Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Downed trees

Posts

Re: Downed trees

#26

Re: Downed trees

john lucas

>Gary I agree about the rootball. They scare me to death so I stay back from them. The can easily weigh up to a ton and have a huge amount of potential energy trapped in there.

Re: Downed trees

#27

Re: Downed trees

john lucas

>Darn Clay I thought we always went by the statement, hey bubba watch this, and then hoped the redneck gods were on your side that day.

Re: Downed trees

#28

Re: Downed trees

john lucas

>The go slow and watch the tree move is my usual approach but everynow and then it just decides to move before you can get the saw out.

Re: Downed trees

#29

Re: Downed trees

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>Yea John, I think "Hey Buba watch this here" are the 5 most common last words a redneck ever say.

There are a number of different forces acting on up-rooted trees especially the BIG ones that I am usually after. First, the root-ball will want to flip back into the hole when cut from the trunk.

Second, the trunk will usually want to settle down, just opposite the way the root-ball is trying to go.

Third, If there are a lot of strong branches like from a spreading tree. When the tree lays down on the ones on the bottom, the ends hit the ground long before the rest of the tree stops moving down, so there will be a lot of thrust toward the stump due to their thrusting action.

You can get into a lot of trouble trying to cut these sprung limbs first, and I can tell you sometimes two saws just may not be enough when you go after them first. Don't ask how I know this.

You and I already know that cutting either way, up or down even with wedges can still be unpredictable. Here is what I think the first cut should be.

I think the cut should be an angle away from plumb, if the tree is laying on its side. It should be closer to the roots on the bottom, and angle away from the roots as you come up. This is to give the root-ball clearance to flip when it is free to go. It should also give the trunk clearance to drop.

But because of the thrust from those sprung branches, this cut can't be just that simple. The thrust will still try to pinch the blade regardless of whether the trunk goes up or down. So whether you have cut up from the bottom, or plunged through somewhere above the middle, and cut down. There should be a a perpendicular, or plumb cut down from the top, which the angled cut will intersect a few inches before that angled cut exits the top. The reason for this cut is to stop the thrust of those branches from sliding more than the width of the kerf when the final fibers are severed.

Of course wedges should be used with this, because sometimes the trunk may want to rise up also. But this should give a chance to get the bar out as the root-ball flips. If you don't use the stop cut, I have had the final bit of sapwood buckle under the thrust, and still get the saw hung.

It is hard to predict what will happen under various situations. A tall tree with a long trunk will act different from a short low spreading one.

Re: Downed trees

#30

I think be very very careful

john lucas

>is what we are all saying. Cutting trees can be very unpredictable even if you have a lot of experience.

Re: Downed trees

#31

Re: Downed trees

MWWoodWorks

>Yes, I was working for Wray's Tree Service. I am still pretty good freinds with him. I am a turner, I don't think I had gotten my lathe yet at that time but was saving up for it! I have been turning since about that time. I am still in the area, just outside of West Point in Shacklefords. About 20 mins. from your neck O' the woods. No longer doing treework, I started my handyman business about a year ago. I am actually planning on going to the meeting in Richmond this month for the first time!! I can't wait!!! I don't know any other turners so I am eagar to get around some people with similar addictions! LOL I have been wanting to go since last year but honestly was afraid of looking like an idiot that didn't know what I was doing. LOL Is it the 3rd thursday or the 2nd to last thursday this month being their are five in January? I assume you are going?

Re: Downed trees

#32

A trick

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>that work for me sometimes, is to guess where the balance point is between the root ball and the tip of the tree, I am talking weight, and then make a single cut a little closer to the root ball than the balance point, if you had an educated guess, the section with the root ball will go back to vertical, and then you can fell it the normal way.

If your guess is that that tree will never go vertical, then you leave enough of the bole to prevent the root ball from falling on you.

As I work alone, I use wedges and a felling ax to prevent or rescue from a pinch, also I rely heavily in a block and tackle, ropes and chains to make them fell where I need them, or to prevent the root ball from falling forward, then after the cut, I pump on it and make it go back.

That asks for some monkey work climbing to tie ropes, the higher you tie the more control you get. I am light weight, a robust friend accomplishes the same with a felling bar,(similar to a peavey, but no hook, just a strong flat metal on the tip) makes the cut to a point and then puts the bar in and lifts, that makes the tree go the way he needs, I am not strong enough to do that, so I climb and use the block and tackle.

Re: Downed trees

#33

Dick Hines

Re: Downed trees

Dick Hines

>Jan 18. We have a lot of people who are new turners. Come on up you will have a good time. I am not sure what the demo is thought.

The meetins are always the third Thursday. At Woodcraft. They give a 10% discount to club members on meeting night..

Hope to see you there

Re: Downed trees

#34

Re: Downed trees

MWWoodWorks

>Ah, very nice to know about the discount! Thanks for the info, I will definatly be there! I'll be sure to say hey!

Re: Downed trees

#35

Re: A trick

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>That asks for some monkey work climbing to tie

>ropes, the higher you tie the more control you get....

Few will climb around here, except for amature tree service wannabees and they don't stay around long for some reason. Most pros seem real good at tossing a weighted cord, but use a bucket truck if possible. The best I've done is from shooting a weighted fishing line from a spinning reel with a slingshot.

I ordered a felling bar without seeing it and was disappointed with it's apparent strength and handle length. I don't think I'd use it except on a very small tree. What looks better (at a high price) is a hydraulic gack with jaws that fit into the kerf and expand.

JKJ

Re: Downed trees

#36

Re: Downed trees

Pete

>Dick,

What time are the meetings at Woodcraft? I'd love to come as well, but I work in DC and live in Stafford. I'm not sure I'd be able to get there in time for a week night meeting; however, Thursdays are much more convienent for me than Saturday morning meetings since my kids play soccer and baseball....

