Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Ethics

Posts

Ethics

#1

Ethics

Paul Zerjay

You ever pull a piece off the lathe, and it just doesn't look as good as it could? I have two of these right now. Time required to fix would be minimal, maybe 1-1/2 hrs with having to re-set and re-finish everything.

I sell everything I turn. And I have been doing it long enough to know these pieces will sell quickly, they just aren't up to MY standards. I guarantee, 9 out of 10 people wouldn't even notice the flaw that is so obvious to me.

You have told yourself in the past that everything that comes out of your shop is the absolute best you can do. But there's that little nagging voice that keeps telling you these will sell, move on to something else and get a bigger inventory built up for that big show you have coming up. But then there's the other voice that says, "It's your name on these pieces, better make 'em right."

My wife says I'm too critical of my own work, and just because I don't think it's perfect, doesn't mean it won't bring joy to someone else.

Any thoughts?

Re: Ethics

#2

Re: Ethics

Lance Kanaby

It's all a matter of perspective and your own values...

Re: Ethics

#3

JL

Re: Ethics

JL

I turn mostly spindles. If the turnings don't match - it is pretty obvious. If I'm turning a leg - the measurements have to be pretty spot on.

So everything has to match and everything has to look reasonable. Furniture is sort of obvious.

I have a burn pile of turnings that didn't quite make it. The people who heat with wood are glad for it.

Re: Ethics

#4

Re: Ethics

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Paul, when we are amateurs, the best we can do is not related to time. When we are selling our work, time becomes a factor. Is it the best you can do with the time allotted so that you can remain profitable? I often obsess about things that are not perfect, but my wife helps me over it. She reminds me how imperfect I am for starters. :D Good enough often means just that. Perfection is an elusive thing that we will never reach, even though it is worthy to strive for it.

Re: Ethics

#5

Re: Ethics

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Your are the guy staring back at you in the mirror each morning. What do you want to think of yourself? And when you start compromising, where does it end? Not to mention how well you sleep each night.

High personal standards seem to be in short supply these days. I am proud to know someone who questions the ramifications of lessening their own standards. Keep up the good work. You are a gem among the rabble.

Re: Ethics

#6

Steven Antonucci

If you do it once, what's to stop you next time?

steven antonucci

I make two different levels of my work for sale.

Level #1

The work that sells. I price it according to the effort, and for the effort I make, it is very good work. There are some pieces that never get out of the shop because they don't live up to this standard, but generally speaking, the work could be a lot better, but I'd have to double the price.

Level #2

The work that I put everything I know and am capable into. It is finely sanded and finished to the best of my ability. Hand carved, ever detail fussed over. I price it accordingly and then usually collect it back at the end of the show. Just like your customer who never saw your flaw, my customer never saw that I went back to fix it, even if it took 2 days to do it.

Using this rationale, it's easy to justify A work and B work, and having price points to support both. It depends on if you want this "imperfect" piece to be a B piece or not. I wouldn't put it out there as an A piece.

That's my .02.

Steve

Re: Ethics

#7

Re: Ethics

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

Yours is the only opinion that counts. Forget what the customer thinks or doesn't think. If you don't like the piece, either fix it or trash it. There doesn't seem to be any other choice. I sell very little of my work so it is easy to take this point of view but I feel that since I want the customer to give me some money, threy deserve the best work that I can do.

Re: Ethics

#8

Re: Ethics

George Guadiane

I like the word Standards better than Ethics, I think it better addresses your concerns.

You are the only one who can decide if your standards are too high.

Re: Ethics

#9

Remember...

Paul Zerjay

This is how I put food on the table. Are you that quality minded of your product at your work? This is business. Time is money. I believe my lovely wife and Mr.Grumbine have good points.

Re: Ethics

#10

Re: Ethics

Fred Bearman

It's your name on the piece - if you are comfortable selling the piece with your name on it, then that's all there is to it. It's not a question of ethics, but the price of your name.

Re: Ethics

#11

Re: Ethics

Randy Johnson

I do a few craft shows and festivals a year and the quality of my turnings varies a great deal, sometimes by design, sometimes not. I can take a great deal of time with the finish, but sometimes a potential buyer might prefer a more primitive look. For those people I always have a few bowls and boxes sanded down to 120 or 150 grit and no more than two coats of oil.

