Another take on valuation
wilbur
Hi Steve,
My wife just finished organizing a basket raffle fundraiser that was held this past Friday. I'm going to suggest that you're looking at the valuation of the bowl you're going to make the wrong way for this particular event.
First of all, the people attending are for the most part looking for "bargains", as Heather mentioned. There are a very few charity auctions that attract the rich and famous who don't mind bidding way more than a piece might bring on the open market. My wife's fundraiser wasn't one of them, and my bet is that your auction isn't, either.
Second, the people attending your auction will probably not be familiar with the usual price schemes for well crafted turned objects. Their reference point for a wooden bowl will be the set of four that they can get at Target for $35. (I'm not making this figure up -- I found this on Google Shopping after searching for "wooden bowl set".) So now you are coupling a bargain-hunting audience with one that may not be educated about the difference between the bowl that you get at Target and the bowl that you get from an artisan.
Third, some numbers to think about. For my wife's fundraiser, they were able to get about $28,000 in donated prizes. The basket raffle raised about $19,000. From talking with other people who have been involved in this sort of fundraising, you can expect items to go for about 1/3 less than their stated value, so these figures seem to be pretty typical.
If I were in the same position, not that anyone would pay top dollar for a bowl that I made
, I'd make a piece that I would expect to sell above the middle of my range, sign it, and price it accordingly. I'd donate it along with information as to what makes this bowl different from the stuff you find at the big box store. You'll get a letter from the charity with the value of the item as you stated. Take the tax deduction, and don't worry about how much it goes for. That's what all the local businesses and individuals do with the prizes that they donated for my wife's basket raffle. Even if your bowl brings in 1/8 of what it might sell for, it still helps the charity.