Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

Posts

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#26

Steven Antonucci

The latest issue was pretty uninteresting

Steve antonucci

>As someone who leans towrds artistic, even I found the current issue pretty boring. Personally, I'd rather read less about people who don't turn (like collectors and furniture makers) and more about folks who actually stand in front of the lathe. I'm not a huge fan of "projects" either, but a tape measure? What the heck is that about?

I think the AAW magazine needs to realize that 95% of the membership is probably still turning UFO's and dog dishes with a scraper and pluging the screw holes with a dowel. When we talk about balance, it's important to ASK the membership what type of articles and representation it wants. If everyone that wants to read a specific type of article would actually contribute instead of complain about how bad it is, perhaps things would change.

I suspect that the issue is similar to what I see at some of the clubs I belong to- people want to complain about what is being presented, but won't step up to be part of the solution. If you dislike what the AAW brings to you, don't renew. If you think that you have better ideas, then by all means, WRITE AN ARTICLE!

steve

P.S. I'll be reapproaching Betty with a new tweak to an old idea...

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#27

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association------WebK

Sean Troy

>It's the minority thats brings in the most money. It has become all about the dollar more so than the majority of membership.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#28

Mike Stafford

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association------WebK

Mike Stafford

>It may be true that the minority brings in the most money but I am of the belief that they may have to do without my money. If enough folks tell them goodbye things will change.

I don't do PC.....

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#29

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association------WebK

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>Yes indeed.......that's exactly who attends the symposium, sits in those demo rooms and buys from the vendors. The meat and potatoes of AAW.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#30

I Second That

David Belser

>If the complaint is mostly about the content of the American Woodturner, then write the kind of article you would like to see and contribute. I talked to a previous editor and was encouraged to submit an article about any of a number of techniques that I use. They have difficulty getting articles. I never "got around to it", writing a good article can be quite a project.

I doubt things have changed.

So how about a rotation or two at the National Symposium about writing for the journal?

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#31

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association

Bill Johnson

>It does appear woodturning now has its very own "Flat Earth Society" by another name of course. Also it does appear the gallery features a piece that is in violation of its own rules, but then I guess that is okay, since it's acceptable by the whims and fancy of the powers that be rather than the rule of law. In an attempt to find out that my conclusion was in error, the website was accessed only to find what little information is available was a very trying read because of lack of contrast between the lettering and the background and from what information was available this organization may be made up of only one person, who (surprise-surprise) is asking for money. While the AAW and its Journal may have its problems the smell in its neighborhood is better.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#32

Re: I would like to understand

David Belser

>So basically, you are not happy with the content of American Woodturner. So why not work with the editors and provide feedback about the kind of stuff you would like to see? You could also write, contribute or help and encourage others who's work and style you admire to contribute.

My personal experience with AAW officers, board, editors etc. is that they have always been willing listen and encourage members to get involved. Have you talked to any of them about your concerns?

I've also noticed that typically both the Spring and Summer issues have a number of articles that are in essence promotion for national symposium. I do not know the specific details of organizing the national symposium, but I do have experience organizing a large symposium (New England, just the past weekend). Perhaps this contributes to the "unevenness" of material.

Personally, I really appreciate learning more about POP presenters before I get to the Symposium.

I've been involved in running a number of different groups. Often it is a real challenge to get members to actively participate in determining the nature of the organization. We have this exact problem in our woodturning club - No one wants to be president and the current president keeps on (reluctantly). One of the hardest things is finding demonstrators and talks, but most of the members just show up and expect a show. After cycling through the same people a few times, the meetings get predictable.

So how does one get members to go out and find demonstrators?

Anyway.... I'm looking forward the panel Michael Mocho mentioned, could get quite animated!

- Dave

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#33

Re:It's no long term service to anyone...

Jamie Donaldson

>...when some disgruntled faction decides to be a bigger frog in a smaller pond, packs up their tools and goes home to their comfort zones. It's also regretable that there are now apparently 2 "CWA" named organizations in the same field, as the established Collectors of Wood Art have been doing a great service to benefit the wood artists among us. I am totally disgusted that the AAW logo has apparently been deemed obscene by someone unknown to the general membership, but that certainly doesn't cause me to harbor ill feelings toward the whole organization. It is always more effective to change an organization from within, rather than taking potshots from outside at a safe distance. I certainly agree with Steve A. that participation is a better plan for representation than isolation.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#34

Re: I would like to understand

Scott Hurley in N VA

>I think the cover piece on the current issue fully illustrates the problems people have been having with AAW. Don't get me wrong, it's a beautiful piece, and I'm sure dozens (hundreds?) of hours went into painting it. BUT, how do you tell it's wood? It could just as well be a piece of painted plastic... Call me a caveman, but I appreciate a nice turned piece that celebrates the grain and figure of the wood itself.

