Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

The Great Peppermill Debate

Posts

The Great Peppermill Debate

#1

The Great Peppermill Debate

Ed Moore in SW VA

I need to make some peppermills. I remember when this topic got kicked around, but I have forgotten what the general conclusion was. I see:

1. Artisan Mills

2. Deluxe Mills

3. Crush Grinder Mechanisms

Which mechanisms are best? Are any prone to rust?

I value your opinions.

Thanks,

Ed

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Quality is Your Buisness card

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Ed,

I look at it from a position of how will it be working in years after daily use. Given that I drift towards mechanisms I trust and that often are more expensive, confidence in knowing I can count on my work still being appreciated down the road is in effect my business card, I have a lot of repeat sales.

I myself like the traditional mechanisms, they have a look that people reach for and tend to understand. The crush grind mechanisms are fun because they open up limitless design opportunities. I make both kinds, I can tell you they sell about two to one (traditional vs crush grind). I buy the Chef Specialties mechanisms for the traditional grinds and buy my crush grind mechanisms from a local supplier.

Take care,

Jim

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

#3

Re: Quality is Your Business card

Ed Moore in SW VA

Thanks Jim. I'm figuring on sticking with one style, so I want to make a good choice.

Ed

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

#4

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

Jennifer Indy.USA

Hi Ed, I just had this exact conversation with a gentleman about these. He a guy who makes a ton of these a year, well over a hundred he says and he told me to get the Deluxe grinder. He also gave me the advice of buying the 12" over the 6 or 8" because you can cut the rod to any length if you need to adjust because things don't go just right on the lathe... If ya know what mean.

Jen

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

#6

Steve Kubien

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

Steve Kubien

I am all about the Crushgrind mechanism. It is smooth as silk and my customers really like not having to remove the little screw thingie and thus readjust their grind as they would with a traditional mechanism (like the Chef Specialties which is also an excellent quality pepper grinder).

The Crushgrind is the only mech for salt that I have never heard of corroding. Yes, the other makers claim that theirs do not corrode but I've spoken with numerous folks who claim that is bunk. With my name on the bottom, I go with what I have the most confidence in. Also, if you want to sets, the Crushgrind allows you to use great hardware for both salt and pepper and they match easily.

They other thing which I do not think should be overlooked is that you do not need to carry two types of hardware in your kit if you are using the Crushgrind.

Yup, the Crushgrind is a little more difficult to drill out and more care must be taken. More bits are needed and it take a little longer. Still, I have no reason to switch back to more traditional mechanisms at this point.

Just my opinion and my reasons. I am sure if you do nothing but mills for pepper, the Chef specialties will serve you and your clients very well. I'm just not 100% sure about the salt mills.

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

#7

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

david

I just finished a commission for 40 of these, all using the Crush Grind with the shaft. I can also say that I have made over a hundred of these. Never considered any other mechanism because I didn't want to deal with the metal knob at the top, which to my mind would never be compatible with my mill design concepts. I use one for salt on a daily basis, with no problems. The shaft is aluminum, which will corrode in a salt environment, but so far no issues have come up using salt. I went through a couple of designs until I settled on this shape which some say looks like a lighthouse or a queen chess piece.

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Great looking Mills David,

I agree that the crush grind mechanisms have opened up the potential for a wide vison on design, to the turner, but I have heard comments like, what is that? What happens when I want to adjust the grind etc? After I show them they get it, but for some they want the standard, for some it's hard to change what they like and what they choose.

I think your style is spot on, I'd want one too, but not the salt, it's bad for your health you know! :-)

I use three pepper mills, three kinds of pepper that I like, sort like Norm and his routers, changing mills instead of pepper corns.

Take care,

Jim

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

#9

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

Nelson

I like the crush and grind. Jim you adjust them from the bottom and once you choose the seting it will stay unlike ones with knob on top that will change as you use it. I make both styles but really like the crush and grind better.

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

#10

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

Nelson

Geezz now I see where you explain how to adjust,haven't had my coffee yet!!

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

#11

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: The Great Peppermill Debate

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

:-)

No worries my friend...LOL, I have done the same... (jim looking for cup #4, long day already)

Take care,

Jim