I'm looking to buy a sharpening system. I've heard a lot of pros and cons about the different ones. Some love them others don't like or never use the one they have. I've been looking at Wolverine, True-Grind, Sharp Fast and the Packard Side Grinding Jig and I'd like some input on any or all of these. Thanks.
The Wolverine is the most widely used, as well as the most widely distributed option. The other systems may be just fine, but if that one distributor stops carrying them it may be difficult to get more accessories. For example, I had some hollowing tools that were made by well known english tool maker. The one place in the USA who carried the tool and cutters stopped. It turned out to be an expensive handle for other tools since I couldn't get the tips anymore. I've used the Wolverine set-up since I started turning. I don't use the wheel dresser (I use a hand held one), or any of the jigs since I freehand sharpen all of my tools, even though I did start with the vari-grind and really liked it but I like the freedom and speed of free hand sharpening. I have the "base" system with an extra platform set up on my grinder.
I haven't used the other systems. Come to think of it, I haven't run into them even as I travel demonstrating and teaching. They've all been the Wolverines.
The benefit the sharp fast has is that won't go off the wheel, but it can't be used for flat front grinds, like a roughing gouge (which is easy to hand sharpen on a platform).
What I don't like about the Sharp-Fast is the bases. They put the platforms below wheel center because they are thicker.
So, if you have the Oneway system with the Sharp-Fast guide, you have a good system.
I've had the Wolverine system since 1998 when I purchased it for my Christmas present. It works very well and even better if you also purchase the Raptor Set-up Tools from Craft Supplies USA. I highly recommend purchasing all five Raptor Tools plus the Wolverine System.
As an aside, I also have a Tormek and a couple of years ago, I purchased the Tormek kit to use the Tormek jigs with the dry grinder. In fact, I purchased two of them to have one on each wheel of my eight inch slow speed grinder from Woodcraft. I also have thw Wolverine system set up on that grinder.
I further enhanced the system by adding two metal frame diamond wheels one in 80 grit and one in 360 grit. I've had these for a couple of years now. The grind from the 360 grit wheel is almost as sharp as the Tormek and somewhat faster.
Of the systems you mention, I prefer Woodcut's Tru-Grind. The Wolverine's V-arm takes up a lot more room -- meaning you'll have to mount your grinder farther from the wall and you'll also need to reserve more room in front of your grinder. In addition, the Wolverine seems to require more jigs to sharpen the full compliment of turning tools most of us have. (The Wolverine uses the V-arm for sharpening roughing gouges, a skew jig for skews, the "platform" for scrapers, and the vari-grind for bowl and spindle gouges. In contrast, Woodcut's Tru-Grind jig is used to sharpen all those tools.) So, the Woodcut takes up less space, requires less storage space, and has fewer items to misplace. Both systems work just as well.
The Sharp-Fast system has many of the advantages of Woodcut's system in that it's compact. In addition, it prevents the tool from falling off the front of the grinding wheel and provides a more solid pivot point when sharpening. The complete system (which is NOT listed on Craft Supplies USA's website) includes several jigs -- in addition to Sharp-Fast's version of the vari-grind jig. These additional jigs allow you to sharpen skews, rouging gouges, and scrapers. They also take up a lot of room in a drawer somewhere.
You didn't mention Tormek's jigs. A few years ago, Tormek introduced a system for using their jigs with a dry grinder. I much prefer Tormek's jigs to any of those you've listed. Having said that, Tormek's jigs are more money and, like the Wolverine and Sharp-Fast systems, there are a lot of jigs to rattle around in a drawer.
I won't express an opinion on any particular commercial system -- each has pluses and minuses, and this is one of those topics where strong opinions can sometimes overwhelm good manners. Be sure to get a system that is quick, accurate and reproducible. The simpler and easier, the better, because you will use it more often, and cut wood with sharper tools for better results.
There's the whole debate about concave, flat, or convex bevels, which, sadly IMHO, doesn't get enough discussion. Once you select a system of shaping and sharpening a cutting edge, you have the hone or not-to-hone debate, and it can go on and on... I use all of the above for different tools that are used for different purposes. I use hollow grinds and diamond hones for many tools (including all spindle turning tools), flat bevels sharpened on a sanding disk for some, and convex tools for finish cuts in the bottom of deep bowls or finishing cuts when reversing and removing the tenon or waste block.
