Very surprised to see the recommendation on the grinder. The reason they recommend an 8" 3450RPM grinder is to yield 6000 to 8000 SFPM (surface feet per minute) from 8" to down to a "worn out" wheel of 6-1/2"
I have never heard of this metric, nor the basis for it. Anybody else understand it?
>The circumference of an 8" wheel is 8 X 3.14+~25" -- call it 2 ft. Multiply that by the RPM and you get about 6900 SFPM. I think the point is that SFPM is an absolute measure of how fast the wheel is moving past the tool, as opposed to RPM, where the actual speed is determined by wheel diameter.
>Jerry Ellis is right. These speeds have been set by the manufacturer of the wheels as the optimum speed for removing metal from HSS and still leave a good finish. I've tried it, don't like it. I can't tell the difference in how my tools look or sharpen and it scares me having the wheel running that fast. My grinder also takes about 3 times as long to get up to speed at 3450 than it does at 1725.
I use 8" wheels instead of 6 simply because the wheels last longer. A 6" wheel has a slower surface speed than an 8 with the same speed motor but again I saw no difference in sharpening quality other than the size of the concave area on the bevel. For a tool with a really long bevel this might make a difference but for my tools it doesn't seem to matter.
I actually think slower is better for beginners because you aren't removing metal as fast. This makes it easier for a beginner to control the shape of the edge. The biggest problem I see with new turners is the edge is wavy or has a dip somewhere near the tip. They tend to push to hard on the stone and if it's a fast moving stone it will take off that last bit of metal really quickly so if you movements aren't really fluid you get an uneven grind. With a slow speed grinder you can watch the edge and hold the tool there longer to remove the high spots.
I had a long talk with Don Geiger last week at the TAW symosium. I love his system. I'm already too entrenched in the Oneway system to completely change over but I'm going to try and get some piece of his line. He has without a doubt the best wheel truing system. Check out his website you might find something for your demo.
I have lead many workshops on sharpening and have done a lot of demos at clubs and symposiums on the subject. I also invented the Geiger's Vertical Solution Precision Sharpening System and the Geiger's Wheel Truing and Dressing Solution and four other devices for woodturners. I have studied sharpening extensively for many years and continue to do so just about every day.
Below are a few recommendations you should consider sharing with your club:
1) A majority of the tools sold for woodturning today are made of High Speed Steel (HSS). HSS does not lose its temper until about 1100 degrees F. If you were using a 3450 RPM grinder and applied a lot of pressure (example: changing a grind on a tool) the maximum temperature the tool would attain is about 750 degrees F. There is no risk of ruining the temper using a 3450 or 1800 RPM grinder. Bluing of the tool is not an indication of having ruined the temper.
NOTE: DO NOT DUNK HSS TOLLS INTO WATER TO COOL THEM! It will fracture the sharpened edge.
2) I prefer an 1800 RPM grinder because, you will take 1/2 the material off your tools in the same amount of time and if you make a mistake, it is 1/2 as bad. I use grinders every day and I always feel a greater level of concern when using the high speed model.
3) The very best thing one can do to improve the performance of a bench grinder is to make the wheels concentric to the axle of the grinder. This will significantly reduce grinder vibration, tool vibration and eliminates the need to balance the wheels using weights. My system (mentioned above) an the one from One Way are two of the better choices. Hand-held dressers only clean the wheels and are not very effective at making the wheels concentric to the axle.
4) I recommend Al Oxide wheels (8" X 1") with a H, I J, K or L hardness. Also, if one can purchase a wheel that fits the axle diameter without bushings, do so.
5) Always wear a face shield and good dust protection when dressing the wheels. And wear a face shield when sharpening.
>As was said, you won't hurt the HSS tools that are now common-place. Also, Oneway sells a lot of equipment to production turners who want to do everything as fast as possible since time is money.
I have 8x1" blue wheels on a 1725rpm grinder and as an amateur I find that just fine.
>As pointed out their recommendation is based on the optimum, and does not take into account there is a woodturner on the other end of the tool. In some cases, a not yet skilled woodturner. Oneway also used to use some really crappy grinders-I'm not sure these days.
If you can afford it, buy a Baldor 1800-every time you use it, you'll feel good about it. The inexpensive 1800 8" grinders that Woodcraft, and others, sell have been good in my experience-wobbly wheels not withstanding. As Don pointed out you need to align the wheels, which will wobble when you have a new grinder or wheel. The cheap ones will be worse, but hey can all be adjusted out with a little effort.
>Grinding is one of those personal preference issues. Everybody does it different, and everybody is right.
I don't know of a single woodturner, myself included, who doesn't use too much pressure when holding the tool against the wheel, and using a jig like the Oneway or similar only makes it easier to push too hard.
