I just did this for my MIL. Some charity and she ask me to contribute to the auction so I donated an early piece that is still laying around. It is a piece that has not sold and as I have progressed (at least I think I have) just does not work real well. It will probably never bring what it should but I don't care.
I feel your pain on this, Steve, and have wondered how to mitigate the loss when I have made similar donations for a variety of causes. Two examples...
A former student established a foundation to assist at-risk young women with addiction histories, and at the end of our lesson, he hit me up for a donation. I was thrilled at his foundation's work, and handed him two signed hollow vessels worth a bunch of money. They sold for about $40 each. Subsequently, at a show here in PA, I donated a couple of pieces to a very well orchestrated fund drive and silent auction benefitting the Make a Wish foundation. I was proud to do it, but they sold for about $25 each. I considered all of the things you did when the auction was on-going, like bidding them up to increase the final donation, etc. It's truly disheartening.
My spouse at the time took my arm, smiled gently, and said 'Remember how good you felt about the donation in the first place? That's the thought you need to carry away from this.'
She was right, as usual. The act of giving is unselfish, and rewarding, but still, each of us hates to see our work devalued so badly.
Maybe you are right, that we shouldn't donate our very best work, but the dilemma there is that I wonder if we would get the same personal satisfaction in doing it.
Keep us apprised as to how you approach it this time.
Great thread! Cause for thought and introspection, as usual.
For starters, it is for a good cause. The school in our community is a pre-K for 3's, 4's, and 5's that missed the cutoff for Kindergarten. It operates on a shoestring budget, and I have had 2 kids through the program already and 2 more in it right now. It's meant to be a warm-up for school for the kids, and their mom's, to get them used to being seperated- and the foundations for learning.
I would never put something in that I wasn't any good. Like you, I hate to see my work selling under value. I was looking for ways to mitigate this issue. Substituting less valuable work that still brings the same money is one way. I'd rather get $25 for a $75 bowl than $25 for a $300 hollowform.
I appreciate you sharing your stories with me. I donate work to a few causes, and I am always looking to maximize the dollars it brings to that fundraiser. I decided to turn a few smaller items that will sell for an aggregate larger amount than one large piece will.
Believe me, I could use the space. I would love to empty my shelves of all of the things I didn't quiet get right, but it wouldn't sit right with me. I know what the problems are- missed forms, or blowouts covered in Bondo and painted over, cracks in drying or blown openings.
Yeah, they're my problems and I am not looking to stick someone else with them. I may look deep into the shelves and pick out the better stuff, but odds are that even that stuff isn't good enough to give away.
But the thought of all of that space I'd get back?...
How about this. Make some small items at the price point and donate to the school-No big deal. Make a high end piece, sell it at a high end market and donate the proceeds to the school, or a piece previously sold at the high end and donate proceeds.
I make something that is worth 3 or 4 hundred if I sold it.The Value is announced at the auction if the Auctioneer is worth his salt .
I always go to the Auction and bid on it to get the ball rolling . Many times Ive ended up with my item back for a 10th of its value But hey its for a good cause and I then claim as a donation on my tax .Sell the item for the 400 and I am still well ahead as Ive had a free add and handed out broacher's at the event
Once I bid a substantial sum and won Afterwards the couple I was bidding against came up to me .They were curious why I was bidding on my own work .When I said because id sell the piece for double what I paid They brought the work for 20 percent more from me and then ordered another.
Steve you do nice work why would you want to show people otherwise
I have just read all the comments after posting my thoughts just like to add .
It can go the other way and that is very satisfying I donated a large platter for a trust that had been set up by a young Girls Father
(the girl had a rare blood disease ) The father and family didn't take a cent but set the trust up for others with the condition .I gladly gave a very expensive platter .The Auction kicked off with a total frenzy my platter went for more than I have ever sold a similar piece for.Once the Auction was finished My platter was on the winners table and somehow another Auction started
just for the platter .It sold for a second time and both times the money went to the charity .
Incidentally the winner the second time was the same as the first .I asked why he had started another Auction and out bid everyone again
"Because it was worth more than I paid the first time "
Steve I am a great believer in the saying what goes round comes round
Re: That's the exact situtation I am trying to avo
Doug Trembath
That's a pretty good solution, plus the things you provide will probably be usable rather than decorative, making everyone a winner. Good choice!
