Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Posts

Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#1

Coring with the McNaughton; Long

robo hippy

Well, as I mentioned in my last post in the latest one about the McNaughton center saver, I had talked with Kel McNaughton. He, and a few turners, were concerned with my 'negative' comments about the system. So, I need to clear some things up here.

First, I think you all know that I prefer the McNaughton coring systems over the other systems available. Simply, it is fastest to set up, and core with. It is also the most versatile system out there. It is the one I recommend, but with the side note that there is a learning curve associated with it, while the other systems are easier to just pick up and use.

While getting my bowl coring DVD together, Kel and I talked a lot by phone and e-mail. He, like any good manufacturer is very concerned about product quality. I respect him as a manufacturer and he seems to be a nice guy as well.

With his new Mark 8 coring set up, there have been some notable quality changes. One was he updated his instructions. They are better than the old ones I got when I got my first coring system some 10 years ago. I just down loaded them and read them a couple of times. I won't go so far as to call them good, but they are adequate to get you started. As an instructor, I consider the best learning method to be to find some one who is competent with the tool and have a work shop/mentoring session with them. This is not always possible. The next best situation is to get a DVD. Going with the expression, "A picture is worth a thousand words", you get a lot more from an hour long DVD than you can from a short pamphlet. The last solution is the written word, and a book isn't practical expense wise for a production product, but what he has is fine. There is a lot of info on his web site to help turners to learn to use this tool. I am some one who has problems translating the written instructions on anything to action, and seeing is a lot more effective learning tool to me. This is what was behind my comments about his instructions being brief. There are a few things that I would mention on the instructions that come with the tool, and I will digest that for a while before I present them to Kel. Writing an instructional manual is very difficult.

As to the quality of the blades. He did make some changes to his manufacturing processes with the Mark 8 system. The older blades were inconsistent in their bends. I believe that most of this has been solved with the Mark 8 blades. Kel did send me most of a Mark 8 system to try out and get my feed back. He sent the medium blades, and the micro blades. I have so many blades that I am not sure which ones are the new ones. I did just order a new meduim curved blade, for the standard set, and will check it out for the curvature.

Drifting (where the blade wants to travel to the outside of the cut, rather than following the curve of the blade) has been one of my hurdles in this coring system that, to me, seems to cause the most problems. I have talked to Mike Mahoney about it a lot. He says it doesn't drift, I say, if it doesn't drift, then why do you have to open up the cut, and move your tool rest to adjust the cut, and why does the blade bind up in the cut some times. To me, this is a puzzle l that I have to solve. Will I ever solve it? Maybe. Will I stop trying to solve it? No. One reason I ordered a new blade is to check it out. I do have one blade that I modified slightly by bending in the tip slightly, and it cuts without needing correcting.

I have made a number of modifications to this tool. As I said in my DVD, Engineers motto: if it aint broke, take it apart and fix it anyway. While I may not have said this directly, these are modifications that I have made to the tool, and they may or may not help you in using this tool. I don't expect every one to agree with my points on the tool, or anything else that I do. We are all different, and some of us are more different than others.

If you want more detailed explanations on why I have locked down my support fingers, ground the spear point down square, and start large bowls with the cutter being as much as 1/2 inch above center, I will explain.

How different am I? Well, I prefer scrapers for roughing bowls. To some this is sacrilege. To others it is just plain crazy. I have had a number of people come up to me after my turning demos and state, I will have to rethink scrapers after seeing how you use them.

robo hippy

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#2

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

fgvanatta

I think your assessment of the McNaughton system is accurate and fair.

I've had mine for almost 10 years, and the biggest problem has been getting started with the original instructions. Or - to be more accurate - lack of instructions. My solution was to turn to Mike Darlow's Woodturning Techniques. Once I figured out the basics the rest was fairly easy.

Frank

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#3

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Texian

Agree with what Frank said. And that there should indeed be concern regarding product quality, especially with respect to blade shape and owners' need to bend them to correct. A couple of years ago I found the product impossible to use and returned it for a refund. At the very least it should carry a warning that it may be difficult for the novice to use successfully, and some practice is required. Beyond that, once a master has been produced it is quite inexpensive to create many copies of a DVD, and it would seem appropriate to include same with this tool. If the system functioned well and easily for the novice it would be excellent value per $ compared to other systems. As it was, that was not the case.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#4

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Skewed

I believe that the others have identified my primary complaint with the system. The blades need to be the arc of a circle and it is easy to check this with a large sheet of paper and multiple concentric rings. If the blade does not lay on one circle perfectly then it will bind and there is a lot of widening of the kerf to get through the cut, not to mention all the smoke. I have given up using my system several times. Then I watch Mike Mahoney do another demo and I go dig the system out and try it again. Quality control in manufacturing is key, presuming that the blades are bent onto a form it is hard to understand not having the correct arc. Unfortunately it took me several tries and much smoke before I figured out that it was poor quality cotrol in manufacturing and not operator error. I have had the system for several years and still have not had success with it.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#5

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Dale Bright

I agree with has been said here. I have had the medium set for a couple of years and just yesterday I checked the curve of the small and medium knives. The medium knife has an almost perfect arc but the small one is a bit off. This is confusing because I never have issues with the small knife binding but i have had a lot of trouble with the medium one.

