Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Notes from last nights club meeting

Posts

Notes from last nights club meeting

#1

Steven Antonucci

Notes from last nights club meeting

steven antonucci

A few of the member of the NJ Woodturners and I held 'secret' meetings at our club last night rather than broadcast the distressing situation with the AAW. These folks are the ones that I consider "active AAW members" and not just interested in the magazine. I found out a few things that were a little bit disturbing:

1.) Not everyone knows Mary was fired. One guy had heard that she stepped down, and took it at face value. Another guy hadn't heard at all. Neither is particularly active on the internet, so they had very little information. Once the facts had been explained to them, they quickly came to the conclusion that many of us have. If it walks like a duck, it's a duck...

2.) When the situation around the bylaws was explained, the cry for revision was unanimous. This came from all backgrounds- high ranking professional people, retirees, and blue collar workers. None of them needed it explained- it was obvious that it was wrong, and common sense terms were all that was needed to fix it.

3.) Outside of the current situation, a few members commented that they would not be renewing membership because they felt that the AAW had "lost it's way". These were guys who have been longstanding members, aren't terribly political, have no aspirations to the AAW board... they just didn't think that the AAW was worth renewing their membership. Comment like "too much carving", "too much embellishing', "is that even turned?" were thrown out with very little provocation. (I use all of those techniques, so I am NOT AGAINST them, I am just reporting the facts)

4.) I suspect that if I had grabbed a torch and pitchfork, I could have easily assembled an angry mob behind me. (I know I could have...but I didn't) If this is the situation in one club, I wonder how many more would be exactly the same? If it's unilateral, then I suggest that the AAW stops moving forward until it fixes this problem. I fear they will only move forward with half of the membership if they don't...

My two cents.

Steve

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#2

Richard Allen

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

Richard Allen

Pitch fork and torch at my club would be seen as showing the way to free turning wood.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#3

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

Stuart Johnson

Steve, I'm one of those members that joined for the magazine. I don't belong to a club and find most of my interaction with other turners comes from either WC or WOW. I dropped my membership a few years ago because I didn't feel the magazine alone was worth the price. I did rejoin this year because of the Segmented Woodturners chapter and to be able to access the online magazines.

I have never met any of the parties involved and only know Malcolm through a few emails, the Segmented Woodturners site and his DVD's. That doesn't mean I don't have some pretty strong feelings about the way things were handled. Without knowing all that has taken place it seems to me the AAW is splitting into two groups just like political parties. There are the Evolved Artists and the Traditional Turners that KNOW they are right and pure while the other group is evil. Like our current politics there are others like you that are independents. Unfortunately many independents tend to listen to the loudest and last voice and change their position accordingly.

In my opinion all of this mess is going to take a while to sort out but first it has to be decided just what to sort out. The first thing is to decide if the BOD mission is to guide the AAW in the direction they want or the direction the majority of the membership wants. If the goal is for the BOD to determine just where the AAW is going then there is no need for any change because the bylaws seem to give them the power. If the BOD is charged with taking AAW in the direction the majority of member want then some bylaws may need changing. In either event the minority and their interest must be protected.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#4

Steve- your observation is correct.....

JamieDonaldson

.... that a great majority of AAW members don't have a clue about recent events. In the interum of the cooling off period, the By-Laws definitely need serious revision, a project that would be assisted by some good legal assistance, and I'm hoping that some interested attorney members would be willing to offer their services for the betterment of our future AAW.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#5

Re: Steve- your observation is correct.....

George Guadiane

How about a "Constitutional Convention?" Each local club, or a percentage of the clubs, drawn by lot could send a representative along with the board to hammer this all out.

No torch or pitch fork, of course.

I think, as Steve pointed out about his meeting, a cross section of all members can probably be found in every/any of the clubs, but to be sure to get a balance, a large representation by a diverse selection of clubs ought to get a consensus of what we NEED to change, what we WANT to change and what needs to stay. This would give a good representation of the current membership in today's AAW.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#6

Conventioneers

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Sounds like a fun party, George, until somebody gets the bills for travel, hotels, meals, etc., etc. If the assumption is that this could all get done in a week, you best figure on at least $2,500 a head, but if it doesn't get done in that week, each club or rep will still be out the dough.

Democracy doesn't come cheap, and it requires way more than the "blood of patriots." This could get really expensive.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#7

Re: Steve- your observation is correct.....

Brian George

The Secretary of AAW posted some comments yesterday about the sudden interest in the inner workings of the AAW, after earlier apologizing for not posting BOD minutes in a more timely fashion. My point being that there seems to be a lot of track covering going on to justify what's happened.

My entire intent on pursuing a "5% committee" was to start people thinking about whose organization it is. I continue to get emails from around the world asking to be included in this.

Steve your meeting idea is perfect. Our club has 1/3 of its membership as members of AAW. Most don't spend a lot of time on the 'net and one doesn't even own a computer.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#8

Steven Antonucci

My point is 'I'm not alone"

steven antonucci

I just have a big mouth :)

For every vocal, dissatisfied post, there are numbers behind them, waiting in the wings- either too timid to voice their opinions on an open forum or ignorant of the situation.

