Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

Posts

Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#1

Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I have the Powermatic 3520A. I managed to spill a fair amount of thin CA glue on the lathe bed right next to the head stock. So some of it ran under the headstock, and now the headstock is glued to the lathe bed; it won't budge. I tried acetone, a heat gun, some banging with a rubber dead blow hammer, while heating. Nothing. I'm afraid to try a blow torch because I fear warping the lathe bed. I unscrewed the hold down plate under the headstock, but that didn't help , either. Is CA glue de-bonding stuff any different from acetone? Any thoughts?

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#2

ebd

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

ebd

>Yes the debonding stuff works great. My understanding is that acetone is an accelerant to get CA to set up immediatly.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#3

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

Greg Haugen

>Acetone is a "debonder" for CA. I have acetone and "debonder" from the brand of CA I have. Acetone does the job but the "brand" debonder does seem to do it a little differently-there must be a different additive. For most practical purposes, Acetone is "debonder" but for this case, it sure wouldn't hurt any to try it.

I'd try calling the CA company if you can or a lathe manufacturer's service shop and see if they'd have any recommendations.

Good Luck.

Greg H.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#4

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

Don Orr

>It's my understanding that CA glue has good tensile strength but poor shear strength. Try cooling the headstock/bed (cold=brittle ?) and give it a good sharp rap or 2. Maybe put a piece of softwood next to the headstock and hit that.

Good luck.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#5

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

john lucas

>Either Acetone or debonder will work but it's going to take time because it has to wick in and soften the glue. It will probably take multiple applications. I think (but I'm not sure) that the acetone will wick in better but is evaporates quicker. The debonder takes a very long time to evaporate. consequently I would try both and be patient. One other possibily might be to take a couple of long pipe clamps and apply pressure from the end of the lathe. As someone else mentioned CA doesn't have a lot of shear strength so you might be able to break the bond after some solvent soaking.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#6

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

James Fox

>Use the debonder, then put a scissor-type car jack between head and tail stock (use wood blocks as buffer) and jack them appart.

Just an idea... Let us know how it works out.

James

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#7

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

Don wilcut

>#$%&^%*&!! Is the same as 'Darn it'

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#8

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

robo hippy

>I like the ideas of the clamps applied from the end, or a jack under the headstock spindle. The key would be to use steady but gentle pressure, and flood the area with ascetone or the disolving agent. Lateral pressure may help as well.

robo hippy

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#9

KEEP SHOP WELL VENTILATED AS YOU STRUGGLE!

Adrien

>

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#10

Ric Taylor

Ask Ruth Niles to Help With Her Pipe Wrench

Ric Taylor

>

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#11

What's wrong with a fixed headstock?

david

>Sorry, couldn't help myself. Sort of miss the swiveling headstock of my old Nova 3000, though.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#12

No, CA glue is WEAKER in tensile strength.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Glues are stronger in shear.

I would suggest loosening the head stock and applying a vertical force from underneath to break the bond. Don't know how much you spilled, but the surface area of the joint may not be too large. Also, the area between the headstock and bed rail probably wasn't surgically clean so that will add some weakness to the joint.

Anyway that you could use a bottle jack, and a rod or piece of wood to go from shop floor to the bolt that secures the headstock clamp block or get on the end of the headstock that has the glue and jack that sucker up?

Good luck and let us know how you fared with this.

Ruth Niles and her wrench may be helpful later to provide a knock on the head for doing this in the first place.....:-)

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#13

Re: No, CA glue is WEAKER in tensile strength.

john lucas

>I ageee. Jacking from below would work better than my idea. Since the glue spilled under inboard side try jacking from the outboard side of the underside of the headstock. This should easily apply enough leverage to break the bond. I would leave the locking nut in place. You don't want the headstock to fall off when it breaks free. You might even be able to simply lift on the motor but I wouldn't do this too hard, you don't want to damage the motor mount.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#14

Re: No, CA glue is WEAKER in tensile strength.

Carole Valentine

>Every thing I have read about CA indicates that it's shear strength is low. From a quick look at Wikipedia:

"Cyanoacrylate glue has a low shearing strength, which has also led to its use as a temporary adhesive in cases where the piece can easily be sheared off at a later time."

