Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

Posts

Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#1

Leo Cuellar

Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

Leo Cuellar

Hi All!

After Terry's post about using 2 jaws for holding work of an eccentric nature. I decided that there had to be a way for those of us without massive lathes to take advantage of this application without shaking our lathes & shops to pieces.

My solution was to make a faux jaw to which a counterweight could be attached to even out the forces from having the wood mounted off center.

First picture is of the lathe running with no chuck and my trusty coffee mug sitting on the ways...



You will notice no waves formed in the cup.

Second picture is with an off center blank spinning in the modified chuck...



You will notice a slight wave pattern from vibration. I would not even be able to set the cup on the lathe without the modified chuck!

Third picture is a shot of what the rig looks like while sitting still.



The bolts fit through the weight from the backside and screw into the faux jaw which has been drilled & tapped. This jaw must be the same thickness or slightly thinner than the original jaws so that it does not interfere with level placement of your stock. The bolts must also be no longer than the total thickness of the metal parts plus a lock washer for the same reason.

Fourth picture is a front view of the chuck along with the first set of weights I've made for it. 3/8th" thick steel mounted with 3/8th" bolts.


I've picked up some 1/2" & 3/4" steel as well to make additional weights from, believing that the nearer the mass is to center, the healthier it will be for the lathe and myself in the long run.

Hanging a weight over the top of the spindle was nowhere near as effective as this method. While I could have set the cup on the lathe, most of my drink would have splashed out.

Now I just have to turn some new jam chucks that will clamp into this size jaw.

Comments & questions are welcome as always.

Thank you for your time!

Leo

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#2

Walt Bennett

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

Walt Bennett

What you've done is essentially made a simplified version of what Johannes Volmer created with his oval turning chuck invention. He came up with a much more complex design with sliding counterweights, besides adjustable 'oval-ness'. For just eccentric turning, one doesn't need the oval part, so just a system of counterweights does very well.

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#3

Leo Cuellar

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

Leo Cuellar

Hi, Walt,

No, no "oval-ness" happening in the turning, just the belly. :D The easily adjustable variable weight will happen eventually. Changing the weights at this point is actually pretty easy, though, I'll need to make a few more in between the weights I have. The harder thing is removing the faux jaw when you need it centered. Might warrant investment in (yet) another chuck. :) Got to play around with it a little yet tonight, tried some of those intersecting bowls that Terry does. Those are way harder than he makes it look!

I haven't seen Mr. Volmer's design, I'll have to look it up.

Thanks,

Leo

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#4

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

charlie belden

Considering the far more complicated counter balancing methods out there, you've come up with an elegant and relatively simple counter balance method - that anyone with a hack saw, some files, a drill press and a tap could make. And since the special jaw you came up with doesn't have to hold the wood, the two screws holding it to the chuck don't need to have fingers in the scroll grooves of the chuck that resist jaw rotation - in conjunction with the bolts that hold the jaws.

The photo of the chuck with the special jaw was pretty dark in my browser. I copied that image and used PhotoShop to make it lighter - and then could clearly see how your idea works.

Thanks for sharing such a great idea.

Now if someone comes up with a way of velcroing counter weights directly on the blank - and keeping them there - at 3800 rpms . . .

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#5

Leo Cuellar

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

Leo Cuellar

Sorry for the poor image on that particular shot, Charlie. I should have turned on another light or oriented the chuck a little differently.

Except for the fact that I cheated and used the plasma cutter at work, yes, this can be repeated with tools at most peoples affordability range. I had wondered about machining that ridge into the back, but I don't yet have a metal lathe. The real issue may turn out to be the tolerance that is engineered into the scrolling portion of the chuck. It does creak a little bit being spun up to 500rpm all at once. I'll have to keep an eye on the screws, and swap them out for new ones periodically just to play it safe. For those with EVS who can spin it up slow I wouldn't be as concerned.

If this helps someone else out, its just my way of trying to pay it forward as so many others do here.

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#6

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

Peter Toch

Hi Leo:

Very cleaver and simple to solve a problem, nicely done. Suggestion to add greater "adjustability" to what you have with minimal effort would be to drill an additional pair of holes on you larger counterweights such that you have the option on mounting the weight closer or further from the center of the chuck. With a little calculation you should be able to have a good range of counter-balances in relatively small increments with a minimum number of weights. Additionally you can "stack" your weights using slightly longer bolts to further increase your range of counter-balances.