To me the speed of the grinding wheel relates to only one thing - how fast the metal is removed from the tool. If it takes 2-seconds to make a pass across the edge of the tool at 1750 RPM, we should be doing it in 1-second at 3500. I can't move the tool that fast with any control. Even the 1750 is too fast for me when I am sharpening small tools because it will grind the end off of a 1/4" gouge in a heartbeat.
For small tools I discovered that the right speed for me is half that of the 1750 RPM. Not having one of the slower grinders (they do make a 900 RPM grinder), I shut the motor off and let it coast down to about half speed, and bump the switch occasionally to keep it there.
I don't see that the wind-up time for the grinder is a problem because I just leave the grinder running continuously when I am turning something with a lot of sand in it. I turn a lot of the western Maple, and it can take the edge off of a bowl gouge in a minute.
The hardness of the grinding wheels is speed related. A wheel that is just right at 3600 RPM may be too soft at the slower 1750, and the one that is just right at 1750 will be too hard at 3600 and can load up and easilly burn the cutting edge of the tools.
Worrying about the tool turning color is a hold over from the days of high carbon steel, where blue meant the temper and hardness of the steel was lost. As already mentioned, this is not the case with High Speed Steels. These tool steels were developed for cutting steel at high speeds without a lubricant, and there is no way we will ever get them too hot with a normal grinding wheel. We used to grind the tool bits in the machine shop to red hot, holding them in a tool holder, without damaging the tool bit. We use the cooling water to keep from burning our fingers. not the to protect the steel. Yes, there is a danger of tiny cracks in the edge of a sharp tool that has been quenched too fast. I have been told that all of my life, but I have always thought of this as a theoretical problem because I have never experienced a cutting edge that was damaged from cooling it to quickly in water. I will conceed that maybe I have a problem with cracking, and didn't know it.
I am curious to what you think about CBN (cubic boric nitride) wheels and the diamond wheels. I have been using CBN for about 4 years, and the major draw back is the price of about $300 per wheel, but under production turning, my 80 grit wheel is 4 years old, and is about half used up. The guys that made my CBN wheels said diamond was for carbide, and not steel.
>A Norton 3X is a very good, long-lasting wheel that works well for high speed steel. It costs only $50 and will last most of us at least a couple of years.
I do not recommend a diamond wheel for HSS. I have a diamond wheel from Woodcraft ($140) and I quickly wore a groove in the center of the wheel where I placed the tips of my tools. There is only a thin layer of diamond dust in a mixture of binder. When you wear through it you are done. I now reserve the use of the diamond wheel to shaping and sharpening carbide hollowing bits. I see no benefit to using a diamond wheel on HSS tools.
Someone mentioned the time factor for re-sharpening; my Vertical Solution Sharpening system is very precise. When I go to the grinder, even if I have moved the V-notch for some reason, I can re-set it exactly where it needs to be in about 2 seconds and it compensates for changes in the wheel diameter. I have about 16 bowl gouges, all but two with the same grind. It takes me right at 10 to 15 seconds per gouge to re-sharpen. I use 1800 RPM grinders and make 1 or 2 passes and I'm done. I don't believe that having a grinder running at 2X the speed with cut this down any at all.
I strongly suggest an 1800 RPM grinder. Of course, I absolutely believe that making the wheel concentric to the axle is the best improvement to any grinder.
I also saw an entry where someone recommends an 8" Baldor grinder. These are very good grinders, but they have a large heavy duty wheel guard with an integral dust collector. So large that you have to raise the grinder up quite a bit to clear the receivers provided with a Wolverine system. Many of you may be familiar with my Vertical Solution that includes a V-notch that adjusts vertically to any height of grinder (now including a Tormek!), I also have a vertically adjustable support system for the Wolverine 3" X 5" platform rest. This solves the problems you will encounter when trying to use the Baldor and some other grinders. The vertically adjustable platform rest is not yet on my web site. I could post a couple of photos if someone wants to see it.
>Hi Jerry, I'm a dyed-in-the-wool high-speed grinder advocate. I feel there is a marked difference in edge quality between the two speeds. Unsafe practices will get you hurt irregardless of rpm....I've seen turners BOG DOWN their low speed grinders by applying far too much pressure, and in one case, explode a wheel when he pushed the tool past the cutting edge. Like the Corvair, unsafe at any speed. Blued cutting edges may not harm HS steel, but the appearance is totally unprofessional.(my opinion) Whether low or high speed grinding, blued steel means too much pressure, and wasted steel. How long should it take to sharpen a tool? One pass over the edge, done. That's it. If you are grinding, grinding, grinding...you are doing something wrong, and cutting the life of your tool in half or less.Yes, I am highly opinionated on this topic, no offense intended.
