Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Lathe Choice - Continued

Posts

Lathe Choice - Continued

#1

Lathe Choice - Continued

David

>I would like to thank everyone for taking the time to respond to my previous post (February 2, 2008). The information you provided was invaluable. So I have narrowed down the list a bit and I thought I would post again, discuss my reasoning and see if there is anything I am missing, and perhaps seek some feedback. For those of you that missed my previous post, I was looking for feedback on lathes in the $1500 - $2500 range.

To those that suggested that I get the best available, I understand your reasoning, and typically that is my approach. However, I must also be realistic. I have college to fund, and, accessorizing a lathe nicely is an expensive proposition. I took this into account when setting my price range. The Oneway 2000 series, Vicmarc, Robust, etc., are beautiful lathes, But I am not prepared to spend that kind of money.

I also considered the Oneway 1640, street price around $3500 delivered. Weighs in at 600 lbs or so. A nice lathe, but for bowls it is likely that I will be turning on the outboard side (leaning over the ways for long periods of time will likely cause some old back problems to show themsevles) and this required the 24" extension (another $400) and dedicated left handed chucks. Again, more than I want to spend.

So I have narrowed my list down to the Jet 1642 EVS (lots of praise), the Powermatic 3520b (lots of praise) and the Laguna 1847 (relatively unknown).

The Laguna is the cheapest at around $1900 with shipping, the powermatic the most expensive at around $2550 delivered and the jet in the middle at $2300 or so delivered.

The Laguna has 47" between centers, the jet 42", the powermatic claims 34 1/2 but others here have said it is closer to 30".

The powermatic 20" of swing over the bed, laguna 18", the jet 16".

Motors are all 2HP, speed ranges comparable, and in the weight category, the powermatic is the heaviest at around 630lbs vs the laguna at 500 lbs and the jet at 450lbs.

All have #2 morse tapers, and the spindle threads are 1 1/4 x 8 tpi.

Realistically, I think it really should be between two machines, the laguna or the powermatic.

Any comments?

Thanks,

David

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#2

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

Allen Neighbors

>My choice, having done quite a bit of research before I bought, would be the Powermatic... it was my choice, before.

Having said that, I did opt for the Oneway 1640. And turning outboard I use the same chucks that I use inboard. The threads are the same, right hand threads, on both ends of the spindle.

Back to your choices, I don't think you can go wrong choosing the Mustard Monster. Good hunting...!!

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#3

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

Gordon Seto

>You may want to do some searching on more realistic street price.

The Jet 1642 (2 HP) was on sale last month at around $1400~$1500 delivered.

Gordon

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#4

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

Mac

>I have had a few lathes on my way to my last one...a O.W....in my opinion,the next best thing to the O.W. is the Powermatic,it's a fine piece of machinery and every one I know who has one is very satisfied with their choice....so I guess you know where my vote goes,enjoy whatever get...and remember to: take the time to enjoy what you are doing....................

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#5

1642EVS vs 1642EVS-2

David

>Gordon is correct, the 1642 EVS is around $1500. However,

the 1642EVS-2 (the one I was referring to) is around $2200.

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#6

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

John Kyler

>My vote is for the Powermatic.

I have it's bigger brother and would put it up against any lathe today.

Also note I think you will find the Oneway has a M33 spindle.

The tail stock is a #3 MT.

Just two things to note.

John

PM 4224

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#7

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

john lucas

>David The Jet 1642 is a great lathe. I have the Powermatic and it is also a great lathe although it is noticeably heavier and more solidly built than the Jet.

I know an awful lot of people who own the Jet or the powermatic and a whole lot of other lathes. I don't know one single person who owns the Laguna. there must be a reason.

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#8

You are choosing between two companies *LINK*

Jerry Hall

>I have a Laguna band saw and a Powermatic 3520a. You are not just selecting a lathe, but a company and an "installed base." Laguna and WMH (parent company of Powermatic and Jet) have both provided me fine after sales service over the years. Laguna is new with the consumer lathe business and is a relatively small company. They are best known for their combination machines, and band saws. New lines come an go with Laguna. I am pretty sure they mostly sell re-labled equipment made and designed by others, with some spec adjustment on their part. It is a guess what their staying power will be in the tough lathe business. They don't work thru a dealer network, it is all direct sales with some pressure cooker sales persons who in general will know nothing about lathes. I believe they are trying to expand their business into the consumer turning phenomenon. Jet and Powermatic lathes are long proven designs with a huge installed base that have only gotten better over time, and WMH continues to invest in their improvement. Look at the nice upgrade to the 3520b which reflects on the input from respected tuner Nick Cook.

