Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

The value of multiples

Posts

The value of multiples

#1

Steven Antonucci

The value of multiples

steven antonucci

I used to think that I could never enjoy production work because it would be boring to make the same thing over and over. I'm slowly changing my position on that.

I have been turning small boxes to build inventory for the coming year. I'm going to be taking a run at selling them at a price point, so I am trying to become efficient in making them, but also meet a quality standard. I have a sales goal in mind, and worst case scenario is that a lot of family gets one for Christmas.

That said, I've probably made 20 of these in the past 3 weeks. On average, I think they take about 30 minutes, and occasionally I rethink the process to either improve quality or efficiency, or sometimes both. A small tweak in form because I have access to something through another holding method. A change in the order of operations that results in better grain alignment.

All in all, I think it's been a great learning tool, and I am trying to figure out how to work it into my class that I'll be teaching at Peters Valley in a couple of months.

Any thoughts?

Steve

Re: The value of multiples

#2

Re: The value of multiples

Greg Haugen

I think the value of multiples is an important aspect of learning anything. By doing anything a student will learn something, may be good or bad. It's the next time when they do it that they'll get the feedback and they'll probably learn another thing. "Form" is an excellent example. If a new turner makes 4-5 bowls or vessels and then looks at them all, they'll be able to pick out features or aspect that they like about each one. Then they'll be able to apply that to the sixth. If they only make one or two, they'll learn something but will forget a portion of it by the time they use it again.

When a new turner comes to me with questions about a procedure or method, I recommend a source that is knowledgeable. By that I mean, if someone truly wants to learn how to make bowls, ask someone who makes them for a living (artistic or utility). They know the in's and out's, the ratios that work well, and the mistakes to avoid. Can they learn how to make a bowls from several people, sure. They'll learn more from the person who has done the "multiples".

Self-evaluation is an important tool in shortening the learning curve. "Multiples" can help with form but also definitely the "process".

Re: The value of multiples

#3

Re: The value of multiples

Barry Irby

I have never really sold many turnings. Occasionally I get "into" making something and make a bunch of them, so I get what amounts to a production run going. If you are really getting a run going, you have to have similar blanks. My blanks for small things tends to be scraps. Cutoffs and drops from other projects. I am still trying to get the "most" out of the piece of wood rather than trimming the piece of wood to the size I need for the run of blanks. So, if you are truly cranking them out, I would think you would want to standardise the size. Or you could work on standardizing the steps and process and not some much the size.

Took a class form Richard Raffan. He was talking about making sets of salad bowls. His comment was that if you were making multiples and you were part of the way through the process and realized there was a better way, that you should not change the technique within the set. That if you did it would somehow show up as differences in the set. I doubt that this applies to you, because you are not trying to make identical multiples. You don't really care of there are very slight aesthetic differences.

I do think there is much to be gained from standardizing the process and perhaps from having several lathes that would allow you to move through the steps without having to reconfigure the lathe for each step.

Re: The value of multiples

#4

It was one of the best things I ever did.

John Lucas

Turning multiples teaches you to not waste motions. You know where your going so instead of taking little bites trying to get down to the shape you take big ones and get close quickly. Then you work on refining the shape.

Then there is the shape itself. When you make a bunch of something you really start looking at the small differences in shape. You make little adjustments here and there and get to see them side by side to compare.

I had 2 special orders for ornaments about 5 years back. I thought, wow, I'll make a bunch and sell some to both ladies and have the rest to take to my gallery. I made 50. I was proud of myself. I took them to the first lady and she bought all 50 for her company. Now I was stuck because I had promised the other 2 some ornaments. So I made another 25. by the end I was really getting a handle on the shape of the finials and balls. My hollowing time was cut by 75% and the wall thickness was better. The spindle time was also cut at least in half.

I will do short production runs of my mirrors of about 10 or 12. These are the plain ones so I'm trying to keep the price point down and the only way to do that is to make them fast. I work much better when I make 10 heads followed by 10 handles. After the first 2 or 3 you start getting really quick and the shapes are better.

Re: The value of multiples

#5

Mike Stafford

Practice makes perfect....

Mike Stafford

I know it doesn't seem that I turn anything but a couple of box forms but in reality I turn many different box forms. If I only turned one all the time I think I would go crazy. However turning multiple boxes at the same time improves my efficiency even if their forms are different. I am able to do the same steps on each box one right after the other which helps me practice those operations.

