Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

The value of multiples

Posts

Re: The value of multiples

#26

Re: Generic is good (for me) because I can adapt

David Walser

Steve,

You ask a lot of very specific and very good questions. I suggest that they might be worthy of their own thread. It would be interesting to get several turners to answer your questions. It might be a good resource for instructors.

Up thread, I said I was disappointed when a basic turning class did not spend much time on spindle turning. Instead, we turned a bowl and, IIRC, a weed-pot. This was a one-day intro to the lathe class taught at a Woodcraft store. I took the class to learn spindle turning techniques because I wanted to start turning pens. (I would have taken a pen making class had one been offered.) My ONLY complaint is that the class did not meet my expectations. I own part of the blame. I could have asked for more details when I signed up for the class over the phone. I didn't because I assumed that I knew what was meant by the brief description I'd read on the store's website. (Part of the reason the description was so general in nature is because the store had more than one instructor for its "intro to the lathe" course and each instructor was free to come up with his own version of the course. So, had I taken the class on another day, I'd have gotten the spindle turning focus I had wanted.)

All of that to say I didn't come to the class with a demand that I make, as part of the class, a particular project. I came with an expectation I'd learn certain skills that I'd be able apply in making the projects I wanted to make when I returned to my own shop. To that end, I expected the instructor to have thoughtfully selected projects for the class to work on that would help us to learn, practice, and apply the skills being taught. I would have considered myself not only presumptuous, but extremely rude, to have demanded the instructor depart from his lesson plan to make a different project than had been planned. (This ignores the not insignificant logistical problems of switching projects at the last minute -- unless the new project can be made from the same blank and with the same tools that were provided for the old project.)

I've seen instructors begin a class by asking what the turners in the class would like to make. This bothers me. Perhaps the instructor can teach the desired skill equally well by turning a candlestick as turning a honey-dipper, but how am I supposed to know that? What I think the instructor hopes comes across as being open to our desires comes across, to me, as being ill-prepared.

I'd be embarrassed to learn that I'd dominated the instructor's time by asking too many questions or asking him to repeatedly go over the same ground again and again. I expect that the instructor has SOME flexibility in his lesson plan, but that doesn't allow him to spend all morning on something he'd thought could be covered in 15 minutes. I also expect that the instructor will need to allocate his time working one-on-one with each of the students -- which means I'll need to wait to take my turn just like everyone else. (This can be an ADVANTAGE of group instruction. While the instructor is working with the others, you can make plenty of mistakes without anyone looking over your shoulder. That tends to make the one-on-one time more productive.)

Lastly, I'm not sure how I'd feel if I felt the class was either too basic or too advanced for me. As I mentioned above, I expect that the instructor will need to allocate his time among the students. If I cannot "get it" within my fair share of instructor time, that's my fault. On the other hand, if I were to breeze through whatever project we were working on, there's no reason the instructor couldn't use our one-on-one time to drill down a little deeper than he did with the rest of the class.

Re: The value of multiples

#27

Steven Antonucci

Thanks.  I've added it to the memory bank...

steven antonucci