Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

Posts

Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#1

Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

charlie belden

The rules for the Turn and Burn contest require that the "burning" device be hand held and the burning be done by hand control.

That got me wondering - is it the concept - or the execution - or more accurately - the method of execution that's most important? If you're into Arts and Crafts you think of Greene & Greene or maybe Stickley. In the case of Greene & Greene, only one of the brothers actually made any furnture. It was the Halls that actually took the Greene designs and made them into actual pieces. And they were the ones who filled in the blanks that ALL furniture plans have. The results were called Greene & Greene pieces, not Halls pieces.

Hell, most of the Sam Maloof rockers out there weren't done completely by Sam - he had two helpers who did most of the grunt work - and probably ALL of the sanding and much of the shaping.

Now there are a lot of folks who have develop wonderful techniques for doing things - and can reproduce pieces as good or even better than the original - and even do minor variations of the original. Yet given really minimal design criteria and told to come up with something original many would be at a loss as to what to make. Copy? Yes. Variations? Yes. Original? Probably not.

I took an oriental brush painting class from a "master". If it was in the large menu of images and the brush strokes to make them - he'd produce the work - at almost any scale - in a couple of minutes. And it'd be perfect - and often beautiful. But if you asked for something that WAS NOT on his "menu" - well all bets were off. I commissioned him to do a flying goose for my jewelry making business (Wild Goose Casting Company - it's an I CHING thing). Apparently a flying goose wasn't in his menu. He tried, a dozen times - but we both agreed none looked much like a flying goose. Flying cranes he could do - in seconds. Flying goose - no cigar.

So here's my question.

If I select the piece of wood and turn and finish the piece and do a line drawing - say in india ink - ON the piece - and then have someone burn in the pattern - by hand or otherwise

A) would it qualify for the contest - as a collaborative piece?

or

B) would it qualify and be valid to say it was MY piece? (think Greene & Greene)

Seeing only the finished piece - SHOULD it matter HOW it was done, or for that matter - by WHOM - or WHAT?

I've heard that when Michaelangelo was coming up with the idea for his The David, he didn't go with what previous sculptors had gone with - the victorious David holding up the severed head of Goliath, or standing on the vanquished Goliath's dead body. Michaelangelo's The David shows David at the moment when he KNEW he could slay Goliath - and HOW. The David is a young man standing calmly and relaxed, confident and certain of what was to come.

And while on the subject of Michaelangelo - do you think he actually did ALL the painting on the ceiling the Sistene Chapel? Should it be called Michaelangelo - and Assistants - Ceiling?

For that matter, should the maker of the captured hollowing system be acknowledged if it was used to make a piece that the maker may not have been able to make otherwise?

So, if I make the piece, sand it and apply a finish to it, create my "pyro" pattern(s) using a computer, a digitizing table and it's pressure sensitive "pen", using some computer graphics program - then set up the jig for laser "burning" my design onto the piece - and have the computer instruct the laser "engraver" where to burn and where not to burn - should that deminish the value of the end result or that the piece was mine?

Maybe it's a Level Playing Field thing - a few may have access to a laser engraver, and all that's required to use it - but most won't. So in order to not penalized those who DO NOT have access to a laser engraver - and all that is required to use it - laser engraving is ruled out. But that begs the question - some can't afford a captured hollowing system. So should pieces made using a captured hollowing system also be ruled out? What about pieces that require a lathe with a BIG swing? Not everyone can afford a lathe that requires. So BIG pieces should also be ruled out?

To me, it's the concept and figuring out a way to make it a reality that is important, not HOW it became a reality. And if that requires figuring out a way to do something in a new or different way - that should get extra credit. If the How It Was Done is shared with others - for free - more bonus points.

What are your thoughts on these questions?

