Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

McNaughton coring system

Posts

McNaughton coring system

#1

McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>I just purchased the larger McNaughton coring system. I've started to read what I can find on the web about it. I won't have time to try it out until next weekend probably so I will try to find all the info I can about using it.

My first question. I noticed the old cutters had square tips and the new one has pointed tips. Since the main reason I bought this over the other coring systems is to control the shape of the bowls and being able to alter it from the standard curve of theses cutters, is the square point better or the pointed one?

I plan to put a lazer on it later. Right now my metal lathe is down so I have to wait until it's back up and running to do the job right. Does anyone have any photos of how they mounted the lazar.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#2

Re: McNaughton coring system

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>John,

I have the same system. the pointed tip is an improved design. It takes less force to cut into the blank. It can cut straight in as well as on either face of the diamond. Steve Russel has a good tutorial on his web page on using the McNaughton. I think Bill Grumbine also has one on his site. Between those two and a few practice pieces, I've been able to cut a variety of blanks. I did have to buy the smaller knives to cut smaller bowls from the larger blanks.

I am satisfied with what I can do with it and would buy it again.

I had previously tried a friends OneWay system and settled on the McKnaughton.

Have fun coreing,

John

Re: McNaughton coring system

#3

Re: McNaughton coring system

tommy james

>john, robo hippy has a nice video and shows the laser with the mcnaughton. i bought one but i have only used it once. i will be interested in your experience with it. the main thing i have noticed is the importance of choosing your wood well. i tried to core a piece of cherry crotch at clay fosters course in june at acc and threw it off the lathe several times. jennifer shirley was in the class and kept saying that i was no mike mahoney. i finally succeeded but i learned that you probably should not try to core crotches. mikes demo in nashville in jan. at taw was excellent. he cored a piece of black ash burl and i also got a piece of this wood at taw and cored it successfully. my experience is that you can expect some failures but it is worth learning the technique. by the way where were you when we were at acc.we all had a great week together but missed seeing your smiling face. tommy

Re: McNaughton coring system

#4

Mahoney DVD

Phil in NJ

>The Mike Mahoney DVD on the system is good, he addresses the question of the cutter geometry and grinds the old one into the pointed geometry.

Alas he makes the system look very easy to use...

At one point he and Paul Chilton were talking about putting a 10HP motor on a lathe so they could core faster...!

-Phil

Re: McNaughton coring system

#5

Tommy's a Professional!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Tommy is going to demo this coring system at the next AAW symposium. I'm telling you, this is a must see demo! We're working on a video accompaniment to the demo as well because you will be laughing so hard you'll miss most of it with tears in your eyes. You'll need the video to see what you missed.

Tommy, you know I love ya! Those classes wouldn't be nearly as fun if you weren't there. Your comedy is worth the price of admission!

Hope all is well down there with you and your family.

Jen : )

Re: McNaughton coring system

#6

Re: McNaughton coring system

robo hippy

>John,

First, about the tip shape. The spear point is a Mike Mahoney innovation. The main purpose of it is to make it easier to cut a core completely off. This is best if you are coring end grain, crotch, or burl. In these wood pieces, because of the grain, if you cut if down most of the way and then try to break the core out (what I do on almost all of my cores), you can tear right through the bottom of the bowl. It is slightly easier to cut all the way off with the spear point than a square point. I have ground off all my spear points to square. Main reason is it is less cutting area on the wood at one time (about 3/8 inch wide shavings to 1/2 inch plus shavings).

This is not a tool that you can just pick up and use. You need instruction of some sort. Either find some one who knows how to use the tool, or there are 2 DVDs out on how to use it. Mike's is one, mine is the other. Of course, I like mine best.

I don't know which lathe you have, but I recomend that for starters, you get and use the standard set of blades. Pretty much for the same reasons you start with turning small bowls before you step up to big bowls. They are fine for most bowls up to about 14 inch diameter.

I have the laser pointer, and love it, but I didn't like the way it mounts. If you look at the picture in the Craft Supplies catelogue, it is on wrong. It is designed to mount out to the side of the handle rather than on top of it, and you use the same set bolts (only longer) to mount the holder that you use to secure the blade. The idea was that you could raise and lower the post to what ever height of bowl you were coring. Too much hastle and bother to change blades . I cut the post off to maximum height, and had the bracket welded onto the handle, making sure that the pointer was directly above/perpendicular to the cutting tip. Much easier.

If you have any questions, e-mail me.

robo hippy

Re: McNaughton coring system

#7

I'll Second That

Fog Tanner

>I would second the Mahoney DVD. I regound my square end cutters and never looked back. The pointed end does take less effort to core, and no problem with directional stability or being able to move the balde where I want.

