Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Ryobi recipro carver questions

Posts

Ryobi recipro carver questions

#1

Steve Kubien

Ryobi recipro carver questions

Steve Kubien

I have the opportunity to pick up one of these for $40. I think it is NIB and never used but I'm not sure. I've heard good things about this discontinued tool but I've got a pair of questions....

Is it worth it? I don't have a power carver but love the idea for platters and such.

What sort of blades will fit? I think the Flex-Cut ones will fit but I'm not sure. Any recommendations?

Thanks folks. Enjoy your Monday!

Steve

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#2

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

John Lucas

I think it's worth it. Sure it's not top of the line and it vibrates enough that you won't want to spend hours on end working with it. However it's given me some capabilities I didn't have before and well worth the price I paid. Flex cut bits do fit in it.

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#3

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Carole Valentine

Absolutely not worth it. Who has it? Where are they located? I might offer them a dollar for it just to get it out of their way. ;)

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#4

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Don Evans

Flexcut makes blades for it but they also make an adapter that allows you to use their regular hand blades with it also.

So if you already have hand flexcuts get the adapter.

Don

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#5

Betty Scarpino

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Betty Scarpino

I might pick up a Ryobi for $20 or so, to keep as a tool to do some light detail carving or for students to try that sort of carving. If it's new, it'll be worth the money. But for serious carving, forget it, you'll be disappointed. Instead, invest $300 an Automach reciprocating carver instead.

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#6

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

John Jordan

Actually, they aren't bad. I have three or four of them, and have used up that many. Not quite the Automach, but a close second. I would buy a truckload of them for $40. And the Flexcut blades are the way to go. Buy the big set-about $130, but you saved all that money on the carver. :)

John

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#7

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Mac Ray

Ditto what John said........I buy them whenever I can get them for $60 or less......useful tool with Flex-Cuts.....blades that come with them are crap..........

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#8

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions *LINK*

Don Evans

Betty, with all due respect this is just personal opinion but the Ryobi is worth the money. Take into account the newby carveer for example that isn't sure of his long term interest or talent for carving. I have two of them one still new in box, grabbed them when heard they were going off market.

If one is inclined to spend that type money I would recomment geting a Master Carver (it's like a Foredom) but better made and you can interchange handpieces and one of them is a reciprocator and there are 4 or 5 others that allow using it with 1/16th " burrs up to 1/4" shaft burrs and sanding. It was available with 3 handpieces not long ago for around $350.00 and one was the reciprocator and you can use flexcuts with it also. I really like mine and it's built like a tank. I like the bench month control not the hanging foot pedal control forit.

Don


MicroMark sells Master carver

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#9

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Carole Valentine

Same here. I have several and really like them. I also have a recip handpiece on my Wecheer (heavy duty) and it's fine after removing the too-stiff spring but I still prefer the Ryobi. It takes just a light touch to start the recip action. I use the Flexcut...as Mac said, the blades that come with it are crap.

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#10

Steve Kubien

Thanks everyone!  I'll pick it up.

Steve Kubien

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#11

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Jim Tusant

Don,

It is more than opinion. I have to agree with Betty. I own all three. If you like to vibrate your hand off, like heat and noise, I would go with the Ryboi. I will agree that it is a good choice for a beginner to see if he likes this type of tool. The Automach is so superior that there really is no comparison. If you are going to use this type of tool on a regular basis and for any length of time, the decision is simple - Automach. The Mastercarver is a great tool but I find that the cable wears on you (fatigue factor) after a short period of use. It is great for hogging or roughing out material. I really like the Mastercarver but not for recipro carving. The simple fact that you need multiple Ryobis kind of makes the point. I have always heard that it only cost a little more to go first class. I guess that's why they make Fords, Chevys and Rolls Royce.

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#12

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Carole Valentine

Well I am a beginner and also poor, so they and my Wecheer and my Cape Forges will have to do for the time being. Have never used an Automach so I don't know what I'm missing. ;)

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#13

Bill Blasic

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Bill Blasic

We had Al Stirt in last week for two days of hands on in my shop and he used the Ryobi and recommended it. I was able to see both the Ryobi and the Automach in action and in listening to both in operation I personally could not tell the sounds apart. I purchased a new one off of Ebay for $70 and the three used ones that followed sold for about $87, $98 and the third used one went for $103 all plus shipping so I think $40 is a steal, buy it and I'll give you $60 :D :D

Bill

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#14

Sorry, wrong link

Don Evans

I gave the wrong link in my message, Micro Mark doesn't sell these and at the moment cannot remember who it is that does. It's easy to google "master carver" if anyone want to check them out.

Don

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#15

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Don Evans

Jim, sorry but I don't agree with the statement about "opinion". It is only that and nothing more UNLESS one making statements about any equipment has owned all of them that is being discussed.

Many time people with get on here and ask about a tool and many who have only used one other will recommend the one they have with having never tried the others in that category. A jugdement requires all the facts not just the one I am familiar with.

