Coring with the McNaughton; Long
robo hippy
Well, as I mentioned in my last post in the latest one about the McNaughton center saver, I had talked with Kel McNaughton. He, and a few turners, were concerned with my 'negative' comments about the system. So, I need to clear some things up here.
First, I think you all know that I prefer the McNaughton coring systems over the other systems available. Simply, it is fastest to set up, and core with. It is also the most versatile system out there. It is the one I recommend, but with the side note that there is a learning curve associated with it, while the other systems are easier to just pick up and use.
While getting my bowl coring DVD together, Kel and I talked a lot by phone and e-mail. He, like any good manufacturer is very concerned about product quality. I respect him as a manufacturer and he seems to be a nice guy as well.
With his new Mark 8 coring set up, there have been some notable quality changes. One was he updated his instructions. They are better than the old ones I got when I got my first coring system some 10 years ago. I just down loaded them and read them a couple of times. I won't go so far as to call them good, but they are adequate to get you started. As an instructor, I consider the best learning method to be to find some one who is competent with the tool and have a work shop/mentoring session with them. This is not always possible. The next best situation is to get a DVD. Going with the expression, "A picture is worth a thousand words", you get a lot more from an hour long DVD than you can from a short pamphlet. The last solution is the written word, and a book isn't practical expense wise for a production product, but what he has is fine. There is a lot of info on his web site to help turners to learn to use this tool. I am some one who has problems translating the written instructions on anything to action, and seeing is a lot more effective learning tool to me. This is what was behind my comments about his instructions being brief. There are a few things that I would mention on the instructions that come with the tool, and I will digest that for a while before I present them to Kel. Writing an instructional manual is very difficult.
As to the quality of the blades. He did make some changes to his manufacturing processes with the Mark 8 system. The older blades were inconsistent in their bends. I believe that most of this has been solved with the Mark 8 blades. Kel did send me most of a Mark 8 system to try out and get my feed back. He sent the medium blades, and the micro blades. I have so many blades that I am not sure which ones are the new ones. I did just order a new meduim curved blade, for the standard set, and will check it out for the curvature.
Drifting (where the blade wants to travel to the outside of the cut, rather than following the curve of the blade) has been one of my hurdles in this coring system that, to me, seems to cause the most problems. I have talked to Mike Mahoney about it a lot. He says it doesn't drift, I say, if it doesn't drift, then why do you have to open up the cut, and move your tool rest to adjust the cut, and why does the blade bind up in the cut some times. To me, this is a puzzle l that I have to solve. Will I ever solve it? Maybe. Will I stop trying to solve it? No. One reason I ordered a new blade is to check it out. I do have one blade that I modified slightly by bending in the tip slightly, and it cuts without needing correcting.
I have made a number of modifications to this tool. As I said in my DVD, Engineers motto: if it aint broke, take it apart and fix it anyway. While I may not have said this directly, these are modifications that I have made to the tool, and they may or may not help you in using this tool. I don't expect every one to agree with my points on the tool, or anything else that I do. We are all different, and some of us are more different than others.
If you want more detailed explanations on why I have locked down my support fingers, ground the spear point down square, and start large bowls with the cutter being as much as 1/2 inch above center, I will explain.
How different am I? Well, I prefer scrapers for roughing bowls. To some this is sacrilege. To others it is just plain crazy. I have had a number of people come up to me after my turning demos and state, I will have to rethink scrapers after seeing how you use them.
robo hippy
....or the wood. Are the knives sharp? Take a look at the shaving coming off the edge as the knife just enters the wood. Sharp = nice ribbon off both sides of the cutter. I also had problem with some junk wood (stringy) when I first started coring and it took me a couple of attempts to realize how the cut should be. The blades almost self feed if they are sharp and the wood is viable.