I have relied heavily on the DVDs from Reed and Mike Mahoney for instruction. The new instructions on the McNaughton site are much improved.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#6

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Russ Fairfield

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#7

Re: Poor Quality Control

robo hippy

Russ,

I am curious as to how long ago you got your coring tool. Did you contact Kel about the problem? I have heard of this problem once before. I know of a few instances where he has replaced items. If you have the newer Mark 8 tool rest (out for about 2 years), and you got the old blades, they won't fit because he has gone to thinner stock for his large blades. The sellers of the system don't always know about these things.

The first major improvement Kel made with the tool was to go to the spear point, which centered on the blade, from the old tip where all of the cutting edge was on one side of the blade. This REALLY helped.

The latest improvement is in his Mark 8 system, where his blades are supposed to be bent to much closer tolerances. I have two new ones on order, and when I get them, I will test them out. The last ones I got, and I can't remember when that was, seemed to be fine.

Kel does have a 14 page hand out that goes out with the tool when you get it. As others have said, this is a big improvement.

robo hippy

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#8

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Russ Fairfield

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#9

Re: Poor Quality Control

Texian

Agree 100% with that. Regardless how much the "new" tools and instructions have been improved, it is too little and too late to get my money.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#10

Re: Poor Quality Control

Dick Strauss

Russ,

I've had the same quality issues with the McNaughton coring system except that the my blades on my system are too narrow by 0.020. This causes them to be able to rotate while still cpatured between the posts making the coring very unstable.

I tried to contact both Greg Jensen (US Rep?) and KM on at least a half dozen occasions severla years ago. Needless to say, neither party sent me a reply! By the time the manufacturing issues were really discovered after many failed attempts, it was too late to return the system to the store. Poor manufacturing quality and no customer service equals lost sales!

FYI-the system was purchased 3-5 years ago so it wasn't during their most recent product transition.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#11

Steven Antonucci

same here

steven antonucci

makes me wonder if it's the knives and not me...

FWIW- I can core with the shallow bent knife, but the other two baffle me...

S

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#12

Re: Poor Quality Control

John Lucas

Now that I'm reading this I realize that part of the problem I had with my system may have been due to some of these issues. I'll try to remember to check. I know there is a very large gap between the blade and the capture pins. I thought this was normal but it does allow the bar to really twist. I know one of the bars is not a perfect circle because when I made my own bars I compared theirs. Add all that together and I can see why I might have been fighting it.

I may just remake the tool support and then rebend the bars so they make a true circle and see if my coring efforts improve.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#13

Re: Poor Quality Control

Dick Strauss

Isn't it sad when you have to fix new tools?

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#14

Mk8 tool support ?

Ralph

Robo

Did you order the new Mk8 tool support?

It appears to me to me to be a great improvment over the original, with the height adjustment it appears like you could "lock" the height better and reduce vibration.

Ralph

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#15

The other side of the coin (long)

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

I bought a McNaughton coring tool little over a year ago. I first tried it with a smaller bowl, approximately 8 inches in diameter. As soon as the tool touched the wood the bowl exited the chuck. I followed the setup instructions and didn't think a learning curve was realistic with the tool that is held securely and set up accurately. With the blank back in the chuck, I tried again... same result! Tried it a third time and this time managed to tear the tenon completely off the bottom of the bowl.

At this point I felt that I probably wasted my money on the tool. I sent an e-mail to Kelton Industries describing my problem and asking for advice. Less than a half hour later I had an answer from Kel McNaughton with some suggestions and asking me when it would be a good time for him to call. I answered him saying that I had a few other things to try and to hold off on calling for the time being. A few days later I tried again with somewhat similar results. I sent another e-mail and to my surprise my phone rang about two hours later. It was Kel McNaughton. He had found my phone number in the AAW resource guide and took the initiative of calling.

We talked for about five minutes about my problem and another 30 minutes about everything and anything, including our new president, the drug situation in the United States and the fact that my lathe is in my kitchen.

