Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Raising the dead OT but not really

Posts

Raising the dead OT but not really

#1

Raising the dead OT but not really

Jorge Casta�eda

1:11:11

Stand up Lazarus! Said JC...

No bible talk here, it is a tale of physics.

Last march a hurricane downed a colossal spruce tree not far from our house. The root ball, rather the root disk, was about 16' in diameter and just a hair off vertical, so a cut just in the right spot should make the root section stand up. After looking it a number of times, just long enough so my brain figured out the total mass of the root disk and an equivalent mass of the trunk so there was perfect balance, and then make "the" cut right there.

1:11:11 was the date. I wanted to post this yesterday but we lost our power in the snow storm. As the trunk in the spot where I needed to make the cut was way up, I had to cut several sections of 18", dictated by my wood burning stove, some to stand up and others to position under the trunk so if my judgment was wrong, prevent the whole shebang from coming down and perhaps hurting me. Another consideration was that the section to remain on the ground was to shift south due to the position of the boughs supporting it.

So I did all the prep and as "the spot" was still too high, I did a cut 18" further out than needed, where I could stand on the ground standing on the north side.

When I finished the cut the root disk side went slightly down, and the remaining section moved south as envisioned.


Another section of the top part was taken off to have an escape route just in case, and then another one to have two to stand on. At this point I went to get the camera and did snap a couple shots, then the moment of truth. I made the cut in "the spot," and the section fell, but nothing happened. I stood there panting for several minutes and looking. As nothing happened and I was dehydrated, I started to walk to go get some tea. "Tic, tic," I heard and turned to find the stump vertical! The thing weights several tons and did not make a sound other than that "tic, tic!" I was expecting a WHAM! and the earth to shake, but nothing, and I did not see it going up...

I have no cognition of all that computing the brain did, just call it an "educated guess" as I have done others, but nothing this massive.




The stump is 3 feet across at ground level.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#2

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

john lopez

Boing !

Glad you lived to tell us.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#3

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

john lucas

Your a brave man. Those things scare the hell out of me. I've often wondered if you could put a cable around the trunk and over the root ball. Then tension this with a com-a-long so that the root ball could only go in one direction-opposite me. I also thought about cutting a limb section to the right length to fit under the trunk to also keep it from settling in my direction.

There was a story a bunch of years ago about a root ball. The tree went down after a storm. The cut the tree up for firewood leaving he rootball. Several days later the guys children were playing behind it and it settled back down crushing both of them.

I tried to cut one one time. I did my best to figure out which way the tension was. I was wrong. pinched the saw. I had an ax and hand saw. Took about 2 hours to free the saw. I had some wedges back then but it happened faster than expected and I didn't have time to insert the wedges.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#4

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

Mike Foster

I've done this with a number of hemlock on my property. Wind storms have blown over a number of them at various times. Some I got to right away. Others it took months before I got to them. If you wait too long, the root ball just stays standing vertical unless you can get to it with a tractor and push on it.

These used to scare me, but the physics of them are really predictable and if you make a clear path, getting out of the way when the rootball falls back down is really not that scary. To me it is cool. I would rather have the rootball fall back down. I have a couple of those 8-10ft standing rootballs in the forest and curse myself for not getting to them sooner as I think they are an eyesore. They are in a part of my forest where I can't really access them with the tractor.

What scares me, and I don't touch, are widow makers. I think they are appropriately named. I have a few of these in the forest as well. One is a12" paper birch that is snapped about 12' up and the top half is leaning on other trees nearby. It is right over a trail that we use almost daily with our dogs. It is also really accessible with the tractor. I have gazed at that thing and thought about it but cannot really predict what will happen if I took the chainsaw to it. It would be great firewood and I would like to take the threat of walking under it away, but call me a chicken, I think I'll leave it till it decides to come down on it's own (hopefully when we're not under it)

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#5

Steven Antonucci

Cutting widowmakers

steven antonucci

I am with you on cutting them, but I have found that the main issue is folks want to cut them fast and run like heck to get away.

When I cut something suspended, I make a huge wedge cut on the top at the closest point to where it is touching the ground. I then make a slow upcut and wait for that cut to start opening. There is a point when the tree will start to move, and I'll stop cutting. It might take 30 seconds for it to get to the ground, but I've got time.

Once the main trunk is on the ground, I'll move up another few feet and repeat until I have the main log near vertical again. By then, it's usually small enough to push down by hand...

Essentially, you are always working on the end that is almost already on the ground. If there is a rootball, start on the other side. If the tree is "sprung", I make a bunch of relief cuts on the top to relieve the tension (lower wood is in compression)...

Now if it's a standing dead hemlock... I'm worried about getting a dead branch to the back of the head...

S

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#6

Chuck Jones - West TN

There is some good advice in this thread.

Chuck Jones - West TN

It is obvious that you guys have some experience with damaged trees... enough experience to know you never have enough experience. There is always an opportunity for surprise, and there is nothing sissy about being overly cautious.

