Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

Posts

A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#1

A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

Colin

An incredible video of an add-on safety item for a table saw.


Video

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#2

Re: A table saw users Christmas present?

charlie belden

A blade guard goes a long ways towards unintended incisions - or amputations. The GRIPPPER, while not cheap - about $70 will keep any part of you aboveand away from those spinning teeth. A shop built version that does the same thing won't cost you anything but some scrap and a small piece of that rubber rug pad stuff. A sled riding in miter slots, or a sliding table will let you keep you away from those spinning teeth. The SawStop is a high tech device - that will minimize the damage should any part of you contact the spinning blade - with problems inherent in high tech stuff.

The module that stops the blade was about $70 a pop, and you'd probably get two initially so if one got triggered - and destroyed - you wouldn't be shut down until a replacement arrived 3-5 working days later. That would be OK if it saved you some bleeding - or surgery. But these things can and do go off - without any contact with skin - false alarms do happen. When they do - your out $70 for the cartridge and another $90 to $100 for another WWII blade and a half hours time to replace the cartridge and blade - if you have both on hand - and you have access to the area you need to get to - without turning your table saw on its back.

The item in the video that wasn't mentioned is that curving around the top rear quarter of the saw blade - riving knife. THAT sucker will probably save you more grief more often - because it keeps the back of the saw kerf open - and away from those nasty teeth coming up at the table that want to hurl your stock AT YOU - at a VERY HIGH VELOCITY. The phenomenon is referred to as Kickback but it often involves Lifting Up And Flippin' & Flyin' - usually up and to the left as you face the saw - but the stock can fly in almost any direction except back.

Idiot Proof devices have always been around, and folks keep coming up with new ones. Unfortunately, Idiots can always find a way around anything that is supposed to be Idiot Proof. The BEST safety device is "wetware" - knowledge - that's APPLIED - EVERY TIME.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#3

Steven Antonucci

Some trickery in that video

steven antonucci

First, I think that the SawStop is a great idea. As Charlie mentioned, there are some reports that they trigger in cutting pressure treated wood because the timbers are so wet. I think that I'd only want one cabinet work, since it would be expensive to change out a misfire.

That said, if you watch carefully, the guy puts his hands in icewater to make them more moist and cold before touching the blade. This increases the sensitivity of the switch. He also inches up on the blade to the very edge before making contact. A real user would likely be moving more rapidly and probably get a small nick, but that would ruin the demo...

1000 G's to stop the blade is amazing. It looked like about 2 teeths worth of rotation in the high speed, which means that you are probably going to need a bandaid instead of a baggie full of ice and a finger sewn back on...

BTW- That show is called Time Warp, and they do all kinds of neat stuff...

Steve

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#4

I'm looking at that saw

John Lucas

I'm hoping to up grade my table saw this next year and will actively consider that one. It may be beyond my price range but as I get older, and probably more careless I think it is a good idea. Of course as I said before, I'll probably buy one of those and then cut my finger off on the bandsaw, miter saw, or one of the other incredibly dangerous tools in my shop.

they did buy them for the Craft Center shop. The first week they had them one of them tripped. He was ripping extremely dry wood that had been stored in the shop for a long time so it was not wet in any way. So although it's a great idea it isn't perfect.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#5

Good observations Charlie.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I am sure that those are good saws and a good idea that will save a lot of hands from major accidents, but I like to see information delivered where all the facts are accurate. Early in, they state that the blade is spinning about 5000 rpms. All the saws that I have owned or inspected, had equal size pulleys on both ends, with 34 ~ 3500 rpm motor, so the blade would be the same.

When I see these videos, they always move the weenie in at ~ 1' per minute, which barely breaks the skin. What I would like to see, if for someone to pretend that they were reaching over behind the saw to retrieve the stock for another pass. Then, If you foot slipped back due to dust on a slick floor, and your hand came down at about 50 to 80 mph, to catch yourself. What damage would that blade inflict on the weenie, assuming a peripheral speed of about 8 ~ 9000 fpm.