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#2

Steve Kubien

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

Steve Kubien

My thoughts on this are really simple.... You/we can have the art vs craft, captured, vs free hand, laser guided vs calipers debate until the proverbial cows come home and not make any progress. We will still have our beliefs and, hopefully, agree to disagree. Hopefully no ones feelings get hurt. When we chose to enter a contest/competition, we play by the house rules. I don't come to your house for dinner, ask what we are having, decide I don't want beef and tell you we are now going to have fish. Please know Charlie, I don't mean "you" specifically. It's more the grand "yooooooouuuuu".

Where do I stand on some of the other things, captured vs handheld, no really opinion as both have their place and I think know less or more of the work being produced. Laser vs calipers...same deal. Art vs craft...I have no bloody idea! :) Computer controlled burning/engraving...I do not think it has a place in a contest such as this.

my 2 cents because you asked for it.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#3

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

charlie belden

Keith:

Having come here from years participating on The Wreck (usenet newsgroup rec.woodworking), I don't take much personally and just in case, have my Nomex Pooh Suit (attire often needed just to read some of the long Flame Wars that broke out - and continue to break out - in that forum).

Modern day electrical resistance heating of niichhrome wire pyrography is merely a quicker and easier - and probably better controlled means of scortching/branding/vaporizing wood that iron or steel tools heated in a fire or in a small forge. The "new" technology does, however, allow for finer lines and crisper details. Laser engravers are just one of the next generation means of accomplishing the same end - getting an idea out of one's head and out in the real world for other to see and experience.

There is an interesting wrinkle I can add. Dentists (and dOntist) are, and have been using, handheld, hand "fired" pulsing lasers to "drill" into teeth. And laser "dental drills" have been around for a while now. At some point, creative folks WILL get their hands on "obsolete" models - and start playing with them. If their results get noticed - and there's enough potential market - someone will make a "woodworker" version that's iniitially only affordable to a few. If there's a niche market with promise of profits, the price will come down - if economicists are correct about Supply and Demand Curves.

Would a piece created with a hand held, hand controlled laser "drill" qualify for this contest? Probably too new an idea to be accepted - yet.

Dermatologists have been using pulse lasers to remove (read vaporize) tatooes. The ink absorbs energy from the laser better than the tissue surrounding it. Conceivably, you could use an HB or 2B pencil to draw the design on a turning - then "burn" the pattern into the wood using a hand held, hand controlled pulsing laser. Should meet the contests criteria - but probably wouldn't be accepted either - yet.

We live in a rapidly changing world with new technologies coming on line - and folks developing the knowledge and skills to use them, often not for their initial intended purpose. Some will allow us to do things that can't be done now.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#4

Steve Kubien

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

Steve Kubien

Ok, I'll play the dental game... :)

A dentist who carves composite resins in making a restoration (filling), dyes it, layers it, forms it, is, in my opinion an artist. There is also really cool piece of CAD/CIM technology in the dental field called a CEREC. With this thing, the dentist takes a picture of a prepared (re: drilled) tooth and then programs the computer to carve the restoration out of a block of ceramic material, which in turn gets bonded in the mouth. This is not artistry IMNSHO and I can say this from the persepctive of having used this machine and making fillings and crowns which are currently bonded in peoples mouths.

Who's right? Who's wrong? Beats me but I have a feeling we can each know art/craft when we see it.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#5

Steven Antonucci

Not by hand, just not by computer

steve antonucci

I certainly believe that you could build a mechanical device that controlled the burns like a rose engine might, but turning the effort into a CAD/google sketchup contest kind of minimizes the "execution" part of turning? There is very little risk or challenge past the computer screen.

In addition, with the IP being in the CAD system, producing multiples would be very simple, so you get further and further away from handmade and more into mass produced...

No CNC, no laser engraving/cutting, no CAD for me, thanks.

s

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#6

Re: Not by hand, just not by computer

charlie belden

Well let me start with mass production and laser engraving. The laser engravers have a very narrow depth of field so unless the turned pieces are pretty close to the same shape and size the set up and procedure would be unique to each piece. Tight radii areas are really tricky to do. And in addition to doing the original art work, there's a fair amount of planning involved in the set up and engraving sequence and process.

