In a few years, if things go well, we might build an addition to our house. If this happens -- or even if it does not -- I am thinking of building a shop, primarily for turning. So I need to start planning. Can you recommend good planning resources that would help me figure out its size, what tools I should place there (other than the lathe, of course) and how, how to do dust collection, ventilation etc etc. ?
Carole Valentine built a new shop within the last few years. Suggest you pick her brain for what she likes, what she doesn't and what she would change if she were doing it again. If I remember hers was pretty well planned out.
As far a sources, the group here is the best in telling you what they would change or add to their existing shops. If you think of it in that way..
environmental capabilities, say heat and air and if in a cold area, maybe a radiant heat floor.
size - I have a 25x25 and could easily expand to twice that. Think about just closed area, not wood storage. I don't keep much wood in my shop, but could use double tomorrow if I could just to put some space between items.
Separate breaker panel - I have 60 amps for the shop and another 50 for one kiln. Even without the kilns, you should have some breathing room in electricity.
Do you want to teach, add more space and electricity for that.
The current shop has a large lathe, metal lathe, metal mill, table saw, large band saw, lots of shelves, cyclone dust collector, large compressor.
No, unfortunately, mine was not well planned out at all! I did it in a hurry and I had no clue what I was doing! I would have made the wood storage/compressor room much bigger. If I had had the money I would have put in a bathroom and sink and central heat and ac. ( I now have a window AC and a little propane vented wall furnace, neither of which has to work hardly at all to keep a constant 72 summer and 68 winter) I have a huge completely open floored and insulated attic space (no trusses) but a pull down stair to get to it. Need a stairway outside up to it. Couple of things I did do right...put a wheelchair ramp along the side of the building and up to the back door. (Originally done for a friend so he could visit, but it's really handy for me to get wood and stuff into the shop on a hand truck.) I insulated, insulated, insulated! There is 14" of insulated space in the ceiling, 6" in the walls and can't remember what under the floor. I used recycled denim insulation in the walls, but if you do that run the wiring in conduit as it is impossible to drill through it or fish wires. I can heat the shop with a candle and cool it with an ice cube! I didn't slack on building materials...not many 2x4s in there except for interior walls. Floor (3/4" ply or did I do 2 layers of 1/2"? Can't remember - any way it is solid) is laid on 2x10s, doubled in the area where the lathe is. Oh and my well loved front porch with ceiling fan! I sit out there when I am doing hand work, carving etc. and my dog loves it too! Also have a little deck out the back door (super wide door) where I can catch the morning sun. Outlets...outlets everywhere, both 110 and 220, including the floor and ceiling, the porch and the back deck. Windows on every wall...that was a compromise of wall space, but I like light and to be able to see out. Still not enough natural light for me. Is it big enough? No...it would never be big enough! LOL I think it is 24x36. Oh yeah, had I known, I would have done the crawl space completely different - sealed, concrete with a drain, 4' high, lighted and easy access. Sorry for the "stream-of-thought" response.
I have been doing a 'shop design' presentation to woodworkers clubs for several years, and a few of the main points I emphasize are:
1. Stationary tool choice matched to intended operations. - Decide on what tools your shop should have (not just what you have now), and plan on some expansion. The lathe(s) should be positioned for access and safety, particularly if this will be one of the main functions of the space. Attention should be payed to inflow and outflow of stock as it enters and exits machines such as table saws, jointers, router tables, etc. Inflow/outflow areas in front of and behind machinery can be 'shared' by different machines if they are cleverly arranged. Flexibility in design can be achieved by putting some machinery on mobile bases, adding a lot of design alternatives (...although in my opinion, a lathe should never be on a mobile base!).
2. Work flow - If setting up for (small or large scale) production, there should be a logical work flow through the space from stock storage and preparation (cutting to length, ripping/milling operations), machining of parts/joinery, assembly of parts into finished assemblies, and then final sanding and finishing. This work flow design concept is predominantly for flat-work cabinetry and furniture building shops, but can have useful applications for other specialty-emphasis shops such as turning and luthier work as well, with obvious modifications needed.