Accidents don't happen at the speed they always seem to demonstrate this.

As for another common TS accident, since I know 3 people who have lost digits using a dado. If the stop is actuated, stopping the inside couple of blades, what happens to the other blades in the stack? Do they keep spinning, along with the NUT holding them on? I think that might be a pretty good hazard.

They probably have already addressed this, but I am just too short on time to look for the answers. And I am not trying to dissuade anyone from buying one of these. I think they are really a good idea especially for the novice, or accident prone.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#6

Re: Some trickery in that video

Bill Howatt

Here is part of a post from CanadianWoodworking.com:

I've personally tripped the saw (with a hot dog ) three times now....two of them at slow-normal feed rates, but the last one....I rammed it through as fast as I could. The difference was a "nick" in the weiner vs. a "scratch", but it was still less than 1mm deep The saw takes something like 2/1000 of a second to activate.

( No relationship with SS whatsoever, and I don't own one...I just got to play with some out west)


I also believe the Sawstop has a Test mode for lumber you suspect may trip the device.

Bill

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#7

Re: I'm looking at that saw *LINK*

Dave Belser

John, I highly recommend this saw. Three years ago I decided to finally replace my inadequate contractors saw with a real cabinet saw, at that time the price difference between this and a powermatic was about $600. Besides the added safety of blade stop, this is a very well built saw - the fact that the riving knife follows the blade instead of being attached to the guard means that you actually leave it in place and use it!

As for the "false positive" triggers, the manual tells you how to test a piece of wood first and you can also disable the stop feature if you need to. The only second hand case I've heard of a false trigger was from a friend that was cutting a ski in half (to show the cross section) and he failed to realize that carbon-fiber was conductive enough to trigger it.

The link attached is to a small set of "finger saves" on SawStop's web site. I think you would have to really throw yourself at this saw to cause an injury that would require more than a bandaid - the resulting damage would still be *FAR* less than without the blade stop.

If I had make the purchase again I would absolutely choose this saw. For me the extra $600 was a cheap one-time insurance policy. I'm a self-employed SW engineer and have crappy insurance (when I have it) and no disability insurance.

- Dave


http://www.sawstop.com/finger_saves.php

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#8

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

fgvanatta

Got to say . . . I purchased the GRRRIPPER about three years ago, and it is ABSOLUTELY the best safety purchase I ever made for the table saw. Those of you sawing small pieces (like for segmented turnings) might want to consider it.

If you're REALLY into small, check out the video on the 1/8" leg attachment.

Frank


GRRIPPER Info and video

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#9

Leo Cuellar

Re: A table saw users Christmas present?

Leo Cuellar

Great link, Frank. That looks like a real finger saver and a very handy jig. As someone who has actually run a finger into a thin dado stack, having the right kind of support for your project is the key to success. I still have all of my finger and there is no scar, but it did rattle my confidence in myself for a while.

Happy Holidays!

Leo

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: A table saw users Christmas present?

Keith Tompkins

Hey Colin, I believe the saw-stop was offered to the major manufacturers first. That now may cause a liability problem...the technology is available, yet the companies refuse to install it on their equipment. Soon all table saws may need this installed.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#11

Wish I had a Sawstop 2 years ago

jimmy edwards

Two years ago I cut off my right index finger, tip of middle finger, and tip of thumb as a result of kickback while not using the bladeguard, riving knife or push stick. I also have a Gripper I didn't use. I am convinced the Sawstop would have prevented the injury.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#12

It works like they say

JohnKyler

Having demonstrated this saw many times with the hot dog, it works quite well. I use a sharpie on the edge of the hot dog so you can see the slight cuts. I feed the wood/hot dog at normal speeds.