Peter Toch

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#7

Walt Bennett

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

Walt Bennett

Here's his website. He's got a diagram somewhere on it.

http://www.volmer---ovaldrehen.de/englisch.htm

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#8

Leo Cuellar

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

Leo Cuellar

Thanks, Peter! Yeah, I was also thinking about stacking last night, which is definitely an option others might wish to pursue. Swapping bolts and or adding/removing washers complicates things and slows things down. I'm finding as I get older that things like that irk me. :D But then this was just a prototype.

I've already thought of a few different ways to make it better. Making the outside edge of the weights "aerodynamic" limits the options of easy stacking potential... One could also go a long way with a couple of smooth guide rods and a piece of ready rod & some jamb nuts.

Leo

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#9

Leo's chuck counter weight mod - photo brightened

charlie belden

Thanks to PhotoShop Leo's photo of his modified chuck can be enhanced to make things more visible - see?


Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#10

Leo Cuellar

Thanks, Charlie! Nice editing!

Leo Cuellar

Already working on version 2 of the weights. Might have some brighter pictures at the end of this week. :D

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#11

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

Peter Toch

Hi Leo:

I know exactly what you mean about having too many bits and pieces to deal with. I too am a strong proponent of the "KISS" method. Your comment about a couple of guide posts and all-thread rod with jam nuts has great appeal as it too is simple and yet gives you continuous variability, I like it. Now that you got me thinking, I'm going to have to design and build one for myself. Darn it, just what I needed, another jig! Not sure whether to thank you or curse you for getting me thinking about this. Isn't it both terrible and wonderful to be a tool/jig junkie.

Thanks, Peter Toch

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#12

Talk to Oneway

Craig Daymon

Leo,

I think this is a great idea. I'd like to see Oneway offering the jaws and a set of weights. It doesn't sound like you are interested in going into business doing this (and the market is probably not terribly large), but you might be able to get a return on your efforts by pitching it to Oneway. (Or some other chuck manufacturer, but I have Oneways, so that's who I'm hoping for.)

Great work.

-Craig

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#13

Leo Cuellar

Definitely agree with your last comment!

Leo Cuellar

Peter,

but I think the wonder usually outweighs the terror. When I get a lathe with a larger swing I'll build one like that. What I'm doing for the next one is a straight edged block. I'll through drill & tap the outside edge so that weight plates can be added without having to swap in/out bolts & washers each time a difference is required.

Post a picture when you get yours done!

Safe spinning!

Leo

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#14

Leo Cuellar

Re: Talk to Oneway

Leo Cuellar

Hi Craig,

Thank you, I'm sure that by now someone else is probably already filing a patent on it. Actually if I had more space for a real metal shop, I would be interested in manufacturing these for the various models of chucks out there. However, I really, really, (did I say really?) hate having to do paperwork >( :D As you said, the market probably isn't terribly large for something like this, so I doubt a larger manufacturer would be interested.

Leo

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#15

Leo Cuellar

Had a better thought...

Leo Cuellar

Peter.

If you make two faux jaws to oppose each other, then the jaws don't need to be removed from the chuck if you need to run the piece centered, just the weight pack has to come off. Also, it helps keep the piece flat with a larger "bearing" surface when tightening the chuck. Realized that fact after I'd already "Swiss cheesed" the first jaw in an endeavor to lighten it :D

Leo

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#16

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

Terry Scott

Man if I place this rig on my balancer think of what I would be able to achieve

Leo you are the man watch this space Ive got an idea brewing

On the side I wonder what the chuck manufacture would say to a warranty claim

Sir how did it break ,oh dam thing just fell to bits when i added 10 pounds of hard cold steel to one jaw set l.o.l

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#17

Fly wheel balancer for leo 

Terry Scott



Leo this just popped into my head a very ruff picture before it pops out again

Make a fly wheel as large a diameter as your lathe will spin .On the back make up a steel band or track that counterweights are attached to but can move around like a railway track .Balance and then fix in place

I only know 2 things about steel Its heavy and it gets hot when heated so wont attempt to make it but for a man of your talents it should be simple.

I can put more input into the design if you think it has some merit

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#18

Thanks Terry!

Jorge Casta�eda

Terry,

I have no idea of how to make a round track other than in a lahe, but there must be a way.

