I am making an oval table. The top is 18x14, The height of the table is 32".
The purpose of the table is to occupy a place by a door where folks would tend to deposit the burden in their hands such as a bag or purse or mail. An alternate purpose could be a plant stand. The table would be used from a standing position not a sitting position.
At this point:
The pedestals need additional finish applied
The pedestals need to be glued to the top and the base.
The base needs to be glued together
The base needs finish applied.
The top needs to be sanded and finish applied.
I have about 10 hours into the table components so far. I guess that there is at least that much more time to go with the table.
So the questions are:
Does the design of the table work? Do two pedestal look okay or should it be a single pedestal?
Does the base design work with the table? What other base design should I consider?
Is the pedestal design, shape, okay. What other shape could the pedestal have which would look better?
Not sure I can answer all your questions, but the first thing I would say is to post this on the general messages board, not the turning specific board.
My take is that I would try a round or oval portion to the base - not sure what it would look like, but for some reason that is what I think my eye is expecting there. The color of the base may make a huge difference though - right now the 'visual weight' if of the base seems to me to be diminished by the relatively light color. I would stain that first before I make nay other components.
To me it looks like the other two pedestals are missing. I would be tempted to add them. But then my tables look like you could set your engine block on them while you work on it.
Hard to tell from the picture which is the long axis of the table, but it sort of looks like it runs fore and aft in the picture. Any case, I think that the two legs should lie on the long axis. Just my opinion.
I'd prefer one. I agree with Barry, it looks like the other two pedestals went AWOL. Otherwise I like the table and with all this free advice I'm sure it will work out fine.
Richard To my eye it's the base that doesn't work. I don't mind the 2 spindles which are very nice by the way. The top is nice. The base just doesn't seem to match the quality and design of the rest of the piece. You could maybe make another oval but cut it out in a C shape for the base. Or maybe put 2 ovals on the ends connected by a spindle that the 2 existing spindles could go into. There are a lot of options. Make some sketches and then make a cardboard mock up full size to see if your ideas work. I think your onto a really beautiful piece, it just needs to go a step further.
The base doesn't look right. Actually the connection of the pedestals to the base doesn't look right.
I reworked the connection and it looks much much better. I hadn't thought about making the base oval. I could see the oval in the horizontal plane but it didn't occur to me that the oval could be in the vertical plane. Connecting the pedestals to an oval base might be an issue but I doubt the issue is beyond me.
I like the top but there are some issues which I can't fix with the top. So the current base is going to be the one with this table.
In my head I see a second table with a top that has the issues resolved and now the base with oval cross members.