Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

First segment bowl

Posts

First segment bowl

#1

First segment bowl

Todd Nebel in Macungie PA

Nothing fancy here, just wanted to try out gluing up some board stock to make bowl. I call it the hamburger bowl.


img

Re: First segment bowl

#2

Re: First segment bowl

Todd Nebel in Macungie PA

White oak and walnut.


img

Re: First segment bowl

#3

Re: First segment bowl

john lucas

That's funny. I was at the insurance agents office this morning and he had a bowl almost exactly like that sitting on the corner of his desk. His dad had made it for him. Obviously that's a good style. Good job.

Re: First segment bowl

#4

Rob Wallace

Maybe not segmented???

Rob Wallace

Hi Todd!

I think I would call this a stack laminated bowl rather than a segmented bowl - there doesn't appear to be any actual glued-up segments in the "rings".

Nice job!

Rob Wallace

Re: First segment bowl

#5

Ellis Walentine

Re: First segment bowl

Ellis Walentine

Nice work, Todd. Those rays in the oak are wild! I can't tell... did you orient the grain of all three pieces in the same direction? I wonder if that's important?

Macungie, eh? Right up the line from here.

Ellis

Re: First segment bowl

#6

Re: First segment bowl

Todd Nebel in Macungie PA

Thanks Ellis. I did try to orient the grain. I thought it could only help with the tooling and final appearance. I think it worked. Not many know where Macungie is, so you must be local. How local?

Todd

Re: First segment bowl

#7

Re: Maybe not segmented???

Todd Nebel in Macungie PA

Hi Rob,

You're right, I didn't know what else to call it. It was a fun test and I like the final result. After two days I can feel a slight raised line where the glue is. Is that normal?

Todd

Re: First segment bowl

#8

Re: First segment bowl

Todd Nebel in Macungie PA

Thanks John, I think it's probably a common design with wood most folks have in the woodshop. It was a fun project testing out a glue up, different grain, and wood density in a single turning.

Todd

Re: First segment bowl

#9

Rob Wallace

"Glue Creep"

Rob Wallace

Hi Todd!

I am by no means an expert at segmented turning, but I have been to enough demos by "seggies" to know that the raised glue lines can be a frequent occurrence. You might want to do some searches on the phenomenon known as "glue creep" in segmented work, and see what has been discussed about it. The solution may be as simple as changing the kind of glue used, or waiting a longer time to begin finishing the piece after it is glued-up. I have only done about 8 segmented pieces and fortunately have not experienced much glue-creep in the few that I've done, but I do know that much has been discussed about this effect.

Perhaps others with far more segmented turning experience than me can chime in to add some advice?

Happy Holidays!

Rob Wallace

Re: First segment bowl

#10

Re: "Glue Creep"

bill Crommett

I have experienced glue creep only on one of my segmented urns. But for real glue creep I have noticed that about one year after refinishing a solid white oak front door for the home a significantly palpable glue creep shows up.

It could be that the glue I use for my segmented forms is the trim and molding white thick stuff from Titebond. It dries fast and doesn't seem to have the bond strength that the yellow stuff has, but I use the yellow stuff for gluing up the rings so I don't worry about the strength of the bond between segments.

Re: First segment bowl

#11

Ellis Walentine

Very local

Ellis Walentine

I'm four miles east of Coopersburg in Springfield township. Drop me a line if you'd like to stop by sometime.

Your hat shipped today. Thanks for the order!

Ellis

Re: First segment bowl

#12

Re: Very local

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

Todd & Ellis,

Are you aware that our club, Lehigh Valley Woodturners, meets just up the road from you on the fourth Tuesday of the month at the Woodcraft store in Allentown? Meetings start at 7:00 PM. Visitors are always welcome!

Re: First segment bowl

#13

Ellis Walentine

One of these years...

Ellis Walentine

... I'll make it up to a meeting. I've been aware of the Lehigh Valley group ever since they started, what, 20 years ago? Let's just say I don't get out much. Sounds like fun though.

Ellis

Re: First segment bowl

#14

Sounds good

Todd Nebel in Macungie PA

I'll be sure to stop by one of the up coming nights.

Re: First segment bowl

#15

Re: "Glue Creep"

Malcolm Tibbetts

For what it�s worth, here�s my view on �glue creep�. There is no such thing. There are several situations which can result in a �ridge� developing at the glue joints.

First situation� The initial glue job is not given enough time to fully cure before final sanding and sealing. Dry wood will swell with the injection of glue moisture. If sealer is applied too early, then the glue can take much longer to fully cure and it takes longer for the wood to return to its original dimension, resulting in a tiny ridge line after the wood shrinks slightly. This can be especially noticed if the wood species on opposite sides of the glue joint are different and react differently. The solution is to wait about a week (or longer) for the wood to completely stabilize before the final sanding and sealing step.

Secondly� The original construction was not done with dry wood (less than 10% moisture content) � or with woods of dramatically different moisture contents. If the completed turning is displayed in a warm dry environment, then wood shrinkage can develop ridges. Solution � don�t use wood with moisture content above 10% (lower is better).

Third� There�s the �inch worm effect�. Over time, with changes in humidity, wood swells and shrinks with each change in season. Every time the wood swells it takes the glue with it, but each time the wood shrinks, the wood does not take the glue back into the joint. Over time, a ridge can develop. The glue did not creep; the wood movement transported the glue, but only in one direction. The solution � do a good job of sealing the wood to minimize seasonal movement; but complete elimination of the problem is unlikely.

At least that�s my theory.

Re: First segment bowl

#16

I'll go with the first situation

Todd Nebel

I only gave the glue about 12 hours to cure before turning the bowl :)

Re: First segment bowl

#17

Re: Very local

Todd Nebel in Macungie PA

Thanks Ellis, hat arrived today. Look forward to seeing you around the Lehigh Valley.