With the Jet or Powermatic you will have a huge number of turners as a resource. You will find lots of turners locally with the same lathe. The internet has enormous amounts of hints and tips for either machine. See link as an example. You will also have an improved assurance that over the years to come you will have parts and service, which is not to say Laguna won't do their best, but they have yet to prove this product as a part of their sales plan and tech support skill set. I applaud Laguna for adding to our choices, but buying a lathe should be a conservative decision, with as few unknowns as possible. There is plenty to learn in turning without being one of the lonely few who own the lathe. From what you say it doesn't sound as though you are in a position to be taking a chance with a new product from a small company just getting started in the lathe business.

This is my 99 cents which is 97 cents more than I have given this forum before. Good luck.

Jerry


http://mustardmonster.googlepages.com/

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#9

Re: 1642EVS vs 1642EVS-2

Gordon Seto

>The 1.50 HP Jet 1642 was around $1300 around new year time.

http://www.osolnikmachinery.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=215

2HP is $1900 here.

For $250 difference, a PM is much better buy.

Gordon

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#10

Jerry, you have ...

Ed Moore

>provided valuable and wise counsel. Not only have you pinpointed the exact issue here, you have supported your conclusion with logic and have not denigrated anyone.

NO ONE complains about their Powermatic lathe. I don't have one, but lots of excellent turners use one daily and enjoy their PM. I think that in the requested price range the PM3520B provides the most bang for the buck.

Ed

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#11

1642EVS $1160 after $100 rebate *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>The 1.5 HP $1160 after $100 rebate.

Woodcraft may come up with similar deal in response.

Gordon


Jet 1642 Sale at Rockler

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#12

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

robo hippy

>If it is a money consideration, then go for the Laguna. Their bigger lathe is well known, but is mostly for production duplicator work. It has a good reputation. Their other tools are also very good. I also have a PM 3520A and a Laguna 16HD bandsaw. The 2 best Christmas presents I ever bought myself. The PM does have 34 inches between centers if you don't have a revolving center in the tailstock, and/or one in the headstock. I can take a 30 inch table leg and turn it between centers. This is the one advantage of the Laguna, the longer bed. Do remember that if you spend $2,500 on the lathe, you will probably spend that much and up to 3 times that much on 'accessories'. Of course you don't have to spend it all at once.

No, I don't have a tool buying problem. Well, not really.

robo hippy

soon to be Robust Hippy

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#13

A Sam Kinison moment

Jay in Tx

>May he rest in piece... Now about that 'tool buying problem'. Sam was very wise in this respect. I'll substitute 'tools' for the other 'stuff' refered to in his skit.

Paraphrasing... $35,000 for 'tool buying' rehab... Let me tell ya, if you still got $35,000, then you don't have a problem!

Jay in Tx, unable to take advantage of the teknatool blow-out at my favorite Canadian toy store,

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#14

Bill Blasic

Re: A Sam Kinison moment

Bill Blasic

>If you go with the 16" or 18" I believe that you will look to upgrade in the future. Go with the extra 2" with the Powermatic and it will drastically diminish the urge to upgrade. Absolutely the best bang for the buck in your price range.

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#15

Steven Antonucci

Overbuying a lathe

steve antonucci

>I used to be one of those people that lusted after larger lathes. None of the lathes you mention are that far out there in the lathe world, but I think you need to plan your purchase around "most likely events".

If you make furniture, the longest spindle makes the most practical lathe.

If you make bowls, the heaviest and sturdiest headstock makes sense.

If you live in the desert southwest where wood is hard to come by, a large swing doesn't make any sense unless you plan to bring back wood by the truckload.

The three lathes you mention are all very good lathes, but each has its strengths and weaknesses. Evaluate them against what you see yourself doing at the lathe "most of the time", and buy with the knowledge that even the most expensive "best lathe" in the world will have its shortcomings in certain situations.

Steven

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#16

Re: A Sam Kinison moment

John K Jordan

>>...If you go with the 16" or 18" I believe that

>you will look to upgrade in the future.

I think that depends on the kind of turning you do or plan. If I turned many very large bowls, I would get the bigger lathe or even better, a massive lathe made specifically for large, heavy bowls.

The 1642 (yes, I use one) will allow long spindles. It will also handle bowls larger than 16" since you can slide the headstock down to the end and turn "outboard".

