Anatomy of a hat failure
steven antonucci
I felt like doing something last night, and the wife had the kids at the beach, so I had the house to myself. After putzing around the garage for a few, I settled in on making a hat.
This would be hat #5, and I would try to incorporate everything I had learned from hats 1-4. I estimate that the time spent is usually in thirds. The first third is spent roughing out, which gets you to this point. If I had a bigger lathe, I could probably cut this time in half, but there is a lot of time spent at lower RPMs. As you can see, the lower RPMs don't throw the shavings very far 

The hat is mounted on a face plate from the bottom, which means I will need to turn it around. Here is a little trick I used for getting the other face plate on and almost perfectly centered. It worked within 1/32", and a quick retrue completes the first "third". (A thick hat form)

The second "third" is spent making the brim. The hardest part is the inner transition measurement where the brim meets the inside of the hat. If you get this wrong, they won't bend. Light is the key, but it also plays tricks. If you look at this picture, you might think it's all uniformly thin, but it's not. When the hat failed, I measured it in a few spots. Brim 60/1000ths. Transition 125/1000ths. Upper spot 40-60/1000ths.
The failure is somewhat of a mystery to me, although I think I know what happened. When you are hollowing the upper, it gets very easy to hog out material from the middle, since the fine cuts aren't usually until you get under 1/4". The problem with doing this is that you have a large mass of shavings that ball up inside the hat, and I had a slight "tear" in the crown that I think came from the ball pushing against it. It would have been repairable.
I reverse the hat against a pair of cole jaws and started pairing off the upper mass. I was probably about 3/16" thick in the top when my turning was interrupted by a loud bang. No catch, just the bang... and the flying hat pieces.

Now, the issue is like a CSI episode. As you can see, my cole jaws are missing a piece, but I think that happened "after the fact". A while back, I lost one of the screws in a pile of shavings, so that jaw was only held on with one screw (duh!), but I am not sure if the jaw came off first, causing the hat the dislodge or if the split caused it to flex out of the tailstock point. The hat was broken along that failure line...
It seems that it may be time to make that thing that Johannes uses to reverse the hats...
Steven



