Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Bowl bruse/metal marks

Posts

Bowl bruse/metal marks

#1

Bowl bruse/metal marks

Keith Inscho

I turned some green oak the other day and discovered some dark rings after the bowl started to dry. I am assuming it is stain from my gouge rubbing the wet wood. I have attempted some additional sanding but to no avail. Is there anything you can use to remove these?

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#2

Steven Antonucci

lemon juice might work

steven antonucci

it's how I clean my hands after I turn oak... also works great for detecting cuts!

S

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#3

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

david

I have encountered this problem on occasion, and frankly have not had much success removing the marks because the stain seems to have penetrated a bit and I did not have sufficient wall thickness. I suppose if you sand or turn away the stain area you could get rid of it that way. I am not skilled enough to say how this can be avoided. Fortunately for me, this does not happen too often. Now let me tell you about sandpaper causing heat stress cracks...

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#4

JL

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

JL

+1 on lemons.

Other than lemon juice, you can also try a paste of oxalic acid (found in "Barkeeper's Friend" among other things). You are chelating the metal (usually iron) and doing a little bit of redox reaction.

I have lemons handy most of the year for baking, so I use them. I also have Barkeeper's Friend - which I use for cleaning.

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#5

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

Terry Scott

Keith id get out the steel wool and vinegar and ebonise all the bowl

Those marks will go quite deep

and whatever you do there will be one patch that just wont come out trust me this is from experience l.o.l

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#6

Thanks Everyone!

Keith Inscho

Ill try the lemon juice first, then the barkeepers friend. If that doesn't work, ill try the ebonizing route. Been wanting to try that anyway. "design opportunity" ;)

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thanks Everyone!

Keith Tompkins

Hey Keith, The marks may be caused by the rear edge of the bevel rubbing against the wood. A solution would be to grind a secondary bevel on the gouge; that would put less pressure against the wood.The back edge tends to lever the cut out of the wood, the secondary bevel helps. A very sharp scraper may take out the marks, a light touch to prevent vibration.

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#8

Re: Thanks Everyone!

john lucas

All of the above may work. I'm with Kieth. Before you turn another bowl grind off the sharp corner on the bottom of the bevel if you have one. I've noticed that a lot of turners are now going to a very short first bevel including myself.

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#9

Tool Grind

Keith Inscho

I suspected the heal may be the culprit, as the dark rings are in the transition between wall and bottom. How much should be ground off? I'm thinking maybe a third of the way up the bevel ?

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tool Grind

Keith Tompkins

I think 1/3 would be a good start...you know, Keith, your bowls don't NEED a transition. Your problems will be less with a bowl with a smooth flowing curve. :D

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#11

Re: Tool Grind

Keith Inscho

Touche! Thanks. :D

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#12

Ellis Walentine

Oxalic acid

Ellis Walentine

They sell it in the hardware store as wood bleach. It's a white powder usually sold in little plastic tubs. Works like magic to get iron stains out of high-tannin woods.

Ellis

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

#13

Re: Bowl bruse/metal marks

Rick Davenport

As stated previously, those marks sure sound like compression marks made from the heel of your gouge.

They are a bearcat to sand out.

A bit of water to raise the grain will sometimes lessen the compression and make it easier to sand.

I wet it down. let it spin slowly until dry, then power sand with 2" disks.

I also have an old 3/8" HSS bowl gouge ground especially for tight transitions.

The sharp heel is ground off and the angle is steeper than all of my other gouges.

It has eliminated 90% of my compression mark problems.

R