What's the best thread size to start learning thread chasing? 12 threads per inch or 20? I'm planing on buying the Crown chasers and wondered if one size was easier than the other. Also any other thoughts and recommendations would be more than welcome.
A happy medium is 16 tpi. You can get enough threads in a short distance to hold OK, but not so many (e.g. 20 tpi) that the threads are so thin as to be fragile and break easily in "chippy" woods. For me 10 or 12 tpi is a bit too 'coarse'.
The finer threads are easier to learn on, because the chaser moves slower across the wood. Speed of the lathe is also important. If your lathe will slow down to 200 to 300 rpm it will be easier to learn thread chasing. Finally, another and perhaps the most important is the type of wood that you use. I highly recommend Boxwood or African Blackwood for learning. Once you master the chasers a lot of other woods will work. I actually recommend using PVC couplings as a beginning material if you do not have boxwood. That gives you and area for both inside and outside threads.
When I started, all of my lathes were belt driven and had minimum speeds of 500 rpm. I spent two years off and on trying to get good threads. Then I reread the Holtzapffel's Volume I where he redefined "Hard Wood". Which was boxwood, African Blackwood, etc. I had some wood that fit that catagorey and turned my lathe by hand to finally get the hang of it and made my first wooden bolt.
Just remember: the number of threads per inch, the speed of the lathe, and the denseness of the wood are all key factors. I personally have a drawer full of chasers that I've accumulted over the last 20 years and use the 16 tpi chasers made by Ray Iles in England the most. I also have them up to 3-1/2 threads per inch and recently did a nut and bolt order useing the 8 tpi chasers, which are way too coarse for a beginner.
Thanks Fred!! I forgot about that PVC trick for practicing in the beginning. slow speed is not a problem with the electronic variable speed and have plenty of African Black wood on hand as well as other very dense woods. So far it seems that 16 tpi is the go to thread. Got to love Wood Central!!!
I have to argue the thread pitch speed. I know it's actually true but in practice I can't tell the difference. As a test one day I ran threads for 1" using 20, 16, 12, and 8. I timed the travel. It is a very slight difference and actually shows up if you make an inch worth. However when you only turn say 3 to 8 or so threads like you would for a box the time difference is so slight you can hardly tell.
That being said I like 16 for the same reasons mentioned above. I have limited experience in this and consider myself still learning. 20 works great in the really good woods for chasing like Boxwood. Not so great in the for me in the lesser quality woods. 16 seems to be easier for me to get a clean thread. In the softer woods I leave the threads a little flatter on top making the threads stronger. With the 20 tPI there just isn't enough thread to do this.
I'm not anywhere near as experienced as Fred, Mark St Leger and Micheal Mocho so take my words with a grain of salt.
I have tried to chase threads with 12 and 16 tpi and the results on most domestic woods was not great. I bought boxwood and blackwood both expensive but the work great. Several years ago Al Crandall from the Central Indiana woodturners posted plans to make a thread cutting jig. I made one and the threads it cuts using a router are perfect with little or no tearout. I've included a link to my response and a picture that archived on WC. I have since made it so it cuts 8, 12, 16 tpi.
I didn't have trouble getting to the site but NONE of the pictures show, just an empty box. Looks like it was created with a MAC. I'm pretty sure I have latest Quicktime but I'll check and make sure. Would like to see this site.
Sorry that the second link didn't work, that site was from 4 years ago and when i saved all my pictures to an external hard drive when I got a new computer they will not open in the frames anymore. I didn't realize that the link was there. If anyone is interested in more info on this thread cutting jig, email me at mfoydelATmac.com, just change the AT with the @ symbol and i will try to get you more pics and info. By the way, I will soon be posting this jig in the classifieds on WC as I now cut my threads on a Rose Engine lathe.
Thanks Mike. I remember this thread from back then and being the tool junkie that I am I wanted to build it but as usual my desires out paced the amount of time and money of the moment. lol One of the reasons I want to learn to do it by hand is that I'm a huge fan of Bill Jones, a 4th or 5th generation British Ivory and Hardwood turner and I want to apply some of his techniques to some of the things I am working on these days. Thanks again and take care.
Thanks John!! Looks like I'm going to go with 16 to start off with and build up the collection from there. Once I get going I'll try to post on my experiences .