Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Posts

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#26

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Russ Fairfield

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#27

Re: For a real thrill, buy a Termite tool!

JamieDonaldson

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#28

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

I've been using Kel's coring tools since 1997. I've gone through a number of knives in that time, either from bending them myself or wearing the tip down. When I first got the tool, it beat me up something fierce as I depended on muscle alone to keep it in line. But then, I figured out how to use it. Since then I have taught women under 100 lbs and in their 60s how to core easily and relatively quickly. And before someone throws the sexist label at me, I speak from experience. Women do not have the upper body strength of men. So if they can do it, it stands to reason that men should be able to do it too. But, the knowledge is not instinctive, and not always apparent. It really helps to have someone who knows show and then direct a person in person.

To be honest, I never really thought much about the bends in the knives and how accurate they were until I had some correspondence with Reed. Wood is so plentiful here that it was almost never an issue if I had to move the knife around to get it going the way I wanted. I don't do nested bowls like Mike Mahoney, and I have more wood than I can use on the lathe. Heck, I burn the stuff to keep warm in the winter! Be that as it may, as I think back on it, I suppose that some of my knives worked better than others. I have gotten to the point with this tool though, where I can move it around with the lathe running and not have any problems, so maybe I just overcame that issue subconsciously. I've never had an issue with the knives not fitting through the gate. That is just my experience though, and my experience does not negate the experience of anyone else.

I've cored bowls with this system all over the country on all sorts of lathes. I've had many a phone call with Kel, and much correspondence. He has always been a gentleman, and has always been concerned about customer satisfaction. No one is perfect, and no product will perform 100% of the time. It is all about service and support of the tools that we own, regardless of where they originate. The thing is, no one can fix a problem if they are not aware of its existence. If someone has a problem with a tool, the manufacturer cannot read minds. He needs to know through communication, and he deserves the chance to make it right, whether it be a single instance or a whole run of bad tools. And knowing what I know of Kel, I suspect that making it right would be his first and foremost consideration.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#29

Steven Antonucci

Hook tools should come with lessons too...

steven antonucci

I just made a hook for a friend and gave it to him. Without the lesson, it would have been worthless...

The lesson lasted 5 minutes, but it was the RIGHT five minutes...:-)

Steve

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#30

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

I'm adding to my previous post in a reply so people will see it. I've gotten several emails about what I posted earlier today, and I want to clarify something. I mentioned bent knives. The only instances in which they were bent were from heavy use, not bent because of misuse or abuse. Well, there was that one that I bent into a pretzel after I hit a nail and ruined it, but we won't talk about that. ;)

All my knives have gradually bent from fast heavy coring - more of a sag really. They can be bent back, but I didn't bother with that, I just bought another one. It was worth the price.

I know people have had trouble with this tool. I know people who use their skews to open paint cans too. I know people who think every tool is just a variant on a scraper. All tools need instruction and/or practice to be used correctly. This one is no different. It's just more exciting. :D

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#31

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Dick Strauss

As I previously posted, I tried to contact both Greg Jensen and Kel at least three times each to resolve the quality issues (with no response from either party). Maybe Kel has become more responsive over time or maybe he is more responsive when renowned turners contact him. I would honestly welcome a note from him if it might resolve the issues I've been experiencing.

Bill G defintely makes it look easy in person...!

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#32

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Don Thur

Personaly I have tough time with the idea that Kel doesn't reply to emails. Heck I sent him one this morning regarding a Canadian supplier who stocks the Mark 8 and I had 2 replies from him this afternoon. I have an original and the pre-Mark 8 set of and the only problem I ever had wasn't with the tool; it was me going too deep, hitting the chuck and then ordering new knives.

I like the system so well that I had a machine shop make me a 20" straight cutter with a carbide tip so I can really horse it; great cutting ease when I attach the biggee to 3' of Kelton handle. I'm so far back that I couldn't tell if the chips are curled, square or flat but they sure do fly @ 1000rpm. I mainly core hardwood burls that are in the 25% M.C. which accounts for lot of drag & tool heat so I tend to have a wider cut path than I would with green blanks.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#33

Joe Fleming

Re: I know it's me...

Joe Fleming

One error a lot of people make is to pull the handle perpendicularly to the axis of the handle. You need to push or pull along the axis of the handle. The curve will take care of the direction change. I say "pull" because sometimes the blades almost self-feed moving too fast and stalling the lathe. Joe

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#34

Joe Fleming

Re: Good Cust. Service VS a quality tool

Joe Fleming

Steve, I'll bet you struggled with the bowl gouge the first time you used it. Did it come with instructions? Or did someone have to teach you how to use it? What about your skew? If you hollow, did you automatically know how to use it or had you seen someone else demonstrate?