I have been a member of a volunteer disaster response team for about ten years. We mostly do tree and debris removal, and we've had too much practice over these years. We usually have 2-3 skid-steers and a couple smaller tractors with us. Several of us have chainsaws longer than your leg and years of experience. We take things out that are quite impressive. BUT WE ARE ALL A BUNCH OF CHICKENS! It is amazing the amount of calm, cool, caution that is displayed by our crew. Nobody jumps into anything that is close to risky without examining the situation, talking it over with each other, having a plan, figuring on the worst possibility, etc.

We have cleaned up after hurricane Ivan, Katrina, Rita, Ike, and a couple the names of which I can't remember, as well as numerous tornadoes, ice storms, and floods.

We are thankful that we have never caused major additional damage to anyone's property, nor physical harm to anyone... well with one exception. A young MD who only works with us occasionally got a little too eager one day and ran in to a spot where another team member was dropping a small pine snag. But it only took 15 stitches to fix his head and we found one of his friends to do it for free.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#7

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

Barb Siddiqui

Awesome prep work. I learned several things from your comments. Thanks, Jorge!

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#8

I have an occasional widowmaker here ....

JamieDonaldson

...on the golf course or archery range, and my favorite tool for some situations is my Stihl saw with a shaft that extends about 12' and allows some safety from falling branches. Of course there was the time that I was working on a large branch way up there, and it broke before I expected. I dropped the saw and ran, and the branch fell on the fully extended shaft and bent it, and as I recall, the repairs cost almost as much as a new saw. :b

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#9

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

Jorge Casta�eda

John,

Root balls scare me too! Many years ago, I was helping a lady to collect medicinal plants in a state park in NY, at certain point there was the stench of something dead, we looked around and determined it was coming from below a tree. She tough of foul play and we went to tell the ranger, he went with us to the spot and after much peeking and shining a flashlight, he determined that there was a deer crushed under it. He figured out the tree was blown in a storm but did not come all the way to the ground it did lean in another tree, then in another storm the wind blew it back, the deer must have been sleeping or taking shelter from the wind.

He mention that root balls kill a lot of people, sometimes the loggers, and other times when the loggers leave the root ball standing, they come down anytime like in the example you mention.

Ever since, when I find one I do my best to put it back where it belongs.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

keith tompkins

Hi Jorge, I had the same thing happen to me with a big hickory tree that fell in the swamp behind my property. I had trimmed the branches, and had cut the trunk in several sections half-way through. My daughter brought lunch down, we sat on the trunk and ate. As she walked back to the house, the tree began to make cracking sounds. All of a sudden,the thing snapped off violently, and the tree trunk stood back up! I don't want to think what would have happened if we were still sitting on it. Glad you didn't get hurt!

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#11

Widow makers

Jorge Casta�eda

scare me too, always in the forest I walk looking up and spotting them, also when felling a tree I wear a hard hat and look up frequently. I don't have a tractor, so I choose the weaker tree where the broken tree is leaning, in a day with no wind, lean a ladder and tie a rope as high as possible, then with as long a rope as practical, and using a chain choker around the base of a good size tree, I rig a four part block and tackle in tandem with a come along, put a strain with the tackle and use the come along as a jigger, that puts an enormous strain, many times it moves the weak tree enough to let the broken piece slide down, on occasion I have broken the tree. If I did not succeed taking it down, I leave it there and eventually a big wind will finish the job.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#12

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

Jorge Casta�eda

Keith,

I am glad you and your girl did not get catapulted!

I do think all the possible scenarios and always proceed very slowly and cautiously.

I meant the tree stump to stand up, in my case it was not a surprise, I am scared the root ball will go back and hurt somebody, so I don't like to see them.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#13

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

Jorge Casta�eda

Barb, always prep and plan after considering all possible scenarios and whenever possible have somebody around, out of range from the action but keeping an eye on things and alerting you of any movement. Work slowly and keep an eye on things, have an avenue of scape, or clean all around when possible, so you can get out of the way. Don't tackle something like this at the end of a long day when tired, do it when fresh and well rested.

I have done this kind of work for half a century, so have lots of experience and work alone, my wife just don't like to participate in forestry.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#14

Mike Stafford

Roy Underhill, of the Woodwright's Shop...

Mike Stafford

tells a story about the time he was harvesting hurricane felled timber when one of those widowmakers cost him some tools.

It seems he had carried his tool box with him to the site of a bunch of felled trees and to keep it out of the way he put it in the hole left by the root ball of an uprighted tree.

Someone cut the trunk of the tree and the stump and root ball stood up and crushed poor Roy's tool box.... :\

Here in hurricane country there are lots of dangers associated with windblown and damaged trees. Whole tops can be sheared off and left hanging in the canopy to become fool killers when you least expect it.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#15

Re: Roy Underhill, of the Woodwright's Shop...

Jorge Casta�eda

Hello Mike,

Here we rarely have hurricanes, mostly it just blow's a gale but many a tree gets broken as you describe, that is the situation i had in mind in my response to Mike Foster.

Re: Raising the dead OT but not really

#16

Re: Scary tales.

bill Crommett

One time about forty years ago I was cutting down a big red Oak about twenty feet from a gravel excavation. A sudden gust of wind blew the tree over backwards and the top went into the excavation and the stump log bounced about twenty feet in the air and came down three feet in front of me. I packed up and went home !