Steve, incorporating boxes into your class can be as simple as moving from an ornament in an acorn form to a simple box. The techniques are similar and one builds skills for the other.

Re: The value of multiples

#6

Re: The value of multiples

robo hippy

Me to my Kung Fu teacher,"Teacher, am I doing this right yet?"

Teacher," 10,000 more times!"

"But teacher, that is what you said last time."

"Well, 10,000 more times!"

We do multiples to perfect our processes. We teach to find out what students do, and how we can speed up their learning process, as we most likely have forgotten the learning process. Observing what they do wrong, and the questions they ask, instruct us more in perfecting our technique.

Efficiency is intelligent laziness. unknown author

robo hippy

Re: The value of multiples

#7

Re: The value of multiples

Lee Buck

Our local sage Dave Hardy says you should make 10 of anything you make. i don't think he meant 10 identical but that after 10 you will have worked through the procedure. I don't know how you incorporate that into a class other than to suggest that your students go home and make 9 more.

Re: The value of multiples

#8

Steven Antonucci

Evolution of my teaching philosophy

steven antonucci

In V1 of the class, I was trying to teach mechanics. Left, right, up, down.

In V1.1 of the class, I tried to introduce objects a carrot. If you learn to make this, then you can learn to make that. What I saw was that it was actually a better means of teaching working methods than the object itself.

In V2, I have an extra day. I went from 2 days to 3 days, meaning I now have the luxury of extending the philosophy from mechanics (rubbing the bevel, cutting vs scraping...), using objects (candlesticks and potentially boxes) to teach design(no ufo's or dog dishes!), working methods (what do you cut first? how do you hold work?), and who know what else?

I may scrub bowls from this year and possibly do it as an afterhours thing only. If you went to a beginner clas and didn't cut a bowl, would you be upset?

S

Re: The value of multiples

#9

I have an imp..p...pppediment

mjonesrdg

There must something in one's genes....something that is not in mine. I might have (probably have) ADD, but I just can't get myself to do repetition. As a kid I mowed lawns...but in varying patterns. Up and back, skip every other pass, diminishing squares, diminishing circles, checkerboard, French checker...you get the picture.

A fella asked me if I could turn three dozen "bullets" for him and he gave me a 50 cal. BMG as a pattern. (It's just a spindle!!) I turned one out in about five minutes and I should have had his order ready in a half day. But no! not me! I had to start adding "lead points", then a little case crimp, then a simulated primer, bronze powder in the shellac, etc., and etc., and when he came back to pick them up, he was a little dismayed. They were all the same form, sure, but you'd be hard pressed to find any three alike.

I think that there is an upside to my affliction. If nothing else, I can say that, unlike many other "hobbies" I've tried, I have never gotten bored with wood turning...and can't imagine that I ever will in my lifetime. I've got at least three projects floating about in my creative cortex that I just can't wait to get going, and by the time I get to the third one, there will be just as many more waiting in the wings.

My hat is off to those of you that can polish your skills with repetitive motion. I accept my fate and my mental imp p ppediments...and if you'll excuse me now, I'm going to the shop to do something I've never done before,(and I am excited).

Mike Jones in Redding, CA.

Re: The value of multiples

#10

Steven Antonucci

Same is relative

steven antonucci

To me, the idea of making production pieces stops at "50 Top Boxes". Much like your bullets, they are snowflakes. Close enough without scrutiny to suggest that they are all the same, but each with enough variation to keep me from hitting myself in the head with a bowl gouge.

I get a kick out of figuring out how to do something "better", even if I already do it pretty well. I haven't gotten as far as John yet, where I am truly doing production work, as I still make them one at a time. I bet I could knock them down to ...

S

Re: The value of multiples

#11

Re: Evolution of my teaching philosophy

Greg Haugen

Steve,

I don't believe "bowls" have to be a part of every class. If they're not involved, people shouldn't be upset either. A very well known spindle turner told me once, "learn how to make spindles before you do anything else. If a bowl turner invited a spindle turner over to their house, the spindle turner could handle it. If it was vice versa, the bowl turner couldn't." After seeing this spindle turner turn a couple of bowls....um...well....it was far from a "desirable" outcome or process. I don't agree with that analogy. I'm a bowl turner, but I'm very proficient with a skew. I do agree with Stuart Batty about how the "fundamentals" of spindle turning are in bowl turning, and vice versa. The main thing with turning is "fun". People are learning if they're making boxes or bottle stoppers, as long as their having fun. The fundamentals are just that, fundamental. They cross over to any style of turning. Everybody has their own method, but the fundamentals usually never change.

