>A friend, Mike Cunningham, sent me the URL for this new organization and after looking it over carefully and corresponding with Wilford Bickel, I decided to join. What impressed me was the positive attitude that is presented by CWA. While it may have discontent with the AAW to thank for its origins, that is by no means what CWA is about now. They seem to be supporting good woodturning teaching, good woodturning methods, and are interested in working WITH the AAW, not opposing it. I would like very much to see CWA grow into a sister organization with an emphasis on excellent woodturning and I hope that others will sign up also. The turnings I saw pictured on the CWA website are the sort of things I like to make.
My decision is a positive one and while it may be encouraged by the disgusting publication scene at the AAW, this is by no means a protest action. The arrogant removal of the AAW logo from the American Woodturner because it is phallic offends me, but I plan to stick with the AAW and hope to see it survive in spite of poor management by the current Board of Directors.
Check out the CWA website and consider giving it a try and joining with me. It has real potential and let's hope that it flourishes.
>Thanks for posting the link. The AAW does a great job at promoting woodturning as art, focusing on high-end museum pieces requirig endless hours of off-lathe enhancements. When I look around at club meetings, I don't see many who aspire to scale such artistic heights. Most of us are "conventional" turners who pursue good craftsmanship and delight in creating beautiful, conventional shapes. There is nothing wrong in featuring art pieces that sell for thousands of dollars; it just isn't where most of us are at.
To every action, there is a reaction. I think it was inevitable that such an organization would appear, and I, too, will probably join it and hope that it'll prosper alongside the AAW.
The very best solution would have been for the AAW to operate two organizations, one for conventional turning and one for the Rembrants of the woodworld.
I appreciate the direction and intentions of this group, I may well join, like you, they appear to make what I make.. or at least things that I like to think I can make, LOL...
>It's sad that the CWA organization is so young, yet already they will have to remove one of the images posted in the gallery section of the website for a blatant violation of the stated rules. In the last row if images, (center)- there is a burl form with Macasser ebony lid that has what appears to be a CARVED FOOT! Such behavior should not be tolerated for a group that is just trying to keep woodturning PURE!
>I agree totally with that ,not every one has the ,time ,money ,or skill to do other things than turn a nice piece,without all the ,carving painting etc Ill become a member Im all for natural pieces like ellsworth,etc
"The arrogant removal of the AAW logo from the American Woodturner because it is phallic offends me, but I plan to stick with the AAW and hope to see it survive in spite of poor management by the current Board of Directors."
What????? Did I miss something???? Phallic???? Please someone fill me in.
My apologies for making a comment that was made as an attempt at humor, but evidently offended. Please know I did not mean any disrespect towards any person or groups of turners who choose to focus on a particular set of technical parameters for themselves.
Certainly, no one wants to force anyone else towards or away from any particular technical approach, since each of us has our own internal aesthetic compass and the ample challenges of following it. I realize that within what are considered conventional turning techniques there is a wonderful wealth of design possibilities, and I delight in them. I understand the desire to focus on those possibilities, and the (hopefully) never-ending refinement of form and explorations into the mysteries of these wonderful materials we have the privilege to work with.
My comment was meant to gently point out the contradictions that as humans we are all bound to discover when we attempt to draw any boundaries. I think the piece in the image is quite wonderful, and I applaud the maker following their instincts to turn the form with the tripod base.
There was in no way any inference of �mental rigor mortis�, and my own perspective is that all the work represented on the site was of high quality and thoughtful execution. I have great respect for anyone who chooses to follow their own instincts and preferences in the pursuit of what compels them.
Great turners- such as Bob Stocksdale, Bert Marsh, Mike Mahoney, -and many others, who have gone to great depth within self imposed parameters of form, thereby showing us the value and possibilities of such concentrated focus and often subtle variations available within select variables.
Parallels can be found in almost any other creative pursuit, where one chooses to work within select structure, form, process, scale or any other parameter. The specific joys of a single musician playing a lute are not diminished or made unavailable just because someone else wants to play an electric guitar with electronic effects and amps turned up to 11 (hopefully not in the same room). I can find delight and irritation in both.
My hope is that by sharing our perspectives within the AAW- and such public forums as this- we can perhaps learn from and even appreciate a broad spectrum of possibilities, and still relish the satisfaction of our being engaged in our personal creative pursuits without feeling the need to justify or defend our choices of techniques or materials.
To this end, I have proposed bringing this discussion to a public forum at the upcoming AAW symposium in Albuquerque, in the form of a panel discussion titled �Whose Turn is It Anyway� which is scheduled for Saturday morning- 10:30 till noon in the La Cienega meeting room.
Some of the questions on the table will include:
� Is determining what is and isn�t turning even possible?
� How important are such definitions and do they effect what we make?
� How has the spectrum of woodturning changed since the formation of the AAW in 1986, and what parameters- if any- need to be established for support of the membership?
This session will attempt to explore these questions head-on, and should result in an interesting exchange of insights that will highlight the diversity of motivations, creative perspective, and common ground shared among today�s turners.
Betty Scarpino, the new editor of the AAW journal, has graciously agreed to be on the panel, and we hope to focus on the common ground we share as turners. We invite all perspectives - Come join us for this interesting discussion.
Again, please accept my apologies for offending anyone with my comment.