I suspect that it's way more than the "5%" needed, and actually may be a majority of the AAW membership that feels this way- on one or more of the topics I mentioned.

"Listening to the people" is how we avoid revolution...viva la revolution! ;)

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#9

Steven Antonucci

Do it "online"- no need to physically gather

steven antonucci

Draw up a simple, unilaterally distributed memorandum of understanding that only gauges a 'temperature check' - just to validate that there is a concern among the membership. In fact, here it is:

To whom it may concern:

We would like to inform you that we, (club name here), have discussed in open conversation the following topics within our chapter meeting on (date). We took a vote amongst the present AAW members within that chapter and would like to report the results of that vote to the Board of Directors.

On the topic of Mary Lacer's termination, we asked the membership how many felt it was unjustified (X for, Y against, Z abstain). We also asked how many felt it was dealt with poorly and/or in bad taste (X,Y, Z)

On the topic of the Bylaws and governance, we asked the membership how many felt that the bylaws needed to be amended to correct governance issues. (X,Y,Z)

On the topic of the transparency of Board meetings, better and more timely release of meeting notes on the AAW site (X, Y, Z)

On the topic of whether or not the current AAW Board is capable of the leadership that supports the current AAW mission statement (X,Y,Z)

We certify that this meeting was held in an open and honest context with all current public information equally disseminated and that the numbers that the executive committee of (club) have presented here are accurate.

Signed,

President of your local chapter

If I were king of the world, I'd want to know what the peasants were thinking so I knew how high to build the castle walls. My goal would be to not have to build castle walls at all, knowing that there's always going to be a peasant building a bigger ladder...

Steve

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#10

On Line Survey

Joel

Use an online survey, such as www.surveymonkey.com, you can calibrate it and get better than YES/No answers.

Joel

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#11

Re: Conventioneers

George Guadiane

Mark, in light of your other posts on this, it makes sense that you would throw cold water on any idea that might change the status quo to better reflect the thoughts, feelings and needs of the greater/whole membership. Do you REALLY think that we are all to dumb or ignorant or, I really don't know what, to have valid, valuable input into the organization that we are part of?

If the board can spend money on retirement packages, lawyers and the like, then we (the Association) must have a lot of it. Why not devote some of it to the improvement of the organization?

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#12

Sounds like a good idea!

George Guadiane

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#13

Got Some Assumptions to Deal With

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Steve,

Your suggestion has some hurdles to deal with.

1. You assume that you can reach all 13,000 members through the internet. Even if they all use computers and have e-mail (which I seriously doubt) you've got a pistol of a job compiling the e-mail list and verifying that each member "entitled to vote" got the notice.

"Wait," you say, "we'll do it through the clubs."

2. Requires the assumption that all 13,000 dues-payers both belong to clubs and go to meetings where and when they can be reached.

3. Assuming a club meeting contact is feasible, there's going to have to be some way to insure that issues are presented to the attending members in a very neutral, dispassionate way to insure the absence of influence, then verify the "precinct" (club) vote tallies are accurate, including, of course, that non-AAW club members are excluded from the vote.

4. Who and how are both the subject and the text of proposals going to be drafted? Won't this require a "pre-convention convention" just to get the 'New Rules' written?

You've got some thinking do, I think.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#14

Are you trying to help or

George Guadiane

just throwing cold water on any idea that you don't agree with?

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#15

Cold Water

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

No, George, just small reality checks.

I'm not, however, playing Sancho Panza to a corps of Don Quixotes.

Your significant line of postings indicate that you're seemingly very quick to convict and brand otherwise honest people based upon rumor and hearsay rather than hard evidence.

What I have suggested is that people spend some time and learn about what they propose to do before they go charging off to 'storm the Bastile' which could well cause far more serious damage to the organization they purport to care for and wish to protect.

Sorry if that crimps your style.

Get over it.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#16

Steven Antonucci

Answers:  Statistical sampling not a vote

steven antonucci

You are a lawyer. I am the math guy, so let me do my thing :)

Your suggestion has some hurdles to deal with.

1. You assume that you can reach all 13,000 members through the internet. Even if they all use computers and have e-mail (which I seriously doubt) you've got a pistol of a job compiling the e-mail list and verifying that each member "entitled to vote" got the notice.

[Answer: Statistically valid cross section of AAW membership is likely avilable to gather data (not vote). Think of it like an opinion poll. If I asked how many folks in NJ Woodturners liked the color red, and counted hands. If you are not in the AAW, I don't care if you like red or not.

"Wait," you say, "we'll do it through the clubs."

2. Requires the assumption that all 13,000 dues-payers both belong to clubs and go to meetings where and when they can be reached.