I have four recent customers that have all had finger saves. One had no idea what he did. The second had a scratch. Third was like a paper cut that didn't need a band-aid on day two. The worst needed seven stitches, and said he would have lost three fingers if it was any other saw. This was the most I have ever seen. But he is very happy. No this is not an advertisement, as I cant sell outside my companies area. But having run these saws, I have no doubt it works at normal speed, and would say the same if I was just an owner. I have been surprised on how many people come in and have close calls, or have lost fingers. It is more than I had ever guessed. And these saws are built as good or better than any other I sell.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#13

Re: It works like they say

Bill Howatt

Nice to get some actual incident feedback.

I don't think some of the doubters realize that the blade not only quickly stops but also drops down and away from the body part when triggered.

Bill

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#14

Re: It works like they say

john lucas

John Do you think people who own those saws are more complacent about it. It's kind of like riding in a car with air bags. It's easy to tell yourself you don't need to wear the seatbelt. I am scared of my saw. Not really scared, lets call it a very healthy respect for it's dangers. Because of that I go out of my way to not get near the blade. I think if you had the saw stop, especially if you haven't already learned to respect the machine, you might tend to be more careless because you think it will protect you. Just asking and wondering no disrespect meant.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#15

Re: A table saw users Christmas present?

Ron

I've had a Unisaw for ~15yrs. Not that I recommend it but I've never used the blade guard nor does it have a riving knife. This is my second table saw. I also have a "healthy respect" for this machine and am very careful using it. Most importantly I'm careful not to do a cut that makes me uncomfortable, instead take the extra time to create a jig or something.

With that said, I plan on upgrading to a SS in the next few years as money allows. A few thousand, and even a couple lost blades and modules if it misfires, would be retrospectively cheap compared to losing my fingers. While I've never hurt myself on the saw, I have thanked God a few times when it wasn't my fault I didn't get hurt. Both my father, and father-in-law put their fingers into tablesaw blades in their 60's. Both were very careful, and LUCKY as all 3 incidences (my dad did it twice) only involved lots of pain and stitches not loss of fingers.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#16

Re: It works like they say

wilbur

Hi John,

I've seen the "what if people become complacent about the saw because of the safety feature" question come up a lot about the SawStop. The thing is, in every field where safety is a real concern, no one involved in these processes believes that this is a real issue. This includes experienced pilots flying an airplane relying on their checklists, or to take some examples from my day job, writing orders for chemotherapy or doing procedures in an operating room. When I write chemotherapy for my patients, the pharmacist making the chemotherapy and the nurse administering the chemotherapy are going to double check to make sure I have the right patient, the right treatment protocol, the right phase of the treatment, and the right drugs and doses. None of this stops me from checking all these things myself.

The thing is, you may think that the wetware, as Charlie put it, is working all the time. Mistakes happen, regardless of the wetware. That's why we have redundancy in safety mechanisms.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#17

Re: A table saw users Christmas present?

charlie belden

Actually, SawStop offered the technology to table saw manufacturers but wanted a long term legal commitment to use their product exclusively with no guarantee of pricing stability over the term of the proposed contract. The manufacturers passed on that proposal. So they tried to get federal regulations passed that specified their patented technology in the proposed regulations. Fortunately, giving a company the corner on a lucrative market is not something that federal regulators fall for. One MicroSoft like predatory company is enough for the U.S.A.

A positive spin off effect of all that was that manufacturers started putting riving knives on their table saws, rather than the almost useless "splitter and anti-kickback pawls" they had been using. Euro table saws have required riving knives for the previous 15 or 20 years. The Euro equivalent of our OSHA also doesn't allow "blind cuts" on table saws - so Euro saws don't accept dado blades.

For $600 you can get safety devices for your table saw that will reduce your risk of injury much better and for more table saw operations - and have money left over to buy stuff to cut - that doesn't have blood in it ; )

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#18

Re: A table saw users Christmas present?

bill Crommett

I once had an old friend that used to say: "Any body that gets hit by a Rail Road train -- ought to "

We all know these are dangerous machines that cut flesh and bones as well as wood, so don't leave your brains thinking about how beautiful a project will be when finished when using a blood extracting tool.