I learned early that when it comes to turned wood, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I have made a few pieces that I personally thought were pretty awful. Most of them are gone, either purchased at a show or (more often) given to a visitor to the shop who thought a certain piece was the neatest thing they had ever seen. I have even had people dig through my to-be-burned pile and rescue things I considered beyond redemption. It isn�t like you are selling a car with sawdust in the transmission. The bottom line, is that I don�t have to satisfy me - I have to satisfy the customer. I have sold pieces with cracks, but those cracks were in the piece when it was made. The customer wanted those cracks or I would not have been able to sell it.

The things I make now are better than what I was making two years ago or even last year. I have yet to make anything that I was 100% happy with. I always hope the next one will be the first but, realistically, I can�t imagine it ever happening.

Re: Ethics

#12

Re: Ethics

Terry Scott

Paul Glad to here someone else thinks like I do.

Put the no 2s aside and revisit them. These are often what I use as a canvas for carving

No way I can fix bad form but defects can be used for as inspiration. For example a crack carve or pierce through and around it

Or Just give away to relatives L.o.l

Re: Ethics

#13

Once upon a time....

Randy Johnson

There was a nationally known knife maker who chanced to come across one of his early efforts that was so inferior to what he was then making he tried to buy it back to get it out of circulation. The owner would not part with it even when offered a knife worth five or six times as much in trade. I'm sure there are a lot of us who have things floating around out there with our names on them that we wish we had back.

Re: Ethics

#14

Re: Remember...

john lucas

Paul I agree with you. I know sometimes the pieces I sell have imperfections. Most people, no virtually very few people would ever notice. I look at it like machine work vs hand work. Hand work will never be perfect and small variations show that.

I don't think it's unethical to sell work like this. When you have to pay the bills you sell what you can. As long as it's not bad work but still quality work then I don't see there is anything wrong with it.

Re: Ethics

#15

Re: Ethics

Carole Valentine

I think the standards you set for your name are a very personal thing. And one's circumstances often influence the standards. I have a ton of pieces that I will not sell because I am not totally happy with them, but like Terry, if possible I use them as experimental canvases.Or they go in the burn barrel. I dare say most of those pieces would sell if I chose to do so and put a low enough price on them...but I am my own worst critic, so I don't. I also have a day job, but you are selling to put food on the table. If you are not happy with a piece, I would say you should still sell it but perhaps not at the premium you would sell a perfect piece (if there is such a thing).

Re: Ethics

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Ethics

Keith Tompkins

Hi Paul, I recently faced a similar dilema. I was preparing a new piece for the AAW instant gallery in Hartford, and the piece was going to feature my new gold-leaf technique of acryic gold misted over 23K gold, with several clear coats. After applying the size an then the gold leaf, I noticed specks that appeared to be imbedded in the size coat and telegraphing through the gold layer. Dirty brush? Redoing the process didn't help, same problem. I discovered the (very expensive) size was contaminated. Time to pack up for the symposium, and the piece isn't right...What should I do? Hell, who would notice anyway? I left the piece home; disappointed that I had no piece for the IG. (I sold my other piece I planned to bring) When I returned home, I redid the gold leaf...that's the winged finial box I recently posted, which I'm now finally happy with. So, my answer is re-do the pieces, esp. if they only require one or two hours each. You will be glad you did.

Re: Ethics

#17

Re: Ethics

Reed Gray

I price my pieces accordingly. The prices when they are on a shelf will vary according to what I like and don't like, and if it has been around too long, the price goes down as well. If people ask me about the price variations, I will tell them why. Most don't care. I will not sell a utility piece with a flaw in it. I do take all my rejects to one show and charge almost nothing for them, and tell the people why they are so cheap. I would rather almost give them away than burn them.

I do know of a guitar maker who is so good that he is back ordered for a couple of years. If the end product isn't to his standards, he will burn it. To me, that is criminal to waste some thing that is still way above what most others can do. "it really breaks my heart to see those stars, smashing perfectly good guitars"... I think that was Randy Newman.

I have gotten a couple of factory rejects from Doug Thompson. I couldn't find anything wrong with them.

I guess my point is I sell some as is because almost every one has some use, and I don't like to waste them.

robo hippy

Re: Ethics

#18

Criminal?