Don

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#16

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

Jim Tusant

Don, you probably need to ask Betty if she has ever used the Ryobi but there is no doubt she has used the Automach. Any, and I do mean any, tool that will get the job done works. However, I DO own all three that you mentioned and I can tell you beyond a doubt that the Automach is far superior to the Ryobi. I am not saying not to buy a Ryobi if you can find a nice one. What I am saying is it is not opinion that the Automach is a superior tool. It is a fact. Almost everyone in the post mentioned purchasing, using and wearing out numerous Ryobis. I have had the Automach for six year and put it to heavy carving use. Gee it is the only one I have had to buy. It runs cool, smooth - vibration free, quite and out performs the Ryobi in every catagory. This doesn't mean that the Ryobi is junk. What is does mean is that it is not in the same class. You get what you pay for. I think that is what Betty was trying to say - not trying to put words in her mouth.

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#17

Betty Scarpino

Re: Ryobi -- yes, what you said

Betty Scarpino

Jim, you did right by the words you put in my mouth, thank you. I've tried a Ryobi and Proxxon and rotary carvers with reciprocating hand pieces, and they're all okay for light-duty work, but if someone can afford an Automach and plans on doing a lot of carving, I recommend an Automach. But even an Automach will wear out, eventually. I've worn out two of them. Smokey Mountain Woodcarvers repairs them (at least they used to).

And oh, an Automach can blow up if too much sawdust gets into the housing (or steel wool). Short circuits them and POW! I found out the hard way, twice (slow learner). Fortunately the steel-wool time happened to a carver that was on its last breath anyway. It could not be repaired, but Smokey Mountain Woodcarvers bought the parts for $75.

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#18

Re: Ryobi -- yes, what you said

Jim Tusant

Betty, thanks for the info on Smokey Mountain. I purchased mine from Japan Woodworker. They do carry parts if needed; however, I probably go overboard on keeping mine greased and I blow the dust out after each use. I never use my Ryobi beacuse it gets too hot in a very short time. Like you say - great for light work or short use. I will not throw my Ryobi away but I sure don't use it. The Automach is such a pleasure to use. By the way, I appreciate the work you do with the American Woodturner.

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#19

Betty Scarpino

Re: Thank you, Jim.

Betty Scarpino

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#20

If You're Looking to Move Serious Wood

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You go pneumatic with a Trow & Holden. 1" for heavy, 3/4" for detail. Both will run on less than 6 cfm, but the chips will fly!!

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#21

Betty Scarpino

Re: If You're Looking to Move Serious Wood

Betty Scarpino

How does that system/machine/tool compare to an Arbortech reciprocating carver or an Arbortech mini grinder with the carbide blade? I use both of those machines when my Automach isn't heavy-duty enough.

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#22

Re: If You're Looking to Move Serious Wood

Donna Banfield

I'd be interested to hear that answer, too. I have an Arbortech with the lancelot and carbide disc, and have been looking at the Automach for reciprocating work since I burned up my WeeCher rotary and reciprocating carver. It just wasn't up to the heavy duty carving.

Do the pneumatic chisels work on removal of wood that isn't solid? The throw on those must be long, and I work on end grain vessels that are hollowed - the walls that I carve are 1/2 to 1" thick. I always thought that the air chisels really pounded the wood, making it risky to use on anything other than a solid log. Am I wrong?

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#23

Re: If You're Looking to Move Serious Wood

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

These are reciprocating air hammers, primarily used by stone carvers. But they have an adapter that takes the tang on wood chisels. I first used one on a visit to a "cutter" company outside Bloomington, IN when I was in grad school. I actually "carved" one of the limestone window sills that went into the WTC. I then adapted one for wood. That's when I started putting a convex bevel on my chisels; a hollow grind was too hard to control because it cut so fast. Blew through knots and left a beautiful chisel polish on the wood.

You imagine pounding a chisel through the negatives on this piece of walnut [about 6' high] ?


Hint: They were where two large limbs grew so the piece is a double crotch. ;)

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#24

Re: If You're Looking to Move Serious Wood

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Donna,

You'll need seriously sharp chisels, and you'll be cautious with the axis through the center of the tool. They will get you into trouble pretty quickly if you're not careful. I also predict you'll be using a polished convex bevel on your chisels before long, and sand bags will be your friends :D

They are NOT, however, going to do small/fine detail on a turning.

Re: Ryobi recipro carver questions

#25

Betty Scarpino

Re: If You're Looking to Move Serious Wood

Betty Scarpino

Donna, I would recommend an Automach reciprocating carver for what you are carving. Pneumatic carvers that Mark's talking about are too aggressive for carving a hollow vessel. (The Ryobi would be okay, too, but you'd only find a re-sale one.)

I used the Arbortech mini grinder (with carbide blade) and the Arbortech reciprocating carver to carve this sculpture. It's made from sycamore and is about 8-feet tall, 20" wide, and 4" thick. So, these two tools would be better for carving solid wood (as would what Mark's talking about). After heavy carving with the Arbortech tools, I followed that with detail carving with an Automach. Then of course rasps, rifflers, and sanding. Endless sanding.

The second image is more of what an Arbortech reciprocating carver would be useful for. Walnut, turned, carved, bleached grooves, about 19" diameter.