Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Posts

what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#1

what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

john lucas

>I'm thinking about putting together an short article for American Woodturning on advice for a beginner on buying a bowl gouge. I know what I would say but my point of view is obviously slanted by what I turn and how I teach. I though I would go to the experts and ask what would you tell a beginner and why.

My choice is a good quality HSS 1/2" gouge with a good handle. I don't think U or V is a problem for the new person because you tend to learn to use whichever one and get used to it and then that's your favorite. I personally prefer the V gouge but there really isn't much difference until you get picky. I like the Thompson V gouge the best so far. I don't have a problem recommending the PM or cryogenic tools except price can be a problem and for that reason I usually suggest a HSS tool since they are also learning to sharpen.

What do you all think?

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#2

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Greg Haugen

>Hhhmmm....I'd say a 1/2" also. I thought about the 3/8" but I think having the extra heft would be good for a new person. Often times also when I'm working with a new person and they have a bowl gouge it's an Ellsworth. I think a new person shopping for a gouge can be overwhelming,"standard grind, swept grind, steels, sizes-"Oh wait-Ellsworth-I've heard of him-I'll get that one." Which is fine, it's a nice gouge. I would make one note about the "english" sizing of Bowl gouges. If someone looks through a Packard catalog and then Doug's site a 1/2" bowl gouge will mean different things. It's a confusing concept for a new person, a 1/2" spindle gouge is 1/2" and a 1/2" bowl gouge is 5/8"-what? I also agree the V vs. U would be a mute point for a beginner. I believe most gouges are "v" technically, Hamlet, Henry taylor, etc. I'd say M2 being the minimum for quality of steel. Yes carbon steel tools work but HSS is alot "friendlier" for a new person learning to sharpen. Past M2 I think it would come down to "budget". As far as handles, a good quality gouge will have a "usable" handle if it comes handled. It's the "sub-par" gouges that I don't think have adequate handles. Personal preference may or may not change that. Turning a handle, I think, is a strongly recommended project for a new person. I know that can become an article on it's own or possibly reference a previous written article by the same publication. Also handles such as the Hosaluk (sp), Bosch, etc. are available.

One of the main issues I see with a new person buying a gouge is the dang grinds they put on them from the factory-mainly the English factories. I'm sure they're many that don't know better and try to use it. But again, grinds can be another article on it's own. So from the stand point of a new person, buying a gouge from someone like Doug would be a good thing, a much better steel for about the same price as a handled english gouge, there's a "workable" grind already on it, and they could either make a handle and make it "their own" (customized) or buy a handle.

Just my two cents.

Greg H.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Keith Tompkins

>Hi John, I would suggest an ordinary handled bowl gouge....a Packard (my choice) M2 1/2" with a standard grind would be an ideal choice. It's an easy grind for a beginner to sharpen, even without a jig, and the learning curve is easier that a swept back design. They can always upgrade to a more sophisticated tool later, but this would be an affordable, yet high quality tool.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#4

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Don at Central Illinois

>When I first started the teacher had me start out with a 1/2" bowl gouge from Packard. He had it in a very similar Ellsworth grind. I think if he had used a different grind I wouldn't have known the difference. HSS a must, grind is optional as there are so many and the difference, sometimes, is so small as to not make a difference to a novice. I think any bowl gouge from Woodcraft, Packard, etc. and especially Doug would be fine. Just my .02 worth, you may have change coming.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#5

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Gary Ljostad

>Hi John. The first project that my students make is a handle for there very own 1/2" bowl gouge. I supply the unhandled gouge. It's an easy introductory project, and they can't wait till the next class to try it out.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#6

1/2"--My 'go to' gouge...

david

>

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#7

Steven Antonucci

Any gouge. They all cut.

steve antonucci

>Too many beginners ask that question. It's the wrong question. All tools will cut. Some are better than others, and price isn't always the best determination of quality.

I think the important thing that you want to cover is a more generic understanding of what a good gouge might look like. Talk about shape and thickness. Talk about removing the heel and grinding the wings back. Discuss the pros and cons of shapes.

Who puts their logo on the gouge is largely irrelevant.

2 cents

Steven

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#8

Thanks greg-forgot about the grinds.

john lucas

>

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#9

Brian McKearney

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Brian McKearney

>Hmmm... Interesting replies so far. I have three 3/8" bowl gouges (2 Sorby and 1 Oneway) and a Crown Pro PM 5/8" bowl gouge. Of them all, I like the Sorbys best and in particular I like my Sorby with a fingernail grind best. The Oneway steel is great, but there's something that's just a little different about the shape that doesn't feel as comfortable to me. I started with a Sorby, so maybe that's why I like it best.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#10

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Peter Hyde

>John I recently bought a Benjamins Best 5/8" bowl gouge. It has a V shape flute and is HSS and has a good handle. The factory grind is not good but we are talking beginners who will need to learn the grinding techniques. For $25 it can't be beat. As for the quality of the steel it keeps an edge about the same length of time as a Henry Taylor long and strong M3. I now own a few Benjamin tools and so far they are as good as anyone else's. I haven't tried Doug's......yet

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#11

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

BobM

>I think I would go with a 1/2" Thompson V bowl gouge. I started off with Sorby gouges and like them but the Thompson gouges are sooooo much better. That way they could also learn to make a handle that suited them and they would have a project to take home right away.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#12

3/8" HSS is my 1st choice........