My position on sharpening is that it should be so fast and easy and stress-free that you would not hesitate to take the tool to the sharpener to touch it up before making your very final cut. That way, you get the best surface, and minimize sanding any other heinous tasks... (you can guess that I don't like sanding much...) If it takes a lot of effort, or causes stress, you are more likely to push a tool too far, and wait until it becomes dull. Your aim, I believe, should be to maintain a near-perfect edge, and never let it get dull before correcting it. You should also strive to maintain a keen edge while removing as little expensive steel as possible, too!
If sharpening (OOPS -- edge maintenance) takes a lot of set up or adjustment time, or causes you stress to get it right, I think it can negatively affect your results, your creativity, and your enjoyment of the sport.
Sharpening is good topic to take up at a local club meeting -- not just a discussion, but if possible, a live demo of various options. I suggest you invest in a system you like and feel confident using.
Wow, guys! Thank you all. I truly appreciate the input from each and, as you've all pretty much noted, its my decision to make. Of all the info, which each of you related to, convenience comes to the forefront. Cost, yes, but my take on any of them is that they would need to be convenient to use.
The old saying comes to mind: "If it wasn't for procrastination I wouldn't make decisions at all."
I have a Tormek. I also have an 8" grinder with a Wolverine. I like the Wolverine. It is easy to set up. It provides you with a stable, adjustable base that you can switch from side to side.
I won't get into the Vari-grind or any of the other "jigs" - that is a matter of preference. I really like having a stable base that is better than the one that come on most grinders.
...System is the excellent adjustable tool rest that is included, and I have never seen a good tool rest that came standard with any grinder. I made shorter support "legs" using square steel from Lowes that eliminates the extra long legs that are part of the Wolverine set-up.
Just a comment on accessories for the Wolverine System. Although Oneway makes additional accessories, INMHO only the flat rest and the varigrind jig are needed or even desirable. Skews and spindle roughing gouges are best sharpened using the flat rest adjusted to match the desired bevel angle. Indeed, it is DANGEROUS to sharpen a spindle roughing gouge or a scraper or any other tool having a sharpening angle approaching 45 degrees or more by putting the handle in the pocket of the V-arm. The edge of the tool can be sucked down against the wheel causing a catastrophic sequence of events that will result in something giving: a fractured wheel, a bent tool, a flying v-arm. A friend of mine had that experience. In his case, he had a badly gouged wheel and a broken finger as the tool slammed down onto the v-arm. The only thing that I would add to the basic Wolverine/varigrind package would be additional varigrind units or equivalents each set to a different one of the gouge grinds that are needed. In my own case, I make simple, non-adjustable, varigrind equivalents for each grind that I use regularly.
I should have mentioned that if you wisely decide never to put the handle of a tool in the v-arm pocket to sharpen the tool, you can saw off a foot or more of the v-arm and solve the protrusion problem that someone mentioned earlier.
I own 3 other jigs but they sit in a box as I find the true grind the most user friendly
On our club website www.sawg.org.nz there are some guides that we make up .The ones (yes I brought a set )from the States wont mention names dont work correctly.
Just be careful if you print off the pdf that you make sure your settings are right or it will shrink the images.
The advantage of these is every time I go to the grinder the setting is the same less waste of metal
Not to throw another choice into the mix, but I just had to say that I used the Wolverine system for about 10 years. Then I bought a Tormek as I wanted to be able to sharpen our kitchen knives among other things. I started using the Tormek for my turning tools and it's SO MUCH BETTER. The Tormek jigs are easy and well documented, no more heating up the tips of tools and everything comes off extremely sharp.
I'd highly recommend that you take a peek as I which that I had when I started out - would have saved the cost of the Wolverine and a decent grinder.
Boy, Dennis, he must have done something very very wrong in his set-up to have had that happen. I just use the platform for that profile, but in the past I have used the V-arm many, many times to sharpen the roughing gouge, with zero problems. I'm sure most of the other folks have had the same results. Like any other tool, you need to use caution, I guess...
If properly set-up, with the edge being ground above the centre-line of the wheel, I cannot see how a tool can get sucked down into the v-arm. Your friend must have been leaning on it pretty hard (another no-no).
