>The "retireder" I get, the more time I have to think of things I just have to have!
Do you use larger roughing gouges...larger than the 3/4" that is in typical sets? I have a number of larger blocks to work on. Maybe I'm just too impatient, but it seems like a larger roughing gouge would save me time and effort. Am I wrong?
I have found several brands of roughing gouges in the 1 1/4" - 2" range, with prices all over the place. If you use them, what do you consider the best "bang for the buck?" If I purchase one, I want to buy the right thing the first time, but knowing I am not a pro who will use it repeatedly every day.
>I like to use my 1 1/2" rather than my 3/4". I typically use it to knock off corners and rough out large (3.5" square and 2.5" square) spindle blanks. I rough the blanks to shape and then "touch" them up with the 3/4".
I tend to use a large skew (P&N 1-1/4") for most of my spindle work, including roughing. If it is a large block for an end-grain vase or something similar, I knock the corners off by tilting my bandsaw table because using any turning tool on an 6" or 8" square piece 12" long or so is just no fun.
If you are serious about getting a larger roughing gouge, look at the P&N. The tang on this tool is massive and strong with little likelihood or bending or snapping.
>I bought one of the 1 3/4" rough out gouges and don't use it much. It doesn't seem to be any faster than my 3/4. If I did a lot of 4 to 6" spindles I might use it more. It goes under the gotta have it but now that I do why did I buy it category.
>Excellent advice on the P&N roughing gouge. They all should be made like that. The weak link in roughing gouges is the stupid little rat-tail tine most of them have for the handle. They bend or break there, and that is very dangerous. In the old days when they were hand-forged, the blacksmith made the tine quite thick and sturdy and this was not a problem. Then we progressed, and started stamping the tools out of flat chunks of steel, which meant there was no way of adding strength to the tine.
For the best of the best of roughing tools, look at the one Doug Thompson is selling (www.thompsonlathetools.com) It is 1 1/4 inches of solid V10 steel (the stuff Gerry Glaser used to use). Doug also cryo treats them, so I find them indestructible. They have a 3/4 inch tine. I would happily pay twice what he is charging for these. You will never wear thiese out (or break them!).
>I still have a 1-1/2" roughing gouge, which I forget who made, and it started to bend over where the tang meets the handle. Got the largest one that P & N makes--25 mm, I think, which I believe is just over an inch. Coupled with a long Oneway handle, it really works well roughing larger stuff. I have a Vicmarc VL300 with a 3-hp motor.
>I rough bowl with a pull cut on a swept wing bowl gouge.
I round end-grain vessels from squares with the same bowl gouge.
A spindle is just a long end grain vessel that you don't hollow. If I get bored, I use that bowl gouge here. I could also use a skew if I want to practice.
My roughing gouge is probably my least used tool. When I do use it, it's only to remind me how much I don't need it. It came in a set with 10 Sorby tools I bought on Ebay for $70 about 8 years ago. I wouldn't own one otherwise...
>For spindles my roughing gouge is my most used tool. I turn almost my entire mirror handles with the roughing gouge. I first round it over which is abvious. Then I use the upper wings as little skews to refine the shape. I call them my left and right hand skews depending on which part of the U I use. The I can use it sort of like a large parting tool to rough shape tenons or rough out near beads and such. This is done by laying the U on it's side. I keep the top corner reasonably square so the corner can cut down the side of the bead. I can do this very quickly. Then there is very little work to do with the skew to finish the handles. The rough out gouge is much faster to sharpen than the skew which is why I worked out this method.
I'll be glad to do some photos this weekend if anyone is interested in how I use the different cutting surfaces.
>Doug has been working on a rough out gouge that has a thick tang like the P@N. He had one at the TAW symposium. It's a beautiful tool and I'll be it will hold an edge much longer than any of the rough out gouges on the market.
>When I make wands, which are your mirror handles minus the mirror, I use a skew to round. I turn beads and/or detail with it. Ever since seeing Lacer's grind, I have been using it too.
I know the cuts you use. I've used them too, but now make those cuts with a skew. Ever see the "bowl races" at a turning event? We could "drag" - your blown roughing gouge against my supercharged skew!
You'd probably win... I don't do that much spindle work...:-)
>Drag race, cool. I could turn the whole handle with the skew but like I said I can sharpen the spindle gouge in less than 30 seconds and that includes walking to the grinder. The skew takes me more like 1 1/2 minutes or more depending on how dull I let it get. I can hone it frequently with the ultra fine hone but the more I do that that the longer it takes to really refine the edge.
>3/4" Thompson bowl gouge (U-shaped). Slowly, as I sharpen it the profile will be like a traditional SRG, but there's no hurry to get there. This gets sharper and stays sharp longer than any SRG I have used, including Hamlet. This Thompson gouge is a great SRG.
