Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Turning for charity/fundraising

Posts

Turning for charity/fundraising

#1

Steven Antonucci

Turning for charity/fundraising

steven antonucci

I am in a situation that I assume is not unique. My wife just told me that she volunteered me to make something for a silent auction for my kids school fundraiser. I will probably make a bowl.

The school is going to probably draw a very small, budget constrained crowd. If I make a really nice bowl, it might get $25. I am pretty sure that the folks coming will not be looking to spend hundreds...

So my question to you all: Given that folks may not value your work for this type of an event, how much effort would you put into it? Do you still produce your finest work or do you make something that fits the budget?

Let's hear your thoughts.

Steve

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#2

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

James Fox

A simple bowl may not be the "work of art" that many of your pieces are, but if it's going to have my name on it I always do the best I can. And also there's the opportunity to show a quality turned object to a wider audience and maybe get a couple more customers in the process.

My $.02 and you get what you pay for.

James

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#3

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

Randy Gleckler

Regardless of what it makes, I've always looked at it this way, if your going to put your name on it, you should always do your best on it. Might make my wood selection limited, or complexity of design change, but I'd always put my absolute best into it.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#4

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

Stuart Johnson

Do a smaller less intricate piece but give it 100%. The buyer just might want something bigger later.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#5

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

robo hippy

I do the same quality as always. For smaller events, I will donate more personal sized bowls. For larger ones, bigger pieces. Coming up is the local Empty Bowls auction, and I will donate several bowls, along with other members of the local turning club. It is fun. I donate to a Raptor rehab center, several schools, Rocky Mountain Elk foundation, a Vet's center, and others. You seldom will see pieces go for what they are worth, but it goes to a good cause.

robo hippy

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#6

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

Keith Newton

If you have old pieces in your inventory that may not be what you are doing now, or too likely to sell, are a good choice. This keeps your inventory looking better.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#7

Steven Antonucci

My thoughts...

steven antonucci

I thought this over, and a few things have popped into my head:

1.) I may include a card, but I won't sign it. Then again, I don't sign a lot of the things I make... but I do sign my work. They are two different things in my view.

2.) I have a minimum standard to avoid the "BTU release program" I employ in my shop. Whatever level of finish it receives, it will be more than sufficient for a user bowl, but not fussy.

3.) Struggling with valuing the work. I donated a piece at an auction that went for 1/8th what it should have sold for. Some might argue that anything was better than nothing. The work isn't worth anything unless the buyer and seller agree. I guess that the bowl will sell for what it sells for...and perhaps I'll go and bid it up myself. ;)

Steve

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#8

You might consider a rolling pin or pepper mill

Dick Coers

The rolling pin will be quick and not have much material. People will see these as more practical. I find that a lot of people just have no idea what they will do with a really nice bowl. It took me 20 years to keep my wife from trying to put something in every bowl I made.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#9

Re: My thoughts...

Stuart Johnson

Is there anything wrong with asking someone to bid up to a maximum on your behalf? For example if Steve feels he could easily sell a bowl for $150 would there be an issue with him buying the bowl for $75 through a friend and then selling it for the $150?

I have a hard time getting around the donor actually making the bids although the end result in this case is the same. Some folks might not bid against the maker. I remember over 60 years ago at my Grandfathers estate auction if any of the six brothers bid on an item everyone else stopped bidding and let the six work it out.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#10

Re: My thoughts...

Randy Gleckler

As a comparative thought, I've been to several symposiums where Turners have donated pieces that have gone for WELL lower than what they normally would have been sold for. It would seem that that's almost par for the course anymore, unless your at a place that either 1 has someone that REALLY wants to make a significant donation to the cause and use your piece as the avenue to do so, or at a place where people really want to collect the particular piece you've donated anyway. If you think it should go for more... Heck. Make the $100 donation straight off maybe :-) Instead of a piece you hope will bring the donation.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#11

Steven Antonucci

If it isn't signed

steven antonucci

nobody will know I made it.

Nah, just kidding. I'd have someone else run it up for me. Plausible deniability.

Steve

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#12

Steven Antonucci

I don't mind 1/2 or so, but .10 on the dollar?

steven antonucci

This isn't going to be a large crowd, so I suspect that there won't be a lot of bidding wars. I'm guessing one bid wins it, maybe one counter bid...

So, while I will get stuck bidding on something, I also made the comment that I could just give them the money and be done with it.

Thanks for helping me figure this out.

S

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#13

Steven Antonucci

Maybe something else?

steven antonucci

A good idea... not a kitchen item, but something else... hmm.

Steve

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#14

Mike Stafford

Ya' never know....

Mike Stafford

what future patron might be lurking in the audience at an auction. If you donate a beautiful piece of work that attracts the attention of a wealthy patron your donated efforts may be rewarded many times by purchases in the future.

And somewhere I read, if it is worth doing it is worth doing right. Even if the people there don't recognize it as not being your best work you will know.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#15

Re: Ya' never know....

Joe Herrmann

I think I would tend to have someone bid it up to a predetermined fair market value with the assurance that I would cover the cost. If the item goes for much less, the monetary donation would more than offset what I could get by selling it for what it was really worth.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#16

Charity the practice of benevolent giving

Jeff Willaford

If you are donating a turning (of any type) for charity put your best foot forward and don't worry about what it brings. As others have said, it doesn't have to be an elaborate piece but it will be your donation and you are the one who has to sleep at night. I firmly believe we each reap what we sow but not always from the same place or effort.