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#15

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Thanks for the help. I'm trying de-bonder stuff and pipe clamps in the shear mode, which isn't working --yet. It's sitting under pressure as we write. And , indeed, the de-bonder doesn't evaporate quickly, as does acetone. I now see that most are recommending a car jack in the tensile mode. I'll try that next, if I awake in the morning and it's still stuck. One problem is that I have a big deal sand box on the shelf under the lathe so I can't easily get a car jack on the floor.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#16

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

John Jordan

>Put the toolrest base 6-8 inches away, take the tailstock off and use a 2 x 4 levering on the toolrest base. It WILL come up, and easier than jacks.

Give me a lever long enough and a place to stand, and I'll lift the earth. Archimedes?

John

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#17

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

Don Evans

>In addition to the debonder:

Try using a putty knife, semi flexible 2" wide blade. Put edge of it on way so it can slide under edge of head and start tapping smartly with hammer. In other words you are trying to wedge it between the head and the ways.

If you can get it started under, not only will it break up the glue but the shock waves will also help loosen the remaining part.

I think with care, this is less likely to break something else.

Don

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#18

Stand by my statement, Carole *LINK*

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca

>The glue layer, in a vertical or thickness direction is very thin. A few thousands, in some areas, in this case. Remember the lathe bed and headstock mounting surface are not super flat. They're flat but not super flat. Grainy surfaces as well. So it stands to reason, especially in this case, that a CA glue bond it would be weaker in tension. In a shear direction you have to fight the whole "glue area" to break it free. In this case that could be a half inch or more of glue patch depending on how much was spilled, and how rapidly it was able to creep or wick underneath the headstock.

Now if the headstock is able to be pushed up from a corner or opposite end of the glued surface then you can create a peel situation, and then it may take even less force to break the joint.

We (IBM) used CA glue (Black Max), applied in a microscopic drop via syringe, to bond the small read write heads to their metal suspensions on hard drives. These heads sometimes wring themselves onto the super smooth surface of the disk during temp and humidity changes within a harddrive. When the disk starts to spin the dab of glue would hold so well that the metal suspensions would get bent all to heck before a head would let go from the suspension or disk for that matter.

Sometime Wikipedia info is not correct. Or it could be that the data was stated as "Tensile Shear Strength". The test was done in shear

Here are some links to look at.

Even "our" Russ Fairfield has stated that CA glue joints are weak in tension

http://209.85.173.132/search?q=cache:GoLMu7GxWJUJ:www.bemrc.org/bemrc-build-class/ca-glue-article.pdf+shear+strength+of+CA+glue&cd=10&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-a

http://www.woodcentral.com/russ/russ6.shtml


http://www.roymech.co.uk/Useful_Tables/Adhesives/Adhesives.html

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#19

Yeah, that will work, and.....

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca

>As I was looking up stuff to reply to Carole, it became apparent that possibly whacking the loose (locking handle set to loose for sliding) headstock from below using a brass or aluminum drift (aw heck who has one of these just use a chunk of steel and a hammer) may free the headstock. CA glues don't like impact forces in tension.

Still, though, I hope you don't live near Ruth Niles......

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#20

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

Juergen

>Acetone is not an accelerator! I only buy medium CA and thin it as needed. It is essentially a solvent for CA. If you thin it too much it will slow the curing time. I never thin the medium more than 50/50.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#21

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>You now have a fixed head lathe... just hope it's in the right location. I would try debonder and try to get a putty knife under some part of the head or a piece of wood on the head then hit it with the biggest hammer available.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#22

You guys should leave Ruth alone.

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Though if I had this problem and she was anywhere close, I'd just have her come over and jerk the thing loose! 8^]

Gary

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#23

Re: No, CA glue is WEAKER in tensile strength.

Don Orr

>Thanks Eddie, Always happy to be educated.

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#24

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!! *LINK*

nailer

>I use CA glues at work all the time. I build ultrasonic transducers.

We use Loctite 768 X-NMS solvent for clean up.

Link to the data sheet.

It is available at electronics houses and industrial suppliers.

It's not cheap but it does dissolve CA.

---Nailer--


http://tds.loctite.com/tds5/docs/768-EN.PDF

Re: Now I've gone and done it-- #$%&^%*&!!

#25

Mike Stafford

I know better...

Mike Stafford

>I learned a long time ago not to mess with a woman with a pipe wrench in her hands...

I have the scars to prove it....