Have the projects that you want.

Re: The value of multiples

#12

Re: The value of multiples

Jeff Ferguson

In some of my research (I am an archaeologist) I was looking into material traces of apprenticeship in stone tool manufacture and I came across a lot of literature on ceramic production. Japanese potters historically went through a long apprenticeship involving years of menial tasks before even working with clay on the wheel. They then (reportedly) had to make 10,000 sake cups before any were fired.

Re: The value of multiples

#13

Steven Antonucci

Oof!  Talk about commitment!

steven antonucci

10000 cups before your first sake! Thank goodness my last time with sake was my last time with sake...

It's a long, colorful story... and a lesson learned!

S

Re: The value of multiples

#14

Re: Evolution of my teaching philosophy

David Walser

...If you went to a beginner clas and didn't cut a bowl, would you be upset?

Finally, a question I can answer with some authority! I took a beginning woodturning class in Tucson several years ago. I wanted to learn how to turn so I could make pens. I came back having turned a bowl and I was mildly upset. The guy was a good instructor and, had I wanted to learn how to make a bowl, I'd have been more than satisfied. But, that's NOT what I wanted to learn!

The problem was the description of the class was written in very general terms. Had the description listed the project(s) that would be made in the class and the skills that would be learned, I'd have come away satisfied (or not taken the class). Instead, it said something like: "Intro to the lathe. The instructor will teach basic turning skills and use simple projects to reinforce the skills learned." I thought "basic" equated to spindle turning and that an open form like a bowl was "intermediate" while a hollow form was "advanced".

So, yeah, if I came to a basic class expecting to turn a bowl I'd be upset if I didn't. I'm petty like that. I get upset when my expectations aren't met.

Re: The value of multiples

#15

Re: Evolution of my teaching philosophy

Greg Haugen

David,

I agree. That was misleading. I know when I teach a class, everything is outlined and very clear as to what to aspect. Steve asked if a "basic" class has to be have bowls involved, and I don't think they "have to be", but a list of what projects are going to be taught should be outlined. An instructor is free to teach with any project they'd like, but professional communication needs to be made. When I teach a "fundamentals" class, I progress through projects that includes some spindle projects as well as a basic bowl and later on a natural edge or a calabash bowl (I leave it up to the student as to which one they'd like to turn).

Re: The value of multiples

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: Oof!  Talk about commitment!

Mike Stafford

I don't remember my last time with sake....

Re: The value of multiples

#17

Steven Antonucci

Generic is good (for me) because I can adapt

steven antonucci

Interesting side thread here, but I dealt with it in V1.1 of my class. It's a delicate balance between having someone so focused on making a (Bowl/Pen/whatever) and the goals of the class. I'm always flustered by people who come to a class to "make something" instead of "learn how to make something" and I really don't know how to handle it?

I am personally challenged by the fact that I have two choices: either see them through completion on their bowl (at the risk of the class) or abandon them (at their own personal loss). It's an easy decision to make (I drop the "maker" not the class, but I still feel like should be able to do both (but I know that it is impossible).

How would you feel if the class all wanted to do one thing and you wanted to do something else? Do you blame the instructor? Do you blame the school for being so vague? Do you go off on your own and just suck it up?

Final questions: If you were in a class with a bunch of other beginners, and you are not in the "middle of the class", do you have a problem being "too advanced" for the class or the class being too advanced for you? Would you feel cheated if you had to be the guy left behind because you couldn't handle the work? Would you feel restricted if you were well past the talent in the class? (I deal with both)

As such, I sit on the fence between teaching projects to teach techniques, but not focus on making the project because people get bogged down in making projects. (like the guy who spent all afternoon cutting a 6" bowl that he shattered at the last minute)

Please share your thoughts.

Steve

Re: The value of multiples

#18

Mike Stafford

Re: Evolution of my teaching philosophy

Mike Stafford

I start my box turning classes with small lidded bowls turned from face grain. Doing this allows me to assess the skill level of each student and hopefully help him/her get ready for end grain boxes later in the week.

