Antonucci - Tapcon Screw
Don Pencil
What size did you use? 3/16" or 1/4"
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Antonucci - Tapcon Screw
Don Pencil
What size did you use? 3/16" or 1/4"
I use both
Gil Jones
I have redrilled all of my faceplates to take 1/4" Tapcon flathead screws.
Mostly I use the 1/4" flathead Tapcons for heavy wood, and the 3/16" flathead Tapcons for smaller/lighter wood. Have never broken any of those screws, and they hold very well.
Gil
Dunno- I throw away the box
steven antonucci
Here is a picture of the screws I use in one of the faceplates. If you look at the underside of the head, you'll see a little flange which I suspect is meant to drill into the concrete board that these screws were designed for so that they sit flush.
There are only four screws in the picture, and you can see how much aluminum the screws have ground away as well as how much they continue to wear. If you look at the picture, you can also see the holes that the screws cut are very clean and they don't pull any wood fibers up so that the face plates can sit flat. The threads are almost the exact diameter of the holes in the faceplate so they also don't wobble.
I checked the metal filings and none of them are magnetic, so it's all aluminum from four screws that you see pictured. If you can tell from the picture of the bare screw, let me know.
Steve
Re: Dunno- I throw away the box
Barry Irby
Those appear to be "Buildex Backer-on #10 1 1/4" screws specifically designed for Hardibacker board. They are for putting up cement backer board for tile.
They are excellent screws but are technically not Tapcon Screws which are a name brand. The local borgs carry two very similar bands of screws. The Tapcon and its clone are blue and the Buildex and its clone are green.
The screws for the backer board are self countersinking with the little fins under the heads. That's why they are chewing up the faceplates. the steel in the screws is very hard and tough. The thread on the green ones are serrated so they won't back out.
Modify the screws?
Rob Wallace
Couldn't you just grind-off the countersinking tabs under the screw heads to save your faceplates from eventual total destruction? I'd be concerned about continual wearing away of the aluminum with every screw tightening I did.
Rob Wallace
Correct!
steven antonucci
I bought them for a tile project, and tried them on wood with the though being if they can cut concrete, they can cut wood. I have also used the blue ones, but the green ones are what I have in stock now. Not sure if the blue ones have the little ribs to counter sink.
Excellent screws.
S
Plan B-modify the faceplate
steven antonucci
Can't put metal back on, so I think I am "pot-committed" at this point. There is a little lip on the screw that should eventually sit flush on the surface of the faceplate once the correct countersink has been drilled.
I lose so many screws in the shavings pile that I have a metal detector by my lathe. Sadly, most of the things in that area are metal, and I never find the screws, but I do locate the cast iron legs accurately!
S
Comments from a non-turner
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
You can get Tapcons and their other-brand clones with male hex heads instead of the countersunk heads. These might not center quite as well, but they'd be easier on faceplates.
I'm a little concerned, though, with this discussion of Tapcon screws on a lathe. Tapcons are hard enough to cut threads through concrete when driven with an impact driver, and there's a kind of general direct relationship between hard and brittle. I've snapped off Tapcons while driving them because they hit a hard spot in the concrete - and they snap right-now-no-warning. I'm not sure how much shock they can take compared to, say, a sheet metal screw of the same diameter.
It'd be a shame to see your project hit the back wall of the shop just as you were getting to the final finishing touch; worse for it to go in the other direction.
You can get power-drive screws that are tempered to be tougher and softer; the tile-backer screws may be in that temper range.
I don't have an impact driver.
steven antonucci
I use a 19.2v Crapsman driver, and I think that it would be impossible to snap a head with it. Heck, it's almost impossible to drive a screw with it...
S
Not concerned about the installation
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
If the head snaps on installation, you know that you've got a problem. But it would be just as subject to shock breakage if, say, f'rinstance, the tool caught.
Laughed hard at that last paragraph!
Chuck Jones - West TN
Different forces and limits...
steven antonucci
Once in a while, we go through this a discussion like this on "What screws blah blah blah".
Here is a short version of why I think the answer is 'any screw' will work for me.
For starters, I am a pretty solid turner. No major catches anymore, but it wasn't always like that. Even when I did get a major catch, I still can't remember breaking a screw? Why is that?
Three forces at three different times make a screw break.
#1 tensile force- Imagine the block on a faceplate, and you pull on the block with enough force to break the screw by "stretching" it. First, this would be a massive effort. Secondly, the screw would pull out of the wood long before it broke. Lastly, there are almost no tensile forces in turning.
#2 shear force- Same block, but instead of pulling, you strike it with a hammer perpendicular to the lathe. This is the type of failure most people are worried about, but drywall screws are rated at 100# each, and Tapcons are 2x or more. It would take a mega catch to shear all 8 at one time.
#3 twisting forces- This is the one I care about the most! It occurs when you drive or remove a screw, and it is the thing that snaps the head off if the screws are too brittle. I have broken many a screw by twisting the head off, and I keep vise grips by my lathe just for this occasion. Never on a Tapcon, but too many to count with drywall and deck screws..
To further expand, if I am making a hat, it's probably 40# of wood mounted on a 2.5" faceplate with 8 tapcons (Buildex for Barry) screws and no issues. Wonder if the AAW Journal wants an article on screws?
Betty? 
S