Jake Niedling

>I use 3/8" for everything from bowls to christmas ornaments. I think a standard wood handle is fine for starters. I have Sorby, Hamlet, Pinacle(cheapest) and they all work fine, if properly sharpened. I like the fingernail grind best.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#13

Sizing

Ralph

>The last couple of years there has been a move to advertise "size" by shaft diameter, not flute.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#14

Well, it depends...

Steven Kubien

>Hey John,

If I am roughing out a blank which was not bandsawed round (usually the case with me), I prefer a 1/2" or 5/8" gouge to knock off the corners and get the outside shape I want. Strange thing lately but I have had the easiest time using my 3/8" U-shaped Thompson for the interiors. I only just started playing with this gouge and I really like it. I say it is strange because it has the exact same grind as my 1/2" Thompson U-shape but this the 3/8" seems to cut way smoother and faster.

I doubt this helps you much. Sorry.

Steve Kubien

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#15

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Texian

>John,

Have both U and V, and would recommend the U with (what I call) straight conical grind for beginners. Conical grind because a jig is not required, and U because the transition from cutting with the nose to cutting with the flute is more gradual, and thus more easily controlled and more easily learned. Granted that an Ellsworth or other "swept back" grind is more versatile, but perhaps not best for the beginner.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#16

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Galen Vetterick

>FYI

New to turning and could have used your comments several months ago.

Bought a Sorby 3/8 bowl gouge as suggested from a local turner. He helped me put a fingernail grind on it and save the 10 bucks difference than getting the same with that factory grind. Learned more on sharpening and like how it cuts. Failed to ask or find out more about gouges and tried to buy a heavier 1/2" bowl gouge and ordered a Benjamin's Best. I now own two the same size as one is sized on flut (Sorby) and other (Best)on shaft! This is why I could have used more suggestions and cautions! Now just trying same "size" gouge but different grinds. Already like the Sorby handle more as a little heavier and the fingernail grind. Will ready postings here more often for help! Thanks.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#17

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

robo hippy

>I agree with the buy the steel (Thompsons if they can afford it) and have them make their own handle.

robo hippy

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#18

Interesting thoughts-keep them coming

john lucas

>

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#19

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

Dick Anderson

>John:

Advice for a beginner. Is your article assuming that the beginners have had some woodturning exposure and experience, or, is it for those fist-timers with no knowledge of woodturning tools. It would be nice if a beginner could buy only one tool and go into woodturning. Unfortunately that is not the case and often cost (money) becomes an issue. Other cutting tools are necessary and your article could 'touch' on that. Also, as others have mentioned, the type of grind is an issue and in that regard there is the freehand (Batty and others) or jig methods. Jigs cost money, but have their own advantages; and sharpening requires a grinder of which there are many types.

Much of the information on type of steel, "U" vs "V", fingernail grind or other, type of handle, tool maker, etc., while useful information, is info more for the experienced woodturner than the raw beginner.

Maybe you could consider a series of articles starting with basic turning tools, then gouges (spindle roughing, spindle turning and bowl), then sharpening methods and tools (grinders and jigs), etc.

Your idea of an article for beginners on bowl gouges is good. However, maybe you will be opening the door to a whole host of more questions from beginners.

Just my two cents worth.

Dick

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#20

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

john lucas

>Dick That is the idea. I'm going to propose a series of very short articles designed to answer the very new turners questions. What is a spindle gouge, which parting tool do I need, which bowl gouge do I buy, etc. Any ideas will be appreciated. There seems to be a need for this but since most turners who are AAW members are beyond this I want to keep it short and sweet. Not exactly like and Ask Dale Nish (because he's a major leaguer and I'm in the minors) but along that line.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#21

Re: Correction

Dick Anderson

>John:

You are not a minor league player. You are truely major league in your knowledge, experience, caliber of turnings and help you have given to others on this site.

Dick

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#22

Re: John's a sandbagger on the .....

Jamie Donaldson

>...golf course also! We played a bit before AAW Symposium trip and he's a pretty good golfer, considering how much he practices. Fun time John! (;-D)

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#23

Re: John's a sandbagger on the .....

john lucas

>I was waiting till you placed a bet to really show off. :)

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#24

Re: Correction

john lucas

>Thanks Dick I know I've been turning and working in wood for quite a while but when you hang around people like Dale Nish, John Jordan, Russ,Wally and a few others you very quickly find out how much you still have to learn. Which is good because if I knew it all I just quit. Too much fun learning new things.

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

#25

Re: what bowl gouge should a beginner buy

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>The first bowl gouge I bought was a fingernail grind 1/2" Sorby (before I know the English style of measuring gouges). Then I bought a 3/8" Sorby. Both have been ground to lengthen the side grinds and I like them a lot. I think I use the 3/8" a bit more th an the 1/2" at this time. I also just bought a Thompson 3/8" V gouge and put a Michaelson grind on it and am really enjoying it.

From my experience and observations of the many new turners that I have seen over the past few years, I would suggest a new turner purchase either a English 1/2" or American 3/8" bowl gouge. My main reason for making this recommendation is that new turners tend to turn relatively small and the 3/8" gouge is more than enough gouge to turn a small bowl.

keithz