If you are truely worried that the price it will bring for the cause is not worthy of your work....don't donate it.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#17

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

Ron

While my best effort won't compare well to many others best effort, that's my recommendation.

I donated a nice bowl and candlesticks to a church sale a couple years ago and was very disappointed that they aggregated them with other ~related items, and then the low bid that took this 'basket.' My wife has also donated beautiful quilts to similar events etc. Guess what, they don't receive what we'd consider they're worth either. At then end of the day though hopefully someone received something they really like, even if we might think they didn't/couldn't afford it. Why should only wealthy collectors enjoy our best efforts? People of less means deserve good stuff too, even if they don't initially 'appreciate' it the way we might think they should.

Donate implies gift, not remuneration ($, or ego).

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#18

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

HeatherAinAK

I have been in the same position for several years with small school fundraising auctions. The first year I made a hand mirror and bought it back because it was going for so low. Many people at our auction are looking for a "bargain" ($50 restaurant certificate for $40). Recently, I haveapproached some fellow parents that I know will be there and know they are in the position of wanting to donate some money so I try to figure out if there is anything that I can make that might interest them. They have now purchased 2 salt and peppermill sets (for more than I think they would retail for). Another idea that I think might sell well at a school auction is a set of several spinning tops. If you include 4 or 5 and show them how fun they are you might end up getting $25 for them but have alot less time invested. I think pens would be another good seller. Or bottle stoppers. I made a fish bonker out of padauk that was very popular with our Alaska fishing crowd.

Good Luck,

Heather

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#19

Steven Antonucci

love the bottle stopper idea. thanks!

steven antonucci

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#20

Steven Antonucci

if you knew that $25-50 max was it...

steven antonucci

Suppose that you know you are going to get $50...would you make and armoire or a pen? Would you sand it to 12000 grit or 320?

I will make something that is a steal...at any price

S

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#21

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

john lucas

Steve I haven't read all the answers yet but here's my take. I learned to look at it as purely a gift. Whatever it brings is what it brings. I do taylor it somewhat depending on whether it's an even with big spendors or an even with people like me :). I don't lessen the quality, it still represents me and I will sign it. For the local Middle School band auction I make functional items out of wood that is good but not expensive. For the University wine and cheese auction that raises money for Art Scholarships I'll make something top end.

I gave up long ago worrying about how much it brings. They seldom bring what you think although I've had a hand mirror sell for as much as $180 at a benefit auction. I think that more of a fun bidding war at a charitable cause that did that. Usually they sell for about what I get or even less. It's my gift to the organization and if they get money for it whatever it is then we both win.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#22

Another take on valuation

wilbur

Hi Steve,

My wife just finished organizing a basket raffle fundraiser that was held this past Friday. I'm going to suggest that you're looking at the valuation of the bowl you're going to make the wrong way for this particular event.

First of all, the people attending are for the most part looking for "bargains", as Heather mentioned. There are a very few charity auctions that attract the rich and famous who don't mind bidding way more than a piece might bring on the open market. My wife's fundraiser wasn't one of them, and my bet is that your auction isn't, either.

Second, the people attending your auction will probably not be familiar with the usual price schemes for well crafted turned objects. Their reference point for a wooden bowl will be the set of four that they can get at Target for $35. (I'm not making this figure up -- I found this on Google Shopping after searching for "wooden bowl set".) So now you are coupling a bargain-hunting audience with one that may not be educated about the difference between the bowl that you get at Target and the bowl that you get from an artisan.

Third, some numbers to think about. For my wife's fundraiser, they were able to get about $28,000 in donated prizes. The basket raffle raised about $19,000. From talking with other people who have been involved in this sort of fundraising, you can expect items to go for about 1/3 less than their stated value, so these figures seem to be pretty typical.

If I were in the same position, not that anyone would pay top dollar for a bowl that I made ;) , I'd make a piece that I would expect to sell above the middle of my range, sign it, and price it accordingly. I'd donate it along with information as to what makes this bowl different from the stuff you find at the big box store. You'll get a letter from the charity with the value of the item as you stated. Take the tax deduction, and don't worry about how much it goes for. That's what all the local businesses and individuals do with the prizes that they donated for my wife's basket raffle. Even if your bowl brings in 1/8 of what it might sell for, it still helps the charity.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#23

Re: My thoughts...

matt overton

Why not make a piece to your best standards, and let a couple of your best customers know that they may get a great deal if they attend. The piece may get a fair price and make a customer of yours very happy. Win/Win.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#24

Remember one thing.

matt overton

Your wife was the one who offered your services. She knows your quality work. Make it for her.

Re: Turning for charity/fundraising

#25

Steven Antonucci

Good thoughts ALL... summarized

steven antonucci

I took the time to read all of the responses and I really appreciate all of the thoughts. Here's what you said:

1.) Quality is important. Regardless of what item I make, it should be made to a standard.

2.) If the auction won't attract a big crowd or deep pockets, it's OK to substitute another item that is more suited to a particular price point, as long as it's well made.

3.) If I make it, I should sign it. (I don't view everything that I make as "my work", so I don't sign every piece)

4.) Most auctions will bring less than retail, and that's OK. It's for a good cause, and anything is better than nothing.

5.) If done right, the event can be used to market my work and potentially pick up commissions.

6.) It may help to include information about what makes the bowl special to increase bidding. If not, shill bidders will certainly help :)

For what it's worth, the wiffe said the event is a Bunco Night at the Community Clubhouse. It will also have a silent auction running for the Bunco players, which may include kids as well. I decided that I will be much better off making a few smaller items (quickly make, high quality) than trying to make an heirloom bowl.

Steve