Craftsmanship = Hand Work?
charlie belden
The rules for the Turn and Burn contest require that the "burning" device be hand held and the burning be done by hand control.
That got me wondering - is it the concept - or the execution - or more accurately - the method of execution that's most important? If you're into Arts and Crafts you think of Greene & Greene or maybe Stickley. In the case of Greene & Greene, only one of the brothers actually made any furnture. It was the Halls that actually took the Greene designs and made them into actual pieces. And they were the ones who filled in the blanks that ALL furniture plans have. The results were called Greene & Greene pieces, not Halls pieces.
Hell, most of the Sam Maloof rockers out there weren't done completely by Sam - he had two helpers who did most of the grunt work - and probably ALL of the sanding and much of the shaping.
Now there are a lot of folks who have develop wonderful techniques for doing things - and can reproduce pieces as good or even better than the original - and even do minor variations of the original. Yet given really minimal design criteria and told to come up with something original many would be at a loss as to what to make. Copy? Yes. Variations? Yes. Original? Probably not.
I took an oriental brush painting class from a "master". If it was in the large menu of images and the brush strokes to make them - he'd produce the work - at almost any scale - in a couple of minutes. And it'd be perfect - and often beautiful. But if you asked for something that WAS NOT on his "menu" - well all bets were off. I commissioned him to do a flying goose for my jewelry making business (Wild Goose Casting Company - it's an I CHING thing). Apparently a flying goose wasn't in his menu. He tried, a dozen times - but we both agreed none looked much like a flying goose. Flying cranes he could do - in seconds. Flying goose - no cigar.
So here's my question.
If I select the piece of wood and turn and finish the piece and do a line drawing - say in india ink - ON the piece - and then have someone burn in the pattern - by hand or otherwise
A) would it qualify for the contest - as a collaborative piece?
or
B) would it qualify and be valid to say it was MY piece? (think Greene & Greene)
Seeing only the finished piece - SHOULD it matter HOW it was done, or for that matter - by WHOM - or WHAT?
I've heard that when Michaelangelo was coming up with the idea for his The David, he didn't go with what previous sculptors had gone with - the victorious David holding up the severed head of Goliath, or standing on the vanquished Goliath's dead body. Michaelangelo's The David shows David at the moment when he KNEW he could slay Goliath - and HOW. The David is a young man standing calmly and relaxed, confident and certain of what was to come.
And while on the subject of Michaelangelo - do you think he actually did ALL the painting on the ceiling the Sistene Chapel? Should it be called Michaelangelo - and Assistants - Ceiling?
For that matter, should the maker of the captured hollowing system be acknowledged if it was used to make a piece that the maker may not have been able to make otherwise?
So, if I make the piece, sand it and apply a finish to it, create my "pyro" pattern(s) using a computer, a digitizing table and it's pressure sensitive "pen", using some computer graphics program - then set up the jig for laser "burning" my design onto the piece - and have the computer instruct the laser "engraver" where to burn and where not to burn - should that deminish the value of the end result or that the piece was mine?
Maybe it's a Level Playing Field thing - a few may have access to a laser engraver, and all that's required to use it - but most won't. So in order to not penalized those who DO NOT have access to a laser engraver - and all that is required to use it - laser engraving is ruled out. But that begs the question - some can't afford a captured hollowing system. So should pieces made using a captured hollowing system also be ruled out? What about pieces that require a lathe with a BIG swing? Not everyone can afford a lathe that requires. So BIG pieces should also be ruled out?
To me, it's the concept and figuring out a way to make it a reality that is important, not HOW it became a reality. And if that requires figuring out a way to do something in a new or different way - that should get extra credit. If the How It Was Done is shared with others - for free - more bonus points.
What are your thoughts on these questions?
Computer controlled burning/engraving...I do not think it has a place in a contest such as this.