Scott

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#35

Re: apology & invitation

Bill Crommett

>Michael: You will have to be careful when you try to give humor to someone who has none. The same gose for dealing with people who are always looking for something to be offended by. It used to be such a nice world when political correctness was unheard from. Now days one must not mention any Q words ,N words, F words J words, S words, H words G words and heaven forbid anyone calls me a Honky or a Gringo.

If people are so thin skinned or juvenile to be offended by anything that does not meet their pre-concieved notions of what is proper I have a word: "Grow up and join the enlightened generation"

(how is that for phallic ?)

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#36

Re: AAW Logo

Bill Crommett

>Right on Charlie. And you said it all in only three lines.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#37

Re: apology & invitation

bowlman

>Michael, et al,

I think that having a special rotation at the symposium is a great idea. I for one would love to be there, but the economy, finances and life has decreed that I forego this event this year. I can only hope that a rotation can be had with AAW Board of Directors and editor present (but not running the rotation ... let them sit and listen and listen and hopefully absorb) ... I would also hope that someone who did attend would give us stay at homes a detailed account of what transpired.

Best of luck! Put me down as one who thinks the logo should be reinstated.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#38

Tell that to Bill Clinton [grin]

Ed Moore of SW VA

>

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#39

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association

Jim Rutten

>Hi Ed,

Please know that I hold you and your work in the highest regard, but since you posted this, I do have a question. What does my $20-$30 get me if I join the Conventional Woodturners Association? Given it is a lot less money than AAW but with AAW I get a magazine 4 (maybe going to 6) times a year. I will agree the articles seem to have shifted a lot towards the artistic which I am not interested in, but even in this past issue I enjoyed reading the article on Giles Gilson and Robert Rosand's article on the parting tool and I especially like the tips section. It looks like you are in the formulative stages of putting out a newsletter. I also get insurance (the limits of which have been discussed on other threads). Also, my local woodturning club is a chapter of AAW. So, I guess, other than being with like minded turners what are the benefits of belonging to this organization.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#40

Excellent!

Ed Moore of SW VA

>Jim, thank you for you kindness and for an excellent question. I regard my $20 dues as a contribution and if it helps the CWA grow into a viable organization then I will have gotten my money's worth. When the AAW was formed there wasn't a well-defined magazine with excellent color photography available immediately to the membership. Just like when turners donate their time and resources to demo at a school or for their club, the only reward is seeing a smile of appreciation, a look of anticipation on a child's face as you make THEIR top, or someone says that they will be at the next club meeting and check it out, our rewards are not concrete, but they help build the program. I care about the AAW and want to see it righted and set back on solid ground, and I hope that the CWA carves out a niche of excellence in its own right. My reading of the CWA is that it wants to go back to basics and focus on turning, but that it has no interest in being the turning police. I hope that my $20 helps it succeed in that admirable goal. If it does, then more tangible results are likely to ensue.

I hope that you and many others join me in helping water and fertilize the seeds that have been planted. Let's help make the CWA a positive contribution to woodturning that is complementary to the AAW.

Ed

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#41

Re: Excellent Post ... Ed

Jerry Whitaker

>My $20 check will be going to the CWA first thing Monday morning. I enjoy looking at the artsie fartsie stuff in the AAW Journal and admire those with that talent and the time to do it. However, I am not that artistic and am therefore drawn to raw nature of the grain of the wood with some very simplistic embellishment. I am not looking for graddiose benefits from the CWA like insurance, a resource directory or even a magazine but rather another resource to see other people work that I can personally relate to.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#42

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>I won't write a whole lot here, as I have some BBQ work and a stogie waiting for me, but suffice to say, I put my money down and joined as soon as it was available to me. If time permits, I will donate as much of my time as I can afford to helping this organization get off the ground and grow.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#43

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I am a member of the AAW, Carolina Mountain Woodturners, and I have belonged to the Conventional Woodturners of America since September of 2007. My family supports all three organizations with our time, money, and our hearts. Between my wife and I, we hold three officer positions in two of the groups. We both volunteered at the Louisville National Symposium.