If you turn occasional long spindles and occasional large bowls, this lathe will work great. For a shorter lathe with larger diameter capacity, if you want to turn occasional long spindles you can't. (easily)

JKJ

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#17

Re: Jerry, you have ...

Barry Irby

>I know several People that have Mustard Monsters and really like them.

OTOH, our local club bought one. A 3520A I believe. There is a problem with it. Something about the shaft. Almost everyone who demos at the club struggles to get things to seat and run true. I believe the story is that some demonstrator (I was Not there) let something get away form him and Didi something to the shaft. Since the lathe gets used once a month and there is no one assigned to tend to it, nothing ever gets done about fixing it. Maybe Dick Hines or some other local club member will jump in and clear this up.

If the shaft of the lathe (any lathe) was damaged by misuse, then there is nothing to degenerate Powermatic about. The reason I mention it is that there is some discussion that the shaft was somewhat longer than that on many lathes and that he problem is that it will not allow many chucks and faceplates to seat properly as they would on a slightly shorter shaft. So, I don't actually know whether the shaft was damaged, miss-manufactured, or just made slightly differently than others. But it is something to check.

You want whatever lathe you buy to be as "standard" as possible. So that any faceplate or chuck will work. It could be a PITA if you have to buy certain adapters and faceplates suited for your lathe. (Your friend wants to turn on your lathe, but his chuck wont work, or the club wants to meet at your house, but there stuff wont fit.)

OTOH, if the shaft "Problem" ever existed on the 3520, they may have corrected it on the B model.

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#18

Re: Overbuying a lathe

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Hey Steve

We may live at the end of the Earth as to available wood like you, but we do have some large wood. I, on a regular basis, turn 18" to 20" platters and bowls from desert Mesquite and some other types of landscape grown trees.

I currently have a 20+" piece of Oak burl in a Las Vegas gallery that came from Show Low where we have a second home. It is within 200 miles of here.

I am not being critical of your statement I am only showing that large wood is available almost anywhere if you look for it.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#19

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Hi David,

I didn't go back to your previous posting to see if this was already mentioned but, if you are patient, I bet you could get a really good used lathe, with all the accessories, at a pretty good price.

It took me two years of occasional looking (ie. checking out the bulletin board at the lumber store every once in a while) but I ended up getting the lathe I wanted in almost mint condition with about $1000 of tools and accesories thrown in, for about $1000 less than just a new lathe would have cost. (ie. I paid about about $3000 for a $4000 lathe and had ~$1000 of accessories and blanks thrown in gratis).

If you budget is tight don't underestimate the cost of accessories, chucks, tools, finishing supplies, etc.

There seems to be quite an active market in used lathes. However the really good lathes (eg. Oneway, Nova, etc) don't come on the market very often.


img

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#20

Steven Antonucci

Understand- it was a two part statement...

steve antonucci

>First part was the availability of wood of that size. I've been in parts of Utah where I was taller and wider than the biggest tree. Sometimes, big isn't an option.

Part two was around the logistics of big. Once you cut and process a 3' diameter log into a blank, smaller seems like a much better idea. I've lifted a 110# oak blank (weighed it to have bragging rights) onto my Nova lathe and turned a 23" bowl- one time! Big wood is heavy makes a lot of shavings, beats you to a pulp getting it round, and takes a lot more care and feeding to get it to a finished product without cracking.

I want a better lathe with more capacity, but not to turn bigger wood-only handle the wood I have today better.

Steve

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#21

Re: Dang Steve- looks like the whole....

Jamie Donaldson

>...shop has never been used!!! (;-)))

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#22

NOT TRUE!!!

Jay in TX

>Jamie,

There's dust in the collector bag (but I bet it was planted there!) At least it looks like a shop and not the urban storage facility that continually encroaches on my 'shop space'.

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#23

Is this better? 

GolfSteve in Calgary

>


img

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#24

Re: Much better Steve! Now it's alive!!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

#25

Re: Lathe Choice - Continued

C.

>Just a note on the two choices PM 3520 has a 4 1/2" ram travel, Laguna 1847 has 2" you may wish to think about that issue! Another thing I've found seem theirs is a dealer in Canada that sells the Laguna buy another name for about 1300.00.

www.busybeetools.ca/cgi-bin/homepage?&NTDESC=homepage2.htm

With all that I would still, if I had the money, buy the PM for weight and 20" over bed + a lot of other reasons! I like turning bowls!

Check with www.toolnut.com on best pricing

Good luck

C