", which was Redd Foxx's tv choice. I don't need an expensive bottle of wine here, but I don't want Ripple either.

I would rather see a newbie get a Sorby and work through the sharpening on that than start with steel that is questionable.

Smart people understand probability. If you get a Thompson or D-Way gouge there is a high probability that this gouge will take and hold an excellent edge. If you get a China import you should have a low expectation of the edge-holding ability of this tool.

Ed

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#23

Sorby, Thompson, Benj. Best

jerhall

Wayne, I own and regularly use all three of these brands. My experience:

- Sorby produces the finest, sharpest edge. Can be honed need be for a better edge for special occasions. I will use the Sorby for fine, difficult finish cuts every time.

- Thompson is much tougher, lasts longer, but does not make as fine a cutting edge, and I am not successful honing. Have no idea why, and had a tough time believing it at first. But can tell the difference when running my finger lightly on the edge. Just my experience.

- Benj. Best procuce a nice edge, hones well, is a bit "softer" as you say but does the job just fine. They have lasted me several years. I only do one or two swipes on the grinder with a 120 g wheel and really don't notice going to the grinder any more. Don't have any "bluing" problem the way I sharpen. The steel does stain, and isn't "pretty" after using wet wood so it is different. I use mine for special grinds infrequently used. But I recommend them as a first 3/8 spindle and 1/2 bowl gouge to my students without hesitation. They are a good value that softens the sticker shock of getting into turning. It makes little sense for them to spend 3x as much on basic tools and avoid getting other essential sharpening equipment because of cost. The Benj. Best tools will always be useful later on to hold special grinds as skills develop.

Of course, we would all like to buy the very best quality from the get go, but that is not always practical, nor is the increased cost always in reasonable proportion to the results achieved for those on a very limited budget. Carbon steel tools did the job for many years. And the work wasn't so bad.

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#24

Grindstone

Ralph Lindberg

I would be concerned that a 60 is too course

While a 6 inch wheel works, my experience is that they too quickly wear down so they are too small to use.

This might be one place you want to look at upgrading quickly

Re: Bowl Gouge to buy

#25

Re: I don't buy all that I am reading ...

Ralph Lindberg

Ed

I don't recall anyone saying the BB tools are as good as the great tools. They, and the "good" tools from Harbor Freight are certainly reasonable tools to start with. For a beginner, or someone that will never be a serious turner they offer a reasonable tool for a reasonable price.

Personally I've never used Doug's tools, but that's mostly because Dave is in the same club as me and I can pick his tools up direct from him (which I have).

I can certainly tell the difference between Dave's tools and the cheap ones. But I'm not learning to grind with Dave's tools.

IMO, for learning (grinding, tool shape, etc) the "OK" tools are a reasonable tool for a reasonable price. For serious work, you need the better tools