I finaly got the pepper mill turned and it was looking pretty decent (for me at my level of being a non-turner). Got the mechanism pushe in, loaded it with some pepper corns, started to turn...and it locked up. I fiddled and fussed and messed until I broke one of the prongs off (this is the short model) and cussed a little. Took it all apart and out of the turning and messed with it and the darn thing just won't work. Anybody else had this experience? I haven't messed up my work yet, so maybe I can get another mechanism, but the local store only had one left after I got this one. Hope it's still there this afternoon. For such a simple project, this sure has gotten frustrating!
Oh, I'm using Mr. Beall's design that uses a brass pin in the handle to ebage the "prongs" and turn the mechanism.
Well,I stopped at the wood store last night an dhtey had one mechanism left. They have some sort of afilliation with Rockler (not a full blown Rockler store, but lots of thier stuff). I tried this one before I inserted it into the turning. It seemed to work better. Seems like if you feel the mechanism locking up, you can reverse it a little and it will free up and then work. I then put it into the turning and pressed it in real good (Mr. Beall's intructions call for a 1 1//16" diam. hole I believe). It seemed to work ok. I'm still not convinced it is a real solid grinder (meaning the whole setup, not just their mechanism). But it did work better than before (it didn't lock up). So, I put it all together and shipped it out hopeing it wil get there before the recipients leave for their Christmas trip. I'd like to play with these some more. At $15 a pop though, it gets expensive when you tear them up!
I relied on the ribs to hols it in the hole. I thought about glueing it in with epoxy like I tried on the first one, but it felt pretty solid and this way, it could be replaced.
In my experience, the top section that fits into a 15/16" drilled hole is susceptible to pull-out when the top is pulled off for filling. Hard to get any kind of glue to adhere to the plastic. There are three prongs that need to be depressed to fit into the hole. Whether the several nibs that are around the cylinder need to be cut out or not is debatable. On some hard woods it might not fit with the nibs; on soft woods the nibs are needed to keep the top mechanism from spinning in the hole. To help with the withdrawl issue, I devised a scraper to cut a channel so that the three prongs spread out and lock in the slight recess. This recess needs to be cut at the right depth, so my tool is made so that it is inserted into the drilled hole up to a specific park, then angled into the inside wall to cut the recess. The top mechanism then snaps into place and it mechanically locked it. I have had some mills returned because the top just spins without grinding. What I have found is the mechanism is spinning freely when hard resistance is encountered. I used some pliers and spun the grinding shaft to overcome the locked position and saw that the shaft could then turn freely when rotated. Then I used some (2) wire brads in a hole drilled through the top surface of the upper mechanism to pin the mechanism and prevent it from spinning. On one mechanism, I fond that the shaft had worn through the flat facets of the female plastic housing. To give the shaft more traction, I used a small nail punch to raise a dimple in the soft aluminum shaft on several facets. This in effect increased the diameter of the shaft and made for a more tight fit of the upper plastic fitting.
David, here is a paste of my e-mail to you earlier this evening, in case anyone else wants to weigh in. You and I reached similar conclusions.
". . . my quarrel is with the way that mechanism is engineered. On very dense and brittle woods -- I was using mission olive for this mill -- the force of those fins is too great against the inside of the body of the lower section, ramp or no ramp. My particular piece may even have had an incipient crack that gave way when the pressing force was applied. Rather than scrap my only olive blank, I ground the fins off to relieve the strain and installed a set screw to keep the mechanism from turning. That was a futile solution, too, and it didn't do anything about the crack. I plan to buy some silver wire to wrap the base with to keep the crack closed. It'll be a little clumsy looking but it'll remind me of the futility of fixing mistakes, as Jim Krenov used to say, " like a cat covering his mess in a litter box."
The lesson for me was that those mechanisms, as designed, are suitable only for blanks that are compressible enough to take an impression of the fins and/or strong enough to resist the spreading forces. Olive is neither. I think a better design would be to have vertical ridges or a roughened outside texture to the mechanism, and epoxy it in place instead of press fitting it. I haven't made a thorough engineering study of the issues, and probably won't, so that's a best guess based on my experience to date with this type of mechanism.
Another engineering shortfall was that the three prongs that are supposed to hold the top of the mechanism in the top section of the mill are very hard to drive home, and all they do is deflect and hold the top on by sheer friction. I could have turned a slight ridge inside the upper chamber for a more positive catch, but then it would have been impossible to take the sections apart without some three-pronged key inserted from the top to disengage the three hooks. Another option I didn't try was to turn a rounded groove and round the hooks to match, so they could be disengaged easily enough with a strong tug. At least then, the plastic wouldn't be in compression -- hence sure to fatigue and loosen. "