Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

What compressor for a shop with people?

Posts

What compressor for a shop with people?

#1

Steven Antonucci

What compressor for a shop with people?

steven antonucci

I have a 26 gallon Kobalt that isn't rated for continuous operation and really isn't good enough for sand blasting. I'm looking to upgrade to a unit with more juice that doesn't sound like a big pancake compressor. The noise is killing me.

What do you recommend?

Steve

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#2

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

If you want quiet go with a rotary... I have a 5 hp CP with a air dryer. You can stand right next to it with it running and hold a conversation.

The 3 hp without a air dryer is very affordable plus a rotary recovers very fast.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#3

Steven Antonucci

Ballpark cost and any brand recommendations?

steven antonucci

and any brand recommendations.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#4

Define "Affordable", Doug

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The lowest price I've seen on a rotary screw unit was somewhere north of $4,500! That's a bit of overkill for most small shops

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#5

Re: What compressor

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Steve,

This very much depends on need. How many people? How many drawing air at the same time? What air tools and SCFM needs?

You will always have to pay for "quiet" so you need to set some $$limits as well.

If you can locate the compressor outside of the workspace (other than in another part of the living room :D ), you can save major bucks on a cost/benefit analysis.

m

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#6

Chuck Jones - West TN

Ingersol Rand 80 gallon, 2-stage *LINK*

Chuck Jones - West TN

One quiet enough to not interrupt conversation in your shop may be hard to find.

I built a very small "shelter" (~3'x4') behind and attached to my shop for it. The sound is barely noticeable in the shop. It would not be as bad as my pancake even if it were in the shop. With the larger tank it kicks in very infrequently. I have had mine at least 5-6 years and am completely satisfied with it.

This unusually cold winter has made me realize I need to enclose the shelter and put a light bulb in it before next winter. There were several mornings when it would not start until I used a heat gun to warm the oil. (There were some mornings this winter when I did not want to start either.)

I bought mine at Tractor Supply and they still carry the same model.


Tractor Supply

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#7

Re: Define "Affordable", Doug

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

A 3hp rotary without a dryer is about 3,600. We tend to buy the cheapest and replace the item in a few years, over time buying something good in the first place would be cheaper. For example how many buy a cheap grinder then put money into it get it to work better, a good grinder in the first place would cost less. Getting back to the subject a rotary compressor is quiet.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#8

Re: Ballpark cost and any brand recommendations?

Don Evans

Steve:

I have a unit from Northern Hydrolics that is:

80 gallon tank

2 stage

19.2 cfm at 90 psi (this is with air in tank & pump running)

15.9 cfm at 90 psi (this is with empty tank and only pump running)

You'll probably never do anything that empties the tank, in other words if you start with full tank the pump will keep up with what u are doing, this is considering our line of use.

It is 175psi and set to start pump when tank drops to 145psi.

I got it on sale for $1000.00 but normal price is (was) $1200.00

I run dental carvers with it, sandblast and have never had any trouble with running out of air.

I don't carve or sandblast every week so normal operations like using it to blow dirt, blow water off things to dry them and other minor things I leave circuit breaker off and only turn it on once a week to refill the tank, then turn breaker back off. By the way, don't turn breaker off while it or any compressor is running as most will not bleed pressure off top of pistons. It will if you turn it off with switch on the unit located on the pressure valve.

I've been really happy with it, it is much quieter than the oilless units. Of course if you want a name and pay for it a Quincy is the way to go. I also have it housed in a small room in corner of shop that was built just for the compressor so noise isn't problem.

I'm not familiar with the rotary Doug mentioned but can see how it would be quieter. Cheaper to build and sound proof a room

This unit came with an A.O.Smith motor 5hp which is excellent made in USA motor.

Don't forget to get regulators and filters that will handle the 175psi.

Don

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#9

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

Bill McWhirter

I have the 80 gal. Kobalt that is "OK," but I would not get it again. Repairman that fixed a warped gasket said that to keep the price down, Kobalt used small pistons and runs them faster than the better compressors. Hence, a lot of heat. You get what you pay for. I have it outside in a shed so noise is not a problem and I have never run out of air.

One of the best things that I did was to get hydraulic lines for the short runs from the compressor to the filter and filter to the copper line, etc. I could never get band clamps tight enough to stop leaking.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#10

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

Steve Worcester

A little less expensive ($2700 delivered QP318VE) than the rotary, maybe a little louder is the QP series from BelAire.

http://www.belairecompressors.com/p_qp-quiet-performance.html

I have had mine for about 8 months and love it. It is in the corner of my 2 car studio. It looks like Dark Helmet, considerably quieter than a standard upright, but is pretty quiet. If you are in N Texas you can come by and see it.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#11

Steven Antonucci

Reword my requirements

steven antonucci

OK... so $4500 is out of the question.

Here are the basic needs I am trying to fulfill.

I have a 26 gallon Kobalt that has served me well, but is noisy. I am OK if I hollow, since I run it for a few minutes and then can blow out chips all day long. If I am using a rotary burr, I can limp by running it every 5 minutes. Sandblasting will cause it to run continuously and the noisy is horrific. I get 6CFM according to the documentation.

I'd like to get something that is rated to run continuously and probably double the CFM. I plan on having it in the corner of the shop, and if it runs with the decibel output of my lathe instead of my router, that's perfect. I've seen the Ingersoll Rand units at Tractor Supply, and wondered if that's the way to go (<$1000).

I don't think I'm going to run any plumbing, just a hose that I clip in where I need air.

Sandblasting and rotary carving are the two major uses I foretell.

