Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

sharpening Hunter tool cutters

Posts

sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#1

sharpening Hunter tool cutters

john lucas

I called my best friend today and while we were talking he mentioned that he was going to try and sharpen his Hunter #3 cutter and wanted to know how I would do it. I thought I would give it a try. I had a #4 cutter that was getting dull As bad as the edge looked under magnification it still cut pretty good.



I center drilled a rod and tapped it for a #4 Torx screw. Then I installed the cutter on the rod. I put this in my chuck and and then flattened the end with a diamond hone to get rid of the chipped edge. Then I took a diamond ball cutter and put it in my dremel. I spun the cutter in the lathe while cutting the inside with the diamond ball cutter. This dished it out about the same as the Hunter cutter is originally. Then I used various diamond hones to clean up the outside.

did it work. No. The ball diamond cutter left way to course of a finish and chipped the edge. The edge chips were smaller but I also ran into a problem of the jig with the Hunter cutter not running true. It was close enough you couldn't really see it but when grinding with the ball it left about 1/3 of the edge still flat. I ground until that was gone and then cleaned up the outside again. Here's a photo of that edge.



Now if you look at both cutters you will see the problem. Notice how shiny the hew Hunter cutter on the right is. That's why they cut so clean. That and the recessed inside which gives the cutter an sharpness angle of close to 25 or 30 degrees. I tried polishing the inside with a green grinding cone in my dremel but it didn't even touch it. I also tried the pink and blue stones and they didn't do anything either.



Did it cut. Not really. It left a rough finish like using a scraper. In this photo the outside was done with the new #4 cutter and inside was done with the sharpened cutter. As you can see, it wasn't worth the effort.

I have another #3 cutter so I'll just give that to my friend tomorrow. It sure was nice to get in the shop again. I needed a break.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#2

Steven Antonucci

What I would try...

steven antonucci

I think you need to try it again :)

Here's what I'd do. Place the cutter in the drill rod on a drill press, and put your diamond surface on the table. Hone the egde until it is flat all the way around. It will not be sharp at all at this point.

Then go back to the lathe and run you hone on the outer surface until it comes to an edge again. You should reduce the diameter of the cutter, but not touch the inner face at all. Slow and wet to keep the edges from chipping, and the diamond stone cutting.

If this work, you might get 3-4X out of each cutter. There has to be a way to do it, since they come sharp...

Steve

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#3

Re: What I would try...

john lucas

Steve I tried that. Even with the course diamond hone it would not remove enough metal to get down to the sharp edge. Then I tried creating a short bevel on the outside to meet the inside. I think all that did was cause more chipping of the edge.

I should tell you that I have been using this cutter for 2 years and letting others use it when they come over to the house. It still had life in it before I tried to sharpen it. I think that is easily worth the cost of a new cutter. Especially when you figure that I failed pretty miserably to sharpen this one. I may try again tomorrow. I'm going to put it back in my jig and chuck it up in a handdrill. Then I will take it to my grinder with the green wheel that I use to sharpen carbide cutter. Maybe that will work but I doubt it.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#4

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

woodspinner

The Sorby articulated tip hollower has a HSS cutter shaped like the #4 Hunter.They use a system like you have only the cutter can rotate on the shaft.They push the cutter (hand held ) against the grinding wheel and let the cutter spin against the wheel.you just keep the cutter on that side angle and the grinder spins and sharpens it. I would try this against your carbide grinding wheel.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#5

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters *LINK*

Mike from St. Clair Shores

John, Here's a link to th accu-finish sharpener for carbide


Accu-finish

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#6

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

john lucas

The Sorby cutter is flat on top so the cutting edge is very blunt in comparison to the Hunter. The Hunter cutters are also to small to hold by hand against the grinding wheel. I used to make scratch awls and tapered the points using the drill and grinding wheel so I know that will work as far as quality of shape is concerned. thanks for the suggestion however.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#7

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

john lucas

Now that is a cool machine, I want one. I couldn't find a price and based on what I see I'm pretty sure it's not in my price range. :) Although it wouldn't be totally out of character to spend $300 to save $20 on a tool that should be thrown away. I would just figure out some other way to justify the cost and tell myself it would pay back. My biggest problem right now is no space in the Garage. The new motorcycle needs a home and I'm going to have to (no not that) sell a couple of lathes. There I said it out loud. It wasn't as bad as I thought.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#8

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

morris

go to Carbide Depot. com and click on inserts. Is this the same one that people are charging $20.00 each? I thought I would some and screws and attach to a bar and save $150.00?????

