Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

Posts

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#26

Re: Amen Carole

charlie belden

There is a distinction to be made between an argument and a discussion

argument |ˈ�rgyəmənt|

noun

1 an exchange of diverging or opposite views, typically a heated or angry one

discussion |disˈkə sh ən|

noun

the action or process of talking about something, typically in order to reach a decision or to exchange ideas

What I was after was a DISCUSSION of an issue raised by the rules of the Turn and Burn contest - specifically centered on whether craftsmanship required that things be done exclusively "by hand". And I raised the topic because, of the many branches of woodworking, turning seems to be the most open to new ideas, new tools and new methods of doing things already being done some other way, or that can't be done with existing tools and methods. The use of things that new technology have made available to turners has, for the most part been embraced by turners - carbide cutters, lasers on hollowing tools, captured hoilowing systems, Prisma Color felt tip pens, high speed turbine drills and micro power sanders. And cross pollination from other areas have been adapted to use with turnings - sand blasters for example.

For some reason, rather than being seen as just another tool a turner can use, computers, computer software and computer controlled devices are seen as not being craftsmanshipy enough to be used to create or enhance a turning. And that has me wondering WHY.

So - in this discussion I haven't had a sense of anyone being angry nor has there been any "heat" that characterizes a Flame War. On the contrary, it's been, for the most part, a polite exchange of ideas and folks have expressed various perspectives and opinions of the issue.

Of course, other may see things a bit differently - and that's fine by me.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#27

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

charlie belden

Don:

I wasn't objecting to the rules of this contest. In the contest announcement and the thread that followed it I asked a question regarding the eligibility of pieces that used a laser engraver. The response to that question prompted asking if hand held and hand controlled laser "drills" would fall within the contest rules. Seems THAT is ok.

But that raised a subject I wanted to have a discussion about - specifically the question of Hand Work being a key criteria for Craftsmanship. And I'll acknowledge my personal bias for Wild Hare Ideas and the use of new technology to make some of those Wild Hare Ideas into actual pieces. Throwing out ideas for others to consider using - or not - has been encouraged here and in other woodturning forums. And discussions like this one seem to be in keeping with the spirit of this and similar groups.

Now if I can just convince the dOntist who I've paid a Mercedes or Porsche worth of bucks to, to let me play with his laser drill - and can come up with a Wild Hare Idea piece to use it . . .

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#28

Dick Hines

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

Dick Hines

Charlie this not that high tech. Just turn something and the burn the dang thi ng.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#29

Ellis Walentine

It's okay, Charlie

Ellis Walentine

You're welcome to question anything you want here. We purposely worded the contest language to include "pyrography pens, brands, and/or other burning instruments." We didn't specify that "other burning instruments" couldn't include computer-controlled processes, because it didn't occur to us that this would be a bone of contention. We underestimated Murphy in this case.

Ellis

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#30

Not that it's necessary, but....

Molly Winton

speaking as a judge, I agree completely with Ellis's call on this.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#31

Don Pencil

Charlie, your focus is too narrow.

Don Pencil

If your thinking concerning rules and craftmanship is as narrow and limited as your selection and use of definitions then maybe that it the issue.

The rest of the definitions on argument may be of value to you.

merriam-webster

Main Entry: ar�gu�ment

Pronunciation: \ˈ�r-gyə-mənt\

Function: noun

Etymology: Middle English, from Anglo-French, from Latin argumentum, from arguere

Date: 14th century

1 obsolete : an outward sign : indication

2 a : a reason given in proof or rebuttal b : discourse intended to persuade

3 a : the act or process of arguing : argumentation b : a coherent series of statements leading from a premise to a conclusion c : quarrel, disagreement

4 : an abstract or summary especially of a literary work

5 : the subject matter especially of a literary work

6 a : one of the independent variables upon whose value that of a function depends b : a substantive (as the direct object of a transitive verb) that is required by a predicate in grammar c : amplitude 4

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Jump to: navigation, search

This article is about the word as it is used in logic. For other uses, see Argument (disambiguation).

In logic, an argument is a set of one or more meaningful declarative sentences (or "propositions") known as the premises along with another meaningful declarative sentence (or "proposition") known as the conclusion. A deductive argument asserts that the truth of the conclusion is a logical consequence of the premises; an inductive argument asserts that the truth of the conclusion is supported by the premises. Deductive arguments are valid or invalid, and sound or not sound. An argument is valid if and only if the truth of the conclusion is a logical consequence of the premises and (consequently) its corresponding conditional is a necessary truth. A sound argument is a valid argument with true premises.

Each premise and the conclusion are only either true or false, i.e. are truth bearers. The sentences composing an argument are referred to as being either true or false, not as being valid or invalid; deductive arguments are referred to as being valid or invalid, not as being true or false. Some authors refer to the premises and conclusion using the terms declarative sentence, statement, proposition, sentence, or even indicative utterance. The reason for the variety is concern about the ontological significance of the terms, proposition in particular. Whichever term is used, each premise and the conclusion must be capable of being true or false and nothing else: they are truthbearers.

Word Origin & History

argument

late 14c., "statements and reasoning in support of a proposition," from Fr. argument (13c.), from L. argumentum, from arguere "to argue" (see argue). Sense passed through "subject of contention" to "a quarrel," a sense formerly attached to argumentation.

Online Etymology Dictionary, � 2010 Douglas Harper

ar�gu�ment (�r'gyə-mənt) n.

A discussion in which disagreement is expressed; a debate.

A quarrel; a dispute.

Archaic A reason or matter for dispute or contention: "sheath'd their swords for lack of argument" (Shakespeare).

A course of reasoning aimed at demonstrating truth or falsehood: presented a careful argument for extraterrestrial life.

A fact or statement put forth as proof or evidence; a reason: The current low mortgage rates are an argument for buying a house now.

A set of statements in which one follows logically as a conclusion from the others.

A summary or short statement of the plot or subject of a literary work.

A topic; a subject: "You and love are still my argument" (Shakespeare).

An independent variable of a function.

The angle of a complex number measured from the positive horizontal axis.

A course of reasoning aimed at demonstrating truth or falsehood: presented a careful argument for extraterrestrial life.

A fact or statement put forth as proof or evidence; a reason: The current low mortgage rates are an argument for buying a house now.

A set of statements in which one follows logically as a conclusion from the others.

A summary or short statement of the plot or subject of a literary work.

A topic; a subject: "You and love are still my argument" (Shakespeare).

An independent variable of a function.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#32

Steven Antonucci

Too late now, but...

Steven Antonucci

We all learn that it is better to ask for forgiveness than to seek permission.

Were it my desire to create a laser enhanced piece, I would have done it quietly and just put it in to see what happened... and perhaps it would have been judged on its merit instead of how it was made. If you ask people for an opinion, you'll usually get one. If you ask them to actually make an effort, a smaller crowd shows up...

S

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#33

Re: Too late now, but...

Mac Ray

Actually,a much smaller crowd would be a relief...........thank you................

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#34

Re: Too late now, but...

Brian George

Personally, I found this whole discussion stimulating and thought provoking. Thanks everyone!...

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#35

Keith Tompkins

Re: Too late now, but...

Keith Tompkins

Me Too, Brian, but concerning your previous statement, if someone was interested enough to purchase a lathe and the tools required to turn something, then enter an exhibition...wouldn't they be considered a turner? Seems like you're walking a fine line there.