I had thought of a laser set up before. There was a link to one off the Kelton site at one time. But after talking to Mahoney during a workshop, he explained that the cutter tip is inline with the shraight part of the blade and it was easy to visualize where the tip was at. Using his method I forgot about the laser and have not gone through the bottom of a bowl.

I guess Mike settled on a 5hp instead of a 10hp. He has a Vic 300 with a 5hp in it - special order from Vicmarc....

Fog

Re: McNaughton coring system

#8

Re: McNaughton coring system

Barry Irby

>I have had the standard set for a number of years. Before there were DVD's on the subject. I really struggled with them and thought they were poorly formed. I think the cutters need to be bent to a segment of a circle. Mine were not. I posted here about it and the Rep contacted me and had me send them to him. He reground my tips to the spear point. I was amazed he would reshape them without checking with me, but I think they are as good or better. They had a tendency to move to the left/outside. Not so anymore.

A friend and I repent the cutters to conform to a circle. They work MUCH better. Before, when you came to the part that was an ellipse rather than a circle it would start to burn the walls of the cut and you had to go back and trim that part away. To bad if that was the part you wanted to keep.

I posted a picture of my aiming device. A sheet of Plexiglas I clamp between the jaws of the chuck. With a wipeable marker you can mark the limits of your blank. Then you can set up the cutter to run just below it and see where it goes. if you turn the post correctly, you can then just keep the cutter beside the posts and have at it.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#9

Re: McNaughton coring system

Greg Haugen

>John,

Grumbine's second DVD has a section on the McNaughton and it's my favorite source/DVD on the subject. Mahoney's is great as well. Reed's is the only one that covers the "laser".

The tip that I liked the best was "neither". The tip I liked best was a retro-fitted McNaughton that Mike Hunter had tipped with a removable, diamond shaped carbide tip. I loved it. If I was still using a McNaughton, I'm using and loving my Oneway Easy Core now, that's what I would have on it.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#10

Re: McNaughton coring system

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>John,

I have the standard and small sets, not the big one, I did regrind from square to spear and works better for me.

I can core in green wood, no problem, after truing the shape to an arc of a circle as already mentioned, they were not, specially the one with more curve.

I have trouble coring dry wood and sometimes besides frequent touch up of the cutting edge, I squirt water into the cut aiming to the tip, a window cleaner bottle works well. (Feel free to use this tip in your writings and send me the $35.00. :0) )

Also somebody here suggested once to make spacer blocks, just a cylinder with a hole the size of your post the proper height for each set of knives, so your tip is always dead center, without having to fuzz with the adjustment and that sure helps and saves a lot of time. (Another $35/00 please)

Have fun

Jorge

Re: McNaughton coring system

#11

Re: McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>Thanks for the tips. I downloaded Bill's last night. I'll look up Steve's tonight. I kind of figured I would have to buy or make some more knives. I thought about building the whole system but I need them now.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#12

Re: McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>Sorry I missed you at the ACC. I simply forgot Clay was there, but I was also really busy at work. Would have loved to visit.

I was running the camera for one of Mike Mahoney's demos and watched closely. What I learned was lift up on the handle(really important) and don't push in any harder than the cutter wants to cut.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#13

Re: McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>Jorge I already have a bunch of spacers I made from PVC for my router jigs. I'll dedicate a few for the McNaughton.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#14

Re: McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>I have plans to completely redo my lazar system for the boring bar. I think I'm going to make some sort of universal adaptor so it will work on the boring bar, hand held bars and the McNaughton.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#15

Re: McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>Barry One of the reasons I went with the McNaughton system was that I don't like all the bowls to be the same. I asked Mike Mahoney and he said he thought this was the most versatile system as far as altering the shape of each bowl.

You do have to cut a little, remove the cutter and make a new path and I think that would offset having the cutter be a perfect circle.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#16

Re: McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>Mike had mentioned doing that and I have one of the tips that I am currently using on my homemade duplicator attachment. I was thinking I might buy some more and use them when I build a smaller set of cutters for the McMaughton.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#17

Re: McNaughton coring system

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

>Add a couple other tips:

Keep the gate as close to the wood as possible.

Keep the handle up but don't lift harder than necessary. Doing so makes it more difficult to advance the tool.

Twist the handle slightly clockwise. The space between the pins on the gate are wider than the thickness of the blade. If the blade is not twisted before the cutting starts, it will be, instantly. This drags the tip of the blade down and causes it to dig in.