I wasn't able to get back to the coring system immediately and perhaps two weeks passed until I could try again. This time things worked properly and I was able to core a couple blanks successfully. I was sitting at the computer starting to write another e-mail Kelton when my phone rang. You guessed it, it was Kel again. He said he hadn't heard from me in a couple weeks and wanted assure himself that my problem was solved. I sure assured him that it was, and we chatted again for a few minutes.

I am completely happy with my McNaughton coring tool and can say only good things about the way Kel McNaughton handled my problem. He told me at the time that I owned one of his tools and it was not performing properly. He felt a responsibility to get it to perform as it should. How many other business owners would do this?

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#16

Re: Mk8 tool support ?

robo hippy

Ralph,

I do have the Mark 8 tool rest. I think the square tube to fit the blades through is a big improvement over the T bar. It is a bit busy on top with all the gates, but it works. The only problem I have had with it is that I prefer my gates to be locked in place. The tool works fine if they rotate/adjust with the cut, but it was one of those 'I wonder what happens if I do this' things, and I prefer that. It helps me stay on track. On this tool rest, if I lock it down with the set screw, the whole thing locks up, and the square tube has to move.

I am not sure what you mean by adjust the height. My guess would be the support bar that goes under the blade as you core. This is a new thing. What it does is keeps you from dropping the handle while you core. The cutter is a scraper, and when using any scraper, you want it pointed down a bit to help prevent catches. If it is pointing up, you can get some spectacular catches. When I first got mine, I thought the T bar was there as a safety thing, but it is how the tool is designed to work: up against the tool support. I don't use it as I learned without it, kind of like a digital rpm read out. Never had one, wouldn't know what to do with one if I had it. It is a good thing for beginners though.

I have always found Kel to be very personal, prompt, and helpful. Not just from my own experiences, but from others as well. I have sent a couple of e-mails and my DVD to Greg Jenson, and heard nothing at all back from him.

As I say in my DVD, the blades tend to drift, and learning how to deal with that is the biggest hurdle, well maybe next to aiming, that you will have to get over. Getting the blank securely mounted is basic, a good grip on a tenon or recess, ease the tool into the cut, and core. You may have to open up the kerf a bit, or move the tool rest, but it does work, and is the best, most efficient coring system out there.

All of my tweaking is for one goal only, to be able to make one smooth continuous cut all the way to the bottom of the core, with no stops for adjusting, clearing chips, or anything else. I have done it a few times. The trick will be to find how to do it all the time.

robo hippy

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#17

Dick Hines

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Dick Hines

I have the McNaughton core system for quite some time, and like it. I had trouble with it at the begining but worked through it. I watch the DVD by Mike Mahoney a couple of time and that was a big help.

Even a bigger help was watching Bill Gurmbine use one. He showed some of his tricks and how I don't have any trouble.

I still take coreing slow and easy but it works great.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#18

Re: The other side of the coin (long)

Carole Valentine

Harry, the answer to your question about how many manufacturers would do that is darn few, if any! I had the same very pleasant experience with Kel that you did (including follow-up calls) and I am aware of several others who had similar experiences. I believe he sincerely cares about his customers and his products and would always respond if at all possible. I am perfectly happy with my coring system as well as all of my other other Kelton tools. And I know that if if I ever have a problem with any of them, whether it is the tool itself or (more likely) user error/inexperience that I will have great support from the manufacturer himself.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#19

Hate to say it, Steve

Jeff Willaford

It's you. :D ....or the wood. Are the knives sharp? Take a look at the shaving coming off the edge as the knife just enters the wood. Sharp = nice ribbon off both sides of the cutter. I also had problem with some junk wood (stringy) when I first started coring and it took me a couple of attempts to realize how the cut should be. The blades almost self feed if they are sharp and the wood is viable.

As for exact curve to the n'th degree.... it's a coring tool... not a finish tool.

PS: I felt the problem must be me when I started coring...and it was. Just a little steeper learning curve than some other tools I've used.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#20

Re: The other side of the coin (long)

Jeff Willaford

I have Kelton hollowers and really like them. I also have the coring tools and no complaints about them.

A few weeks ago I sent Kelton Industries an email asking for information on their captive hollowing rigs. Next thing I know Kel is on the phone to discuss my requirements, lathe, experience and a dozen other things. He was very free witih his information and very helpful to me. I wish every vendor I dealt with was as responsive as Kel.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#21

Steven Antonucci

I know it's me...

steven antonucci

Just hate the idea that there is a turning tool I just can't get the hang of...

I may just check the curves before I use them again. I'll feel better.

S :b

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#22

Re: Good Cust. Service VS a quality tool

Steve Criscenzo

I asked for recommendations for a coring system several weeks ago and most said that they liked the McNaughton system for its versatility but did not like the learning curve.

When I read this current thread on a similar subject, I see concerns about quality control and suggestions about needing to modify the tool to make it work as it should.