>You said "I have a number of larger blocks to work on."
Are these blocks bowl blanks or large spindles?
Most people will tell you not to use a roughing gouge on a bowl. If you do, treat it with extra care.
Not sure if this applies only to the ones that have that flimsy little tang or to all of them. It may be the grind, those wings may get in the way on a bowl, especially on the inside.
I have one of those with the small tang. If I were buying again, I would go with a heavier duty one.
OTOH, I do most of my bowl roughing with a bowl gouge with an Ellsworth grind. Pretty happy with that.
>One potential problem with a very large roughing gouge is with the larger radius you are presenting a longer portion of the edge to the wood at one time. All else equal, this can requires more force than a narrow edge which can be significant when working on a rough chunk or rounding a square. To think of this, imagine how much cutting edge will intercept a spindle using a monster 8" wide half circle sharpened edge compared to a 1/2" wide half circle edge.
In fact, for very rough chunks of wood where splintering is not a problem, I sometimes knock the excess off with a spear point scraper rather than a gouge. The narrow point removes a lot of wood quickly with very little force involved.
>That was the same question that I had, are you roughing out bowls or spindles? The roughing gouge is for spindles. It can work on bowls, but for me a scraper works much better. I used to rough with my gouge, but tried the scraper and it works better for me. After all, the roughing cuts are scraping cuts. For spindles, I use a spindle gouge, and have used a skew. I never thought of a skew as a roughing tool until I watched Richard Raffins video and saw him use it. Wow!
>... they should be correctly labeled as a "spindle roughing gouge" and that reason is safety. I don't condone anyone going near a rough bowl blank with a SPG.
>Jamie, if you mean flawed design is a safety issue, I agree with you. The rat tail tines should be banned from the market. P&N prove it is possible to make a roughing gouge that is safe and economical. Manufacturers continue to make the rat tail variety because it is easy and fast -- but is that the standard we want for our tools?
Roughing gouges can be used safely on bowls with two cautions -- far less than that needed for skews, which have a huge learning curve and can be very dangerous.
First, never use a spindle roughing gouge on a bowl (or for spindle work) if it has a rat tail tine. Cut it off and weld in a 5/8 inch piece of drill rod with a MIG arc welder and mild steel wire -- or buy a P&N gouge or a Thompson.
Second, turn the outside of the bowl with the grain facing the tool in the same way it does when you are spindle turning. When spindle turning the grain runs from the head stock to the tailstock and your tool rest is parallel to the bed. When you rough the outside of a bowl, you change the grain direction of the wood 90 degrees. When you screw the wood on a faceplate, the grain is now running across the bed . Set your tool rest at 90 degrees to the bed and you will see you are cutting the wood grain in the same direction you are when you are in spindle turning mode. (cross grain -- not end grain) Now start turning from the center of the piece of wood -- where your spigot is going to be -- and work out to the outer edge. You sneak up on those sharp corners at the edge and they disappear without complaint. As the bowl takes shape, you start getting into end grain -- but it is like turning an ogee on a spindle. It is possible -- and safe.
Never, never, try to shape a bowl by truing up all the corners first, with your tool rest running parallel to the lathe bed. That is called sticking steel rods into windmills. Not a hobby I recommend.
I have never had a problem working the way I am suggesting. I have roughed many thousands of bowls over the last ten years. But I have seen lots of problems with skews -- especially trying to turn too large a piece of wood with too small a skew. One of those skew corners will catch for sure and rip the wood right off the lathe. I am not against skews. They are wonderful tools. But, even more than the spindle roughing gouge, they require some understanding of the laws of physics that are at work when turning.
p.s. There are some very good professionals using this technique. Johannes Michaelson uses a shallow spindle roughing gouge manufactured by Doug Thompson to rough out all his hats.
>I have both a 1-1/2" and a 2" (outer dimension) roughing gouge. I never use them.
I use my standard 1" roughing gouge all the time for spindle work. Most of my spindle blanks are 3" or 3-1/2" square and the standard roughing gouge will round them plenty fast. Like John, I found early on that a roughing gouge could be used for shaping as well as roughing. But then I'm not real good friends with my skews.
For bowls, I now use my 3/4" (7/8" rod diameter) bowl gouge. But it takes a fair amount of horsepower to keep the lathe from bogging down. My Conover didn't have enough power (1-1/2 hp DC motor) but my Robust (3 hp AC motor) does.
>I have a 3/4" roughing gouge but very seldom use it. When I do it is usely for finials, just to make the square wood round. I use my bowl gouges for 80% of my turning. I can knock the corners off a square piece if wood quicker with the bowl gouge as quick as a roughing gouge.