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#9

Alan Zenreich

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

Alan Zenreich

John,

According to their web site, the Accu-Finish One with one wheel list at about $650. A similarly equipped Accu-Finish II model costs about $1,350.

Later today I'm going to attempt sharpening/lapping the flat surface of an Easy Wood Tools radiused square carbide bit with 3M diamond film wheels on our Jooltool. This will be my first use of these wheels, and I'm hoping for good results.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#10

Let us know how it goes.

john lucas

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#11

possibly the RCMT but I'm not sure

john lucas

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#12

I just bought a

Terry Quiram

CutterMaster for sharpening end mills. I think it might work for sharpening the Hunter style cutters. I will need to experiment. Anyone have any worn out cutters they would donate for experimentation purposes? If I am successful I will return it to you no charge.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#13

Jim Evans

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

Jim Evans

I have one of the carbide depot cutters and I just bought a Hunter tool, and I can tell you there is a lot of difference between the 2. After looking at prices and performance I would recommend the Hunter.

The cutters that you buy from places like carbide depot are more of a scraping type cutter, where as the Hunter is more of a cutting type cutter.

By the time my Hunter gets dull I will have more than paid for the cutter and would buy a new one rather than messing with trying to sharpening it.

At my age I don't have time to try sharpening a cheap cutter to begin with. :-)

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#14

Re: I just bought a

Richard Galloway

I have a bit I'll let you try sharpening. Just need to know where to send it...

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#15

Lyle Jamieson

Re: What I would try...

Lyle Jamieson

I have had a very high tech shop that specializes in maching parts for Navy guns, try to sharpen it. This was on a half million dollar machine. He could not get the factory edge back, not even close. This stuff is so hard and so brittle, it can not be sharpened. It is manufactured under high pressure and high heat. You can tell the Hunter, nonograin carbide by the shinny surface compared to the old carbide that is dull gray. The replacement cutters for my system are only $20.00 and that is cheap when you think of how long they will work til they need replaceing.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#16

Jim  I agree- the price is worth it.

john lucas

If you divide the price of the cutter by the number of boxes and bowls I've either turned of used it to finish cut, it's pretty cheap. Like I said I got 2 or maybe even more years out of this bit and it was still cutting pretty well even though the edge was obviously chipped. There's an awful lot of work gone through that tool.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#17

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

Bill Howatt

Your experience mirrors what I was told by a machinist who turns and makes various turning tools as a sideline. I asked if I bought a carbide cutter intended for metal working would it work like a Hunter or similar. His replied it was not worth the bother; I'm sure he'd tried it.

Bill

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#18

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

John Jordan

What new motorcycle?

I would buy new cutters. I sharpen a fair amount of different carbide tools for my machine tools. I wouldn't try with these, the reason they work pretty well is the precision with which they are made.

What new motorcycle? Why didn't I know about this?:) I've bought more this week.

John

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#19

Bill Blasic

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

Bill Blasic

John,

Keep the lathes and park the bike in the living room?

Bill

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#20

Re: Jim  I agree- the price is worth it.

Barry Irby

I talked to Mike about the cutters and the tools. Told him that I had a catalog of the cutters that was about fifteen years old and that back when it was new I had invented tools like his, in my head, but never got around to making any. He explained that I would have been disappointed a stymied. That at that time the quality of the carbide simply was not there. the material was too coarse and since them they have come along with micro grain carbide and now nano grained carbide. His point was that without the right material and right tooling to sharpen it, its a lost cause.

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

#21

Re: sharpening Hunter tool cutters

Steve worcester

Over the last year, in my own research to develop a carbide tool, and having now given a lot of feedback to Mike about what I want in a tool, I can tell you his cutters are unique. They wouldn't work for metal cutting anymore than a metal cutting insert would work for woodturning. Inserts have several different traits that are unique to their application from the hold down holes diameter and fit of the screw ( needs to fit perfect so when you torque down the screw it doesn't shatter the insert or allow chatter) to the chip clearance, like the flute profile of a gouge, and polish of the cutter. While you might be able to attach a Carbide Depot insert to a Hunter tool, it definitely doesn't performs as well. I tried it.

You might be able to sharpen the cutter if it doesn't have chips, by diamond hones or even some patience on a Tormek, if it's chipped, toss is and by a new insert.