Then I read that if I buy the tool, then I need to buy a third party DVD in order to learn how make it work properly.

Finally I read how happy folks are with the support they get when they have problems with the tool.

I don't get it. While I happy that you can get good support, shouldn't the expectation be that the tool comes properly machined, has adequate directions, and works as advertised without owner modifications.

Steve

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#23

Re: Good Cust. Service VS a quality tool

Jeff Willaford

Steve, I can only speak for myself. I have not experienced any quality issues with the McNaughton coring tools I purchased. I realize others have but I'm not convinced they are in the majority. Most any vendor can have a manufacturing problem get out the door before they realize it but act quickly to resolve problems.

I did read the instructions that came with the tools and did buy two videos on using them. Coring, to me, is not like any other turning process I've undertaken. After overcoming my initial 'operator errors' I found I can successfully core using the tools in the manner the instructions called for without modifying anything.

I also own a couple of skews but they did not come with instructions. Nor did my gouges have instructions and the scrapers did not either. My hollowing tools also lacked instructions. The use of some of these tools was intuitive to me but not so with others. I have purchased videos on bowl turning, skew use, spindle turning and finishes to help improve my understanding of how to properly and better use my tools. Just my opinon.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#24

Re: Good Cust. Service VS a quality tool

Edward Bartimmo

Steve,

I had to laugh. You captured the essence of it. After attending a coring workshop three years ago I bought the full set (I believe it is pre-Mark 8 but has the tips sharpened to spear points). Embarrassingly enough I admit that it has sat idle in its box on the garage floor all this time. I pulled it out a few months ago for its maiden flight and I encountered all of the issues that have been mentioned by other users. The blade did not fitting into gate and it could not be advanced forward through the gate. Although the spear points are supposed to fold the shavings in half to aid in expelling them. Despite my attemps to opening the gap, I still found the shavings to be crumpling up and binding the gap similar to what Robo Hippy mentioned. To resolve the binding issue in the gate I introduced the blade's profile to the belt sander for some fine tuning. Even with the blade now being able to fit into its gate it was a struggle to feed it through the wood. It continued to bind within the gate as well as withing the blank. When selecting a different blade it worked with amazing easy was exactly like the videos... I can only speculate that the blade curvature was not even annd consistent, which caused it to bind as it passed through the gate as well as along the gap in the blank. I still need to check the curvatures of the blades.

The system is based on simple sound principles. McNaughton's advantage of flexible shape coring makes it a great fit for a wide array of turners. Unfortunately, a great concept with poor execution is a non-start or at best a lot of unnecessary heartburn. Ignoring the learning curve, spectacular customer service doesn't offset poor manufacturing quality and inconsistency product performance. It is such a good idea that I like many others want to believe, and in some cases are willing to tinker and tweak the system until it performs as it should have when it comes new directly out of the box.

If Kelton would like to call me I would more than willing discuss remedying my issue, such as swapping out my existing blades for a set of mark 8's. I very much want to be a McNaughton Banner Waver.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#25

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

robo hippy

I am a tinkerer. I seldom leave things as they are, and experiment to see what happens, especially if I am having some problems. The tweaking I have done makes the tool work better for me, and like all woodturning methods, what works better for me may not work better for you. Part of any learning curve is to see what others do, figure out why they do it that way, and see if all or any part of it works for you. I have lost count of the different gouge profiles I have used. I got my first McNaughton 10 years ago. I had a terrible time with it, and ended up putting on the shelf. Our club, which was just starting, was looking for an idea for the next demo, and I asked if any one had one, and knew how to use it. One guy did, and after seeing him use it, a lot of things made sense, and over the course of a couple of years, figured it out to the point where I started teaching people how to use it. I heard people were experimenting with different tip profiles, so I started experimenting as well. Mike Mahoney did his DVD, and I looked at it, and thought that we did similar things with it, but used different approaches to teaching, so I did my own. As the system comes now, it works fine. But, again, I am a tinkerer.

Now, as to needing an aftermarket DVD, well, you can get a lot more into a DVD than you can on paper short of doing a whole book. You can learn from the instructions alone. Lots of people have. The other systems, Oneway and Woodcut, both are on fixed pivoting centers, and are pretty much idiot proof. Simple to use. The McNaughton, since it is free handed isn't so easy, and there are a number of tips and tricks that can help you get through the learning curve faster. As I said earlier, a one on one session with some one who knows how to use it is the best way to learn. A demo from an experienced user is very good as well. A DVD is good, and you can learn through the instructions that come with the tool.

I have extensive experience with the other coring systems, and the McNaughton is my choice as a production turner. There are some people who never can seem to get the hang of it no matter how hard they try, or how much and how good the instruction they get is.

robo hippy