We prefer woodturnings that allow the natural beauty of the wood to be released from its log. Turnings, that could be plastic, are not our favorites. The name of all these groups is �WOODturners�. This is why we decided to support the CWA and its mission. We will continue to support the AAW and to attend the national symposiums that are close enough for travel by two disabled people.

The CWA is a fledgling group with limited people and resources. The upfront request for dues is needed to keep the lights on and the web provider paid. The member-only section has much more content than the public section. The first volume of the newsletter was published yesterday. It featured an informal dinner meeting of ten of us at The Southern States Symposium in April. The group does not want to be the turning police; our purpose is to support the education of basic woodturning.

The comment about the letters CWA as being already taken: a Google search of AAW brings hits on: doors, American Wrestling, Agri-women, Aerolastic Wing, and Apathetic Wikipedians. The CWA is not against anybody, come join and help us to grow.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#44

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association

Brian McInturff

>What would be found in the Members only section of the CWA. I don't see a link to a Members Section either.

Brian

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#45

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association

Larry Bisbee

>I sent my $20 membership fee to CWA yesterday and I'm looking forward to reading the newsletter(s). Over the years I've enjoyed the articles published in the AAW American Woodturner, but it seems that more and more articles are written for the major collectors of art forms, professional woodturners, and not for those of us that are just woodturners/hobbyist. The only benefit for me to join AAW every year (two years membership for $90) is the magazine. I also subscribe to Woodturning Design (two years subscription for $39.94) filled with a lot more woodturning articles that are more to my interest. I don't care about the AAW logo, but I do care about the magazine/article content. I wish CWA many years of success and it has my support. The next two issues of American Woodturner will determine if I send them another $90.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#46

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>The member's site is a completely different website. There is no link to it. It requires membership and a password for entry.

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#47

Please take a look at ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>my response to Jim Rutten below that is entitled "Excellent". It says what I really want to say and says it better.

There is plenty of room for improvement in the initial responses of Michael and me, and our apologies effectively acknowledge this. Don't let our shortcomings cause you to miss out on an opportunity to contribute to or benefit from the CWA.

Basically I am a "builder". I am happiest when I am building/making something physical or "growing" an organization. I was one of the founders of the Smith Mountain Lake Woodturners. We grew out of the Blue Ridge Woodturners in 2004 and now have around 70 members. The AAW is having growing pains now (Some wag will say that I am one of them [grin]), but we all hope that it is able to right itself and get back on course. Personally, I was very happy with how Carl Voss was handling the Editorship of the American Woodturner. I was involved with the article that Bob Rosand wrote about the sea urchin ornaments. There was good interaction between Carl and Bob, back and forth as it should be, the sort of thing that was missing when Bob wrote the article in the Summer issue that has just come out.

Please take a second look,

Ed

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#48

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association

rick pixley

>This looks like a purist approach to woodturning. I like the concept, but not the rigidity of the rules as stated in their bylaws.I see them as an open opportunity to create confusion and disharmony. I hope not...An example would be that "there will be no secondary carving"(section 3 bylaws) on any pieces supported by their organization and there it is, right off the bat, a beautiful piece supported by three legs pictured in their gallery. Not offensive in any way to me but for a "purist" it obviously was missed and the "rules" weren't adhered too..

I think I'll just stick to our current AAW and just quietly work on "cleaning house within"...So that said it's time for us to do our research (who said what,did what,is rude,etc?),learn the rules,and throw the rascals out...AAW..hear the hounds baying(sp)?

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#49

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association

Wilford Bickel

>CWA officers (formed in 2008 and memberships started being accepted in Jan. 2009) are staying out of this discussion with the one exception - we are going to defend the decision to allow the bowl that is being discussed. I have personally seen Frank Penta demonstrate a multi-axis turning that leaves a three footed base that when photographed would look very similar to this bowl. Knowing there is a way to turn this type of foot we left it up to the member to ensure his work complied with the rules. Had there not been a way to do it turning we would have questioned it but it can be done with the lathe! As has been said we are not turning police and if we know of a turning technique to make a 3 footed bowl we will allow it unless obvious it was done off the lathe by carving. This is our main point that many things that are being done with carving are able to be done on the lathe with turning if you take the time to expand your turning skills and learn the procedures. Frank has a excellent write up on his website teaching how to make these feet!

Wilford Bickel

CWA Chairman

Re: Conventional Woodturners Association *LINK*

#50

Re: apology & invitation

cassandra speier

>Michael, what a gracious and well written rebuttal.