All this from "Nine fingered Bill".

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#19

Re: It works like they say

Bill Howatt

I have never put much stock into the "safety features make you complacent" theory. If I'm going to pass somebody and it looks unsafe I never think to try it just because I have airbags and seatbelts. We do dumb things because we aren't either paying attention or assessing the situation correctly, not because we overtly think the safety features might save us.

I won't say there has never been an instance of trusting safety features but I think they are far from the norm.

Bill

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#20

Steven Antonucci

The old saying: you can't be too safe

steven antonucci

I agree that having a "factor of safety" (engineering speak for redundancy protocols, etc) is a great idea. I don't think that the SawStop eliminates all of the errors one can make at a tablesaw, but minimizes the potential damages by taking that sharp spinning thing out of harm's way if the user screws up.

Better than a healthy respect for a multi-HP motor spinning an 80 tooth razor sharp woodcutting blade has always kept me out of the hospital. Personally, I am more afraid of a kickback than being cut, simply because I NEVER make a cut on a tablesaw without a sled or a pushstick. NEVER. This removes the source of the error entirely.

What I would like to see included in the box with a tablesaw is a pushstick and DVD that discusses how to make your saw the safest tool in the shop. If your hands are never near the blade, you can't cut your finger off...

That said, perhaps v2.0 will sense a binding load on the blade and trigger to prevent a kickback...

S

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#21

Older WWs

Bill Howatt

I think you raise a very good point. I am well into my 60's and know darn well that I'm not as alert as I was years ago. I can see increased safety features being a benefit for older woodworkers.

Bill

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#22

John, I have a question.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I have three friends who mangled their hands using stack dados. It looks to me, that the braking unit might be about 1/2" wide. If the stop is actuated, stopping the inside couple of blades, what happens to the other blades in the stack? Do they keep spinning, along with the NUT holding them on? I think that might be a pretty good hazard, if they keep spinning and come off.

They probably have already tested and addressed this, but I am just too short on time to look for the answers. And I am not trying to dissuade anyone from buying one of these. I think they are really a good idea especially for the novice, or accident prone.

If this has not been tested, I would suggest giving it a try, and post the results.

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#23

Re: Some trickery in that video

dick gerard

Steve,

Their may be some trckery there, but the important thing is that its cheaper to replace the blade and cartridge than undergo re-attachment surgery.

Also, when I worked at Woodcraft, I had the oportunity to unload and assemble several SawStops. They are really built like a tank! They have to be to absorb those 1000 G's. Any other would probably be seriously damaged by absorbing that much stopping force.

Plus, assembling them was easy. Everything lined up and fit just like we always thought all tools should be.

Just my 10 cents worth ... 2 cents adjusted for Congress and the economy.

Dick Gerard

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#24

Re: A table saw users Christmas present?

jimmy edwards

Keith there has already been a lawsuit relating to the Sawstop technology. It was for NOT having the technology on the RYOBI saw. It wasn't for the technology failing. See OSORIO V.ONE-WORLD TECHNOLOGIES< INC., RYOBI TECHNOLOGIES, and HOME DEPOT INC. Cause #06-10725NM6 US District Court of Mass. Filed 4/24/06 It was reported and widely discussed in the Woodmagazine.com forums and elsewhere. Plaintiff didn't use bladeguard, riving knife, push stick, or fence. Tried to free hand it and ie. kick back, lost several fingers. On 3/4/2010 the jury awarded osorio 1,500,000 with him being 35% negligent. Case is on appeal. There are reasons the Sawstop tech is not on other brands and Sawstop has advance its own lines of saws. I repeat, the Sawstop would nothave prevented the accident, It WOULD HAVE PREVENTED THE INJURY!

Re: A table saw users Christmas present? *LINK*

#25

Keith,  Charlie there was a lawsuit, scrool down t

jimmy edwards

I understand the Sawstop inventor couldn' get together on the royalties/licensing fees so the make their own saws.. Don't think we will see the technology on other brands.