Carole Valentine

90% of the wood I get was headed for the fireplace or the burn pile to begin with...if some of what I make out of it turns out to be crumby enough that I don't want to give it away to relatives or even use it myself, much less sell it, then I figure I just gave it a little detour on it's way to it's original destiny. And I got in a little practice and hopefully some learning. Nope, not going to accept any guilt over that.

Re: Ethics

#19

Re: Ethics

Paul Zerjay

Hi Keith

Great to see your fantastic piece the other day. But lets be realistic here. That's like comparing apple to oranges. My piece in question is just a little $150 outside art fair piece. Yours belongs in Del Mano.

Re: Ethics

#20

Analogy from flatwork land

wilbur

I think it depends on the flaw you are trying to fix. If it's a design flaw, that's one thing. But if it's a bit of tearout that might have a minimal impact on your ability to sell the piece, that may not be something to worry about too much.

If you are trying to sell furniture pieces, for some customers, the idea that the piece was hand made carries a price premium. What comes along with a hand made object are small variations that is evidence that you didn't do the piece with a CNC machine -- things like small variations in the spacing of dovetails, the imperceptible variations in the top due to hand planing that can't be seen but can be felt, and so on. What you might think is a flaw at first can also be looked at as adding character to the piece.

One other thing: I think that the hand tool philosophy applies to woodturning. After all, you are using your hand to control the tool. It's the spinning clamp that has the motor on it. ;)

Re: Ethics

#21

Re: Analogy from flatwork land

Barry L Elder

When and if I ever receive a "perfect" piece of wood, then the end piece will be perfect. Until then, I will work with the beauty in the wood that my God has given to me. I am not particularly given to turning a piece of wood into a piece of plastic to meet someone else's definition of perfect. There have been many great comments in this thread, but in each, there is personal thought. We are all different and that is great in itself.

Re: Ethics

#22

Paul, you answered your own question

Ruth Niles

Not that your name isn't worth the best.

No way if you do this once, you'll do more poor quality work.

Sounds like only a professional turner will note the type of flaw you indicate.

Listen to your wife, it's beautiful and someone will love it.

Re: Ethics

#23

Another perspective

charlie belden

Only God is perfect - or so the saying goes. But frankly, if you look around at some of His/Her/Their "creations", you certainly have to wonder about even His/Her?Their standards of perfection.

Aim high. If you miss the first time - have other arrows in your quiver - and adjust your aim for the next shot.

If you attain perfection - then where do you go?

The last thing you want to do - is get root bound?

Re: Ethics

#24

Re: Ethics

Doug Trembath

Paul, I didn't read every response, so maybe this perspective has already been shared, but...

When I was turning as a production turner, I burned or broke a lot of pieces which were simply not good enough to sign. My craftsmen friends would lament that they couldn't recognize the flaw, and it was criminal to destroy something that nice. I disagreed. Then I came up against the same type of dilemma Keith shared, a time crunch with a major show coming up. I then made what I felt was a major change in approach. I sold quite a few pieces subsequently without a signature. I reserved signing for work that I felt was my best, and priced it accordingly, but I allowed many people the opportunity to own a piece that they treasured that could not afford a signed one. I got a LOT of gratification from seeing the faces of single mom's and other struggling craftsmen who simply did not have the funds available, and my work sits proudly displayed in their homes, with the added benefit that they remind me of it at each subsequent meeting, or when they saw me at the next show.

I'm proud to say that these pieces, although not something I would sign, bring joy and pride of ownership to folks who would not have that opportunity otherwise. It occurred to me that not everyone who treasures art and quality craft is a well-heeled collector capable of spending excessive amounts of money for what remains, in the final analysis, a non-essential frill.

Sometimes when we experience success in these ventures, we can come to a point that we end up taking ourselves too seriously, and forget the reasons we got into the craft in the first place. I'm much happier and more satisfied with this approach, and maybe a bit more humble than I was before.

Just this man's experience and opinion...

Doug Trembath

Re: Ethics

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Ethics

Keith Tompkins

Hi Paul, thanks! I think instead of the apples and orange comparison, we should all compare our work to our own standards. We all make pieces that don't quite measure up in one way or another. Sometimes, we just have to chalk things up to experience, and make the next piece just a little bit better. BTW, don't sell yourself short...you're doing some pretty impressive stuff!