Still haven't opined on using a hand held, hand controlled laser "drill" for burning in the pattern.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: Not by hand, just not by computer

Steve Kubien

Still haven't opined on using a hand held, hand controlled laser "drill" for burning in the pattern

That wouldn't bother me as I see it being no diffetent than a burner or a dental drill.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#8

Just Depends On The Rules Of The Game

Texian

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

Keith Tompkins

Hi Charlie, I have a few thoughts concerning this topic. First, the Sam Maloof analogy. A chair that came out of the Maloof studio is a Maloof chair, no matter how many assistants had a hand in it. Just as in the apprenticeship system in Europe, the apprentice did what he was instructed to do by the master. Nothing more, nothing less. There was no room for interpretation or artist license. The results were recognized as the work of the master. This was a win/win situation: eventually the apprentice became a master, ensuring that skills would be passed from one generation to the next. In Maloof's case, those working for him could come up with their own designs, hire helpers, and repeat the process. In that case, the DESIGN is key...we all see "Maloof influenced" chairs all the time.

I use music analogies all the time: Example, Paul McCartney wrote the song "Yesterday". (maybe in colaboration with Lennon). A million artists could record the song, yet it's still a McCartney song. They could perform it far better, but that doesn't change a thing. Like the Maloof rocker, it's the originator of the artwork, and the artwork itself, that counts.

Concerning new technologies, I feel there is a line between craft and manufacturing. Computer aided equipment is designed to speed up manufacturing processes, while improving accuracy. At the same time, a lower-paid, less skilled employee can operate the machine. I feel a certain intimacy with the material is lost when too much technology is employed...the cnc router could care less about grain direction or anything else, and the operator need not know a piece of maple from particle board.

I think we must compare apples with apples, and in this case only handheld tools should apply.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#10

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

Dave Moore

Complex topic for sure.

There's a lovely little book I read years ago by David Pye. It's called the Nature and Art of Workmanship.

It doesn't answer every question of course, but it sure helped me to get a perspective on what I do. It's a tiny bit dated by now; I think it was written in the 70's maybe, but it's still valid in many ways.

In broad strokes he says that there is often a false boundary drawn between '"hand" work and "machine" work. Some machine work can be wonderful (nothing wrong with Mason Jars for example), and some hand work can be pretty awful. (He pokes fun at the "hairy cloth and gritty pots" that were all the Art and Crafts rage when he wrote the book).

He floats the notion that a better distinction is between what he calls "workmanship of certainty" and "workmanship of risk". Either can be successful or unsuccessful, but all work starts with workmanship of risk. Even automated production has to work from an original pattern of some kind, and the original is usually produced by the risky method.

Jigs reduce risk, of course. A chisel is riskier than a plane, which is really a jigged chisel and so on.

He gets into beauty too. Why do most folks find a harbor full of fishing boats to be prettier than a parking lot full of cars, for example. Good question. Both can have seagulls, so that ain't it. ;)

It's a good read. I found it very helpful.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#11

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work? *LINK*

Juergen

This should give Priddle's burner a little competition. All you need is an old DVD burner and a few parts,


http://www.make-digital.com/make/vol10/?pg=143

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#12

Steven Antonucci

Agreed

Steven Antonucci

Not against new methods of work, but I believe that the "work loses it's soul" the more that we rely on technology to complete it. I would not consider myself a carver if I used a Carvewright CNC machine any more than I would consider the work "mine" if the material aspects of it were completed by a robot under computer control. Doesn't matter if the computer is firing a laser or spinning a cutter...

However, if my mind and motor skills determine the outcome, then I have no issues with firing a laser to accomplish the task.

S

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#13

Steven Antonucci

That looks like a great way to hurt yourself! ;-)

Steven Antonucci

Got to love an article that has a warning every other sentence... must... resist... urge... to ... build this....

S

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#14

Don't like the rules? Don't play.

