Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

CA glue over time?

Posts

Re: CA glue over time?

#26

Keith Tompkins

Re: CA glue over time?

keith tompkins

HI David, This may be a bit off-topic, but using the appropriate glue in all woodworking situations is important. I used to do quite a bit of segmented work; grain direction is important for long term stability, no matter what glue is used. I've spoken with several segmenters whose work has failed, and it's usually been grain-orientation problems that caused the probem. CA glue got a lot of bad press here, but grain direction certainly played a bit part. Wood is going to move, any attempt to stop it just won't work. (Gluing in raised panels is a good example, the panel will invariably split over time).

I've done my own unscientific tests on glue-joints, trying to keep variables to a minimum. Using perfectly jointed (joined) stock, I glued up panels of various woods, including oily woods, and followed all directions. One big surprise...Gorilla polyurethane glue, upon sharp impact, always broke right along the glue-line. Every time, the glue joint fractured, while every other other type of glue joint held...Elmer's carpenter's glue, Titebond 1, Elmers' glue-all, and epoxy,etc.. I didn't test CA, as I'd heard from others about long-term problems. A fairly recent test by Fine Woodworking mag. surprisingly echoed my findings...polyurethane glues came in dead last.

My current work involves creating glue-lines that are invisible. I use titebond 1 for dark woods, white glue (guitar makers glue) for holly and light woods. Elmer's glue-all is surprisingly strong, I've discovered, and I use it as well.

Re: CA glue over time?

#27

Re: CA glue over time?

Dave Belser

That's really what it all comes down to, no amount of glue is going to "fix" a poorly done joint, a joint that is not appropriate, or the improper choice or application of glue. I guess the problem with CA glue is that it's strong enough and quick enough that you might just get away with it for awhile. And when the joint fails, don't blame the glue - your the one that made the choice to use it! (more or less)

This has been an interesting discussion.