Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Would You Buy It Again?

Posts

Would You Buy It Again?

#1

Would You Buy It Again?

charlie belden

I'm usually a bit leary of owner reviews of tools. There's a natural inclination for Owner Bias - "I bought it - so it must be they best thing out there" and the review is often done within days of acquistion, while The Glow is still on - the New Car Smell still wafting in the air. The review is seldom followed up on - after The New Tool is not longer new - and it's been used on actual projectS

The question I want answered is -"Now that you've used it for a year or two - and given what's out there now - WOULD YOU BUY IT AGAIN?"

If you have the same question here's one big YES - and I did.

I researched hollowing systems for my Mini before I decided on the MiniMonster. It performed so well I told other turning club members about it and a few borrowed it for a week or two. Two that could afford it bought their own after having to return mine. I ended up giving mine to a club member with more skill and passion - than money - knowing he'd do more with it in a month than I'd do in a year.

I've got a set of John Jordan hollowing tools - in two different sizes - a set of mini hollowers like Bob Rosand makes and sells, as well as a Sorby Hollow Master. So it's not that I can't hollow without a MiniMonster. But I missed the MiniMonster.

Today, I called Randy and ordered another MiniMonster. THAT's the best endorsement I can come up with - I had one - and now, after using the first one for a couple of years, bought another one.

Have YOU got a tool that you'd replace with the same tool? If so, what's the tool and why would you folk over a chunk of change for a replacement?

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#2

Steven Antonucci

Yes in two cases

steven antonucci

My Tormek is the only tool in my shop that I can't upgrade from.

My Nova lathe has served me well, and I will continue to suggest that it is the best $1000 lathe on the market. If I only had $1000 to spend, I'd get another in a second. It's not the best lathe in the world, but it does 99% of what 98% of all woodturners need 95% of best in class...

S

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#3

Chuck Jones - West TN

I haven't been turning long enough to...

Chuck Jones - West TN

...be buying a second copy of anything. I'm still trying to buy one of everything on the shelves. :)

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#4

Steve Kubien

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Steve Kubien

Actually, I've got a few...

My lathe is a Nova 1624 and as Steve A. said about his Nova 3000, best $1000 lathe you can buy, period. If I only had a 1K to spend, I would have the same as I have now.

I have a couple of specialty tools which are beyond what they are advertised as. The first is a hook knife by Del Stubbs. Hands down, the finest tool I have used right out of the box. There is no way to improve its performance as it is delivered. I've been using it for about 5 months now and will be placing an order for another with a different sweep very soon. If you have any desire to carve spoons, get in touch with Del.

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#5

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Wayne Kuhn

Wolverine jig and vari-grind (the original)

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#6

Re: Would You Buy It Again?  *LINK*

Donna Banfield

Here's another vote for Del Stubbs' carving knives. The best spoon and kuksa knives, hands down. He forgot to include the link to his site, so I added it below.

Doug Thompson gouges -- have and will buy them again and again and again and again.... Recently bought several 1.5 x 1.5 curly maple stock to turn handles for a couple I bought at the Symposium; now I have some extra handle stock to have on hand when I acquire more of Doug's steel.


http://www.pinewoodforge.com/

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#7

Richard Allen

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Richard Allen

Glaser woodturning tools, oops they quit making them. Good news is I bought spares when they were still in stock.

Stronghold chucks, they work exactly the was they are suppose to each and every time.

Axminsiter precision 4 jaw chucks, these chucks are more than a device to hold wood. They add confidence every time I chuck a hunk of wood in them.

Oneway vacuum drum chucks, insanely stable

Oneway faceplates, total quality in something as simple as a faceplate

Oneway dust hood, eliminating dust from the lathe without getting in the way.

Sioux angle drill, the reason there isn't a woodturners power sanding tool is because the Sioux is already here.

Lee Valley calipers, does more than a caliper should do in the most effortless way.

Oneway safety drive, simple, effective and perfect for what it does.

Alvin artist compass, draw circles from 1" to 40". I have 6 different circle drawing devices and the Alvin is the only one I ever use.

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#8

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Jim Sebring

DVR xp, Oneway tailstock system, Thompson tools, Tormek, Robust rests.

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#9

Bill Blasic

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Bill Blasic

Thompson 5/8 V (all my Thompson tools in reality) and my Nova Chucks and Revolving Centers and my lathes, my Monster.............. Matter of fact I would have a very short list of the things I wouldn't buy again.

Bill

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#10

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

john lucas

Oneway sharpening system-because it has saved me so much steel

Nova live center because it's indestructable, extremely versatile and more compact than my powermatic copy of the oneway

Thompson tools, especially the detail gouges. Those are my go to tools for so many cuts.

Powermatic 3520 lathe. I know there may be better but not at this price and frankly I'm not sure the higher lathes will do anything this won't do.

Vicmarc chucks- I love the jaw choices, the best chuck key on the market and very rugged

Hunter #5 carbide tool. This is the best tool I own for doing the last pass on the inside of boxes and open neck vessels. Used properly I can start with 220 grit easily.