Pete

Re: Downed trees

#37

Mike Stafford

Roy Underhill story...

Mike Stafford

>Roy Underhill tells the story about the time he was harvesting some wood after a hurricane. He and some friends were cutting a large trunk section free when suddenly the root ball stood back up leaving the main trunk section splintered and shattered where they were working on it. Fortunately they were okay but the tool box they had left in the hole where the tree was rooted was never to be the same or seen again.

Re: Downed trees

#38

Re: A trick

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>John,

"What looks better (at a high price) is a hydraulic jack with jaws that fit into the kerf and expand."

Agree, that would be the way to go and a bucket loader is a good option too, if you are by a roadside, I live and work deep in the woods, no road and it is only wimpy me to carry stuff around, so that dictates my tools and methods.

Re: Downed trees

#39

Re: Downed trees

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>for a downed tree that is more upright than down a plunge cut is a good option. It is also a good option for felling a tree. the plunge cut itself is a bit tricky for a beginner though. to use a plunge cut you make your notch as you normaly would. Then rather than cut into the hinge from the bach of the tree you plunge the tip into the middle of the tree near where the hinge will be. then establish the hinge and cut towards the backside of the tree stopping a few inches befor the bar exits the tree. pull the bar out and finish the cut from the backside of the tree.

On a partialy downed tree you will need to leave a bit more for the last cut. the advantage of using a plunge cut is it lets a less experianced operator line up the hinge evenly making it less likely that the tree will roll on the way down. it also puts the operator further out of the line of fall and in a better spot to make a safe exit as the tree starts to come down.

one other thing that can help with trees that are leaning is to use a humboldt notch. this is merely a reversed notch which will leave the butt of the log flat rather then the stump being flat. to do this the first cut for the notch is made from near the ground angled up. the second cut is made parallel to the ground. I like a humolt because for milling it results in less waste for me as I don't need to trim the butt of the log other than the splinters left from the hings.

I spent a lot of time this past summer milling walnut trees that were pushed over with a bulldozer. the trees still had their root ball but only a limited abount of limbs. What I had was basicaly a bunch of downed trees just like you are describing. I only have one 42" bar and at $160 for a spare the option of carring a spare bare and chain will not happen anytime soon for me. I have never cared much for cutting root balls off but I fell very comfortable doing so after this past summer.

I did not find any advantage to using a plunge cut when the tree is all the way down. what workes best for me is to drive two wedges from the top as soon as the bar has cleared enough wood to allow room for them. then as I am about 2/3 - 3/4 way through the log I place two more wedges. as the last few inches are cut I stop and check all the wedges and give them a tap or two if needed. I start the cut from the top of the log and continue all the way through towards the ground rather than cutting from both directions.

I cut my own wedges out of elm and make them with a similar pitch to the plastic ones you can buy. by making my own if one gets cut it does less damage to my ego and my wallet.

One last word about making plunge cuts with a chain saw. As one can imagine it is a cut that is not for the inexperianced. To limit the chance of kickback the initial cut is made with the bottom 1/2 half of the tip and then as the cut gets started the top half of the tip is brought into the cut. start the cut with as low a chain speed as you can, and if you don't feel comfortable making a plunge cut don't try it until someone else can show you how.

one last word about felling trees. It is only a saw and can be replaced easily and quickly. You only have one body.

Robin

Re: Downed trees

#40

Re: Downed trees

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I lived in logging country when I was a kid. (Puget Sound) I worked in a logging camp as a summer job when I was a teen-ager.

What you need is a 100 foot high spar pole, a steam donkey engine, and some cable.

Wally

Re: Downed trees

#41

Re: Downed trees

Marv

>Hi John,

Whether a downed tree that fell on it's own or one you fall yourself, it's all about the weight and where it is and where it wants to go. Always start at the top of the tree where the little stuff is. Get all the limbs off and out of the way. Then just start cutting the bigger stuff down to size, small piece at a time. While you do this, try to keep it balanced. In other words, don't cut only from one side if that is possible. When the weight of a branch looks like it will pinch your saw blade, cut from the underside. I have never used a wedge. If you need a wedge, you are sawing on the wrong side of the branch. But as others have suggested, it's always good to have a backup saw handy just in case. I have a big saw and a smaller one. The smaller one does most of the work.

I'm 70 years old and have cut up alot of trees over the years with nary a mishap. I grew up in Washington and Oregon in the logging and milling industry. I always take my time, never in a hurry. I study the tree thoroughly before making any major cut. I prefer to work alone because I don't like having to worry about the other guy getting in a hurry and doing something stupid. It's basically just good common sense and having alot of respect for anything that can potentially cause blood to flow or bones to break.

Marv

Re: Downed trees

#42

Re: Roy Underhill story...

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>That reminded me of a horrible story that was in the news after a storm hit the East coast. I am not sure exactly where this happened. A whole tree was down and the homeowner was sawing it into pieces starting at the top. He did not know his young son had come outside and was playing in the hole left by the upended root ball. You can guess the rest of the story. Sad, sad ,sad!

Re: Downed trees

#43

Solo logging, gone bad story

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>I had a first cousin, now decease, who was cutting some firewood, and somehow managed to get a log hung, that bucked and knocked him down, and left him trapped under it across both legs.

He could still reach his saw, and got it started, and managed to saw it on both sides, for a self rescue. This only presented the next challenge. He managed to drag himself to his truck using only his arms, then managed to get up into the cab. Don't ask me how, I could not have done it.

Once in the cab, he could not use any of the pedals, but fortunately, he was close enough to the road to hear passing traffic, and got on the horn, and yelled enough to attract someone to come to his rescue.

I don't recall hearing him talk about the pain, but I'll bet there was more than a little.