>Count me in with the smaller group of those who prefer the high speed grinders. That is all I have ever used from Day One of my turning career. If a person can develop a light touch on the wood, there is no reason that he or she cannot develop a light touch on the grinder as well. In my experience, a high speed wheel gives a much smoother grind, whereas the lower speed wheels bump along like something out of the Middle Ages.
Now, having written that, I also have a Tormek, and have been using it more and more for my turning tool sharpening. But for dry grinding, it will always be high speed for me.
>Well, I guess I am the only turner with CBN wheels. A friend who has at least 6 different grinders thinks I am excentric for having a Baldor grinder and $300 grinding wheels. I do love the Baldor, expensive, but worth every penny. I have a WC slow speed grinder, but mostly it gathers dust. I could see having a high speed grinder with really rough wheels for the few occasions when I need to shape a tool.
>Did you see that Tormek now makes a support to use their jigs with a standard grinder? This may have been around for a while but I just saw it a couple of weeks ago.
I use the Tormek for most sharpening but it is pretty much useless for reshaping a tool. I rigged up something crude to use the support bar on the standard grinder but this kit should make this simpler.
>John I bought one of those a few weeks ago, but have yet to find time to get it all put together. I am trying to figure a way to use both it and my Wolverine without them getting in one anothers way. I'm in the middle of some shop remodeling as well, which isn't making things any easier, and inconsiderate customers keep asking me to do work!
>Where do you get your CBN wheels? I have been looking all over North America for a source. Carborundum has said it will custom make one for me. I will be getting a quote in a few days. But, custom work is likely to be outrageously expensive!
>I got mine made by Northwest Super Abrasives right here in Eugene. 541-683-0801. I was chatting with Norton, and Amplex, and they told me there was some one right here in town who could make them for me. An 8 inch by 7/8 inch wheel cost $300. Do specify arbor size, but if you need it bigger, any machine shop could probably drill it out. 3/16 inch of material bonded to an aluminum core. No need to balance the wheels. I did talk to a 3M rep and he mentioned that they were getting into them. Any place that does a lot of metal grinding can get them. They do need to be trued from time to time, and have to be taken to the maker to be reground. They use a super hard aluminum oxide wheel for this. You clean them with the same stuff (my guys just gave me a couple of the worn out grinding wheels) as they will load like the other grinding wheels, and they will eat a diamond dresser.
>Ran into the same dilemmna. Figgered on using 2" wide flange aluminum angle vertically for the standoffs with wood blocks for mounting to base and for mounting bar block. This allows 'nuff swing for the Wolverine clamp arm.
Dunno if you saw the offer for the free extra Tormek mounting bar block which sadly expired in Mid February.
>I've used a grinder a lot in my 62 years but only for wood turning tools the last few years. I made the mistake of updating my old belt driven arbor 6" grinder for an 8" low speed direct drive. The 6" ran at about 1150rpm or 1806 ft/min surface speed. The 8" 1750 rpm at 3665 ft/min. Both had the same 1" wide and grit wheels.
I did MUCH better on the slower 6" in both surface finish and shape.
The 6" had a wooden version of the Wolverine jigs and the 8" the real deal.
Still try to use a light touch but must be getting too slow in my old age to keep a good shape on the tools with faster surface speed.
>Thanks. This is valuable information to me. I will be contacting your supplier if the Carborundum (Norton) price is outrageous. I have had some success with diamond wheels. I have a 180 grit (plated diamond only) that is fabulous for effectively honing tools. (If you want a better cut, you need a sharper tool.) I have been using it for 2 years now with no load-up. It is really fantastic on the new metals like you find in the tools that Doug Thompson sells, as the metal will hold a really "scary sharp" edge without crumbling -- something of a problem with older steels. I also have two 80 grit diamond wheels with about a quarter inch of diamond on them. Both tend to load up and need cleaning -- but are lasting well.
Now, the industry does not approve of using diamond wheels to sharpen tool steel as this steel will destroy the diamonds. I think I have been getting away with it because I am not putting the stress on the diamonds that they would get in industry where they would be working all day at intense temperatures. We try not to heat up our precious tools and should only be touching up our edges. However, I do want to try the Boron wheels -- if they are as good as the industry claims, they should be a real advancement in sharpening technology for us.
>You can have them made to whatever grit you want. I had 320 grit wheels, and they were nice, but a lot softer than the 80 grit. They lasted about 1 1/2 years. I now have a 150 grit wheel on the 'fine' side. The CBN does give a more polished edge than comparable grit wheels of other abrasives.