Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Supernova2 Question

Posts

Supernova2 Question

#1

Supernova2 Question

Carole Valentine

Anyone gotten a new one lately? I ordered one while they were on sale and it was very stiff and gravelly compared to my other 3 Supernova2s. I talked to the folks and they sent me a replacement which supposedly they had checked before sending, but there is no difference between it and the first one. Jeff had the same experience. Anyone else? Has Teknatool "tightened up" the SN2s? Will it loosen up over time? I have blown it out but really don't want to disassemble it. Have never had to take any of my other SN2s apart.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#2

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Supernova2 Question

Chuck Jones - West TN

I bought my first one 2-3 years ago and my second one 4-5 months ago and I did notice a difference. Not as bad as yours seems to be, but it did not operate as smoothly at first. After using it a few times I can't say that I can tell the difference now. It did cause me to look closely at the markings and noticed that the second one was made in... yeah you guessed it, China. I just ordered a third one this week because Woodcraft has them on sale for $120. I have too many jaws for the SuperNova to switch now. (Guess how many 50mm jaws I have? Can't buy one without getting another 50mm set).

Re: Supernova2 Question

#3

Re: Supernova2 Question

Carole Valentine

Let me know what you think of the new one when you get it. I don't know if this is standard for the chucks now or if it's a strange batch.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#4

Steve Kubien

Re: Supernova2 Question

Steve Kubien

I have one of Kiwi and one of Chinese origin. They were both the same when I got them and they are the same now...all good. They may have changed their tolerances.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#5

Ellis Walentine

Sent message to Teknatool

Ellis Walentine

All we can do here is hope the manufacturer is willing to offer an explanation or a fix.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Supernova2 Question

#6

Re: Supernova2 Question

Carole Valentine

Possible that they have Steve. All of mine except the new one are NZ made and very smooth. I checked and the new one is made in "PRC". (I suppose they think PRC sounds a hair or so better than plain old "China" ;) )

Re: Supernova2 Question

#7

Re: Supernova2 Question

Jeff Rich

I purchased a new SN2 last summer during the big sale.

I noticed it was not as smooth in its action as the one I bout 2 years prior.

I thought it was just tighter and would work out, but it is still just as "tight"

I have taken it apart to inspect, maybe burrs or metal chips, but it looked ok.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#8

Re: Supernova2 Question

Tommy Holmes from NW FL

Carol, I just checked the SN2 that I got last week and mine is like yours, tight and gravelly. Checked a couple of others made in NZ, one never opened, and all the others are smooth without the gravelly feeling. I would say it's usable but certainly not what I would expect after using the older ones.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#9

Re: Supernova2 Question

Carole Valentine

Yep, usable, but certainly not the pleasure to use that the others are. Apparently, from what I am reading here, what I have is pretty common. Still, I am going to try and contact them directly and see what they say. Could have been just a bad bunch that landed.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#10

Re: Supernova2 Question

Jim Sebring

I received a new SN2 from the Woodcraft sale a couple of weeks ago. I have two others, plus a flock of G3s. Because of the heavy grease coating on the new chuck, I completely disassembled it and thoroughly cleaned it. There were no metal burrs or chips inside. Without the back plastic cover and circlip in place everything turned smoothly. After I reassembled everything, I found one 'hard' spot while cranking the jaws in and out. It's always in the same place in the scroll circuit, so I suspect it is a tight spot on the plastic back cover, rather than on the scroll itself.

This chuck was obviously made in downtown China. The soaking in medium weight grease is a departure from the usual lightweight oil most Chinese-made machine tools have been coated with in the last few years. I degreased this chuck and lubed it with some dry lube made by Remington for firearms. All that grease or oil is a great dust catcher. I don't expect I'll have to disassemble and clean this chuck again for several years.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#11

Re: Supernova2 Question

Barry

I always thought that heavy grease was covering up sloppy manufacturing tolerances. But you are right. too much grease and oil attracts dust and dirt.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#12

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Supernova2 Question

Chuck Jones - West TN

Carole,

I received my SuperNova2 #3 this afternoon. Only had a few minutes to look at it, but turning the jaws on it is definitely worse than the other two. Is it worse than the second one was when I first got it in September? I can't be sure of course, but I think it is. As I said the second one definitely got better with use, and I could tell the new one was somewhat better with only a few complete scrolls (I think).

My first one and second one were side by side on a shelf today with jaws up such that I could not tell which was made in NZ or "PRC". I inserted the hex wrench and it did not take a full turn to tell which was which. I could tell blindfolded.

Does all this really matter? I'm not sure, but it is irritating. My second one gets the job done just fine and I wasn't really noticing it until I saw your post. It's all your fault. :) Does make me wonder if it will hold up as well. Everyone likes to save a few bucks, but in this case I think I would pay several dollars more just for the satisfaction of a smooth working tool. At least I would have liked to participate in that decision.