I've used Kelton coring tools for 10 years. I have all the blades (some prototypes of the current systems) and the old gate. I've cored more than a 100 bowls (not even approaching Grumbine, etc), but in all of that time, I have only cut through the bottom of one bowl. My education was watching Mike Mahoney for about three hours and taking notes, then trying it out.

Disclaimer - I have Kelton hollowers (my favorite for smaller vessels), coring tools (I've used Oneway and Woodcut - I like Kelton much better), the hollowing gate, and the sharpening system. I even have the hook tool and like it better than Hosaluk's, Martel's, Oneway's termite, or the Sorby ring tool. So, I am a fan.

I can't speak to the quality of recent purchases, because I've had mine for years and they all worked out of the box.

Joe

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#35

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

Dick Strauss

Several years ago when I first encountered the issue, I tried to contact both Kel and Greg J but did not receive a response from either of them.

I just sent another message to Kel and am hopeful that he will be able to finally address this issue.

Take care,

Dick

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#36

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Russ Fairfield

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#37

You are right.....

Barry Irby

I bought the coring system back in the day when the knives were sharpened square across the ends. I struggled with them so much that i post here about it. I concluded they were not bent to a radius of a circle. Their American Rep (Greg ?????) picked up on my complaints and suggested I send them to him. I did and he returned them saying they were bent correctly but that they had changed the grind to the point one and he ground mine. Some how, I was stunned that he would modify them without discussing it with me. They did not work any better. A friend and I re bent them to the profile of a circle. They were clearly sections of an ellipse. They worked much better.

Having said all that, I can not imagine a company with such poor production and quality control can survive. I certainly would not recommend them based on my experience.

Of Course, about a year ago I loaned my set to an acquaintance and showed him how to use them and sharpen them. He returned them having mangled them beyond belief. He ground the tops of the cutters until the hardened steel disappeared. He wrapped duct tape around the horizontal bar of the restraining bar and install a piece of EMT conduit over it. He must have removed the roll pin to do that, but I could not get it out so I cut the conduit with a Dremel tool and removed it. I paid Mike Hunter to install cutters on the ruined ones. I did not check, but that may have cost more than new cutters from McNaughton. I did not go back to McNaughton because I had such poor luck with the cutters to begin with and did not want to have to re manufacture another set. Maybe they have improved the cutters, but you couldn't prove it by me.

I thought the set I got was expensive and looked like something I made In high school shop class. Actually, not quite that good.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#38

Re: McNaughton PR disaster.

Dave Moore

I suspect it's not representative, or they would have been out of business long ago. Not many companies can survive a 50% dissatisfaction rate I would think.

Calling this a disaster of any kind seem a little over the top to me.

This coring system totally kicked my butt for a while when I first acquired it, I found it to be really intense and anxiety provoking to use it at all. I certainly spent time cussing at it...I even made up some new swear words at one point.

Now I just core with it without much fuss at all. Basically I had to learn how not to fight it ...I had to get familiar with what each knife wanted to do, rather than working with what I thought it "ought" to do...then set up and aim accordingly.

I ended up just practicing with some uninspiring Aspen logs that were headed for the woodstove, thus removing any sense that I would "mess something up" Just started coring away without worrying what I ended up with and just watching what the knives actually did when I quit trying to "steer" them. I quite rapidly noticed that they did more or less the same thing every time, so then it became a matter of figuring out the starting orientation.

A few lampshades, a larger number of overly thick bowl bottoms from overcorrecting trying to avoid another lampshade...basically getting out of the way and letting the knife do it's thing...fewer and fewer problems .. and it became a great tool for me, quite fast and quite repeatable.

I agree the "instructions" that came with it were laughably inadequate; I have not seen the new ones but they would pretty much have to be an improvement.

Kel should cut a deal with Reed or Mike or Bill or all three to include a video in the box, maybe. Or make one themselves. Something.

I notice Craft Supplies is offering Mike's video as a "free" add-on with the purchase of any complete set, and that's fine, but I think if Kell took responsibility for including something comprehensive in with the product it would really help folks to get comfortable with this system.

Some folks will always hate it, for whatever reason, and that's fine too, but if it was in any way "unusable" then everyone would be unhappy, and they're not.