I make a paper towel dispenser that really works much better than the commercial ones. No brag, now, I stumbled on the design in just needing one for the home many years ago, but it really works well. I bring this up because I'm making one for my new home, and another for the ex... Go figure!
Best of luck with the auction, Steve. It does seem to be a good cause.
Frankly, I have given up giving things for charitable causes. They almost always sell for way below market value -- and, I have never, in 12 years, even got a "Thank You' note from any of the many charities I have supported. I would rather sell a bowl and give half the proceeds to a charity. We both win. They get more than they would get at auction, and I get something out of it too.
Never any question of whether or not I would put in quality work, just at what price point. Given the amount of work that I sell in a year, it really doesn't matter what it sells for. It's not like I'm devaluing my name LOL
I was just trying to figure out how to maximize the donation value. It's going to be with smaller, more consumer grade objects and not high art.
Many of us donate to charity auctions. An important point to remember and a sore point with all artists - IRS rules (as I understand them, do a google search) only allow the artist to take a deduction for the costs involved in the item, not it's "market value" or auction value. As a result if Joe the Woodturner donates a bowl worth $100 made from found wood and his labor, he can only deduct the value of the finishes, sandpaper, utilities, etc. (a few $). However if a patron buys the item from the artist for $100, the patron can donate it to the auction and declare a $100 deduction themselves. The artist then pays income taxes on his income of $100!!! My guess is that this is in place to prevent artists from deducting all of their income by obtaining deductible valuations on unsold, but donated works to offset the income from their sold works. The bottom line is that you can only declare a deduction on something which you have actually paid $ for. The same is the case for home improvements, etc. As my tax guy once said, the IRS says your time is worth #%#!!
Personally, I would do my best work. Remember, that piece represents you as a turnier. Also, you don't know who will see the piece and want to buy some of your work.
Maybe Ill write out a cheque bank back into my own account then donate it or say I had to buy a cub meter of the wood it was made from so I got one good enough to donate
The rest of the wood was burnt as it was faulty is this a loss
What Ive done in the past is get a receipt from the organization for the amount the work sold for.Stating you made a donation for an amount rather than what it was for
My accountant seems to have worked this somehow.
My Grandfather used to say Son everything in life is taxed even the toilet paper you w .... your a.... with so get used to it
Don't have a pic yet, doing some major re-organization in the studio and it got put on hold...
Email me so I have a record, and when I get one done, will send you some info and a pic. Not too complicated, but when you want one towel, you get one towel, every time.
When contributing work to a charity (for an auction or otherwise) the amount of your deduction is limited to the lesser of the fair market value (FMV) of the item or your basis in the item (what it cost you to make it). Before you think this too unfair, this rule doesn't just apply to artists. It applies to anyone contributing "ordinary income property" to charity. So, with rare exceptions, if you contribute an item that would have generated ordinary income if it had been sold by you, your deduction is limited to your cost (or the FMV of the item, if less). Otherwise, I'd be able to claim a deduction for the time I give to charity. (As a CPA, all I "sell" is my time. Should I get to deduct $550 for volunteering an hour at the local homeless shelter?)
Some in this thread have suggested ways around this rule by, for example, getting the charity to simply give you an acknowledgment for the value contributed without mentioning what was contributed. Please don't follow that advice. Charities lose their exemptions and taxpayers go to jail for playing such games. While such penalties are rare, they happen.
Thanks for the word of caution. I've already been through this with my accountant, as I was looking for a way to lower my taxable income a few years ago, and I was going to start donating a bunch of work to various organizations. I figured it was win-win, but he quickly corrected that perception.
I'm sure that it's probably something else that they were trying to prevent, but what can you do...
I donate lots of things to charities every year, but I only write off the ones that are legitimate. I was merely agreeing with you that turned artwork we make isn't a legit deduction and there are no workarounds that won't trigger an audit.
Believe me, if I could do what I love to offset the money I make in real life, I'd already be there...I think the nature of the beast is that you have to pay for something before you can donate it and write it off, and that you better be way more organized at record keeping than I will ever be.
So thanks for chiming in with a professional opinion.