Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

Posts

Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#1

Chuck Jones - West TN

Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

Chuck Jones - West TN

I've turned a 15" platter from a very nice piece of black walnut. I was really pleased with the shape and the quality of the finish off the gouge and shear scraper. None of my usual tear out. I sanded it to 400 and it is slick as glass to the touch. Problem is when I wipe off the sanding dust I can see zillions of speckles where the dust is remaining in tiny pores. I can blow the dust away, and I can not feel the pores and can barely see them... but I know the darned things are there. I started over at 150 and sanded all the way up to 400 again and still have the same problem. I'm about ready to make a frisbee out of this very pretty piece and send it sailing down the hill to the gully.

Anyone know a way to fix it?

I've turned more black walnut than just about any other wood and don't recall ever having this problem before. I have had a similar problem with some cocobolo.

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#2

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

mjonesrdg

Chuck...walnut is an 'open grain' wood, meaning you can sand half way to China and there will still be open pores. I like to use Deft sanding sealer for this condition (found at most paint dealers and big-box stores). Click on "Articles" on this page, then "Russ's Corner" and follow his directions for it's use.

Good luck with it from another Jones.

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#3

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hello Chuck,

I also turn a lot of Walnut and this always seems to be the case for me. My solution is to use Waterlox as a finish and use mutiple coats. Sometimes up to six or seven.

For me it fills the grain quite nicely.

My process is to flood the piece on the first coat and keep it wet for about a half an hour. Then wipe it dry. I wait 24 hours and repeat. After all the coats are applied, I wait a month, then buff with all three compounds on the beall system.

I realize this is a long process for a lot of turners, but on some pieces it is worth it to me.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#4

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

Barbara Gill

By speckles do you mean little sparkles? If so that is probably silica. Over many years I have probably handled over a hundred thousand bd.ft. of walnut. Often there is silica in the wood.

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#5

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

john lucas

Chuck I'm tempted to answer like Dave and will anyway because others may learn from it. However I know you've worked with enough open pore woods to know that problems exists. I would lean toward Barbara's answer. I've had what I consider silica problems in Oak barnwood. I liked the effect.

A short story. I read once that when finishing a gun stock you should use linseed oil. Put on a coat, then steel wool it down, and apply another coat the next day. It would eventually fill in the pores and give an incredible high gloss with an easy to repair finish. I started in August refinishing my dad's rifle to give it back to him. I had put on about 10 coats and it was looking really great in about 3 small areas so it got me excited enough to keep going. 30 days later and yea thirty coats and about half of it was looking good. Now I was both frustrated and excited. Fortunately Christmas was a long way off. 78 coats later I had a spectacular finish. Linseed oil is of course very thin.

Now I use Birchwood-Casey's true oil. It's made for gunstock refinishing and builds very quick. About 8 to 12 coats usually makes a glass like finish.

Whatever finish you use for open pore woods you have to fill the pores to get a really glossy finish (or very smooth satin with no pores look) You can either fill the pores with some sort of pore filler (Russ liked pumice) or you can apply enough finish to fill in the pores. I've also created a slurry from 600 grit sandpaper and finish to fill the pores. Some think this muddies the wood but I don't. You're only using it to fill the pores if you sand it off between coats.

To keep it from looking plastic you have to remove all the finish except the finish in the pores. This is why you steel wool off the finish each application. After the pores are filled you actually only have about 2 or 3 layers of final finish so the wood looks natural but with a high gloss.

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#6

Warning!!!

Dick Wilson

I agree with the three compound buffing method. Just make sure that in your finishing process that you have filled in every pore. If you don't, when you buff with white compound you will have white "pickling" that you can't get out. Been there and done that.

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#7

Chuck Jones - West TN

Not the silica kind of speckles

Chuck Jones - West TN

What I mean by speckles is the sanding dust I am seeing that stays in the little holes after I've wiped most of the dust off. I can blow it out with air pressure.

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#8

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut *LINK*

matt overton

I have had good luck with Crystalac and walnut, then waterlox.


http://http://www.mcfeelys.com/product/CPF-2530/CrystaLac-Wood-Grain-Filler

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#9

Re: Warning!!!

Joe Dickason

You know if you listen long enough you can learn something without even trying. I believe that I have experienced the problem mention by Dick Wilson. After buffing I've noticed white specks in walnut & cherry. Can't get them to go away. I haven't been buffing very long. Thanks, Dick. Would I have to start sanding over to make them go away?

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#10

Re: Warning!!!

Barbara Gill

The instructions that came with my Beale System warned about using the White Diamond compound on woods with open pores.

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#11

Chuck Jones - West TN

Hold on to the Frisbee

Chuck Jones - West TN

I think I may be able to salvage this thing after all, thanks to the good advice from you folks (as always).

Dave's Waterlox seemed to require the least amount of reading so I had the Waterlox in my hand and was ready to go when I remembered the 30 day part. If there is any hope of using this platter for what it was originally intended, I don't have 30 days.

So I followed the link to Mr. Fairfield's corner. Wow! Does he ever have some useful stuff there. Again, in the interest of time I had to do some brand substitution for things like the Watco liquid finishing wax. But I believe it's going to work. I've only done one coat of lacquer so far, and it's amazing how it changed things. Now I have to order some Trewax or decide to substitute something else there too. The local stores are pretty much limited to 150 grit garnet sandpaper and Johnson's Wax.

Thanks for all the help.

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#12

Re: Warning!!!

Dick Wilson

White Diamond will do it every time. :(

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#13

Re: Warning!!!

Dick Wilson

Joe, You are talking about an incredible amount of sanding . Best not to use white diamond on open pore wood or dark wood IF...IF you have not totally filled the pores with the finish process.

Re: Trouble finishing a piece of black walnut

#14

Ellis Walentine

Joe, please e-mail me

Ellis Walentine

Notices sent to the address you have on file are bouncing. I'd like to straighten it out if possible.

Thanks,

Ellis Walentine, Host