Glock 30- I think it's the best 45 pistol out there. I can hit a pie plate at 75 yards with that short barrel gun and it's absolutely reliable.

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#11

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Carole Valentine

My Uvex Bionic Faceshield

Oneway Wolverine (without that I would probably have to quit turning!)

My Thompson gouges (especially the detail gouges)

My Kelton hollowers and ER handle system

My Lee Valley calipers

My McNaughton coring rig

My DVR until Brent decides to offer a swivel headstock on the Robust

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#12

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Phil Powell

Five years ago I bought a Robust American Beauty from Brent English. Not

but worth every cent! Very powerful and almost silent. You bet I'd

buy it again. I have gouges that I'll take to the grave with me and others

that would preform better as surveyors stakes. Vicmarc chucks and Skippy

Peanut butter.

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#13

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Mike from St.Clair Shores

Powermatic 3520, sold the A and bought the B

Vicmark chucks

wolverine sharpening system

Thompson tools

Grex DA sander

H&K 40 cal.

NSK Espert 500

Lindow/White Rose Engine

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#14

Steve Kubien

Oneway tailstock system?

Steve Kubien

Jim, what exactly are you talking about here? Did you replace the Nova tailstock with a Oneway?

curious

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#15

Re: Oneway tailstock system?

Jim Sebring

Oneway MT2 live tailstock center system.

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#16

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Jim Sebring

We need Grumbine to check in. He carries a different piece than some of us do ;-)

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#17

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

An interesting corollary would be -- what have you purchased that you wish you had not purchased? Not necessarily defective, but something that you really would not buy again. I can think of half a dozen woodturning items that I never use, but it sure seemed like a "must have" at the time.

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#18

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Scott in Falcon, CO

I would buy my Powermatic 3520B again, I'm still convinced that I made the best choice for the money there. Alsi, I plan on buying more Thompson gouges.

In Emmett's "What wouldn't you buy again" category would be my Oneway Termite hollowing tool. Clogs way too easily to be useful for me.

Scott

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#20

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Jennifer Indy.USA

I don't think I would buy a Trend Airshield again. It worked as advertised but just didn't hold up over time. For the price I paid for it I think it should have held together better. I cross that off my list of things to buy twice.

I would buy my John Jordan Hollowers again, my Thompson tools, my Flexcut hand chisels, my Stihl chain saw, my this and thats.....too long of a list to go on.

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#21

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Yup

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

All my General machines, Yup :D , My Jet Mini Yup :D , My Byrd Shelix cutters Yup Yup :D :D , my Sauer and Steiner hand planes Yup Yup Yup :D :D :D , my drill press, nope :\ ...LOL

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#22

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Jorge Casta�eda

Powermatic 3520b

Extension bed for it

Stronghold chucks, Vicmarc chucks

THOMPSONS TOOLS

Kelton center saver

Kelton sharpening system a very little known but excellent system

The Robust tool rests.

All the One way accessories I have, love the one that lets me put a piece still on the chuck, on the tail stock

Huskavarna chain saw...

Many others from the flat work world..

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#23

Chuck Jones - West TN

Emmett what is the max message size allowed?

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#24

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Given the same set of circumstances (ie, about $400 to spend on a lathe), I would buy the Jet Mini again in a heartbeat. I've pushed that lathe to its limits and would buy it again.

My Doug Thompson tools are my favorite.

My John Jordon hollowing tools I would buy again.

My Oneway Talon Chuck.

I actually would not buy my Delta Bandsaw again. It's a great saw, but I have since used the equivalent Powermatic version and just liked it a little better. I won't sell my Delta to switch, but given it over again, I would get the Powermatic.

Neat idea for a thread.

Mike

Herding cats in Apex, NC....

Re: Would You Buy It Again?

#25

HAVE You Bought The Same Thing Two or More Times

charlie belden

OK - so lots of folks have tools they're sure they'd replace with the same things if it came to that. It's sort of human nature to stick with what's familiar. But new and perhaps "better" things that do the same thing - and perhaps more - or with more ease - keep being introduced. So one might be tempted to go with a New & Improved tool, machine or accessory.

I've been really tempted to replace my Jet Mini VS with the newer model - with a 12" rather than a 10" swing - that has indexing bulit in. The one I have works - so a new one isn't going to replace it any time soon. On the other hand, the euro style bearing guides on the bandsaw WERE replaced with ceramic guides and I'm satisfied with the upgrade.

Other than the MiniMonster articluated arm captured hollowing system, the only other tool I bought the second time was a Dewalt 625 plunge router. This really shouldn't count because having multiple routers, and two of the same make and model is not unusual. Same goes for chucks - you can never have too many chucks, or jaw sets.

The question should have been "What Tool or machine HAVE you replaced with the identical make and model?" The follow up question is "WHY? What was so good about the first one that caused you to BUY another one?"