3. Layout and positioning of machinery with dust collection efficiency as one of the major considerations - The efficiency of the dust collection system needs to be considered when positioning and setting-up the ducting system in the shop. Major chip generators (e.g. planers, jointers) or dust generators (e.g. surface/stroke sanders) should be located the closest to the central dust collection unit with the shortest run and largest diameter ducting; machinery and other dust pick-ups requiring lower air cfm ratings can be located more distantly, given the static pressure loss in longer runs of the duct system. Select a cyclone collector system at a static pressure/cfm rating (and thus motor HP rating) which is at or well above the minimum expected requirements for the existing and future machinery to be served by the system. There are many published and on-line sources which go though the necessary cfm & duct size requirements for the machinery to be used and the intended operations of the shop. Add floor sweep ports, and a few "extra" drops for expansion, or for occasional special operations.
4. Separate areas for storage, machining, assembly, and finishing - This is somewhat self explanatory, and will be dictated by the level and scope of intended operations of the shop space. How much lumber/how many blanks, etc. need to be kept in the shop space? How many workbenches or assembly tables are needed? What kind of joinery and other preparation work is necessary? Few would argue that a separate area for finishing, sealed off from dust-generating operations is a highly desirable addition to any shop. Such an area may need to have its own exhaust and make-up air system in place (explosion proof?). Spray booths or other special areas for finish application (and what kind of finishes will be used) should be considered as efficient means of accomplishing satisfactory brushing, spraying, and dust-free drying operations.
5. Infrastructure -Electrical requirements (i.e. sufficient 220V and 110V volt high current circuits (with appropriate breakers) for all machinery - separate sub-panel - lights on different circuits than machines, convenient electrical drops to hand-held corded power tools, etc.); sufficient lighting including general room lighting as well as task lighting for "delicate" operations (carving, turning, inlay, etc.); air quality considerations (air conditioning and heating; filtration if desired/necessary), plumbing - if sink/toilet needed in space; floor materials - poured cement (in floor heating?, sub-floor dust collection ducting), wooden floors, other materials; wall materials - drywall? plywood? car siding?, etc., space for cabinetry and shelving, surface treatment (painted? natural?), pegboard? wall-storage systems, etc.; compressed air - kind of air piping (black-pipe, sweatted copper, hoses only, but NOT PVC!), and locating compressor in separate space and/or with noise reduction; adequate easily-accessible storage for hand tools, corded power tools, blades, bits, chucks, fasteners, hardware, abrasives, etc.; amenities - telephone service, cable TV/Internet service, intercom to house (if necessary), music system, refrigerator, desk, etc.
Laying out a shop using some of the available on-line software such as Grizzly supplies is fine as long as dust collection efficiency, work flow, and safety are considered first - NOT just how the machinery will "fit" into the available space - a common error committed by woodworkers is not adequately thinking through and researching the needed parameters of how the shop SYSTEMS will work together. Vendors such as Oneida Air (which sells dust collection equipment) have free shop layout and dust collection design services to maximize on the efficiency of the dust collection system. In my opinion, any shop in an enclosed space should have the most efficient dust collection possible, and the positioning of equipment to maximize this trumps most other considerations of where machinery should be placed, although with careful planning, most shop spaces can be designed to meet most, if not all design criteria I've mentioned above. There are several different books on the market which discuss home woodshop design and provide some tips and advice.
I actually have a separate presentation for both beginners and established turners about setting-up an efficient and safe woodturning station using basic principles of industrial ergonomic design, and meeting the specific needs of woodturners to function effectively with turning tools, sharpening equipment, and other turning-related operations.... but that's another story...
It is exciting and fun to plan one's dream shop, or at least make the best of the available space dedicated to working with wood. I think most woodworkers consider their shop a continual work in progress, with changes necessary as tools and woodworking priorities change through time.