Looks like a good solution to me, I have been making some unbalanced pieces myself, after seeing what yo do.

Thanks!

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#19

Leo Cuellar

Now, that is some serious thinking!

Leo Cuellar

Terry!!! For large scale work like you do that would be the ticket for sure. Without having to have the whole works built from scratch...? A large (industrial) pipe flange with short stub and a blind(flat cover) welded opposite the flange on the stub side, might be serviceable with additional machining. Then centered, balanced, bored & threaded appropriately, for your lathe.





This will be quite heavy, and still quite expensive to build... We are currently cleaning out our bone yard at work, so I might be able to acquire some parts to play with, if they are not too badly rusted to be serviceable. Actually, I think a flange from duct work rather than piping would be thinner & lighter for the weight ring portion. First thoughts anyway... give me a couple of days to rummage :D

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#20

Leo Cuellar

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Lo

Leo Cuellar

I think it would be more fun to explain to the insurance agent how the large holes got in the side of the shop.

So far no problems, tested with the second faux jaw added last night. Dropped by the hardware distributor yesterday & bought a whole bag of screws for the jaws. I figure the pennies spent replacing them every few times will be good insurance.

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#21

Leo Cuellar

Wasn't finished with...

Leo Cuellar

my first cup of coffee yet, Terry, when I read that. Now that I've got my head properly screwed on...

Does your chuck have a screw in thread adapter?



If so having a new insert built would be the way to proceed.



I would double or triple the length of the treads where they screw into the body of the chuck. I would also double the diameter of the collar that the tommy bar fits into. Forgive my crude picture editing skills...



The black horizontal lines represent the pathways(holes) for the bolts that will affix the flange to the base plate. I'd do at least 4, probably 6 threaded for the plate mount, indicated by the red vertical lines to whatever diameter you would care to make it. I'd personally lean towards 1/4" to 3/8" alumin(i)um plate for ease of workability. A used large circumference circular saw blade would also probably be a good choice for the base plate. It is rated for speed, but you would have to have the bore changed and the teeth removed. This would best be done by water jet cutter (expensive) as any heat would most likely warp the blade.



Sorry this diagram is so exaggerated & out of scale... I'd have just drawn it, but don't have a scanner. The track & sleeve portion I'd make out of steel, I'd have a fab shop make it up for the appropriate diameter if I couldn't find what I wanted in the junkyard or metal vendors shorts pile. Then space out & weld the coupler nuts to the sleeve portion of the tee. Haven't figured out the "railroad cars" yet though :D

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#22

Leo Cuellar

New mods with a brighter

Leo Cuellar

for everybody.


I decided that straight edged weights would be easier to manipulate as they could be added/removed from the side as needed. The main add on weight is through drilled & tapped at right angles to & outboard of the holes that attach it to the faux jaw. The second faux jaw was added to balance the piece if you need to have it centered in the chuck. All you have to then is remove the weight stack, which will save a little wear & tear on the more fragile threads in the scrolling mount. The weights can be made out of any suitable bar or sheet stock. I chose a 1/2" width for ease of drill & tap with enough meat left over for strength. This chuck is a Grizzly clone of the VM100.

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#23

Re: Wasn't finished with...

Terry Scott

Yep just as I imagined it ,we seem to be on the same page

Wish you lived closer we would have allot of fun playing and designing

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#24

Re: New mods with a brighter

john lucas

Leo I like what you've done. After reading your first post I started thinking about another mod that is easier. Why not use a plate on the backside. You could make a plate that slides over the insert and screws onto the backing plate. (this won't work with open back chucks) Have the plate extend out enough to be able to screw weights in it. With maybe 2 sets of holes and roughly 2" x1/2" steel rods with threaded ends you could add weights anywhere along it's circumference to counter balance things.

Re: Eccentric turning lathe vibration revisited(Long)

#25

Leo Cuellar

Re: New mods with a brighter

Leo Cuellar

Thanks, John, that would definitely be another good way to skin the cat. Check out Terry"s post, "flywheel balancer for leo" & mine, "wasn't finished with..." Terry of course came up with a great idea & I tried to flesh it out a bit.

I also wonder, if one had enough horse power to turn a large flywheel, would you need to do all that much balancing?

I hope you're getting a chance turn a bit more now, can't wait to see what new things you've been cooking up!