This way students get to use a variety of tools and everyone knows that the more tools you use the better turner you are.... :b ;)

Re: The value of multiples

#19

Steven Antonucci

Does the bottom of a small box count as a bowl?

steven antonucci

I reread the course catalog description and it does say bowl in it, but if you read my other post, you will see my angst about saying we're making something instead of using the objects as learning tools.

Personally, I'd have the students cutting 10 small bowls to take home and finish at their leisure. I am constantly surprised how long it can take to remove the inside of a 4" bowl.

Steve

Re: The value of multiples

#20

Steven Antonucci

More tools doesn't work for PV

steven antonucci

Each lathe has a set of 8 basic tools, usually all ground to some ridiculous profile. We usually start by making fun of how much abuse the tools take and then fixing them all. I try to work with one tool at a time, so that I am only dealing with one issue at a time.

By the end of the second day, someone has put the bowl gouge in the spidle rouging gouge set-up, and hence we have completed the Circle of Grinds.

Steve

Re: The value of multiples

#21

Steven Antonucci

I don't either, but thankfully my buddy took pics

steven antonucci

It is safe to say that it is something to this day that even the smell of sake sends violent waves of convulsions through my system, just in case I think about doing it again.

I think my picture is still hanging at the Golden Sakura with a reward notice.

Steve

Re: The value of multiples

#22

Re: Generic is good (for me) because I can adapt

Greg Haugen

To me teaching is multi-tasking, especially in a "class" setting. This is also why it's so important to have everything laid out in advance and to go by it during the class. If it's a "basics" class and a someone who is in it is much more advanced it's not the instructors fault. The class cannot be sacrificed, that's key. I'll try my best to challenge a "stand out" within the class's criteria. If we're turning bowls, make it thinner than the others, practice your cuts, as I rotate around I'd possibly show them how to roll a bead on the outside. Again, if the class is laid out well and it's being followed, the class can't be sacrificed and they need to know what they're signing up for. On the flip side, if someone is having troubles, if they'd like I'd offer to work with them on breaks or a shortened lunches. Still keeping the class together.

Class size is a key too. At a certain size, assistants are nice to have available. If someone is struggling, I'd have assistant help out with them while I was with the others, but would still make a point to rotate around to everyone equally.

Putting myself in these shoes, I'm pretty laid back. I've taken a small group to a "big name" turner's house a couple of times for a hands on session. I was a part of the group, but more advanced than the others. When I caught class, I helped the others or did a little more with that technique. I knew going into it, it would be that scenario. I was thanked by the turner later for the extra help since a couple of the others were struggling hard. I still learned a lot and had a lot of fun. Everybody got something out of that day and it was a lot of fun.

Re: The value of multiples

#23

Re: Does the bottom of a small box count as a bowl

Greg Haugen

Steve,

Let me ask you this. How is it different turning a "bowl" compare to turning a "box"? You say you have "angst" against a project but a box is a project.

When I teach, it's close to a demo. I don't sand or apply a finish in a demo. It's a demo. It's not a finish "project", it's the "techniques" that get you to the project. My demo pieces are given away and I'll usually have a "Finished piece" that will be auctioned off to help the club further. I'll instruct and go over the theories and procedures that I use to sand and finish. When I teach it's the same thing. It's not a finished project, it's the techniques that will get them to the project. I'll teach about the sanding and finishing.

Re: The value of multiples

#24

Steven Antonucci

Good question: my answer

steven antonucci

When I teach, I start explaining that wood grain runs in one direction in spindle orientation. The only thing to remember is start big and cut to small.

When you flip the wood to bowl orientation, you cut foot to rim on the outside, and rim to foot on the inside. Nine times out of ten, that bowl is coming out of the chuck, and going to have to be recut on the outside to run true again. 8", 7", 6", 5"... and hence we finish with a 4" bowl.

If I switched to an end grain box with a "lower" bowl, I can have them make a top, sneak up on a fit, teach a jamb chuck, and odds are...hold on to that piece of wood through all but the most horrific catches. It's also going to be a lot easier for them to divest in a smaller piece of wood that only took 5 minutes to get to a point, rather than a bowl which may have taken an hour (in theory).

My thought is to move side grain to the final day if we get some interest in it, or to demo it after classes but try to really sink in the "spindle turning" concepts.

Steve

Re: The value of multiples

#25

Re: The value of multiples

charlie belden

I seldom do the same things twice, lidded boxes being an exception. But I do keep notes - to myself. And if I need them in the future - I�ve got them. And if they have holes in them - I revise them - for the next time.