No I'm not affiliated with McNaughton. I'm not even endorsing the product. I'm just saying I was able to get it to work well for me, though I did have to dedicate some time to making that happen.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#39

Re: McNaughton PR disaster.

Barry Irby

As far as the instructions go, the ones that came with mine were very poor, but I can't remember ever buying a tool or machine that had a good comprehensive set of instructions included. You might get something like an owner's manual or assembly instructions but not much in the way of a users manual. The book that came with my car certainly doesn't help me drive it other than to inform me where the buttons and switches are. My table saw and lathe and almost nothing on how to use them. Not saying it wouldn't be good for McNaughton to be a leader in this area, but I can't say they are lagging the industry.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#40

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

robo hippy

Every one who has tried to use the McNaughton Coring system probably has sworn at it, or as Bill Grumbine says,"bad words were said". Every one who has learned to use the tool swears by it as the best one out there. Some people can never get around the learning curve.

I just got 2 new blades from Craft Supplies, and will give them a work out this week and report on the over all quality later.

I am not sure how Mike got the deal to have his DVD included with the purchase of a coring set through Craft Supplies. I did get one to review it, and it is better than his last one. Not quite the way I would do things, but it is better than the written instructions. He does use the newer Mark 8 system. You can show so much more info on a DVD than you can on paper.

robo hippy

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#41

Re: McNaughton PR disaster.

Bill Howatt

When I bought my coring system I knew from reading the forums that it would likely present a challenging learning curve. For that reason I also bought the Mahoney DVD which turned out to be a very good investment. If I had to follow the instructions that came with the tool I doubt if I would have been a happy camper.

I am satisfied with the tool but would be more satisfied if the DVD had been included in the first place.

Bill

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#42

KM Contact Info?

Dick Strauss

Does anyone have a better contact email for KM other than info @ kelton. co. nz with no spaces?

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#43

Re: Poor Quality Control

Mike Mahoney

I have been reading about the curves of the Kelton Center Saver blades. Contrary to a popular belief the blades are not meant to be parts of a curve. On the contrary. This is what gives the tool its versatility to plunge deeper or shallower and not give you the same curve over and over. Any positive curve tighter or longer will do. Plus this tool like so many other woodturning tools (gouge and skew) don't come with good instructions. These tools have to be practiced with to become skillful with them.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#44

Re: Poor Quality Control

Mike Mahoney

Sorry. I meant to say these blades are not meant to be parts of a circle. Just curves

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#45

I have to disagree....

Barry Irby

Assuming this is a center Saver system where the purpose is to maximize the amount of the wood you can save out of the center of the larger bowl.

With a straight knife, you could remove a cone, ranging from a very slender one all the way to a disk.

The curved knives must cut a kerf for the knife to follow. Assuming you want that kerf to be as narrow as possible to avoid blindly grinding away the wood you are trying to save, the only curved shape that a knife can follow into the minimum kerf is a section of a circle. Once the knife becomes a section of an ellipse it is as if it has an elbow in it and you must widened the kerf to allow it to cut deeper.

The ones that came with my system were so poorly shaped that the kerf would have to be an inch wide to complete the cut. Actually, two were like that and one was relatively well done and much closer to being a segment of a circle. So, my problem was that the middle knife in my set worked as I expected and the other two did not. It seems to me that is the quality control were what it should have been the set would have been consistent. What could have been the purpose of shipping three with rather random shapes?

No doubt that if say the first five inches of the knife is bent on a gently curve and then the rest is much more radically curved, and you only use the first five inches, the knife may work well, but when you try to take a deeper core, you are going to have a problem. Two of Mine were clearly sections of distinct ellipses, not even close to being circles.

While you have a thousand times the experience I have with the system, I suggest you have not had a knife as poorly formed as mine.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#46

Re: I have to disagree....

Mike Mahoney

Yes you are right. The curve has to be continuous. There can't be an alternative curve on the blade. I have never seen one like that.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#47

Re: I have to disagree....

Bill Neddow

I agree totally with you, Barry. Three of the knives in my two sets of tools (large and regular blades) came as ellipses, and the tools have always been sloppy in the "gate".

I guess that is why I eventually bought a Oneway system and use it all the time.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#48

Dick Hines

Re: KM Contact Info?

Dick Hines

This whole thing is turning into a witch hunt. The next thing you know they will be dunking Kel in a tub of water.

Re: Coring with the McNaughton; Long

#49

Re: KM Contact Info?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

This whole thing is turning into a witch hunt. The next thing you know they will be dunking Kel in a tub of water.