Keep the tool sharp, not by grinding but with a fine stone or diamond hone.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#18

Re: Does that mean he doesn't get the $35.00? ;^)

Donna Banfield

>

Re: McNaughton coring system

#19

I'll send him more spacers :)

john lucas

>

Re: McNaughton coring system

#20

Re: McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>Thanks Harry, no one has mentioned the gate twisting. Makes perfect sense.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#21

Re: McNaughton coring system

robo hippy

>As far as point geometry goes, I have tried every configuration out there, from the old ones where the wing on the cutter was all on one side, bevel right, left, square or round. I haven't figured out how to do concave (like a beading tool). It made no difference as far as I could tell in how the blade tracked. The newer blades have the cutting tip centered on the blade, and this makes it easier to remove some from the inside of the cut if you have to aim a bit shallower, some thing that was impossible with the old blades. The only thing that changed the tracking path of the tools was to bend a tip in slightly. The bends in the blades are inconsistant, and they are stamped. The very tip can not be in the form, and it tends to be straighter rather than following the curve. This is part of why the blade drifts to the outside as you cut. This drifting is part of the cause of the burn marks on bowls and cores. The blade wants to go straight, and not follow the curve, so it binds in the cut. Part of it is in the opperator being not as consistant in holding to the track as a fixed center coring tool is. I have talked to Mike about this and he doesn't think they drift. If you never have to adjust the tool rest, or open the kerf a bit wider, then there is no drift. The blades are longer than the other systems out there, and they flex, which is another cause of the drifting.

I have heard that Randy of Monster Tools has an adapter for putting his laser system on the McNaughton. I haven't checked it out, but his system is the best laser pointer I have seen.

As far as knowing where the blade tip is, yes it is in line with the blade coming out of the handle, but I still ended up either 1 inch too shallow, or 1 inch too deep. I ended up always aiming a bit shallow to keep from making lamp shades (more practicle than funnels for me). With the laser pointer, there is no guess work. I still aim by eye, but the laser lets me know exactly how close I am. Not every one can develope the fine feel that Mike has for the tool.

I did have one of my blades retipped with one of Mike Hunters carbide cutters. It does cut nicely, tracks well, but I was getting more clogging up of the kerf with shavings. One reason could be that the shavings are wider than the cut/kerf. They unfold and clog up. I have the same problem with the spear poing McNaughton blades, but not as much as the Hunter tip. Another reason could be that the sides of the cut aren't as clean as the McNaughton. Lots of little waves/ridges on the sides, and they tend to catch the shavings. This just could be me, and my still learning the differences between the two cutting tips. I do get less clogging with the square tips.

I do have an end grain turned collar to go around the tool post to keep the cutter at center height. Acutally, I keep it about 1/4 inch above center. There is some flex in the blade, and the tool rest, so by the time you get to the end of the cut (just before the core pops out), you are below center. If you want to see how much, just try to remove the stub that is left after the core pops out with the coring blade. Of course, the larger the core, the more flexing there is.

I do have all 3 coring systems, and prefer the McNaughton. It is considerably faster to set up, use and sharpen than the other systems, and you can core any shape with it from deeper vessel to plates. It is far more versatile than the other systems. However there is a learning curve.

robo hippy

Re: McNaughton coring system

#22

Re: McNaughton coring system

Dale Cook

>Hi John, I also purchased this system about 3 years ago but used it for the first time 4 weeks ago. I got 5 bowls out of the first one and have since gotten 6 out of a smaller burl. I did put on a lazer for the second and third try which helped. You want to be cutting at center so I put the tailstock on and lined up the cutter with the tailstock with the handle held up in a cutting position. I was also advised to start with a softer wood that cores easier so I had some black willow burl that cut very nicely. Good Luck.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#23

straight cutter usage ?

john lucas

>The set I got came with a straight cutter. What would you use that for? I know many years ago I saw Rude Osolnik use a straight cutter to core out a cone but that was before all the coring systems came out.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#24

Steven Antonucci

welcome to the best and most frustrating tool

steve antonucci

>ever invented!

I am firmly convinced that you need to know voodoo to get this thing to work every time. As far as getting all of the knives in and out of the wood, that's alchemy. The most curved knife is like trying to route NETBIOS (where are my geeks?).

Still, it is a lot of fun to dismount a bowl core correctly and you can expect to increase your production by at least 2x immediately, 2.5x if you try to make 3 from 1 since half of them will be funnels...

Steve

Re: McNaughton coring system

#25

Re: straight cutter usage ?

Greg Haugen

>Coring cones.

The only two people I've heard of using that straight knife on a regular basis is JoHannes Michelson, who has now made his own straight tool, and Bill Luce, cored a cone out of the "vase/vessel" forms. I never used mine and thought it was an "outdated" option, but after hearing how those two used it, it does have it's purpose but they're rather dedicated.