Carole Valentine

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#15

Ellis Walentine

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

Ellis Walentine

Hi Charlie,

The gist of your original question was whether a computer-controlled burning process would be acceptable as a technique in our current contest and my answer was no. No doubt it is possible to achieve artistic results with CNC processes, but it isn't in the spirit of craftsmanship as we construe it for contest purposes. That's not to say that there isn't great conceptual and technigal skill involved in CNC work, or that the resulting object isn't artistic; it's just that it isn't allowed in this particular contest. We're looking for pieces by amateurs that succeed on their artistic merits, whose decorative aspects include, but are not confined to, controlled woodburning. Controlled by a human.

I guess it comes down to your definition of craftsmanship. In all the contests I've been involved with over the past twenty years, we've generally thought of the judging criteria in terms of three main parameters: Originality, craftsmanship, and degree of difficulty. Craftsmanship is usually conceived as the sum total of the engineering and execution of the piece, as measured by the choice of the materials, the appropriateness of the design for the intended purpose (whether or not the piece was intended to be functional), appropriate joinery and finishing, and the technical proficiency of the execution. This technical proficiency can be thought of as skill -- the confluence of hand, eye and brain to produce the finished result. When the brain's involvement stops at the computer, and a robot finishes the job, craftsmanship suffers, no matter how lovely the finished product. We're not judging merely the outcome; we're judging all the skill and vision that went into it.

Ellis

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#16

Re: Don't like the rules? Don't play.

Brian George

That comment seems a little Draconian to me. With all due respect it smacks of the attitude that "you don't like our country, then leave."

If rules are not challenged then those who rule shall always do it their way, IMNSHO.

If I put a paint stroke on my turning, am I then a painter? No! I am a turner that has used paint as an embellishment! I may very well be painter as well but, that is not the essence of my turning.

If I turn a disc of wood and then incorporate that into a bronze casting, is it a sculpted piece or a turned piece? Can I enter my "sculpture" into a turning contest? NO! I think I am a sculptor who has used wood turning as an embellishment! I may very well be a turner as well but, that is not the essence of my sculpture.

If I carve a beautiful piece and include a small turned spindle, am I turner or carver? Same conclusion as above.

IMNSHO, and not referencing any specific contests or artisan specific galleries, there are artists and artisans that enter contests to expand their venues and do so by using an embellishment of wood turning to accomplish that end. They are no more turners than I am a sculptor or painter.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#17

Steve Kubien

Re: That looks like a great way to hurt yourself!

Steve Kubien

Sounds like a world-domination weapon to me. I'm in!

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#18

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

charlie belden

So in the case of a Maloof chair - Sam, in addition to coming up with the design and making the key parts - the arms of the rocker for example - acted as the QC guy for work done by others under his guidance and perhaps supervision. Ignoring the value of the apprenticeship system, I''m not sure I see a significant difference between a CNC unit getting a chair seat close and an assistant doing what is primarily grunt work.

I think there is a clear difference between using technology in the making of a One Of A Kind piece and using technology to mass produce something. And it's the concern about technology being used to mass produce pieces (read: make what I'm making and perhaps selling, but doing it quicker and less expensively) that seems to be the main source of opposition to using new technology to do something currently being done by an older, more established and accepted method.

It's the Status Quo Ante Inertia that must be overcome by anyone using new technology to make what's in their head into something real that others can see, touch, hear - hold and play with. And that's understandable. We tend to be comfortable with the familiar - and often uncomfortable with or threatened by the unfamiliar. That's genetic, part of our evolutionary heritage. But we, as a species, have adapted to change and as a result have arguably advanced beyond any other species on the planet. We have the ability to fold the new and unfamiliar into our Familiar Fabric - eventually - if that works better.