Don't you think that's a pretty big "if"? Over the years I've heard several turners claim to have had a similar experience. I've concluded that this is NOT a problem with Wolverine's design in that, properly set-up, user error cannot cause the problem to occur. Properly set up, the Wolverine's V-arm can be used safely to sharpen spindle-roughing gouges (SRG).
However, I think there is a design issue in that it's very easy for a user to improperly set-up the V-arm. For example, assume a user sharpens one SRG and then sharpens a shorter SRG. If the user neglects to readjust the V-arm, the shorter SRG may engage with the grinder's wheel at or below the wheel's center line. Bang! Or, if the user fails to lock down the V-arm after adjusting it to produce the proper bevel angle on the SRG. If, while grinding the SRG, the V-arm is knocked out a little from the wheel -- Bang!
Note: I'm not arguing that the Wolverine is unsafe and I didn't list this issue as one of the disadvantages of the system. As long as a turner is aware of the potential issue and uses care to always set-up the V-arm properly, there's no problem. Some may view the issue is legitimate in that the other systems do not allow user inattention to inadvertently cause such a problem.
It definitely can happen, but usually through user error in the setup or something else. It happened to me once in a moment of distraction (in my old shop, I was grinding and saw a snake slithering towards me out of the corner of my eye! My new shop is snake proof!) My SRG is now a P&N which has a round tang and I use it in the colleted Kelton ER handle. That way I can very quickly remove it from the handle for sharpening and I don't have all that handle in the way just inviting me to make a slip. I no longer dread putting my SRG to the grinder.
What happens is that when sharpening is done with the v-arm, the frictional force of the wheel tends to push the tool into the wheel. This, in turn, increases the frictional force, which increases the pressure still more, and so on and on. For nose angles below some critical value, this process strikes a balance and there is no problem. However, for sufficiently blunt angles, the process will feed on itself and the tool will jam. The minimum angle at which this will happen depends on the coefficient of dynamic friction between the tool and the wheel, which in turn depends on the characteristics of the wheel, the tool and on the speed of the grinder.
This concept is easily verified by mounting a tool at various angles and with power OFF, turning the grinding wheel toward the tool by hand. I did this with a square end scraper and found that at 45 degrees of face angle, I could get lockup only by pushing very hard downward on the tool. At 55 degrees face angle the tool would eventually lock with only its own weight. Note that this experiment involves static friction, which generally is less than dynamic friction, so the critical angles for the dynamic case will be larger. How much? I do not know and do not want to run the experiment with my grinder
Regardless of what the critical angle is, it can be inadvertently exceeded by inattention in setting the v-arm, flexure of the tool, or slippage of the v-arm.
Sorry, bad choice of words on my part. I should have said something to the effect of properly set-up and the user is paying attention and using their head. I assume that goes with most of what we do when turning and related activities.
I could see it happening if you sharpen a gouge at a very blunt angle. The sharper angles naturally push the tool up the wheel to achieve those bevels. My spindle and detail gouges are sharpened at 35 degrees and my rough out gouge at 45. All of these are well up the wheel from the center when using the V arm. There isn't any way to get a catch and pull into the wheel when sharpening this way. I'm up about 1:30 or 2 oclock on the wheel.
If you use a really blunt angle similar to what come on some new rough out gouges then you would be sharpening somewhere between 2 and 3. As you know when you get to what I will call 3 oclock it can easily be sucked into the wheel and you get a catch.
I'm a fan of the Wolverine and ONeway system. I don't like the new Wolverine jig which looks an awful lot like the sharpfast or vice/ versa. on a couple of tools when I use the Wolverine jig I like to slide the tool sideways across the wheel. I can't do that with the new Wolverine jig.
I'm with Jamie, I like the flat platform although I modified mine. I milled a slot across it like a miter slot. This lets my homemade skew sharpening jigs slide sideways. It is a big improvement over the oneway skew jig I think. I have one for my oval skew and one for my flat skews. This keeps the bevel consistent. With the Oneway skew system it's very hard to keep the bevels consistent. This isn't a problem at first but after a ton of sharpening the bevels really get off and it takes a while to get them back to the same angles.