With a cloud of smoke and fireworks like on the 4th of July, my 18 inch Craftsman chain saw craped out. Of course there is no repair. I certainly would appreciate any suggestions as to what brand I should consider for replacing it. Thanks in advance.
Jerry, I have had 2 saws. Got them from Home Depot - cheap. Used them in my basement shop. Up in smoke they went. A friend of mine got a Makita which I have used. It is beefy little sucker with a heavy duty motor. It with probably cost a couple hundred bucks but you get what you pay for.
Stihl makes an outstanding electric chainsaw. 3 sizes. ME 140 - their 14" blade model, ME 180 - their 18" blade model and ME 220 their 20" blade model. I purchased the 20" for around $500. Check your local saw shop or Stihl's website for a local dealer. http://www.stihlusa.com/chainsaws/electric.html
I don't work for Stihl, but I like to promote products that I own and that work well ;-)
I purchased one from Harbor Freight for under $50.00 and have had no problems at all and cuts everything I have tried....bought the extended warranty also.
I bought the one from Harbor Freight for $40 on sale. I think the regular price is about $70. I have used it several times over the last 2-3 months and it works great. I am amazed at the power it has.
I am a dyed-in-the-wool Husky/Stihl user and often make very nasty remarks about other brands. But I already have too many gas powered saws and didn't think I should spend a lot of money on another one that I use only because I don't want to go outside in the weather. Well, okay, maybe it was my wife that decided that. Same difference.
Jerry, this comes up here once in a while. I think the consensus is that there are two groups. Stihl (top of the line) at about $500 and Makita at $300 to 400 and everything else. there may be others in the top group, but the factor that separates them form everything else is several hundred dollars.
There are a bunch in the low end market and I doubt any of them compared with the top ones, but most of them are under a hundred bucks. I blew though several Remington's and could not stand the idea of spending 300 plus, so I bought a Craftsman and added the extended warranty, fully expecting them to have to hand me a new saw. Wouldn't you know, it out lived the warranty. So either buy a cheap one and treat it like a disposable or spend the big bucks.
Jerry I went through a Poulan and a Remington and both bit the dust. The plastic drive gear was the problem. I believe both are made by Electrolux the vacuum people which is not to say they are not O.K. for a light (very light) duty application. I now have a Makita and have bruised it abused it and it still keeps on purring. Over three years of dependable work in the garage where a Husky or Stihl gas would make SWBO particularly hard to live with.
I don't want to hijack this, but maybe some here who have the Stihl can explain their power numbers. The biggest electric that Stihl makes is the 220, but it has less power than the next size down, the 180. I've been trying to justify spending the big bucks that Stihl takes, and still am, but one of my issues is which one.
The Stihl 18" model has 15amps and so does the 20" model. One big difference is the power head weight. The 20" model is nearly 4 lbs heaver than the 18" model.
Non of the electric chainsaws will compare to a good gas chainsaw. The gas has much more power. The electric saws have enough power if you patient.
Thanks, Curtis. My reference to power was to the kw spec of each of them. The 180 shows 1.8, but the 220 shows only 1.7. Likely no big deal. I have an oldie but goodie 026 that I got very used and that just keeps on ticking. But, I would like to do some bowl blank trimming in my basement shop during the winter. That's the driving force behind looking at electric. I'm sure that the 180 will do the trick, and from what you've said, it's 4 lbs that I don't have to lug around.