Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Respirator, air powered

Posts

Respirator, air powered

#1

Respirator, air powered

Kelly in Port Orchard

Help; I need some input. I got some extra money by selling some stuff and now want to buy myself a new, fancy air powered respirator. I am looking at the Triton model and also a Trend Airshield. Does anybody out there have any recommendations?? I can spend about $300. to $400. I will use it for all types of woodworking but mainly for turning. I do wear glasses if that is a factor. I have found that by just using a face shield, it gets foggy. Thanks for your help. Kelly R.

Re: Respirator, air powered

#2

Re: Respirator, air powered

JohnKyler

I have both the Trend and Triton. For the money I like the Triton. I'm not as wild about the skirt around the bottom of it.... But like it for safety. It includes the hard hat, ear muffs, face shield, and air. I don't have fogging problems with the powered units, as they blow air past the face shield and keep the breath/fogging to a minimum.

Re: Respirator, air powered

#3

Chuck Jones - West TN

I bought Trend Airshield Pro

Chuck Jones - West TN

Don't know anything about the others but I'm as happy as a pig in the mud with the Airshield Pro. I had a little trouble getting used to putting it on and getting things adjusted. Thought I was going to have to hire a wardrobe assistant for the first couple days. Once I got over that, I love the thing. Rarely do anything on the lathe without it now.

Bought mine from Craft Supply. Bought a package deal that included a second battery, battery cradle, extra filters, and extra visor protective sheets. Best I recall it was something over $500. I really think I could have gotten by without the extra battery and cradle. One charge is a lot of woodturning for me.

Glasses are definitely not a problem. However, I do have a little trouble with visibility. I think it's the protective shield on the visor, but it hasn't been bad enough for me to experiment yet. Took me a couple days to discover that you can raise the visor. That's handy for pushing your glasses back up and for scratching your nose.

My wife says the low battery alarm sounds like the back up alarm on earth moving equipment, but it's a frequency that is completely out of my hearing range. I can usually tell when it's going off because my dog who stays in the shop with me comes over and give me a dirty look.

Good luck with your decision. It's one of the best purchases you'll make. I should have bought one before I bought the lathe, but I wanted to play tough. Worked for a while, but I came to realize the black walnut dust and I would not be able to get along any more.

Re: Respirator, air powered

#4

Re: I bought Trend Airshield Pro

Barry Ward

I have the older model trend that I got about three yrs ago and love it.They gave me extra bat with it,so I allways have two bats ready to go if one runs down on me while using it.

Re: Respirator, air powered

#5

Re: I bought Trend Airshield Pro

john lopez

If you end up with a Trend be careful not to drop it.

I used mine and liked it a lot but it did not survive the impact.

I ended up doing an upgrade with parts from allelectronics.com.

I bought a more powerful battery, recharger, switch, m&f plugs, wire, and a more

powerful blower. It cost me about $100 and some time.

I ended up with a hip mounted battery pack instead of enclosed

within the unit.

you can browse respirators & pricing here

http://www.envirosafetyproducts.com/respirators-3m-safety-respirator.html

Check out the 3M line, some of them look like they might work well.

Re: Respirator, air powered

#6

I have the old style Trend, works fine.

Gil Jones

Re: Respirator, air powered

#7

Re: Respirator, air powered

David Walser

I prefer the Triton over the Trend. By putting the battery and fan on a belt pack, the Triton reduces the weight on your neck. I think this matters if, like most of us, you spend a lot of time at the lathe looking down, with your head and shoulders leaning forward. This puts the weight of the respirator at the end of a "lever" made up of your head and neck. The muscles in your neck and shoulders have to hold up that extra weight. In short, I think the better balance provided by having the weight on your belt makes the Triton more comfortable to wear for a long time. (And, the more comfortable it is to wear, the more likely you are to use it.)

A second advantage of using a belt pack is that the unit draws air from behind you -- out of the flow of dust and chips. I think this helps the filters last longer because the unit is working in a cleaner environment.

Lastly, the belt unit design allowed Triton to use off-the-shelf filter cartridges. You can find several sources of replacement filters for the Triton unit.

The Trend unit is fine. Many are happy with theirs. I'm just pointing out why I prefer the Triton.

Re: Respirator, air powered

#8

Re: Respirator, air powered

D. Hansen

If you go with the Trend be certain you get the newer Pro model. The batteries are further back which lessens the weight balance problem but the best thing is the filtration is way way up there. The pro has an alarm telling you when to recharge and it the battery can be recharged in the unit. the fan in the pro is also better. I have had the trend old model the Raycor 3M and the Trend Pro. the Pro beats the others hands down.

Re: Respirator, air powered

#9

Denis Putland

Thats ok David if

Denis Putland

you do not have gas problems like I do >( >( ;)

Qoute David "A second advantage of using a belt pack is that the unit draws air from behind you -- out of the flow of dust and chips. I think this helps the filters last longer because the unit is working in a cleaner environment."

That aside I like my Triton and the shroud as it keeps all de chips from falling down my shirt.

Denis

Re: Respirator, air powered

#10

Re: I bought Trend Airshield Pro

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

I don't have an advice or opinions on the respirators/face shields but if you click the link provided above and in the center of the page is a link to a 20%off coupon for the Trend Pro.

Andy

Re: Respirator, air powered

#11

Re: Respirator, air powered

Kelly in Port Orchard

Thanks to everyone that replied. That why I love this message center. I will check it all out and let all of you know which one I buy. Have a great weekend, Kelly R.

Re: Respirator, air powered

#12

Re: Respirator, air powered

Terry in Ottawa

Do you wear a turning smock? How would that work with a belt-mounted respirator?

Re: Respirator, air powered

#13

Re: Respirator, air powered

David Walser

I do wear a turning smock. Usually, I wear the respirator belted on the outside of the smock. It's comfortable and works well. Other times, I wear the respirator UNDER the smock. That works well, too.

The "style choice" depends on whether I'm already wearing the smock when I decide to put on the respirator. Typically, I put my smock on as soon as I step into my shop. Other times, such as when I am prepping blanks on the tablesaw, I might not put on my smock but will have on my Triton Powered Respirator. (I use the Triton as my face shield at the tablesaw and elsewhere in the shop.) Rather than take my smock off, I simply belt the respirator over it. And, rather than take the respirator off, I simply put the smock on over it.

Note: My smock zips up the front like a jacket and does not have pockets at belt level. Other smock designs might not work as well with a belted respirator.