Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

2035B headstock ticking noise

Posts

2035B headstock ticking noise

#1

Aage Rendalen

2035B headstock ticking noise

Aage Rendalen

Any suggestions? When I rotate the spindle by hand, I hear a 'ticking' sound inside the headstock. I can't see anything that's wrong. I'm wondering if one of the bearings might be at fault. Lathe is almost five years old, and it gets used nearly every day. The sound would be consistent with a strand of the belt slapping against something, but when I loosen the belt, I can't feel anything abnormal.

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#2

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

Jim Sebring

What brand is a 2035?

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#3

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

john lucas

2 potential problems come to mind. Check the set screw in the drive pulley. Second, check the index locking pin. I don't think it's that but I've seen that on other lathes. The only other possibility I can think of would be if the spring was broken on the spindle lock letting it touch the spindle lock collar.

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#4

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

Ron

I suspect you have a PM 3520B, correct?

I bought a new one about 2yrs ago, after a short period of time I had the same clicking you're talking about. Drove me crazy trying to find it. It only occurred under belt tension and finally isolated it to the motor.

Called PM and they sent someone out to look at it. He spent an hour or so going through all the same things I had and also concluded it was the motor. He came out again a week or so later and installed a brand new motor.

Guess what, after a short amount of time I started to have the same clicking. It's worse if I tension the belt harder, but even with the belt loose enough to slip some it would still click some. I've decided to live with it for the last year+. I untension the belt when I'm not using it, and mostly just let the motor weight tension the belt when I do use it - this seems to help but I still get the same clicking most of the time.

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#5

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

Mike from St. Clair Shores

I am having the same problem with my 3520B also. I did a bunch of web searching several weeks ago and found that this problem is quite common. I tried everything that was suggested in all the posts, but the clicking continued. Only when I loosened the belt to where I could still turn but really loose did the clicking noise almost stop. I can still hear the clicking but it's very faint and I am trying to live with it.for now. I called Powermatic and got the name of a local repair facility just before Christmas and they said they were really busy and wouldn't be able to get to it until after the first of the year. Still waiting to hear from them.

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#6

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Aage,

If it is indeed the Powermatic 3520. every time I have read of this problem it has been the set screws coming loose. I think I remember that there may be two set screws in each hole.

I would check this first.

Dave

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#7

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

robo hippy

I had the problem with my old A model a couple of times. The set screws in the pulley do tend to loosen after a while, and the pulley moves, and that starts the ticking. Another time, I traced it to a burr around the hole on the spindle that the spindle lock goes into. I did wear out bearings once, and they creak and groan, kind of like me. If the ticking is inside the headstock, it is most likely one of these problems. Had a buddy who traced the ticking to his motor, and the motor bearings were bad.

robo hippy

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#8

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

Juergen

At what RPM does the noise go away? I assume you're hearing the noise with the chuck removed. Some Vicmarc chucks make clicking sounds. Also check to see if you have any flat spot(s) on the belt, created by a catch or belt slippage. It may sound counterintuitive, but tighten the belt to minimize any slap.

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#9

You are correct.  Every time ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

that we hear about this problem on the Powermatic 3520 it turns out to be the set screws on one of the pulleys. It may be double set screws, but when tightened properly, the ticking goes away.

Ed

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#10

Mines been ticking for two years

Paul Zerjay

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#11

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

Ron Sardo

Behind the digital read out (3520B) there is a speed indicator on the spindle shaft, loosen the set screws and move the indicator away from the wall. Retighten the set screws and you should be good to go.

Let us know

Woodturner's Resource

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#12

Dick Hines

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

Dick Hines

Aage, check the set screw in the spindle lock. I have had trouble with mine comming loose from time to time. If you can get the spindle lock button out it is an easy fix. If not you can cut a allen wrench off and then you can get to the screw.

The last time mine worked loose I put a drop of CA on the threads and it has not worked loose again.

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#13

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise *LINK*

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Set screws that have loosened are probably worn out. Set screw tips have either a cutting edge (circle) or cutting teeth. If these are deformed, then replace them. If they are doubled, the outside one will always be deformed by the hardness of the inside screw. Always replace it.Dick: a dab of silicone is a better thread locker than locktite, if you ever plan to take it apart.

A large, long screwdriver can be used as a stethoscope to locate problems. Place the tip close to the housing of bearings. Place the handle of the driver against your ear flap and mildly push. DO THIS ONLY IF THERE IS NO DANGER OF HITTING A MOVING PART! You should hear only a smooth whirling noise. If you hear: scrapes, clunks, pops, grinding, etc, then you have a bad bearing. Check both end bells of motors. Compare the noises of good bearings on other machines. These noises will transmit thru inches of metal. Auto parts stores sell a device with a diaphragm that magnifies the noise, a useful device for home mechanics.


mechanics stethoscope

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#14

Aage Rendalen

Thanks for the suggestions

Aage Rendalen

I'll try out your suggestions tonight. One of you mentioned a spring, and it actually sounds like a broken spring hitting something. I've already tightened the set screws on the spindle without any effect. From your comments I conclude that this is a manufacturing issue that PM should look into.

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#15

What worked for me

Jack Savona

I had that ticking in the first year I owned my 3520B. I moved the belt over one groove toward the center of the pulley so the side of the belt was away from the larger pulley and the ticking stopped immediately.

Re: 2035B headstock ticking noise

#16

Re: You are correct.  Every time ...

Ron

Not every time, I guarantee it since mine was NOT set screws. I, and the PM repair guy, independently ruled out everything else (set screws, pulley alignment, shaft rotation sensor, etc) and isolated it to the motor under side load from the belt. Replaced the motor as mentioned in previous reply and ended up with the same problem shortly on the new motor.