Re: The value of multiples
charlie belden
I seldom do the same things twice, lidded boxes being an exception. But I do keep notes - to myself. And if I need them in the future - I�ve got them. And if they have holes in them - I revise them - for the next time.
Production is about standardization and process.
By standardization I don�t mean each piece has to be identical - only critical dimensions need to be the same - give or take a smidge (a term that drives machinists nuts). So you need tools that let you quickly check critical dimensions. The time spent making templates to do that pays off - if you�re making a dozen or a gross of something. If you have a ton of money - having a half dozen inside and outside calipers - each preset for a specific operation will substitute for shop made templates.
It�s the process that you REALLY need. GET THE PROCESS ON PAPER. This is really important when it comes to things like lidded boxes. Skip a step or get the steps out of order and you can box yourself in - figuratively speaking. Turn a tenon off at the wrong time and you have no way of holding the part for a necessary operation downstream in the process.
With lidded boxes there�s a lot of chucking and reverse chucking and towards the end you have to put the lid and box together and �blend� their outsides together. If you don�t get the order of things right you can waste a lot of time - and materials.
Which gets us to tooling - especially chucks - and chuck jaw sets. Each jaw set has specific �best� inside and outside diameter. By �best� I mean best gripping strength - and least �marring� effect - you don�t want any evidence from the chuck in the finished piece. That �best� I.D. and O.D. IS NOT with the jaws fully closed and definitely not fully opened.
The jaws are created round - as one piece - then cut apart into four pieces. So the �kerf width� creates a gap between adjacent jaws when they create a near perfect circle. You want to have those jaws grip our wood all the way round - for holding power AND to avoid marring your wood. So check you�re manufacturer�s specs for I.D. and O.D. for the jaw set(s) you plan on using - and WRITE IT DOWN - then use them to make the jaw set template(s) for checking diameters - of tenons and openings for the lid and box.
Then there are the tools for removing wood.
Remember, we�re playing with DRY wood when doing lidded boxes. DRY wood is harder to turn than wet wood and just seems to take longer. For lidded boxes, a few forstner bits and a jacobs chuck to put them in - that fits in your tail stock - will save you a LOT of time - both for hogging out wood - and sharpening time. Save the sharp turning tools for tuning things, not beefing out wood. The forstner bits needed are dictated by the jaw set(s) you�re using - and they should be undersized to allow for �tuning� with turning tools. Put tape or a Sharpe pen line on the shank of each bit - for depth control. (NEVER guess how deep you�re drilling because you WILL guess wrong - ocassionaly)
With lidded boxes with �continuous grain� - you want to remove as little wood as possible where the lid and the box come together. A nice thin parting tool is essential in this case - preferably a SHARP thin parting tool. A fine toothed japanese pull saw works pretty good for me - when I saw in a straight line - that�s square to the long axis of the lathe.
Set ups to do an operation take time - the right chuck, the right tool rest height, the right tools (turning tool and measuring tool, bit, jacobs chuck etc.) Set up once - do ALL the parts that need that set up - and then move on to the next operation and set up. Batch processing will save you a TON of time - IF you have a process and procedure that works. If you don�t - it can create a lot of parts - that are the same - but wrong.
Production work is also about efficiency. Time spent hunting for a tool, or finding a place to put it when not in use is wasted time. Have only the tools you need at hand - and handy - get everything else put away - and out of the way.
You�re going to have a lot of parts. Where are you going to put them - and how are you going to keep them from rolling off and ending up under something heavy - and next to something that bites� stings, stinks or all three?
Another thing to work out is how to keep track of parts. With boxes you need to keep track of which lid goes with which box. A dozen lids and a dozen boxes - turned from the same wood look pretty much the same - til you put a pair together and the grain doesn�t liine up. Playing the �Well THIS lid ain�t the one for THIS box� game ain�t something you want to play. You can�t write on the parts - cause you�ll likey turn off the writing - and you sure as hell don�t want �18a� visible on the finished piece. Consider �post-it� dots you can write on and stick on parts. They go on and off nicely - and leave no evidence behind.
Think about Parts Control.
Production work CAN crank out a lot of pieces, each taking much less time than a One Of A Kind - if - you�ve got a process and procedure down pat - AND all the tools needed.
Personally, I prefer to Wing It most of the time - but I do makes notes to myself - for possible future use. I hate repeating mistakes.
I�ve posted this link before - but something like this might be of use to anyone considering doing a bunch of lidded boxes.
http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Turning/TurnedBoxes/TurnedLiddedBox1.html