I think I'm just going to find live with it. I sure don't want to start off with another incompatible chucking system at this point. I've been completely satisfied with the performance of the SuperNova2... but then what would I know? That's all I've ever used.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#13

Send a message to Teknatool

Stuart Johnson

It looks like Ellis sent a message to Teknatool but it might be more effective if everyone of you with the problem sent them a message. Let them know you are multi oweners and you are not happy.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#14

Good point

John K Jordan

I don't have one with the problem, but I have eleven supernova chucks. I'm going to let them know what I read here and the fact I'll won't buy another one if it doesn't turn smoothly. Even if it seems to work fine, roughness in the gears does not inspire confidence in the investment (and these things are not cheap).

JKJ

Re: Supernova2 Question

#15

Re: Good point

Carole Valentine

Hold on for a bit folks...appears there is a possible explanation and easy fix. We will know next week and post then when we are sure. Nova chucks have been excellent chucks in my past experience and we don't want to throw out the baby with the bath water!

Re: Supernova2 Question

#16

Re: Good point

Barry Irby

Let us know if you come up with an easy fix. I have one that is stiff. I have taken it apart and cleaned and polished the workings, but have not made an imporvement. At least, not much better.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#17

Re: Good point

Stuart Johnson

This could get to be interesting. If there is a quick, easy fix a lot of folks will be happy. However, I feel you shouldn't have to fix new purchases regardless of how quick and easy.

I only have one SuperNova but would like one or two more someday but if I need to make repairs it will have to be reflected in the price.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#18

Chuck Jones - West TN

I agree

Chuck Jones - West TN

We should give them the benefit of the doubt and wait to see if the fix is the answer. All companies make mistakes at some point. It's how they recover that counts with me. I think that chuck was a good deal at $180 a couple years ago. They will be a great deal at $120 if they work anywhere near as good as my first one.

I sent a message to Tom Geist yesterday and he called me mid-morning today. As Carole said he seems confident he has found the problem and the fix and he's shipping two copies to me Monday/Tuesday.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#19

Cured - 5 seconds

Jeff Willaford

One phone call to Tim Geist and the cure was made. No more gravelly stiff SN2. Tim confirmed that the problem was with the C-clip holding the back in place...NOT the gears. I just received replacement clips from Tim and 10 seconds later...two sooooooth running chucks. Either the original clip was bent or too thick. Whichever...it's fine now.

I would suggest anyone experiencing a similar issue contact Tim for resolution. I agree the problelm should have been caught at the factory but sometimes stuff happens. Teknatool is now aware of the problem per Tim.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#20

Re: Cured - 5 seconds

Carole Valentine

And if that's a not smooth enough for you, rub the clip around on a little 320 grit on a flat surface. My chuck is now as smooth as all of my other ones.

Re: Supernova2 Question

#21

Re: Cured - 5 seconds

John K Jordan

Good to know!

Re: Supernova2 Question

#22

Easy fix in a different way

gil jones

The one I recently bought from Woodcraft ($119) was a bit hard to turn the T-handle and there was a wee bit of roughness.

I popped off the cir-clip and the problem was gone, so I checked the cir-clip thickness (.0750"), and compared it to the cir-clips on my other two SN2's which were both .0685".

The extra .0065" of steel in the cir-clip was forcing the base of the plastic backing plate into the scroll plate with enough pressure to cause stiff operation (my thought anyway).

Removing .0065 of cir-clip steel is not fun, so I removed .0065 of plastic from the base of the backing plate where it contacts the scroll ring (with my belt-sander).

Problem gone, smooth operation restored.

Probably the latest shipment of cir-clips are a bit too thick, and nobody noticed, or checked.

And no, I am not recommending that you modify your plastic OEM backing plate as I did, but it is a quick fix. Getting a new (thinner?) cir-clip from Tim is probably the best way.

Still, we should not have to repair 'new' products.

Gil

Re: Supernova2 Question

#23

Well of course

Dave Belser

Thanks! That explains everything. I have 2 and one has become quite stiff *AFTER* I took it apart to clean and lube it. Well Duh! I didn't have the proper tool for removing the clip so I used screwdrivers, needle nose pliers etc - whatever I could to get grip on it and pop it off.

So obviously, I must have bent or dinged it enough the make the whole chuck tight. I did finally buy the correct tool for removing the clip, I'll take it apart again and check the clip closely to see if I can recover it. If not I'll get new clips.

So again - Thanks!

- Dave

Re: Supernova2 Question

#24

Re: Well of course

Carole Valentine

I had to laugh when I read your post, Dave! I have finally learned - after personally destroying enough things with the "screwdriver of death" - that when there is specific tool manufactured for a very specific job (like removing or installing a c-clip) that there is usually a very good reason to use that tool! :D

Re: Supernova2 Question

#25

Donna Parrillo

Who's Tim? And how to I contact him?

Donna Parrillo

I've been following this thread with interest because I am having the same problem. I would like to contact this Tim fellow, but have no idea who he is? Can you pass along his contact info? Thank you, Donna P.