Production is about standardization and process.

By standardization I don�t mean each piece has to be identical - only critical dimensions need to be the same - give or take a smidge (a term that drives machinists nuts). So you need tools that let you quickly check critical dimensions. The time spent making templates to do that pays off - if you�re making a dozen or a gross of something. If you have a ton of money - having a half dozen inside and outside calipers - each preset for a specific operation will substitute for shop made templates.

It�s the process that you REALLY need. GET THE PROCESS ON PAPER. This is really important when it comes to things like lidded boxes. Skip a step or get the steps out of order and you can box yourself in - figuratively speaking. Turn a tenon off at the wrong time and you have no way of holding the part for a necessary operation downstream in the process.

With lidded boxes there�s a lot of chucking and reverse chucking and towards the end you have to put the lid and box together and �blend� their outsides together. If you don�t get the order of things right you can waste a lot of time - and materials.

Which gets us to tooling - especially chucks - and chuck jaw sets. Each jaw set has specific �best� inside and outside diameter. By �best� I mean best gripping strength - and least �marring� effect - you don�t want any evidence from the chuck in the finished piece. That �best� I.D. and O.D. IS NOT with the jaws fully closed and definitely not fully opened.

The jaws are created round - as one piece - then cut apart into four pieces. So the �kerf width� creates a gap between adjacent jaws when they create a near perfect circle. You want to have those jaws grip our wood all the way round - for holding power AND to avoid marring your wood. So check you�re manufacturer�s specs for I.D. and O.D. for the jaw set(s) you plan on using - and WRITE IT DOWN - then use them to make the jaw set template(s) for checking diameters - of tenons and openings for the lid and box.

Then there are the tools for removing wood.

Remember, we�re playing with DRY wood when doing lidded boxes. DRY wood is harder to turn than wet wood and just seems to take longer. For lidded boxes, a few forstner bits and a jacobs chuck to put them in - that fits in your tail stock - will save you a LOT of time - both for hogging out wood - and sharpening time. Save the sharp turning tools for tuning things, not beefing out wood. The forstner bits needed are dictated by the jaw set(s) you�re using - and they should be undersized to allow for �tuning� with turning tools. Put tape or a Sharpe pen line on the shank of each bit - for depth control. (NEVER guess how deep you�re drilling because you WILL guess wrong - ocassionaly)

With lidded boxes with �continuous grain� - you want to remove as little wood as possible where the lid and the box come together. A nice thin parting tool is essential in this case - preferably a SHARP thin parting tool. A fine toothed japanese pull saw works pretty good for me - when I saw in a straight line - that�s square to the long axis of the lathe.

Set ups to do an operation take time - the right chuck, the right tool rest height, the right tools (turning tool and measuring tool, bit, jacobs chuck etc.) Set up once - do ALL the parts that need that set up - and then move on to the next operation and set up. Batch processing will save you a TON of time - IF you have a process and procedure that works. If you don�t - it can create a lot of parts - that are the same - but wrong.

Production work is also about efficiency. Time spent hunting for a tool, or finding a place to put it when not in use is wasted time. Have only the tools you need at hand - and handy - get everything else put away - and out of the way.

You�re going to have a lot of parts. Where are you going to put them - and how are you going to keep them from rolling off and ending up under something heavy - and next to something that bites� stings, stinks or all three?

Another thing to work out is how to keep track of parts. With boxes you need to keep track of which lid goes with which box. A dozen lids and a dozen boxes - turned from the same wood look pretty much the same - til you put a pair together and the grain doesn�t liine up. Playing the �Well THIS lid ain�t the one for THIS box� game ain�t something you want to play. You can�t write on the parts - cause you�ll likey turn off the writing - and you sure as hell don�t want �18a� visible on the finished piece. Consider �post-it� dots you can write on and stick on parts. They go on and off nicely - and leave no evidence behind.

Think about Parts Control.

Production work CAN crank out a lot of pieces, each taking much less time than a One Of A Kind - if - you�ve got a process and procedure down pat - AND all the tools needed.

Personally, I prefer to Wing It most of the time - but I do makes notes to myself - for possible future use. I hate repeating mistakes.

I�ve posted this link before - but something like this might be of use to anyone considering doing a bunch of lidded boxes.

http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Turning/TurnedBoxes/TurnedLiddedBox1.html