I am going to give a presentation to our local club on basic bowl design at our october meeting. I have read Russ's fine article on design. Wondering if anyone here might have other sources or thoughts which might add to the presentation?
There have been many discussions about design -- of bowls and a lot of other forms -- here over the years, Skip. If you do a keyword search, you will probably find plenty of insights worth considering.
..."The Art of Turned Bowls" is an excellent update of his earlier "Turned-Bowl Design." He has published several standards that should be in the library of every turner, and the language is clear and easily understood, without his Aussie accent.
Malcolm Zander also gave a demo on this topic at the Hartford AAW Symposium this past June - not sure of there are written/printed resources from him on this topic.
One of the best 'tricks' I learned in design was from Keith at an Albany symposium. He held up a chain with one end in each hand to simulate the shape of a bowl's sides and said, "Here are some good turning designs" as he moved his hands together and then further apart.
HI Jamie, I agree, Richard's book is the definitive book on bowl design, it should be required reading. Thanks Rob for suggesting my design ideas; Jack, Steve Sherman and I did a few design demos together, he showed me the catenary trick. Pretty neat...you can drop the chain inside a bowl form as well to check your progress.
Thanks to all for the information and suggestions. Would like to hear more about the chain trick. How did he move his hands etc. Thanks for the links to other material. Looks as though I might have a late night reading all this material.
Hey Skip, Yes, I've seen it done. Just take a length of chain, such as a necklace, and suspend it between your hands. Look at the curve it generates...smooth, flowing, with no interruptions. Moving your hands apart, or closer together changes the curve, yet retains the flowing curve. If you can turn a bowl with those same lines....viola.
Philip Streeting has a multi page article on both the chain and another similar method using curtain wire. Breif explanation: Use a cork board with paper on it. Use push pins to hold the chain like you want it. Trace the outline onto the paper.
The suspended by its ends chain trick illustrates what is called a Catenary Curve. Fix each end of a chain or rope or power line to two points at about the same horizontal level. Gravity will try and pull the chain, rope or power line down, less succesfuly at its fixed end points, more in the middle between them. Move then end points closer together and the curvature of the chain increases. Move the end points apart and the curvature of the chain, rope or cable decreases. Pull on the end points away from each other hard enough and the chain, rope or cable will go almost straight.
Look at any suspension bridge - the Golden Gate Bridge for exampe - and you'll see a catenary curve. You'll also see one on a skateboard "half pipe ramp" While called a "half pipe" it IS NOT made up of a quarter circle and a flat tangent to the curve at the bottom line. THAT combi would compress the hell out of the ramp rider on the bottom - and buckle or break his or her knees
Oddly, the catenary curve cannot be described exactly mathematically. There are mathematical equations that closely approximate a caternary curve - but not perfectly accurate.
The problem with hanging chains, ropes and cables is - gravity only works DOWN - so you have to lean your head over so its parallels the two fixed end points to see the curve well.
If you want to see a catenary curve approximation - on a flat piece of paper - sitting on a table - get a LONG hot melt glue gun glue stick. Lay it on the paper and push the ends towards each other. If you want to trace a curve you get that you like - drill a hole near one end of the long glue stick and drive a finishing nail through the slightly oversized hole into a piece of wood below - plywood for example. Now push. pull or try and rotate the other end of the glue stick. If you see a curve you like - trace it.
The long hot melt glue stick is also handy for checking for ripples and interruptions to a "fair curve". Bend it over the curved surface you want to check - and looks for gaps under the glue stick. THAT shows you WHERE your curve is off.
Now there a mathematical function that can produce some great looking curves. It's called a Hyperbolic Curve. Google "hyperbolic curve"