I intend to donate one of these bowls to the local annual Habitat For Humanity fund raising banquet/auction. Which do you think would get the highest bid?
This one is black walnut. About 12 3/4" x 4". Has a small bead for a foot and has a cantilevered rim.
This one is red maple. About 12 1/2" x 5". Has a rather nice foot and a cantilevered rim.
Both are finished with 3-4 coats of Maloof Poly-oil and will be waxed and buffed.
Last year one similar to the black walnut sold for $400 at this event. That may seem a bit incredible, but it's a small town with strong support for Habitat, and a short list of entertainment opportunities in the winter. I think part of the reason is everyone knew the wood came from a giant black walnut tree that I took down in a church yard in the downtown area. This one is from the same wood, but I'm not sure we should try to ride that horse again.
I am donating some other smaller pieces and I'm concerned that too much from same source might not be good. My wife also donates her lampwork items (necklaces, beads, etc.) to all of these local benefits.
It depends on the buyers. Either one could go higher. The walnut tends to be hit or miss, I can't make enough of them, or I can't give them away. You just never know.
For my 2 cents, I like the walnut one better, so that is the one I would donate. They are both very good, but the shape of the walnut one just seems a tad nicer, at least to me.
Both are very nice, and you're a generous fellow for donating either (or both).
In my view the Walnut bowl is the finer of the two for a number of subtle reasons, some of which are just personal preference. BUT -- that's not what you asked. Which will fetch a higher bid ? I couldn't say, but if you donate both, you can let us all know!
Nice work -- and I commend you for supporting such a good cause.