To me, the concept is the key, the means of execution merely something to be worked out - WHAT more important than HOW.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#19

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

charlie belden

Ellis wrote:

"Craftsmanship is usually conceived as the sum total of the engineering and execution of the piece, as measured by the choice of the materials, the appropriateness of the design for the intended purpose (whether or not the piece was intended to be functional), appropriate joinery and finishing, and the technical proficiency of the execution.

This technical proficiency can be thought of as skill -- the confluence of hand, eye and brain to produce the finished result.

When the brain's involvement stops at the computer, and a robot finishes the job, craftsmanship suffers, no matter how lovely the finished product. We're not judging merely the outcome; we're judging all the skill and vision that went into it."

==========================================

So it's the skill and vision that went into the piece that's being judged. And it's the skill that's the issue here. The skill is defined as eye-hand coordination driven/controlled by the brain - specifically a human brain and a humans eye and hands. Lack those things and the craftsmanship suffers.

OK - given those criteria - the use of a lathe to control two of the parameters for creating a 3D object, embellished or not (the lathe fixes one axis of the part being worked on AND the rotation of the object on one axis - at a time in the case of multi-axis pieces) - seems to violate the criteria.

And should an indexing mechanism be used to locate where a change to the originally turned object is located seems to also violate the criteria - the locations should be eye balled rather than located by a device.

If a template is used, that a human "drew" and perhaps made using hand tools exclusively, to identify when the turning matches the desired vision - does that violate the criteria?

John Jordan uses a long Zip Tie to check the outline of his pieces to identify if it has Fair Curves or not. Is that "cheating" because he can't just SEE that the curve is a Fair Curve or not - and know where it's off if it is?

It seems to get back to Pye's Risk vs Certainty thing. It's the willingness to risk failure and pursue a vision anyway that is valued most - all other things being equal.

Interesting.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#20

Don Pencil

Re: That looks like a great way to hurt yourself!

Don Pencil

OH YEAH!!!

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#21

Re: Don't like the rules? Don't play.

charlie belden

Brian brought up the issue of access to venues. If you're doing something that isn't "Like" anything that's been done before - and want to make others aware of what you've done - either for ego gratification, the hope of monetary reward or just to be evangelical (I did THIS and it was fun! Maybe YOU might find it interesting enough to try - and maybe come up with another interesting result - and share it).

Museums, galleries and exhibitions typically aren't venues for really new or really different ideas. How can they know about them if there's only a few if any places to show them?

I guess one could be devious and create pieces using whatever means - and not volunteer that some of the finished piece was done using "non-traditional" methods. As far as I know, there's no Show Me Exactly How You Made This requirement. And lord knows, in the art world, SECRETS only add to the WOW factor. Hell, a local college (now a UNIVERSITY) had a well known ceramics instructor who had a "secret glaze formula" that made him a fair amount of money and established him as a prominent figure in the ceramics world. To my mind, TEACHERS should have no "secrets" in the area that they're teaching - but that's a whole other issue.

So where should/can pieces done in a new way, or pieces that can only be done using some new method get exposure?

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#22

Don Pencil

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

Don Pencil

Charlie,

You have made some great points and sparked a very interesting and thought provoking debate and I am certainly glad you did. But you are now just arguing or the sake of arguing. The way this is going is called spliting hairs.

This is a judging of excepted turning methods enhanced by a hand held woodburner. That's it. The contest rules have been questioned, explained, and demostrated to be valid. Suggestions (if that is what they are) for rule changes have been rejected.

May I humbly suggest this craftmanship debate be a topic for another thread outside of the contest rules forum.

Here is a wonderful idea, you should sponser another contest someplace for an "all comers" contest. No restrictions. "Run what you brung". No rules at all. No judging criteria. I would like to see that.

Don

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#23

more power-aaaarrrrgh

john lucas

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#24

Amen Carole

Barbara Gill

The rules make perfect sense; it is not rocket science. I don't remember Ellis putting it up for suggestions or discussion. Some people seem to enjoy recreational argument. It does get to be a bit silly.

Re: Craftsmanship = Hand Work?

#25

Well Said Don

Barbara Gill