>Your response seemed more smarmy than did Michael M's. This is a poor way to represent a fledgling organization. After viewing the web site, I wonder how this organization will promote "conventional" woodturning. A gallery only??? No helpful articles or forum for Q & A?
If I were a potential sponsor, I'd now take a "wait and see" position regarding a sponsorship. It looks like some within this new organization still have some chips on their shoulders.
>from me in return. I felt that CWA was being painted with a broad brush that made them look unfairly narrow. In the 24 hours that I have looked at their website and given CWA some thought I have found them to be balanced and not at all like the "turning police" characterization that was implicit.
My position is that there is an interesting group being formed that is focused on good woodturning and we should take a good look at it, and possibly support it. In no way should I be regarded as a spokesman for CWA, my membership application just went out this morning.
>Rumor has it that one person and possibly two were responsible for the removal of the logo from the cover of the journal because "they" felt that it was phallic. If true, that is the product of a very troubled mind. Anyone that can see phallic symbolism in our logo sees it everywhere.
>AAW seems to have lost it's way and that's reflected in the journal, in particular the spring and again in the summer issue. The AAW is supposed to be for ALL woodturners and needs to show that with balance in its journal in each and every issue.
>Had to go an actually look at the AAW logo. Triggered a completley different mammary - er - make that memory and associations. (The String Bikini has been taken too far!)
The problem with inductive logic is that you will always be able to find info to confirm that you're conclusion is right - even when it's not.
>Rats, I don't need politics, opinion or puritism in my hobby, my art, my passion. I know what I like, I know what I appreciate, I know what I aspire to. To which, I will gravitate towards. Otherwise, my feet and my wallet move just fine in other directions.
Goodness, it's just a piece of spinning wood, into which we all stick a sharp steel stick and hang on for dear life for a miracle to emerge.
>At this point I still will. I always find much to interest me.
If in fact one or two very troubled people had enough clout to get the AAW logo removed because they somehow have seen it as a phallic image then in truth the AAW is in trouble.
>Mike, they turned away from thier Mission Statement a long time ago. As far as the logo thing, thats about as rediculous as anything I have ever seen in my life. I guess we better not advertise bowl gouges or round nose scrapers lest they become phallic symbols. Thats an indication of some serious problems within the organization. Anyone notice the quality of the paper in the journal has also gone down hill? It's just not the same quality.
>Look at Bob Rosand's article on parting tools. The very first photograph caption has the ID of the tools reversed. Rather than spending months of time editing and working on the First Segmented Woodturners conference article (as the editor mentions in her letter) perhap a bit of time should have been devoted to looking at photo captions...an obvious error.
One project article but 5 "human interest" (for want of a better term) articles all in one issue. Where's the balance and inclusion?
This is the second issue where the logo is missing from the cover.
Look at the two photos on page 60, almost as good as the "Pre-turned Wood object photo in the last issue. Real inspiration there........
>Where the opinion that the AAW has somehow lost it's way comes from.
Is the beef largely with the contents of the Journal?
After reading the comments here I went back and looked through both of the last two issues. They both appear to have a pretty good balance of content. Granted the spring issue has 10 pages of "feature" relating to collecting and studio turning, but there are as many if not more pages of project and technique - a pie crimper, a stool, and faceplate. The previous issue has even more practical technique and project articles.
Is the idea that "conventional" woodturning should be plane wood and utilitarian?
Most of the "decorative" stuff has been around for centuries. Craftsmen have been painting, carving, splitting, reassembling etc. turnings for a very long time. Ornamental, Architectural, Furniture, Sculptural etc. There is a long history.
If you don't want to carve/paint/burn/texture your turnings then don't. Why do you turn? to relax? then don't challenge yourself. I think a lot of turners enjoy the craft part of making useful items that are also beautiful. This means taking the time to do a good job and working an idea to prefect it.
I don't see the AAW as pushing in any one direction. The organization is driven by it's members, and there are many sub-groups. If you have an interest that's undeserved, then work with others that have the same interest to bring more attention to it.
A good example of this is the ornamental turners.
I'm sincere in wanting to understand this attitude, hopefully I won't regret this post.
To answer just part of what you say (I'm headed out the door). Faceplates......Something like 6 or 8 photos and two pages devoted to what should have been a paragraph or two in a tips section. Who needs multiple photos of faceplates to basically be told not to use drywall screws and to pre-drill.
The stool article was more suited to Wood magazine, it was a mortise and tenon article, not a turning article. In fact turning was only mentioned in a few sentences in three paragraphs deep in the article.
The current issue has one turning project that assumes that you want to disassemble your tape measure and make a wood case for it.
I have an interest in artistic turning as well as functional turning but not only has the journal moved too far toward artistic but much of the content is not (Spring issue in particular) even turning related. How about "Spinning" in the spring issue? What was the purpose of showing us a galvanized bucket containing colored light bulbs (not turned by the way) and the Castrol oil can with spout and bulb? How about the pre-turned wood object.
This issue has one project, one article for beginners on parting tools (too bad editing got the parting tool photo caption wrong) and five devoted to "human interest". Anyone of those 5 would be fine in a single issue....but five in one issue?....Saylan, Gilson, Seitzman, Muskego chapel and dysfuntional.........we don't need five of them in one issue.
I am happy to see a return of the Tips section and liked Alan Lacer's article.