Steve

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#12

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Reword my requirements

Lyle Jamieson

Two things important to me when I got mine. I use die grinders a lot to carve. I wanted an oil bath model. They run slower with larger pistons. The winney oil-less models will drive you crazy. The slower the pistons drive the longer it will last. 60 or 80 gallon tank and high CFMs. OK three things. I ended up with Ingersol Rand 7HP, 220, for much less then $1000.00, Maybe half that on sale.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#13

Re: Reword my response

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

That's more better.

I've had a 3hp (real) IR SS3L3 in may garage for better than 5 years now. It puts out 12 SCFM, and I use it for air tools (carver, drills, impact gun and ratchets), spray finishing, clearing turning waste, cleaning tools, and blowing mud and snow off my boots ;) . IR service was outstanding when I had the pump go bad, got a new pump installed plus a new pressure-trol that raised by operation range (105-145 psi) and I have never run out of air. Would I buy it again? At $650 delivered into my garage, shoot YES!

However (there's always one, right?), as the prices on their units have comedown, I go for a 2-stage Quincy 5 hp, 60 gal. if I had my druthers, which will put out 16 SCFM at 90psi. A 2-stage compressor will have much less oil carryover and is actually quieter than a single -stage pump. I've seen them as cheap as $1,200 on sale, although the latest price I've seen is about $1,600.

That said, you can go with the 5hp IR 80 gal. 2-stage that TS has for $1,000 and never look back. Excellent machine.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#14

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

1. By any and all means, start using the synthetic oil kit right from the start. It will (with IR anyway) double the warranty.

2. You should plan on a dedicated 25 amp circuit for your new beastie unless you want your lights dimming when he cuts in. I started my 3 hp on a 20 amp circuit, but had to go to a 25 for cold winter use because it's mounted in the garage.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#15

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

Terry Scott

Steve this has been a very expensive journey for me and I still havnt got it right

We have a power supply problem so are only able to run single phase .Be careful when purchasing because compressors (here) are listed as (for example 16cfm ) but in fact this is not the free air at 100psi

I have the biggest motor and compressor I can run on single phase which is 2hp 18cfm 12 of free air a twin head /pot this struggles with a sandblasting cabinet and I am always waiting for catch up

It is quite as I have in my shed 3 metres from the lathe

The worst thing for air use age is a die grinder they require 10 or 11 of free air

I have found power consumption is less if the compressor has an over ride so it runs

continually in waiting mode (special name for it ?) and is not starting up and stopping starting up and stopping

When my compressor comes on the whole house goes bla and lights flicker e.tc

If you can go three phase with a large holding tank this is the way to go.

Talk to Andy Dipetrio he has it sorted

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#16

Steven Antonucci

Thanks (I did speak to Andy already)

steven antonucci

Appreciate all the thoughts here. Seems like th Tractor Supply may be getting a visit shortly.

Steve

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#17

Re: Power

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Terry,

Single phase is the rule here in the US outside of industrial zones. The cost to bring 3-phase into a residence is not a pretty prospect, requiring separate metering and supply, permits, inspections, etc. If Steve has a 200 amp service to his home (common here in New Jersey) he should have plenty of juice to avoid shrinking the TV image with the start phase on a 5 hp motor.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#18

Alan Zenreich

Re: Which compressor to ***BUY*** ???

Alan Zenreich

Steve,

Real men build their own compressors.

...ducking...

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#19

Steven Antonucci

It'dcost more 2 run line than buy the compressor!

steven antonucci

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#20

Steven Antonucci

Start melting pendants for the gears for me ;-)

steven antonucci

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#21

Chuck Jones - West TN

My 5HP fine on a 220, 10ga wire.

Chuck Jones - West TN

I have fairly good, but not the best service to my shop breaker box (several hundred feet of #2 aluminum underground). From there I have 10 gauge wire running more than 50' from the breaker box to the compressor (through a double pole switch) and a 20 amp breaker. Lights barely dim when it kicks in; not as bad as my table saw. The wire gauge is the key. If the breaker isn't tripping it aint a problem. Only problem I have had is, like I said in earlier post, it tripped the breaker on a couple of the single digit mornings we had this winter until I heated the oil with a heat gun.

By the way, I use all sorts of air tools except for spray painting--sand blast cabinet, other kind of sandblaster, die grinder, pneumatic drills, sanders, ratchets, etc.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#22

Use synthetic oil in cold garages ! ! !

pete labelle

For you cold weather oil sump compressor users, head to Tractor Supply and buy synthetic compressor oil. Used to have problems below 20 degrees starting my garage based compressor, but with the synthetic oil, it hasn't failed me, even at -5F !

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#23

Re: Use synthetic oil in cold garages ! ! !

don lewonczyk

Steve check craigslist. I found a IR two stage 60 gallon tank and air dryer brand new never used but was 8years old for $900.oo. A heavy machine with cast iron heads and works great. I bought the syn. oil from TSC and never any problems with grinding tools, impact tools, etc. Mine is in the shop and a little noisey but bareable, good luck on whatever you go with. DonL

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#24

Chuck Jones - West TN

I have used synthetic oil since day one!

Chuck Jones - West TN

But part of the problem is my compressor is in a shed on the north side of my shop with no wall enclosure. I will enclose it soon... soon as the weather gets better.

Re: What compressor for a shop with people?

#25

Re: It'dcost more 2 run line than buy the compress

John Lucas

Steve Been there, doing that shortly. I bought an old big as hell 2 stage compressor for $125. It's going to cost me $240 to run the new 220 line I need to be able to run it. Well in reality I'm also going to run a big 220 welder, this air compressor and I'm going to upgrade my dustcollector to a 220 model so I guess it's worth it but still going to be expensive.