Re: CA glue over time?
keith tompkins
HI David, This may be a bit off-topic, but using the appropriate glue in all woodworking situations is important. I used to do quite a bit of segmented work; grain direction is important for long term stability, no matter what glue is used. I've spoken with several segmenters whose work has failed, and it's usually been grain-orientation problems that caused the probem. CA glue got a lot of bad press here, but grain direction certainly played a bit part. Wood is going to move, any attempt to stop it just won't work. (Gluing in raised panels is a good example, the panel will invariably split over time).
I've done my own unscientific tests on glue-joints, trying to keep variables to a minimum. Using perfectly jointed (joined) stock, I glued up panels of various woods, including oily woods, and followed all directions. One big surprise...Gorilla polyurethane glue, upon sharp impact, always broke right along the glue-line. Every time, the glue joint fractured, while every other other type of glue joint held...Elmer's carpenter's glue, Titebond 1, Elmers' glue-all, and epoxy,etc.. I didn't test CA, as I'd heard from others about long-term problems. A fairly recent test by Fine Woodworking mag. surprisingly echoed my findings...polyurethane glues came in dead last.
My current work involves creating glue-lines that are invisible. I use titebond 1 for dark woods, white glue (guitar makers glue) for holly and light woods. Elmer's glue-all is surprisingly strong, I've discovered, and I use it as well.



