Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Polishing bars question.

Posts

Polishing bars question.

#1

Polishing bars question.

John Lucas

I'm playing secretary/receptionist today and I'm bored. Between phone calls and counter help I've been looking up the differences between all the various polishing compounds for buffing. I wanted to know the approximate differences between the various colors preferably a grit comparison.

so far I've failed miserably. I have found that the black is the coarsest, the brown Tripoli is less and the White is finer. I haven't found where the Red rouge fits in although if it's call jewelers rouge it's a very soft abrasive for polishing gold and silver. I haven't found where the Green fits in which is common among woodworker who use it to sharpen. I've also found light green which is apparently just for polishing stainless steel ( they don't say what will happen if you buff lacquer with it) Pumpkin, Gold, Blue and some other tans.

I looked up the guitar polishing sticks on the Stew-mac web site and they are all shades of tan but are listed as course through ultra fine so at least you know which one is for what.

I'm only asking because I have a set that includes 6 different colors and wanted to know if I could use any of them for buffing my finishes. I have tried running tests on scraps and really can't tell much difference in them other than the black leaving a more satin appearance which means it's courser than the others which I just found out today.

Anybody found anything else?

Re: Polishing bars question.

#2

Re: Polishing bars question.

Texian

Good question John. My 35+ year old set has black, white, and two browns called tripoli and red rouge, but I don't know which brown is which. Have been using the white (rouge?) to lightly buff lacquer. Shines it up a little and makes the surface feel smoother (which I think is good for sales), but is not aggressive enough to remove minor orange peel. Need to get/make a couple more buffs and experiment with the two brown ones.

Re: Polishing bars question.

#3

Re: Polishing bars question.

Carole Valentine

Talk to Doug Black. I posed a similar question to him one night on the WoW chat. Unfortunately I have forgotten what he said, but he seemed to understand a lot about the different compounds and they carry a ton of different ones in his stores.

Re: Polishing bars question.

#4

Don Pencil

Re: Polishing bars question.

Don Pencil

John,

They almost all are for buffing various metals and/or plastics.

If you dig deep enough you will find that there are different grades within each of the compounds. For example, the "white diamond" for turners is called other things in the metal polishing industry like "brightener" and it comes in several grades of abrasiveness.You will have a great deal of trouble getting these compounds compared to sanding grit as the polishing industry does not think in those terms.

The reason there are several colors in one of the "store bought" kits is because it is assumed that you will be using it for different degrees of polish on various metals.

This is why, because of testing over time, there are only three or so compounds used for wood and wood finishes. The rest have generally been ruled out do to color, aggressiveness, vehicle, or all of the above.

Don Pencil

Re: Polishing bars question.

#5

Don Pencil

PS

Don Pencil

Also the woodturner needs to keep in mind that they are only buffing two things in general.

1. Bare or sealed wood. If that is the case then, sanding is a better way to get to a place where the next step is tripoli than another buffing compound.

2. Wood that has an applied finish such as lacquer or urethane. In this case you use a very mild compound like "PL" and that is all you need to get the job done there.

Don

Re: Polishing bars question.

#6

Roger in MO

Re: Polishing bars question.

Roger in MO

John, we used tripoli, then rouge to polish copper that was hammered into bowls and plates. This was back in the 1950s in College Industrial Arts.

I found this info in an old text book. "some of the cutting materials used are lime, tripoli, crocus, rouge and flour of emery etc. These are mixed with tallow or some other heavy grease and pressed into bars...

Tripoli is decomposed, impure limestone or rotten stone.

Rouge is a soft iron oxide. It comes in different shades of red, the darker the color the harder the rouge. the lighter product is called rouge and the darker crocus.

From Metalwork technlogy and practice, OSWALD LUDWIG, McKnight and McKnight, 1947

This doesn't help on the grit size but at least ranks them to some extent.

Then again there just might have been some changes in the last 60 years (grin)

Roger

Re: Polishing bars question.

#7

Re: Polishing bars changes.

bill crommett

Another grade of grit: Back in the 50 s they made a glue based metal buffing compound that was great for etching grain in bird carvings made with soft cedar or pine. The last time I tried to get some I was led up a blind alley.

Re: Polishing bars question.

#8

Re: Polishing bars question.

david

Try this:

http://www.sydneywoodturners.com.au/site/articles/finishing/buffing2.html

Re: Polishing bars question.

#9

Re: Polishing bars question.

john lucas

Thanks David. I had found bits and pieces of much of that info but this puts it all together.

Re: Polishing bars question.

#10

Re: Polishing bars question.

John K Jordan

Nice one! That's going into my reference files.

Re: Polishing bars question.

#11

Don Pencil

Re: Polishing bars question.

Don Pencil

Note that it is still hard to get a grit comparison.

Makes you wonder doesn't it.

Don

Re: Polishing bars question.

#12

Re: Polishing bars question.

Dich Hines

John, make sure you freshen up your make up and fix you hair. And go to the rest room when all the other guys go.

Re: Polishing bars question.

#13

Re: Polishing bars question.

John K Jordan

>Note that it is still hard to get a grit comparison.

I suspect the grading is very sloppy and there is a wide range of particle size in each stick. Way back when I polished metal for a living (I ran a small metallography lab and polished uranium-aluminum nuclear reactor samples and did grain-growth microscopy) we bought graded abrasives and they were quite expensive.

After the sandpaper for wet grinding I used three grades of diamond paste and Linde A and B (white powder). All grits were carefully graded and guaranteed. One learned to be very clean between grits - one stray particle and you started over. I used an ultrasonic cleaner between grits.

Perhaps if they don't state the grit sizes no one can hold them to it. :)

JKJ

Re: Polishing bars question.

#14

Don Pencil

Re: Polishing bars question.

Don Pencil

John,

How correct you are. Thanks. That was an excellent word picture for the problem of getting them to define compounds by grit.

It's not a system a guy buffing an auto bumper and the like really cares about. The manufacture tells them which one works best for each application and their off to the races. Buzzinga, pretty bumper.

Don

Re: Polishing bars question.

#15

Don Pencil

Re: Polishing bars question.

Don Pencil

John,

How correct you are. Thanks. That was an excellent word picture for the problem of getting them to define compounds by grit.

It's not a system a guy buffing an auto bumper and the like really cares about. The manufacture tells them which one works best for each application and their off to the races. Buzzinga, pretty bumper.

If you could see how they make the standard bars it becomes even more clear. Big vats of "stuff". Getting the abrasive consistenly mixed throughout the bar ain't gunna happen.

Don