Re: Amen Carole
charlie belden
There is a distinction to be made between an argument and a discussion
argument |ˈ�rgyəmənt|
noun
1 an exchange of diverging or opposite views, typically a heated or angry one
discussion |disˈkə sh ən|
noun
the action or process of talking about something, typically in order to reach a decision or to exchange ideas
What I was after was a DISCUSSION of an issue raised by the rules of the Turn and Burn contest - specifically centered on whether craftsmanship required that things be done exclusively "by hand". And I raised the topic because, of the many branches of woodworking, turning seems to be the most open to new ideas, new tools and new methods of doing things already being done some other way, or that can't be done with existing tools and methods. The use of things that new technology have made available to turners has, for the most part been embraced by turners - carbide cutters, lasers on hollowing tools, captured hoilowing systems, Prisma Color felt tip pens, high speed turbine drills and micro power sanders. And cross pollination from other areas have been adapted to use with turnings - sand blasters for example.
For some reason, rather than being seen as just another tool a turner can use, computers, computer software and computer controlled devices are seen as not being craftsmanshipy enough to be used to create or enhance a turning. And that has me wondering WHY.
So - in this discussion I haven't had a sense of anyone being angry nor has there been any "heat" that characterizes a Flame War. On the contrary, it's been, for the most part, a polite exchange of ideas and folks have expressed various perspectives and opinions of the issue.
Of course, other may see things a bit differently - and that's fine by me.