[Answer: Again, statistics. If we assume an even distribution, and not only the people who like red will attend meetings, the numbers should be close enough for government work]

3. Assuming a club meeting contact is feasible, there's going to have to be some way to insure that issues are presented to the attending members in a very neutral, dispassionate way to insure the absence of influence, then verify the "precinct" (club) vote tallies are accurate, including, of course, that non-AAW club members are excluded from the vote.

[See above: it's not a vote. It's a opinion poll]

4. Who and how are both the subject and the text of proposals going to be drafted? Won't this require a "pre-convention convention" just to get the 'New Rules' written?

[Answer: I think we are all adults. I would point people to resources for information, and let them make their own decisions before the vote. Having educated voters, perhaps discussion before the vote would be warranted. You'd be welcome to argue either side of the case, as I'm just the math guy]

You've got some thinking do, I think.

Statitical samples are used to predict who wins and loses elections, what you will buy, when you will buy it, and how far you will travel. Since we're not trying to be perfect, but only get a temperature on the organization, I think this would be simple and very eye-opening. If it was just 5% grumbling, then to hell with the malcontents...but if it's closer to the majority, someone should know.

S

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#17

Re: Are you trying to help

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Definitely.

But also trying to help people from stomping on their privates.

In an international organization with 13,000 members these are not simple matters to deal with, and simplistic approaches will surely fail, leading to more hard feelings, more broken friendships, and much more recriminations.

You want to change the make up and governing rules of the AAW? Great, get off the internet forum soapbox, go research not-for-profit charitable association / corp rules, see what can and can't be done, learn what works and what becomes too cumbersome, then work up a plan for deliberate, seriously considered detailed steps to be taken to move toward those goals with the maximum amount of AAW member input involved as well as all governmental rules and regulations followed.

Don't expect this to happen overnight. You have a rather long road ahead of you with more than a few curves.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#18

Re: Cold Water

George Guadiane

Early on, I made statements, some of which may have been across the line. For which I apologize.

At this point, I'm asking questions, if you read my posts for content rather than position.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#19

Does that have to be my job or

George Guadiane

can I raise questions for people with that kind of knowledge?

Do I have to know how to build the car to be allowed to drive it?

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#20

Re: Answers

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Steve, I understand your proposal, but a charity can't operate on an opinion pole, no matter how valid the sample. Were that the case, we wouldn't need the vote, just a bunch of pollsters. Plus it will take far too long.

When they're not demanding Directors' heads and taking sides in an employee matter on which they have no hard evidence, people (forum members, anyway) have focused on changing the AAW By-Laws.

So, why not put together a cogent set of proposals, with the current AAW By-Laws as the start, that address what you think need to be changed. Consult with knowledgeable counsel since you're going to need legal advice anyway, make changes if required, then get it out there to the membership, send those proposals to all the club presidents with a request for feedback.

What? You waiting for the committee (5% or otherwise) to be formed?

Make no mistake, I'm not dropping the gauntlet or challenging you personally. But there's been whole bunches of rhetoric flying thick and fast and not a single concerete and detailed proposal put forth (that I've seen) beyond the "Trow da bums out" kind of stuff that does nothing but vent spleens. Might be good for the digestion, but doesn't do a thing for the AAW. ;)

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#21

Steven Antonucci

I'm in Sales too, Mark: Qualify, Qualify, Qualify

steven antonucci

No sense in preparing a proposal if the customers are just tire-kickers. If they ain't buying, you should know that before you do all of that work.

I'm merely suggesting that we quickly and easily get AAW members together to qualify the level of discontent (and in a manageable way- not some national convention-although we did have 10% in Hartford...I digress)

If the numbers don't support change, then change won't happen. If the numbers expose the desire to change, then we can debate what, who, why and how and get some proposals together.

But I ain't writing word one until I know where WE all stand. If I'm alone, then I just saved me a bunch of headache for nuthin'

S

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#22

Re: Are you trying to help ....Mark

Stuart Johnson

Please stop being a voice of reason. Torches are being doused and pitchforks set aside. We are trying work up a good ire here, right or wrong, and you keep telling us to think of the consequences.

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#23

In this case yes you do.

Ray - Middletown, IN

You can't yell file in a crowded theater then stand around wringing your hands hoping the firemen show up to save the day.

Ray

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#24

Food for thought

Ron Sardo

1) How about a mailing to all the AAW Club Presidents informing them what is going on and asking them to inform their members as to what is going on?

2) On line surveys are easy to build

Re: Notes from last nights club meeting

#25

Re: Are you trying to help ....Mark

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

Isn't that called a "realism check?"

Let's be realistic. I am certainly angry over the firing of Mary Lacer. I would like to see our bylaws changed to remove some of the godlike power from the Board of Directors. But... and there always is a but, it will be a difficult activity to coordinate.

I am the current president of a local chapter. When, during a meeting, I ask for volunteers, the majority of the attendees develop a sudden fascination for their feet. All heads go down and they stare at the floor. It is difficult to make eye contact with anyone. I suspect we may have the same situation here.

Folks may rant and rave about the BOD but very few will take an active part in doing anything about it. Just my thoughts with no intention to inflame an already flammable situation.